Jonathan Howard and Wendy Orent call this week their "Red Wedding": within days, FDA Commissioner Marty Makary resigned, Vinay Prasad was pushed out of CBER, Tracy Beth Hoeg was fired, and Senator Bill Cassidy lost his Louisiana primary. The hosts argue this is not a tragedy but a long-foretold collapse — a group of physicians who built careers as COVID-era contrarian podcasters discovering that running a regulatory agency is fundamentally different from posting about one.
Howard works through the wreckage: Makary's reported approval of flavored nicotine products days before his ouster, the FDA's treatment of the rare disease community, the leaked memo claiming pediatric COVID vaccine deaths that career staff refused to sign off on, and the broader pattern of "regulatory whiplash" that drove the agency into dysfunction. The episode then turns to who is still standing — Jay Bhattacharya at NIH, Robert F. Kennedy Jr. at HHS — and what Kennedy is reportedly doing to vaccines from behind the scenes via Martin Kulldorff's review effort.
Throughout, the hosts return to a single thesis: the skills that made Makary, Prasad, Hoeg, and Cassidy famous during COVID — opinion, tweeting, posturing — do not translate into running institutions, and the medical commentators who vouched for them (John Mandrola, Adam Cifu) have lost any remaining credibility.
Key Topics Discussed Bill Cassidy's primary loss and the cost of the Kennedy confirmation vote
-
Cassidy's earlier vote to convict Trump after January 6 followed by his decisive vote advancing RFK Jr. as HHS Secretary.
-
Howard and Orent's view that Cassidy's promise to "keep Kennedy in line" was hollow from the start.
-
What Cassidy's defeat signals about Trump's grip on the Republican base in Louisiana — and the hosts' read that his lame-duck status may give him cover to block the next round of HHS nominees.
Marty Makary's resignation and the "worst FDA Commissioner in 25 years" framing
Vinay Prasad, regulatory whiplash, and the rare disease community
Tracy Beth Hoeg, the leaked pediatric deaths memo, and the Maryanne Demasi interview
The Makary–Prasad ZDoggMD clip on FDA "vindictiveness" — and the irony
John Mandrola, Adam Cifu, and the cost of vouching
Jay Bhattacharya, NIH, and the resignation letter from departing staff
Kennedy's behind-the-scenes vaccine review and Martin Kulldorff
Casey Means, Surgeon General nomination withdrawal, and MAHA fracturing
Notable Moments
References Mentioned in the Episode
People Referenced
