Explore every episode of the podcast Theology Girls Podcast
| Title | Pub. Date | Duration | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Episode 60: The Hidden World of White Christian Women with Kristin Kobes Du Mez | 08 Sep 2026 | 00:38:57 | |
Today we’re sharing a conversation with New York Times Best Selling Author, Kristin Kobes Du Mez. Kristin and Katy discuss her upcoming book, “Live Laugh Love: The Secret History of White Christian Women and the World They Made.” In this episode you’ll hear Kristin share insights on new thought and positive thinking, Elisabeth Elliot, Hobby Lobby, network marketing, and more. Make sure you stick around for our bonus conversation on Substack with Kristin where we discuss the influencers and prominent Christian women she writes about in the book and their take on Live Laugh Love. Don’t forget that you can join our Second Service community and have access to all our subscriber perks for just $12 a month, including weekly bonus episodes, exclusive content and our quarterly book club, including live Q&A sessions with authors. https://thetheologygirls.substack.com/7days Follow Kristin on Instagram @kkdumez and make sure you check out her Substack. https://kristindumez.substack.com/ Check out Kristin’s website here. https://kristindumez.com Preorder “Live Laugh Love” today. https://amzn.to/4ibNHzv Grab a copy of “Jesus and John Wayne” by clicking here. https://amzn.to/4gUmRcI Grab a copy of “A New Gospel for Women” by clicking here. https://amzn.to/4di38CH Episode Sponsors: Access Forge - Use code TG for $150 off your virtual course https://learn.accessforge.com/ Ninni Co. Pacifiers - Use code THEOLOGYGIRL for 10% off your order https://ninnico.com/ Email us at thetheologygirls@gmail.com to inquire about out ad space for your business or ministry Grab tickets for our next in person event on 10/2 with Tara Beth Leach by clicking here. https://www.eventbrite.com/e/theology-girls-live-tickets-1993639416161 Make sure you rate, review and subscribe to the podcast anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 59: Questioning Faith Without Losing It with Chelsea Long | 01 Sep 2026 | 00:51:54 | |
Today we’re sharing a conversation with brand new author, Chelsea Long. Chelsea and Katy discuss her upcoming book, “Faithfully Dissident Daughters: Reclaiming Christian Womanhood Beyond Patriarchy” and how it’s possible to question your faith without completely losing it. They also discuss how Chelsea’s own experience during postpartum that led to her own faith deconstruction and the many ways the female body and experience can reveal the heart of God. Make sure you stick around for our bonus conversation on Substack with Chelsea where we discuss reclaiming trust in yourself after years of being told not to. Don’t forget that you can join our Second Service community and have access to all our subscriber perks for just $12 a month, including weekly bonus episodes, exclusive content and our quarterly book club, including live Q&A sessions with authors. https://thetheologygirls.substack.com/7days Follow Chelsea on Instagram @chelseakimlong and make sure you check out her Substack. https://www.chelseakimlong.com Preorder “Faithfully Dissident Daughters” today. https://a.co/d/0aFTBMhT Episode Sponsors: Access Forge - Use code TG for $150 off your virtual course Seminary Now - Use code TG30 for 30% off your subscription https://learn.accessforge.com/ https://seminarynow.com/pages/theology-girls Email us at thetheologygirls@gmail.com to inquire about out ad space for your business or ministry Grab tickets for our next in person event on 10/2 with Tara Beth Leach by clicking here. https://www.eventbrite.com/e/theology-girls-live-tickets-1993639416161 Make sure you rate, review and subscribe to the podcast anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 58: A Woman’s Place is in the Story with Sandra Glahn | 25 Aug 2026 | 00:35:07 | |
JOIN OUR BOOK FALL CLUB by clicking here and get your first 7 days for free, as well as all our Second Service perks. https://thetheologygirls.substack.com/7days Today we are featuring an episode with professor, author, and theologian, Sandra Glahn. Sandra and Katy discuss her latest book, “A Woman’s Place is in the Story” and all the ways we misread women’s stories inside of scripture, as well as her 10 year journey with infertility and how it impacted her ministry and writing. Make sure you stick around for our bonus conversation with Sandra only available for Second Service community members on Substack where we discuss her role at Dallas Theological Seminary and what some of her complementarian colleagues may think of this new book. You can join the Second Service community for just $12 a month and take advantage of all your subscriber perks. Click here to get your first 7 days for free. https://thetheologygirls.substack.com/7days Follow Sandra on Instagram @sandraglahnauthor and make sure you check out her Substack. https://substack.com/@sandraglahn Order “A Woman’s Place is in the Story” today. https://a.co/d/0h6ocnUF Episode Sponsors: Ninni Co. Pacifiers - Use code THEOLOGYGIRL for 10% off your entire order She Reads Truth - Use code THETHEOLOGYGIRLS for 15% off your entire order Email us at thetheologygirls@gmail.com to inquire about out ad space for your business or ministry Grab tickets for our next in person event on 10/2 with Tara Beth Leach by clicking here. https://www.eventbrite.com/e/theology-girls-live-tickets-1993639416161 Make sure you rate, review and subscribe to the podcast anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 57: Beyond the Manosphere with Zachary Wagner | 18 Aug 2026 | 00:57:21 | |
JOIN OUR BOOK FALL CLUB by clicking here and get your first 7 days for free, as well as all our Second Service perks. Today we are sharing a conversation with New Testament Scholar and author, Zachary Wagner. Zachary recently authored a book called “Men of Virtue,” and Katy and Zach discuss all things masculinity and why more and more young men are drawn to what I would consider “manosphere” influencers for their formation as Christian men rather than looking to the person and work of Christ. They also discuss why the phrase toxic masculinity often shuts down conversations, why more men are being drawn to religious institutions, as well as how we can help the men in our lives embrace a more Godly form of masculinity. Make sure you stick around for our bonus episode only available on Substack for our Second Service members where Zach shares which fruit of the spirit has been particularly hard for him to embody. You can join the Second Service community for just $12 a month and take advantage of all your subscriber perks. Click here to get your first 7 days for free. Follow Zachary on Instagram @zacharycwagner and make sure you check out his Substack. Order “Men of Virtue” by clicking here. Order “Non-Toxic Masculinity” by clicking here. Episode Sponsors: Crescent Oasis Counseling and Coaching Seminary Now - Use code TG30 for 30% off your entire subscription Email us at thetheologygirls@gmail.com to inquire about out ad space for your business or ministry Grab tickets for our next in person event on 10/2 with Tara Beth Leach by clicking here. Make sure you rate, review and subscribe to the podcast anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| BONUS: What they Don’t Tell You About Women in the Bible with Lydia Grace Kaiser | 14 Aug 2026 | 00:42:12 | |
