Inspired by High Fidelity and the "Top 5" List, The Reel Debaters were founded by unapologetic movie nerds with "sharp minds" and a pure love of cinema from Manitoba's vibrant and ever-growing film scene.
each episode, this crew of cinephiles and industry insiders sit down to explore film and television through a lens that’s equal parts irreverent and insightful, with deep respect for storytelling and a sense of humour that doesn’t take itself too seriously.
When not arguing with each other to a sure and cinematic death, they fill the gaps with conversations from within Manitoba’s film industry stretching all the way to Hollywood's doorstep.
They even talked to a Kennedy.
Behind the ludicrous landscape that is their collective consciousness lies a genuine curiosity about how we connect with the stories we tell and the impact film has on who we are.
"I agreed that what really matters is what you like, not who you are like… Books, records, films – these things matter. Call me shallow, but it’s the fuckin’ truth"
Rob
Site
RSS
Apple
Data updated on 01/10/2026
Recent rankings
Latest chart positions across Apple Podcasts and Spotify rankings.
Shared links between episodes and podcasts
Links found in episode descriptions and other podcasts that share them.
Discover shows related to The Reel Debaters, based on actual content similarities. Explore podcasts with similar topics, themes, and formats, backed by real data.
#317 "We Didn't See These Movies" Top Summer Watch Lists
Season 8 · Episode 317
Sunday, September 27, 2026 • Duration 01:34:38
This week, the cast broods over the best movies and TV they consumed while on summer break; they introduce the new format of the show moving forward and bring Martin back for a long-awaited return after he was in video game design school.
The Oscars are supposed to be the final word on the best film of the year. But every movie fan has at least one moment where the envelope opens, and the reaction is: wait… what?
This week on The Reel Debaters, we step into the cinematic multiverse and debate the Oscars that almost were. If a single vote, campaign, or moment of momentum had shifted, the Academy’s history might look very different.
And what else would Oscar week be like with a conversation about good old Timothy Chalamet stepping on his own campaign with not-so-kind words about the ballet and opera, which gets a little attention as well.
Produced by: Jimmy Skinner, Emily Clark Charles Fernandes
Recorded and Mixed at: Sick Bad Panda Podcast Studios
Episode Description: Regaming the Oscars of the past to see if they went differently
The Reel Debaters Podcast combines movie debates, reviews, and interviews with filmmakers, actors, and creatives from across Canada and beyond — all from the heart of Winnipeg’s growing film community.
Proudly made in Manitoba, where Canada makes movies
Listen on: Spotify | Apple Podcasts | YouTube | Amazon Music | Google Podcasts
#315 "No, Moonlight is the Winner" The 2026 Oscar Predictions
Episode 315
Sunday, March 8, 2026 • Duration 01:34:42
Awards season is hitting its chaotic final lap, and the Reel Debaters are stepping into the prediction arena. In Episode 315, the panel breaks down their 2026 Oscar predictions, the unexpected moments and controversy from the BAFTAs, and the massive studio shake-up involving Netflix, Paramount, and Warner Bros.
Topics include:
The Best Picture showdown between One Battle After Another and Sinners
Why Paul Thomas Anderson may finally take Best Director
The rise of Michael B. Jordan as a Best Actor favorite for Sinners
Why Jessie Buckley’s performance in Hamnet is dominating the Best Actress race
Supporting category sleepers and potential Oscar night surprises
Plus the usual Reel Debaters arguments, jokes, and film nerd chaos.
Emily’s Link reference during the BAFTA Conversation:
#314 "Once Upon A Time In Hollywood" The Best What If's Part 2
Episode 314
Sunday, March 1, 2026 • Duration 02:12:59
In this episode, we open the alternate-universe vault and peek inside the casting decisions, last-minute rewrites, and near-misses that reshaped Hollywood history. Some were accidents. Some were gambles. All of them changed everything.
#313 Fast and Fictional: Drift Kings and Character Design. Create a new FF character.
Episode 313
Monday, February 23, 2026 • Duration 01:27:50
In Episode 313, we step on the gas and build a brand-new character for the final ride of the Fast & Furious saga. What kind of chaos agent joins the family? Street racer? International fixer? Long-lost legacy wildcard? We craft the backstory, the vibe, and how they would shake up the franchise’s last lap.
