It's A Clue – Details, episodes & analysis

In the our kickoff of Season 4, we delve into Nancy Drew & the Crooked Banister! Kelly wants a robot that will rub her back. Karen wants a robot that provides a “spontaneous bring”. We are both big Robby the Robot fans, we loved the cool clues but hated they went nowhere, and we love a flaming moat but hate a loose birch tree bridge. Also - Rawley totally faked his own death right?

Rated 9.25 out of 12 poisonous paintings

Recommendations:

• Here One Moment, by Lianne Moriarty
• Vanishing in the Haight, by Max Tomlinson
• Dead Wake, by Erik Larson
• Anxious People, by Fredrik Backman

Proud winner of the Nobel "I Tried" Ribbon in Literature.

Listen on: Apple Podcasts   Spotify

Support the show

https://www.instagram.com/itsacluepodcast/

In the Season 3 Finale, we get to go to Turkey with the Clue Crew –— Karen thought it was sassy, and Kelly thought it was meh but full of derring-do. We also discuss our theories on doppelgängers, our summer dreams, and how much we want to go to the Grand Bazaar and the Basilica Cistern.  Some thoughts to ponder: Would you buy a life insurance policy from Ned Nickerson? Would you have known Aisha was the mannequin? Should locksmiths and librarians have a Hippocratic oath? 

Rated 7 out of 12 deadly waterwheels.

Recommendations:

• Loot - Apple TV (Maya Rudolph)
• People to Follow - Olivia Worley

Proud winner of the Nobel "I Tried" Ribbon in Literature.

Listen on: Apple Podcasts   Spotify

Support the show

https://www.instagram.com/itsacluepodcast/

In Episode 57, let’s talk about our very first Hardy Boys book - The Tower Treasure! (Spoiler alert, we both friggin’ love the Hardy Boys now!). But first, Kelly loves an earmuff, Karen has a brain meld with Will Shortz, the word “panopticon” is used for the first time on this show, and Aileen’s gonna hook us up with proof of robotic puppets. Over in . . . Bayside? Baywatch? Bayport?….we have our first perishing, there’s lots of reckless driving, and Joe & Frank get paid even though they probably couldn’t take a fingerprint off a moving horse. 

Rated 9.5 out of 12 Decrepit Water Towers

Up Next:

• Baby-Sitter’s Club Super Mystery 1: Baby-sitter’s Haunted House

Recommendations:

• All the Sinners Bleed by SA Crosby
• Lovelight Farms by B.K. Borison

Proud winner of the Nobel "I Tried" Ribbon in Literature.

Listen on: Apple Podcasts   Spotify

Support the show

https://www.instagram.com/itsacluepodcast/

Let’s dig into Nancy Drew & the Moonstone Castle Mystery! But first, we’re in the chute to the holidays, Kelly’s crowd sourcing a cookie recipe, and Karen had a full-on mail mystery. Meanwhile, George and Bess are full-on BEEFING, the entire Clue Crew finally gets arrested, we’re missing a people talker to tell us about the random castle in the middle of Indiana, Nancy fears being a friendship pusher but is an #influencer, and moats are swum (ew). A group of Corvettes is a cascade, Mrs. Hemstead is an NPC, and Baby Joanie-Jolene-Judy-Jodine’s grandparents have Stockholm Syndrome. 

Rated 11 out of 12 River Police 

Up Next:

• Hardy Boys 1: The Tower Treasure
• Baby-Sitter’s Club Super Mystery 1: Baby-sitter’s Haunted House

Recommendations:

• Bad Cree by Jessica Johns
• Silver Nitrate - Silvia Moreno-Garcia
• Mexican Gothic - Silvia Moreno-Garcia

Proud winner of the Nobel "I Tried" Ribbon in Literature.

Listen on: Apple Podcasts   Spotify

Support the show

https://www.instagram.com/itsacluepodcast/

In Episode 55, we discuss Nancy Drew & The Clue of the Dancing Puppet. First though, Kelly tells us about The Soupening, Karen is in “snuggalump mode”, and we get to see each other this week IRL! Tammy puts the A in “Amateur” but needed more villainous agency, Nancy receives a gratuitous number of head injuries, and some California-based slippery operators slap a giant puppet on a non-existent problem, which seems like a bad idea. In other news, we left in some outtakes, Kelly references a ridiculous number of movies and musicals, and Karen hates a cute little bait-and-switch ghost. Be sure to help us decide if it was it a police electrician or an electrician for the police.

Rated 9.5 out of 12 Falling Cannonballs

Recommendations:

Sisters of the Lost Marsh, by Lucy Strange

One of the Good Guys, by Araminta Hall (out in 2024)

Proud winner of the Nobel "I Tried" Ribbon in Literature.