Today we are sharing a conversation with author, Lydia Grace Kaiser about her new book, Bible Truth About Women: What They Don’t Tell You.” In many ways, Lydia Grace continues the dialogue Katy had with Preston Sprinkle back in March of 2026 and takes her readers further into issues such as the “misleading claims” that those in complementarian spaces have used as a means to bar women from church leadership. Make sure you stick around for our bonus episode only available on Substack for our Second Service members where Lydia Grace shares about a lesser known female Biblical character that she loved researching. You can join the Second Service community for just $12 a month and take advantage of all your subscriber perks. Click here to get your first 7 days for free. Follow Lydia Grace on Facebook and make sure you check out her website. Grab your copy of “Bible Truth About Women: What They Don’t Tell You” by clicking here. Episode Sponsors: Kindred Photo Co. - Tell her the Theology Girls sent you for 10% off your shoot Seminary Now - Use code TG30 for 30% off your entire subsription Email us at thetheologygirls@gmail.com to inquire about out ad space for your business or ministry Grab tickets for our next in person event on 10/2 with Tara Beth Leach by clicking here. Make sure you rate, review and subscribe to the podcast anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 56: Holy Ground in the Ordinary Moments of Life with Kimberly Knowle Zeller | 11 Aug 2026 | 00:35:41 | |
Today we are sharing a really a recent conversation with my new friend, author and pastor, Kimberly Knowle Zeller. Kimberly and Katy discuss her new book, “Small Steps: Blessings to Lift Your Soul on the Pilgrimage of Life”, as well as her journey on the Camino de Santiago, the power of offering blessings for every season and circumstance in life and so much more. Make sure you stick around for our bonus episode only available on Substack for our Second Service members where Kimberly does something really special and not only reads one of the blessings from her book, but also shares why her book specifically might mean a lot to someone who is walking through a season of doubt or deconstruction. You can join the Second Service community for just $12 a month and take advantage of all your subscriber perks. Click here to get your first 7 days for free. Follow Kimberly on Instagram @kkowlezeller and on Substack here. Grab your copy of “Small Steps” by clicking here. Episode Sponsors: Be a Heart - Use code THETHEOLOGYGIRLS for 10% off your purchase She Reads Truth - Use code THETHEOLOGYGIRLS for 15% off your entire purpose Email us at thetheologygirls@gmail.com to inquire about out ad space for your business or ministry Grab tickets for our next in person event on 10/2 with Tara Beth Leach by clicking here. Make sure you rate, review and subscribe to the podcast anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 55: Leading Worship While Female with Kelsey Kramer McGinnis | 04 Aug 2026 | 00:56:18 | |
Today we are featuring a conversation with author, musicologist, and frequent contributor to Christianity Today, Kelsey Kramer McGinnis. Kelsey and Katy talk about all things church ministry and worship leading, especially as it pertains to women. They discuss why women can write worship songs and lead them, often praying and speaking between songs, but are not able to preach in certain faith spaces and how blurry that line really is. They also discuss topics like aging out of leadership, funny baby voice, tracks, tech in worship, and more. Stick around for our bonus Second Service episode only available on Substack where Kelsey re-imagines a church service using her expertise as a musicologist and how people actually interact with music and congregational singing. You can sign up today for just $12 a month and snag all our subscriber perks. Plus, get 7 days for free when you use this link. Follow Kelsey on Instagram @kelseykmcginnis and on Substack here. Episode Sponsors: Seminary Now - Use code TG30 for 30% off your subscription Ninni Co. Pacifiers - Use code THEOLOGYGIRL for 10% off your entire purpose Email us at thetheologygirls@gmail.com to inquire about out ad space for your business or ministry Grab tickets for our next in person event on 10/2 with Tara Beth Leach by clicking here. Make sure you rate, review and subscribe to the podcast anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 54: High Control Groups and Finding Freedom with Grace Snively | 28 Jul 2026 | 00:46:34 | |
Today we are sharing recent conversation Katy had with her friend, artist and entrepreneur, Grace Snively, about a high control group they were both part of over a decade ago. Grace and Katy process what it was like to be in the group in real time, as well as what it was like to leave the group, and rebuilding your faith after leaving a group like this. Check out our bonus Second Service episode on Substack where Katy and Grace share how trauma still shows up in their everyday lives as well as red flags to know whether or not you’re in a high control group and why faith based groups are prone to power abuses. This episode is only available for paid subscribers. You can join our Second Service community for just $8 until the end of July (normally $12) and take advantage of all our paid subscriber perks. Click here to join and lock in at the discounted rate for the remainder of your subscription. Check out Domas Studio by clicking here and make sure you follow Grace on Instagram @gracesnively You can also shop Grace’s apparel store, Grey House Goods by clicking here. Episode Sponsors: Crescent Oasis Counseling and Coaching Ninni Co. Pacifiers - Use code THEOLOGYGIRL for 10% off your entire purpose Email us at thetheologygirls@gmail.com to inquire about out ad space for your business or ministry Grab tickets for our next in person event on 10/2 with Tara Beth Leach by clicking here. Make sure you rate, review and subscribe to the podcast anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 53: Listener Mailbag and Theology Girls News with Katy (and Jon) Goldstein | 21 Jul 2026 | 00:57:24 | |
Today we are sharing our first ever listener mailbag episode where Katy answers your questions. Katy is joined by her husband Jon for this conversation who chimes in and shares his take on household responsibilities, time management, egalitarian marriage, healthy churches, seminary, and more. And make sure you listen through till the end for two very exciting Theology Girls announcements. Check out our bonus Second Service episode on Substack where Katy shares a very hot take she has when it comes to the Old Testament. This episode is only available for paid subscribers. You can join our Second Service community for just $8 until the end of July (normally $12) and take advantage of all our paid subscriber perks. Check out Sheila Gregoire’s “Bare Marriage” podcast episode where she audits church websites. Episode Sponsors: Seminary Now - use code TG30 for 30% off your subscription Email us at thetheologygirls@gmail.com to inquire about out ad space Grab tickets for our next in person event on 10/2 with Tara Beth Leach by clicking here. Make sure you rate, review and subscribe to the podcast anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| BONUS: When Longing Becomes Your Lover with Amanda McCracken | 17 Jul 2026 | 00:37:19 | |
Today we are sharing a special bonus conversation with Amanda McCracken, author of “When Longing Becomes Your Lover” and limerence expert. Amanda shares about her experience as a 40 year old virgin who had become addicted to longing for love rather than actually pursuing healthy relationships, and how she connects the harmful teachings of purity culture to her struggles. Make sure you stick around for our bonus Second Service episode with Amanda on Substack where she shares what she wishes she would have learned as a teenager in youth group instead of purity culture teachings. Join our Second Service Community for just $12 a month to receive weekly bonus episodes and essays, extra live discussions, as well as be part of our quarterly book club. Grab a copy of “When Longing Becomes Your Lover” by clicking here and check out Amanda’s incredible TedX talk about limerence. Listen to The Longing Lab by clicking here. Episode Sponsors: Kindred Photo Co. - tell her The Theology Girls sent you for 10% off your shoot She Reads Truth - use the code THETHEOLOGYGIRLS for 15% off your entire order Make sure you rate, review and subscribe to the podcast anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 52: Living in the Tension with Kristin Mockler Young | 14 Jul 2026 | 00:59:00 | |
Today we are sharing a conversation featuring podcaster, author and “Insta Pastor,” Kristin Mockler Young. Kristin and Katy discuss her upcoming book “The Other Side of Certainty” and what it looks like to live inside tension rather than look for clear cut answers when it comes to faith. Kristin shares about her rise to internet fame and what it’s like being a female pastor, particularly one who’s been outspoken about Christian nationalism and caring for marginalized communities, as well as diet culture and raising daughters. Make sure you stick around for our bonus Second Service episode with Kristin on Substack where we discuss whether or not she’s ever changed her mind as a result of some of the critiques she’s had online. Join our Second Service Community for just $12 a month to receive weekly bonus episodes and essays, extra live discussions, as well as be part of our quarterly book club. Pre-order your copy of “The Other Side of Certainty” and join her launch team for exclusive announcements and content by clicking here. Listen to the Becoming Church podcast by clicking here. Check out Kristin’s writing on Substack by clicking here. Stay up to date with Kristin and support her work by visiting her website. Episode Sponsors: Seminary Now - use code TG30 for 30% off your subscription Ninni Co. - use the code THEOLOGYGIRL for 10% off your entire order Make sure you rate, review and subscribe to the podcast anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 51: A Woman Led Faith with Claire McKeever-Burgett | 07 Jul 2026 | 00:45:58 | |
Today we are sharing a conversation featuring author and feminist theologian, Claire McKeever Burgett. Claire and and Katy discuss both her books, Blessed are the Women and In the Beginning Were the Women and how she uses the art of sacred imagination to retell the stories of lesser known women throughout the Biblical text. Claire also explains how she uses the ancient Jewish practice of midrash in her writing, as well as what an embodied liturgy looks like for Christians today. And make sure you stick around for my bonus episode with Claire on Substack where we discuss why the argument for a “plain reading of the text” as the only way to approach the Bible doesn’t really work. Join our Second Service Community for just $12 a month to receive weekly bonus episodes and essays, extra live discussions, as well as be part of our quarterly book club. Order your copies of Claire’s books, “In the Beginning Were the Women” and “Blessed are the Women” Check out Claire’s writing on Substack by clicking here. Stay up to date with Claire and support her work by visiting her website. Grab a copy of Elaine Storkey’s “Women in a Patriarchal World” as mentioned by Katy by clicking here. Episode Sponsors: She Reads Truth - use code THETHEOLOGYGIRLS for 15% off your entire purchase Ninni Co. - use the code THEOLOGYGIRL for 10% off your entire order Make sure you rate, review and subscribe to the podcast anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 50: Let’s Talk to a Female Pastor with Kari Maddox | 30 Jun 2026 | 00:48:00 | |
Today we are sharing a recent conversation with Kari Maddox about what it’s really like to be a female pastor. Katy and Kari discuss her recent rise to internet fame due to a series of reels she created addressing women’s leadership roles in the Bible and early church, as well as the push back she’s received. Kari also shares about her ministry journey and misconceptions some people may have when it comes to female pastors. Make sure you listen to our bonus episode Second Service episode with Kari where she addresses how to handle those who believe women pastoring is actually sinful rather than a theological disagreement. Join our Second Service Community for just $12 a month to receive weekly bonus episodes and essays, extra live discussions, as well as be part of our quarterly book club. Order your copy of Kari’s eBook ”How to Read, Study, & Stay Consistent in the Bible” by clicking here. Check out Kari’s church Activate Church in Camas, Oregon by clicking here Episode Sponsors: Seminary Now - use code TG30 for 30% off your subscription Ninni Co. - use the code THEOLOGYGIRL for 10% off your entire order Make sure you rate, review and subscribe to the podcast anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 49: Women, Spirituality and Coming Out of Hiding with Bekah Stewart | 23 Jun 2026 | 00:44:34 | |
Today we are sharing a recent conversation spiritual director, coach, and author, Bekah Stewart to discuss her book “Permission to Matter: Reclaiming Women’s Humanity & Authority at the Invitation of Jesus”. In this conversation, Bekah and Katy discuss the value of spiritual direction, advice for women who feel sidelined in faith based spaces and what it looks like to come out of hiding. Bekah also shares various spiritual practices and questions to ask to help women identify their God given calling. Make sure you listen to our bonus episode Second Service episode with Bekah on Substack to hear her defend feminine spirituality and share why she believes that even theologically conservative women can learn from her book and others like it that prioritize the female experience and voice. Join our Second Service Community for just $12 a month to receive weekly bonus episodes and essays, extra live discussions, as well as be part of our quarterly book club. Order your copy of “Permission to Matter” by clicking here. Support Bekah and follow her work by visiting her website and subscribe to her page on Substack. Episode Sponsors: Seminary Now - use code TG30 for 30% off your subscription Be a Heart - use the code THEOLOGYGIRL for 10% off your entire order Make sure you rate, review and subscribe to the podcast anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 48: Disordered Eating, Purity Culture and Healing with Anna Rollins | 19 Jun 2026 | 00:40:24 | |
Today we are sharing a recent conversation with author Anna Rollins about her new memoir “Famished: On Food, Sex, and Growing Up as a Good Girl”. Katy and Anna discuss how growing up in conservative spaces shape how women view their bodies, disordered eating, complicated GLP1 medication marketing, and how we can raise children to have healthy relationships with food. Check out our bonus episode with Anna where we discuss whether or not the church has a vested interest in keeping women small and silent. If you or someone you know is struggling with disordered eating, click here for help and resources. Order your copy of “Famished” by clicking here. Support Anna and follow her work by visiting her website and subscribe to her page on Substack. Episode Sponsors: Seminary Now - use code TG30 for 30% off your subscription Ninni Co. Pacifiers - use the code THEOLOGYGIRL for 10% off your entire order Make sure you rate, review and subscribe to the podcast anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 47: Processing the SBC Vote with Meredith Stone | 16 Jun 2026 | 00:39:24 | |