Listen on: Apple Podcasts   Spotify

Support the show

https://www.instagram.com/itsacluepodcast/

Let's go to Hong Kong with Nancy Drew in "The Mystery of the Fire Dragon"! It is well nigh Halloween, Karen has been going all around but found time to update her eyeballs, and Kelly has read so many vampire books she's terrified after sundown. This book is a solid "meh" on the Nancy-o-Meter, but on the plus side: there's a stop in NYC before a trip to Hong Kong, and a bookstore smuggling front that is giving "Joe-from-You Bookstore Lair" vibes. Everyone gets individually kidnapped, we believe in thought transference, Karen could eat a piece of cheese, Officer Tommy has 54 problems, and don't forget your lipstick in case of a 505 emergency. 

Rated 6 our of 12 exploding ovens. 

Recommendations:
Bright Young Women by Jessica Knoll
Dracula by Bram Stoker 

Proud winner of the Nobel "I Tried" Ribbon in Literature.

Listen on: Apple Podcasts   Spotify

Support the show

https://www.instagram.com/itsacluepodcast/

Let's go to Adult Summer Camp & investigate "The Clue in the Old Stagecoach" with the Clue Crew! Karen wants to know which side of the tree lichen grows on, and Kelly wants to flirt around a campfire in a uniform. Then on to one of our favorite light-hearted, laugh-out-loud funny capers yet! Nancy solves the mystery of Sally the Bear, the gals are hilarious water ballet-ers, Rick demonstrates Kenergy, and we get a valuable PSA about the importance of dead tree removal. Don't forget to Googer geigle counters. 

Rated 11.75 out of 12 Hand-Knitted Sweaters

Recommendations:
- The September House by Carissa Orlando
- Holly by Stephen King
- The Brothers Hawthorne by Jennifer Lynn Barnes

Proud winner of the Nobel "I Tried" Ribbon in Literature.

Listen on: Apple Podcasts   Spotify

Support the show

https://www.instagram.com/itsacluepodcast/

In Episode 52, the Clue Crew heads to Hawaii to investigate The Secret of the Golden Pavillion! Karen loved the horror elements of this book, but not the gratuitous Mr. Rogers-ing. Nancy almost gets taken down by tripping off a volcano, and she probably irons her underwear. Kelly rebrands magnifying glasses and can’t remember Gilligan’s Island. Togo is a prize winner and is rewarded in scritches and helicopters. And the boyfriends survive a near-miss and help take down a bunch of scorps. All in all, an unsatisfying mystery, but Hawaii sounds fantastic!

Rated 10 out of 12 Double Scorps, or 20 out of 24 Single Scorps. 

Recommendations:

Fourth Wing by Rebecca Yarros

Knock at the Door (film by M. Night Shyamalan)

Hide by Kiersten White

The Brothers Hawthorne by Jennifer Lynn Barnes

Proud winner of the Nobel "I Tried" Ribbon in Literature.

Listen on: Apple Podcasts   Spotify

Support the show

https://www.instagram.com/itsacluepodcast/

In Episode 51, Kelly & Karen discuss Nancy Drew & the Haunted Showboat! After a refreshing summer during which time Kelly reunited with her Barbies and Karen took on the roller derby alter-ego "Sylvia Wrath", your hosts are officially ready to take a literary trip to New Orleans with the Clue Crew. Join them as they discuss inappropriate methods to diffuse car bombs, what pecan-caramel things are called, and why it's called a showboat. Plus some suggestions for plot improvements by Kelly and additions to Nancy's list of life-skills by Karen. Brought to you by canoes. 

Book recommendations:
- Safe & Sound, by Mercury Stardust
- Mister Magic, by Kiersten White
- The Quiet Tenant, by Clémence Michallon 

Proud winner of the Nobel "I Tried" Ribbon in Literature.

Listen on: Apple Podcasts   Spotify

Support the show

https://www.instagram.com/itsacluepodcast/

On episode FIFTY (!!!!) of It's A Clue, Kelly and Karen are joined by professional podcast host—and a true Helen Corning if there ever was one—CRAIG!  Join us as Craig moderates this hard-hitting Q&A session, featuring questions submitted by you!

In this episode, we discuss:
- Why we started the podcast
- When we first fell in love with Nancy Drew
- What's George's actual problem
- How we got our jingle
- Which book Karen didn't read before recording
- And many more ridiculous topics.

Thank you to all of our listeners who have supported us through 50 episodes and 2 seasons! We're off on a summer break, but we'll be back to you with Season 3 when the leaves change color (aka September). 

Happy Sleuthing!

Proud winner of the Nobel "I Tried" Ribbon in Literature.

Listen on: Apple Podcasts   Spotify

Support the show

https://www.instagram.com/itsacluepodcast/