Today we are interrupting our podcast schedule to bring you a conversation Katy had last week with Executive Director of Baptist Women in Ministry, Meredith Stone. Katy and Meredith discuss the recent SBC vote to further restrict the voices of women as well as do a deep dive on the tainted history of the Southern Baptist Church. Meredith also explains why this issue continues to come up over and over and why simply leaving the denomination is sometimes more complicated than we think. In our bonus episode on Substack, Katy asks Meredith what she makes of the “secret” Baptist churches that exclude the word Baptist from their name in an effort to be more appealing and how this practice is often harmful for women. Support and learn more about Baptist Women in Ministry by clicking here. Follow Baptist Women in Ministry on Instagram at @baptistwomen Episode Sponsors: Crescent Oasis Counseling and Coaching Ninni Co. Pacifiers - use the code THEOLOGYGIRL for 10% off your entire order Make sure you rate, review and subscribe to the podcast anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| BONUS: Gospel Music and Gratefulness with K-Anthony | 12 Jun 2026 | 00:32:04 | |
Today we are sharing a bonus conversation with Jamaican-Canadian Gospel artist and songwriter, K-Anthony. K-Anthony was the winner of the prestigious 2024 Juno Award for Contemporary Christian/Gospel Album of the Year with his EP Arrow. Katy and K-Anthony discuss his recent graduation from seminary and why writing theologically sound and rich music matters. They also discuss the intersection of the music industry and AI as well as staying grounded when you’re given a platform. Click here to stream K-Anthony’s music and make sure you follow him on Instagram at @kanthonylive to stay up to date on his latest releases. Episode Sponsors: Seminary Now - use code TG30 for 30% off your subscription Kindred Photo Co. - tell her the Theology Girls sent you for 10% off your shoot Make sure you rate, review and subscribe to the podcast anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 46: Beyond Christian Nationalism with Benjamin Cremer | 09 Jun 2026 | 00:43:56 | |
Today we are sharing a conversation with Pastor Benjamin Cremer about his work in combating Christian Nationalism online and why it matters. Ben and Katy discuss his unlikely rise to internet fame and how at times it has come with a cost, as well as why most pastors are seemingly afraid to talk about suffering and injustices from the pulpit. Ben also walks us through the many ways Christian Nationalism has harmed women in particular. Make sure you check out our Second Service bonus episode with Ben where we discuss whether or not he thinks the American church is actually capable of correcting itself or if it’s too far gone. Follow Ben on Instagram at @brcremer, follow his Substack and visit his website to learn more about his work. Listen to Ben’s podcast Into the Gray where he posts weekly sermons here. Episode Sponsors: Kairos Classroom - use code THETHEOLOGYGIRLS for 10% off your tuition She Reads Truth - use code THETHEOLOGYGIRLS for 15% off your entire order Make sure you rate, review and subscribe to the podcast anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 45: The Case for Protestantism with Beth Felker Jones | 02 Jun 2026 | 00:36:05 | |
Today we are sharing a conversation with author, professor and theologian Beth Felker Jones about her new book, “Why I Am Protestant.” Beth and Katy discuss what Protestant has to offer believers (especially women) while many believers are being drawn to Roman Catholicism or Eastern Orthodoxy. Beth also reframes what some may see as division as each specific denomination fulfilling a calling to show an aspect of God’s nature to the world. Don’t forget to check out our bonus Substack episode where Beth and Katy discuss what those who are leaving Protestantism get right but also what they may miss, as well as a candid story about her parents who recently converted to Roman Catholicism. Buy a copy of “Why I Am Protestant” by clicking here. Follow Beth on Instagram at @bethfelkerjones and on Substack or visit her website to learn more about her work. Episode Sponsors: Seminary Now - use code TG30 for 30% off your subscription Be A Heart - use code THETHEOLOGYGIRLS for 10% off your entire order Make sure you rate, review and subscribe to the podcast anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 44: Redeeming Eden with Ingrid Faro | 26 May 2026 | 00:56:41 | |
Today we are sharing a conversation with theologian, professor and author, Ingrid Faro, about her newest book “Redeeming Eden”. Ingrid shares how many people throughout history have misinterpreted creation and the fall in ways that oppress and limit women, as well as how women in the Bible advance the story of salvation. We also talk about Ingrid’s nontraditional faith journey, deconstruction, and what it was like essentially starting over in her 40s. Make sure check out our bonus Substack episode with Ingrid where she and Katy discuss whether or not the church owes women an apology and what exactly that might look like if actually applied. Purchase your copy of Redeeming Eden by clicking here. Follow Ingrid on Instagram at @ingrid.s.faro and visit her website to learn more about her work. To view Ingrid’s Seminary Now course, click here. Episode Sponsors: Kairos Classroom - use code THETHEOLOGYGIRLS for 10% off your tuition Ninni Co. Pacifiers - use code THEOLOGYGIRL for 10% off your entire order Grab a ticket to our Theology Girls Bible Quiz Trivia night on June 12th for just $25 each by clicking here. Make sure you rate, review and subscribe to the podcast anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 43: Becoming a Friendlier Church with Matthew D. Kim | 19 May 2026 | 00:39:08 | |
Today we are sharing a conversation with pastor, professor, and author Matthew Kim about his new book “Becoming a Friendlier Church.” In this conversation, Matthew and Katy talk through why most churches perceive themselves as friendly even when that is not the felt experience of visitors, and how often minority groups have often been made to feel left out in church spaces. Matt discusses how pastors can also practice inclusivity in their preaching without compromising their values. Listen to our bonus episode with Matthew on Substack where we discuss multi-ethnic churches and being friendly out of necessity versus predominantly white churches putting up walls out of convenience and the theological implications that holds. Make sure you follow Matthew on Instagram @Matthew.d.kim Purchase a copy of “Becoming a Friendlier Church” by clicking here. Episode Sponsors: Kairos Classroom Kindred Photo Co. - tell her the Theology Girls sent you for 10% off your shoot Join our Summer Book Club by clicking here. Grab a ticket to our Theology Girls Bible Quiz Trivia night on June 12th for just $25 each by clicking here. Make sure you rate, review and subscribe to the podcast anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 42: For the Love of Women with Dorothy Greco | 12 May 2026 | 00:43:27 | |
Today we are sharing a recent conversation with author Dorothy Greco about her new book, “For the Love of Women: Uprooting and Healing Misogyny in America.” In this episode, Dorothy and Katy discuss what exactly misogyny is and how it shoes up across a variety of spheres, including the church, and what faith leaders can do about it. Listen to our bonus episode with Dorothy on Substack where we discuss misogyny in healthcare. Make sure you follow Dorothy on Instagram @dorothylgreco and also on Substack. Purchase a copy of “For the Love of Women” by clicking here. Episode Sponsors: SeminaryNow - use code TG30 to get 30% off your subscription Be A Heart - use code THETHEOLOGYGIRLS for 10% off your purchase Join our Summer Book Club by clicking here. Grab a ticket to our Theology Girls Bible Quiz Trivia night on June 12th for just $25 each by clicking here. Make sure you rate, review and subscribe to the podcast anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 41: Debunking the Proverbs 31 Woman with Jessica LM Jenkins | 08 May 2026 | 00:36:30 | |
Today we are sharing a conversation with friend of the podcast and upcoming author, Jessica LM Jenkins. Jessica and Katy discuss the Proverbs 31 woman, who she was and who she wasn’t. Jessica and Katy discuss how to read wisdom literature as a whole and also how pastors and ministry leaders can teach on the Proverbs 31 without shaming women. For more information on the Proverbs 31 woman, check out Jessica’s “Women of the Bible in Context” podcast. Make sure you follow Jessica on Instagram @jessicalmjenkins and also on Substack by clicking here. Episode Sponsors: Kindred Photo Co. - book a photo shoot and mention the Theology Girls to get 10% off your shoot Crescent Oasis Counseling and Coaching Join our Summer Book Club by clicking here. Grab a ticket to our Theology Girls Bible Quiz Trivia night on June 12th for just $25 each by clicking here. Make sure you rate, review and subscribe to the podcast anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 40: How Hierarchy Hurts Marriage, Sex, and the Church with Sheila Gregoire | 05 May 2026 | 00:44:17 | |
Today we are sharing a conversation with Christian marriage and sex expert, Sheila Gregoire. Sheila is known for her podcast Bare Marriage and the multitude of books she’s written on the subject, including The Great Sex Rescue, The Marriage You Want, She Deserves Better, and a Good Girls Guide to Sex (just to name a few). Sheila and Katy discuss all things purity culture and complementarian theology and why hierarchy is bad for women, sex, marriages, and the church. Make sure you stick around for our bonus episode on Substack with Sheila where we discuss how even soft complementarianism is harmful for women and where they miss the mark on supporting women. Click here to support Sheila, read more of her work and purchase her books. Stream the Bare Marriage podcast by clicking here. Check out Happily Never After - The Curious Case of Love and Respect series that is frequently referenced in this episode by clicking here. Episode Sponsors: Seminary Now - use our code TG30 at checkout to get 30% off your subscription She Reads Truth - use code THETHEOLOGYGIRLS at checkout for 15% off your entire order Grab a ticket to our Theology Girls Bible Quiz Trivia night on June 12th for just $25 each by clicking here Make sure you rate, review and subscribe to the podcast anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 39: Lessons from Women in the New Testament with Dr. Lynn Cohick | 28 Apr 2026 | 00:41:24 | |
Today we are sharing a conversation with Biblical Scholar and president of The Center for Women in Leadership, Dr. Lynn Cohick. Lynn and Katy discuss all things women in the New Testament and Early Church, including why historical context matters when approaching Biblical stories, hidden figures in the writings of Paul, all the ways females have contributed to Christian thought and theology, and so much more. Make sure you stick around for our bonus episode with Lynn where we talk about common misconceptions regarding women in the New Testament available on Substack. Click here to support Lynn and read more of her work. Stream Lynn’s Alabaster Jar podcast by clicking here. Episode Sponsors: Seminary Now - use our code TG30 at checkout to get 30% off your subscription Ninni Co. Pacifiers - use code THEOLOGYGIRL at checkout for 10% off your entire order Grab a ticket to our Theology Girls Bible Quiz Trivia night on June 12th for just $25 each by clicking here. Make sure you rate, review and subscribe to the podcast anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 38: The Rise and Fall of Dispensationalism with Daniel Hummel | 21 Apr 2026 | 01:01:07 | |
Today we are sharing a conversation with author and historian Daniel Hummel about his book “The Rise and Fall of Dispensationalism.” Daniel not only defines dispensationalism but also discusses why he thinks this theology (which places a heavy emphasis on Israel and a physical rapture of the church) has made its way into American politics and why it’s appeal has begun to fade over the past decades, particularly with Gen Z and Millennial adults. Make sure you check out our bonus episode on Substack with Daniel where Katy asks him about how dispensationalism has caused a misunderstanding of the character and nature of God. Grab a copy of “The Rise and Fall of Dispensationalism” by clicking here and support Daniel’s work by visiting his website www.danielghummel.com Other Resources: “Is Pete Hegseth Waging a Christian Zionist War?” Episode Sponsors: Seminary Now - use code TG30 at checkout for 30% off your subscription She Reads Truth - Use our code THETHEOLOGYGIRLS for 15% off your entire order Apply to be a Theology Girls Cohort Leader by clicking here - applications close on 4/24 Make sure you rate, review and subscribe to the podcast anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 37: Love Like a Mother with Elizabeth Berget | 14 Apr 2026 | 00:43:30 | |
Today we are sharing a conversation with author, Elizabeth Berget about her upcoming book, “Love Like a Mother: How the Sacred Work of Motherhood Reveals the Maternal Heart of God.” Elizabeth and Katy discuss what inspired her to write this book as well as the pressures placed on young moms to get it right and the misconception that God is male and how it may impact our theology negatively. Elizabeth also recounts the ways she experienced women and mothers particularly caring for the immigrant community in Minneapolis during the ICE raids this winter. You can pre-order “Love Like a Mother” anywhere books are sold or by clicking here and the book will officially release on May 5th. Follow Elizabeth on Instagram at @elizabeth.e.berget and on Substack by clicking here. Additional Resources: Try Softer: A Fresh Approach to Move Us out of Anxiety, Stress, and Survival Mode--and into a Life of Connection and Joy by Aundi Kolber Episode Sponsors: Crescent Oasis Counseling and Coaching Ninni Co. Pacifiers - Use our code THEOLOGYGIRL for 10% off your entire order Make sure you rate, review and subscribe to the podcast anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 36: Behold Coffee and the Faithfulness of God with Rachael Steudeman | 10 Apr 2026 | 00:52:12 | |
Today we are sharing a conversation with Behold Coffee founder and owner, Rachael Steudeman. If you’re new to the podcast, check out episode 11 with Katy and Rachael as they discuss their friendship and reconciliation process. In this episode, you’ll hear how Behold Coffee went from a dream to reality in just a matter of months. Rachael also shares valuable tips for anyone hoping to start a business of their own, and how she plans to be a Christian business that actually engages culture and impacts the local community. You won’t want to miss our bonus Substack episode with Rachael where she and Katy discuss how the charismatic church often mishandles issues surrounding chronic illness, grief and infertility. Behold Coffee officially opens for business on 4/11 in Kimmswick, Missouri, just south of St. Louis. You can purchase coffee beans and have them shipped to your home anywhere in the United States by clicking here. Follow Behold Coffee @beholdcoffeeco Additional Resources: Check out Cake House Designs by clicking here Check out Hosanna Revival by clicking here Check out Daily Grace Co. by clicking here Check out She Reads Truth by clicking here and use our code THETHEOLOGYGIRLS for 15% off your order Episode Sponsors: Seminary Now - Use code TG30 for 30% off your subscription Make sure you rate, review and subscribe to the podcast anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 35: Emerging Sexual Identities with Mark Yarhouse and Julia Sadusky | 07 Apr 2026 | 00:51:20 | |
Today, we’ve got a really important conversation to share with you featuring licensed psychologists and authors, Mark Yarhouse and Julia Sadusky to discuss their new book, “Emerging Sexual Identities”. In this conversation, Katy chats with Mark and Julia about all the new terminology being used by youth today to discuss their sexual and gender identities, the dangers of conversion therapy versus a more “values based” approach, as well as how the church can serve and love the LGBTQ community better. This episode will be particularly helpful for parents of school aged children and teenagers, as well as those working in youth and young adult ministry. Make sure you grab a copy of “Emerging Sexual Identities” for yourself by clicking here. Make sure you follow Julia at @drsadusky and Mark @dryarhouse on Instagram Additional Resources: Revoice Eden Invitation Building Catholic Futures Episode Sponsors: Seminary Now - Use code TG30 for 30% off your subscription Be A Heart - Use code THETHEOLOGYGIRLS at checkout for 10% off Make sure you rate, review and subscribe to the podcast anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 34: Why the Resurrection Changes Everything with Dr. Matt Easter | 31 Mar 2026 | 00:38:34 | |
Today on the podcast, we’re sharing a conversation with Missouri Baptist University Professor of Biblical Studies & Director of Christian Studies, Dr. Matt Easter about how the resurrection changes everything. Katy and Dr. Easter dive deep into the significance of the resurrection for those navigating despair, sickness, and aging, and also why it matters that women were the first to see the empty tomb and what that means for us today. Make sure you listen to our bonus episode available on Substack where Dr. Easter dives deeper into women at the empty tomb and the stories of female martyrs throughout church history. Check out Dr. Easter’s work at Missouri Baptist University by clicking here. Read Dr. Easter’s Time Magazine Article, “Why is Easter Always on a Sunday?” here. Read Women Who Do: Female Disciples in the Gospels by Holly J. Cary Read The Resurrection of the Song of God by N.T Wright Read Surprised by Hope by N.T Wright Make sure you rate, review and subscribe to the podcast anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 33: Ruth and Trusting in a Redeeming God with Stephanie Watson | 24 Mar 2026 | 00:39:08 | |
Today on the podcast, we’re sharing a conversation with author and ministry leader Stephanie Watson about her new book, “Ruth’s Need for a Redeemer: A Bible Study on Loss, Loyalty, and Unexpected Love.” Katy and Stephanie explore the themes present in the book of Ruth, such as covenant, loyalty and provision, as well as the tension between academia and practical application type Biblical study. If you’re in need of a new personal Bible Study or one for your small group, make sure you click here to order “Ruth’s Need for a Redeemer.” Follow Stephanie’s publishing company Invite Press and check out all their wonderful Christian books and authors. Don’t forget rate, review and subscribe anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 32: Art, Justice, and the Sacred Imagination with Kelly Latimore | 17 Mar 2026 | 00:49:54 | |
Today on the podcast we are sharing a powerful conversation Katy recently had with iconographer Kelly Latimore. Kelly and Katy discuss why icons and symbols have been traditionally rejected in Evangelical spaces, telling stories through creativity and how art can often be a form of activism and lift the voices of women and other minorities. In our bonus Substack episode, Kelly and Katy discuss the ways he attempts to uplift marginalized communities as a white male without appropriating them. We’ll also share some specific pieces of art from the main episode that Kelly references if you’d like to check those out. Support Kelly’s work by checking out his website www.kellylatimoreicons.com and following him on Instagram @kellylatimoreicons Other iconographers Kelly recommends following: @artofmarza @the_modern_saints_by_gracie @andhersaints @Psalmprayers @Markdoox Two other influential iconographers: Fr. William Hart McNichols Br. Robert Lentz Don’t forget rate, review and subscribe anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 31: A Fresh Start for Your Family with Wendy Snyder | 13 Mar 2026 | 00:56:16 | |
Today on the podcast, Katy shares a conversation with positive parenting educator and family life coach, Wendy Snyder. Wendy is the founder of Fresh Start Family and has an upcoming book coming out in May called “Fresh Start Your Family: Powerful Parenting to Restore Peace in Your Home” which is available for pre-order now. Wendy and Katy chat about all things parenting, the risks of authoritarian parenting techniques, uncovering fundamentalism in Evangelical spaces, how to navigate technology with your kids, and so much more. Subscribe to our Substack to hear our bonus episode with Wendy where she debunks myths about gentle parenting. Make sure you check out Fresh Start Family and all Wendy’s amazing resources and make sure you follow Wendy on Instagram @freshstartwendy Pre-order “Fresh Start Your Family” by clicking here for just $22 Please check out other resources Wendy mentioned: Jesus, the Gentle Parent by L.R Knost The Myth of Good Christian Parenting by Marissa Franks Burt and Kelsey Kramer McGinnis Woven: Nurturing a Faith Your Kid Doesn't Have to Heal From by Meredith Miller I've Got Questions: The Spiritual Practice of Having It Out with God by Erin Moon GET YOUR TICKETS HERE for our next Theology Girls in-person event on 4/10 Don’t forget rate, review and subscribe anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 30: From Genesis to Junia with Preston Sprinkle | 06 Mar 2026 | 00:46:18 | |
Today on the podcast, Katy shares a very important conversation she had with podcaster, author, and theologian Preston Sprinkle about his new book, “From Genesis to Junia: An Honest Look at What the Bible Really Says About Women in Leadership”. Preston and Katy cover a lot of ground including why it took him so long to write on this subject, trad wife culture, Doug Wilson, why context matters as well as the “problem passages” that tend to solidify a complementarian theological view regarding women and how to exegete those passages. Do us a favor and share this episode with a friend, or maybe even a conservative pastor today. Preston has a unique ability to speak to the conservative Evangelical world on this topic and we really believe this book could be a catalyst for change in the church. Make sure you check out our Substack and become a paid subscriber for just $8 a month to hear our bonus Second Service episode where Preston and Katy explore what both egalitarians and complementarians sometimes get wrong when approaching this topic. You can view all of Preston’s work on www.theologyintheraw.com Purchase a copy (or two) of “From Genesis to Junia” by clicking here Don’t forget rate, review and subscribe anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 29: Rethinking Purim and Esther After Epstein | 03 Mar 2026 | 01:00:16 | |
Today on the podcast, Katy shares a conversation with Jessica LM Jenkins about the book of Esther, Purim, and rethinking the Biblical story in light of the Epstein files and the sexual exploitation of women and girls. Before listening, please know that topics surrounding human trafficking and sexual abuse are discussed in this episode, so please listen with care. If you or someone you know if suffering from sexual violence of any kind, please contact 1-800-656-4673 to speak to someone today. Make sure you’re a paid subscriber on Substack to hear our bonus Second Service conversation with Jessica. “Women of the Bible in Context” episodes that relate to our topic today: Naomi & Ruth: When Everything Falls Apart (Ruth 1:1-15) Epstein and the Church's response to the Sexual Abuse Crisis Don’t forget rate, review and subscribe anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| BONUS: Motherhood and Making Things that Matter with Joy Williams | 27 Feb 2026 | 00:52:40 | |
Today on the podcast, Katy shares a special bonus conversation with co-founder and owner of Ninni Co. pacifiers, Joy Williams. Katy and joy discuss all things related to starting a business and the joys and challenges of being an entrepreneur, as well as how Joy’s faith has both been strengthened and challenged during this journey. You’ll also hear some special, and very exciting news about Ninni Co. toward the end of the episode, so make sure you stay on till the end. Use code THEOLOGYGIRL at checkout when you shop at www.ninnico.com to receive 10% off your entire purchase. Make sure you check out our bonus Second Service episode on Substack where Joy shares things she had to “un-learn” about God to move forward as a mom and business owner. Don’t forget rate, review and subscribe anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 28: Melody, Message and Good News with Lloyd Nicks | 24 Feb 2026 | 00:49:12 | |
This week on the podcast, Katy shares a conversation she had with Grammy Award winning singer and songwriter, Lloyd Nicks, who wrote the popular worship song, “That’s My King”, made popular by CeCe Winans. Katy and Lloyd chat about all things worship leading, song writing, Gospel music, the Black church, and his new song “Heal For You”. You can stream “Heal For You” anywhere you listen to music and make sure you let Lloyd know how much you love the song by sharing it with friends and family on your social media accounts. Click here to listen to “Heal For You” Don’t forget rate, review and subscribe anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| BONUS: Sex Ed Reclaimed with Kristen Miele | 20 Feb 2026 | 00:52:20 | |
This week on the podcast, Katy shares a conversation she had with Kristen Miele, founder of Sex Ed Reclaimed. Sex Ed Relcaimed is a biblically grounded sex education curriculum helping Christian parents confidently teach sexuality to their kids — at every age, from 3 years old to 18 years old. Kristen has incredible courses available to purchase on her website, and you can use the code IMREADY for 20% off your purchase. Kristen and Katy talk about all things sexual education, purity culture, the gaps in public, private and homeschooling and Kristen shares some tangible tips for parents navigating what somewhat feels awkward and uncomfortable. Check out all of Kristen’s resources on her website www.sexedreclaimed.com and make sure you grab your course today. Tell a friend about her work and follow Kristen on Instagram @sexedreclaimed Don’t forget rate, review and subscribe anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 27: Why are Women Leaving the Church with Kimberly MacNeill | 17 Feb 2026 | 00:49:10 | |
This week on the podcast, Katy shares a powerful conversation with Pastor Kimberly MacNeill about why women are leaving the church and attending less than ever before. They discuss hyper masculinity in our Sunday services, sexual abuse scandals, and the lack of a female presence in church leadership as what may be contributing to this phenomenon, as well as provide advice for ministry leaders who seek to elevate the voices of women. Make sure you check out our bonus Substack episode for paid subscribers where Katy and Kim “re-imagine” what the church might look like if they looked to Jesus’s example of leadership, rather than power and authority. Books and Resources: The Blue Parakeet: Rethinking How You Read the Bible by Scot McKnight A Church Called Tov: Forming a Goodness Culture That Resists Abuses of Power and Promotes Healing by Scot McNight and Laura Barringer Jesus and Women: In the First Century and Now by Kristi McLelland Together in Ministry: Women and Men in Flourishing Partnerships by Rob Dixon Here is the article Kimberly referenced regarding most worship songs being written by men Don’t forget rate, review and subscribe anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologgirls | |||
| Episode 26: Women, the Bible, and the Faithfulness of God with Sandy Richter | 10 Feb 2026 | 00:55:08 | |
This week on the podcast we are sharing a conversation with Old Testament scholar, professor and author Sandy Richter. Sandy and Katy discuss women’s roles in the Old Testament, lesser known female characters, and what the church gets wrong when using the Old Testament (or Bible as a whole) as a way to prohibit women’s roles in church leadership. Make sure you check out our bonus Substack “Second Service” where Sandy covers the forward movement of scripture and normative vs. situational passages. You can find all of Sandy’s work on her website. Purchase Abigail and the Waterfall here and make sure you head to our Instagram to win a free copy. You can read Sandy’s work with Seedbed on Women in Leadership by clicking here. Make sure you rate, review and subscribe to the podcast anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 25: A Message for the Politically Homeless with Lauren Pinkston | 03 Feb 2026 | 00:37:56 | |
This week on the podcast we’re sharing a powerful conversation with Tennessee Gubernatorial candidate Lauren Pinkston about what makes her campaign as an Independent different. We chat about her faith in Jesus and how that informs her politics and how we can reach across the aisle to care for those who believe differently than us. Whether you live in Tennessee or not, this is a campaign and a movement that we all can support and get behind. If you find yourself disillusioned with politics and the two party system in America, support a candidate like Lauren so more people like her put their hat in the ring and decide to run for office. If you’re not already, subscribe to our paid Substack community for just $8 a month and listen to our bonus Second Service episode with Lauren where I ask her some pointed questions about the rise of Christian Nationalism. You can donate to Lauren’s campaign and learn more about her by clicking here. Check out Lauren’s podcast about bi-racial adoption by clicking here. You can read Lauren’s Substack article Would You Rather Be American or Christian? here. Don’t forget to rate, review and subscribe anywhere you listen to podcasts and make sure you follow us on Instagram @thetheolgoygirls | |||
| Episode 24: The Case for Theologically Rich Formation with Jocelynn Brewer | 30 Jan 2026 | 01:05:27 | |
This week on the podcast, we are sharing a conversation Katy had with her friend Jocelynn Brewer about the importance of having theologically rich Bible study material and curriculum for children and women and why there seems to be a gap for both of these demographics. They discuss how to handle tough questions from your kids as well as passenger princess theology, and whether or not women even desire deeper theological study. Check out 10 Dumb Things Smart Christians Believe by Larry Osborne by clicking here Purchase Rebecca McLaughlin’s book 10 Questions Every Teen Should Ask (and Answer) about Christianity Check out She Reads Truth and don’t forget to use code THETHEOLOGYGIRLS at checkout for 10% off Thank you to our sponsor Ninni Co. and make sure to use code THEOLOGYGIRL at checkout for 10% off your purchase Don’t forget to rate, review and subscribe anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls and subscribe on Substack by clicking here | |||
| Episode 23: Minneapolis and Loving Like Jesus | 27 Jan 2026 | 01:02:31 | |
This week we are taking a break from our normal podcast schedule and having a conversation with Elizabeth Berget and Laura Kelly Fanucci about what’s happening on the ground in Minnesota (specifically Minneapolis) and all that’s taken place due to the ICE presence there. We chat about who’s been impacted the most, including women, children and churches as well as the Christian response, regardless of what side of the aisle you find yourself. We also talk through what it looks like to care about secure borders but also be against the way immigration enforcement is being carried out. Make sure you check out our bonus episode on Substack for paid subscribers by clicking here. If you want to get involved, check out the resources below: Neighbor Notes on Substack Welcome the Stranger by Matthew Soerens Follow Sharon McMahon on Instagram Listen to The Holy Post Podcast Make sure you follow Elizabeth @elizabeth_a_berget and Laura @thismessygrace Don’t forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| BONUS: Women and Peacemaking with Shane Claiborne | 23 Jan 2026 | 00:39:34 | |
This week on the podcast, Katy shares a conversation she had with author and activist, Shane Claiborne. Shane provides insight Jesus shaped peacemaking, gun violence and the Christian response, or lack there of, when it comes to common sense gun reform. Katy and Shane also discuss what conservative women can do specifically to move the needle forward in their communities. This episode primarily highlights Shane’s book, “Beating Guns” which you can purchase here. Don’t forget to head to our Substack and listen to our Second Service episode where Katy asks Shane about the Evangelical refusal to speak up about gun violence and if he remains positive about the future. Check out Shane’s organization Red Letter Christians to learn about all the ways you can support his work there. And if you’d like to learn more about how Shane turns guns into garden tools, check out Raw Tools and all the phenomenal work they do. Don’t forget to rate, review and subscribe anywhere you listen and make sure to follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 22: Pilgrimage as a Faith Practice with Wendy Schulz | 20 Jan 2026 | 00:35:51 | |
This week on the podcast Katy sits down for a conversation with Wendy Schulz, founder of Life on Pilgrimage. Wendy shares about the modern pilgrimages she leads women on across Italy, Ireland and France and how pilgrimage can be an invitation to slow down and be present. You’ll also learn details about how exactly to participate in a pilgrimage and why traveling with Life on Pilgrimage is different than simply planning your own journey. Check out Life on Pilgrimage by clicking here and make sure you follow Wendy at @lifeonpilgrimage Don’t forget to rate, review and subscribe to the show anywhere you listen and follow us @thetheologygirls on Instagram | |||
| Episode 21: What’s God Really Saying Here with Matthew D. Kim | 13 Jan 2026 | 00:37:22 | |
This week on the podcast Katy sits down with pastor and professor Matthew D. Kim to have a conversation about his new book, “What’s God Really Saying Here?” which covers the bizarre, weird, and troubling passages in scripture. Matthew covers the difference between expository preaching and topical preaching, and why preachers should let the text interpret the text, as well as why we shouldn’t fear difficult passages in scripture. We also chat about the passages that didn’t make it into the book and Matthew shares a story of the fruit that came from teaching on a difficult topic in his own congregation. Purchase “What’s God Really Saying Here?” Make sure you rate, review and subscribe to the podcast anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 20: Becoming the Pastor’s Wife with Beth Allison Barr | 06 Jan 2026 | 00:52:06 | |
This week on the podcast Katy shares a powerful conversation with New York Times Best Selling Author Beth Allison Barr about her new book Becoming the Pastor’s Wife. Beth defines both patriarchy and complementarian theology, as well as provides an explanation as to why the roles of women have become limited in certain religious spaces. Beth also provides advice for women that find themselves in a church context that doesn’t affirm women in leadership roles. Make sure you check out our continued conversation with Beth on our Second Service bonus episode available on Substack. Purchase The Making of Biblical Womanhood by clicking here. Purchase Becoming the Pastor’s Wife by clicking here. Make sure you rate, review and subscribe to the podcast anywhere you listen and please follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirls | |||
| Episode 19: What Can Protestants Learn From Catholics with Mary Varni | 30 Dec 2025 | 00:52:36 | |
This week on the podcast Katy discusses what Protestants can learn from Catholics with Mary Varni. Mary works for the Archdiocese of St. Louis in their Respect Life office and is wealth of knowledge on Catholic social teaching and doctrine. Mary debunks a common misconception about whether or not Catholics pray “to” Saints and also what determines whether or not someone is truly pro-life or not. Learn more about the Respect Life Apostolate in St. Louis by clicking here. Read the Gospel of Life by here. Make sure you rate, review and subscribe to the podcast anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologygirl | |||
| Episode 18: A Historically Accurate Nativity with Jessica LM Jenkins | 23 Dec 2025 | 00:45:41 | |
This week we chatted with Jessica LM Jenkins about how reimagining a more historically accurate nativity can impact both how we elevate the voices of women as well as our faith and theology. Make sure you check our bonus Second Service episode on Substack where we discuss the nativity as an act of resistance and also how Mary’s story can give women hope today. Below we’ve included Jessica’s links so make sure you follow her and grab some of her nativity paper dolls for Christmas. Historically Accurate Nativity Explanation Podcast Episodes: #13 Historically Accurate Nativity Part 1 #14 Historically Accurate Nativity Part 2 #31 Presence Over Power: The Nativity as God's Answer to Trauma Visit Jessica’s website: www.wewhothirst.com Follow @jessicalmjenkins (Instagram, Threads, Facebook) Listen to Women of the Bible in Context: Her God, Her Story, Her Voice | |||
| BONUS LIVE: The Magnificat with Angela Beise | 19 Dec 2025 | 00:46:52 | |
Today we’ve got a special bonus LIVE recording to share with you from our quarterly in-person event “Magnify the Lord” where Pastor Angela Beise of The Crossing Grant’s Trail takes us on a deep dive into the Magnificat (otherwise known as Mary’s song). We hope this message encourages you and that you find hope in Mary’s story. Please make sure you share this episode with a friend, and don’t forget to rate, review and subscribe anywhere you listen. To visit The Crossing or find a campus near you, click the link here. | |||