Then it’s review time:
The Beauty (FX)
Iron Lung (2026)
The Olympics.
Heated Rivalry (Crave)
New characters. Bold reviews. Big swings. Strap in and press play.
Next Reel Debaters Trivia+ Night
Rd trivia+ presents It’s always sunny in Philadelphia st Patrick’s day trivia+
In this episode, we lace up with legendary Hollywood shoemaker Jeff Churchill, the man whose craftsmanship has quite literally carried some of cinema’s biggest characters across the screen.
From the emotional textures of Jojo Rabbit to the high-speed intensity of Mission: Impossible, and across the superhero universes of Marvel and DC, Jeff has been quietly shaping movie history… one pair of boots at a time.
We go behind the scenes of his fascinating career, exploring:
-How he got started in the world of professional costuming and shoemaking
-What really goes into designing footwear for stunts, action, and character authenticity
-The pressure of working on massive franchise films
- Collaborating with costume designers, actors, and directors
-His creative process, from sketch to screen
-The hidden storytelling power of a great pair of shoes
With over 8 major films and series featuring his work hitting screens soon, Jeff’s craftsmanship is about to be everywhere. If characters are running, fighting, flying, or saving the world… chances are, they’re doing it in his shoes.
Tie your laces, step into the spotlight, and walk with us through one of the most fascinating careers in modern filmmaking.
#311 "10 Things We Fan Fic About You" Best Teen Heartthrob Fan Fiction Debate
Episode 311
Sunday, February 1, 2026 • Duration 01:24:42
Welcome back to the circus.
Episode #311 is stacked with fan fiction fantasies, Oscar-season chaos, and a classic Reel Debaters internet skirmish that absolutely did not need to happen.
This episode includes:
The Teen Heartthrob Fan Fiction Debate
We challenged each other to pitch the best teen heartthrob fan fiction idea imaginable. Tropes were abused. Logic was abandoned. Dignity left the building early. You’re welcome.
Movie Reviews
Mel Brooks’ The 99 Year Old Man – Does the comedy legend still have the spark, or is this one strictly for the diehards?
Predator: Badlands – New setting, same primal rules. We break down whether the franchise still knows how to hunt.
The Threads Fight That Wouldn’t Die...
Michael found himself deep in the trenches of Threads after arguing that Avatar being nominated for Best Costume Design actually makes sense. What followed was a spirited, slightly exhausting debate about CGI, world-building, and where costumes truly begin and end.
We also dig into why Wicked: For Good failed to land an Oscar nomination, with industry chatter pointing to awkward marketing, confusing campaign messaging, and reported voter fatigue. Was it politics, poor strategy, or just bad timing?
Reel Debaters Trivia+
Thank you to everyone who came out for Gilmore Girls Trivia+. You made it a night Stars Hollow would be proud of
#310 Coming Soon To A Calendar Near You, The 2026 Film And Tv Preview
Episode 310
Sunday, January 18, 2026 • Duration 01:48:38
The future is knocking, and it’s holding a release calendar.
In Episode 310, we crack open the crystal ball and take a long look at what 2026 has lined up for movies and television. From big studio swings to prestige TV gambles, we sort the hype from the head-scratchers and argue about what’s worth getting excited about.
Before we race ahead, we rewind briefly to Hollywood’s first major awards stop of the year with a review of the 2025 Golden Globes and....
The continued blur between film and television prestige, with streaming platforms flexing hard
A noticeable shift toward international stories and creators getting real spotlight
Wins that felt inevitable and some shocking losses
Whether the Globes are finally finding their footing again, or just better at throwing a party
Next Reel Debaters Trivia+ Night
January 29th At The Handsome Daughter
5 rounds of Themed Trivia, a colouring contest and cosplay challenge all in the theme of........... THE GILMORE GIRLS
Doors open at 645, Register at 7, Trivia starts at 730
Credits
Executive Producer: Michael Petrow
Jimmy Skinner Charles Fernandes
#308 If You Give A Chad A Spot with Finn Mccager Kristen Sawatzky and and Jesse De Rocquigny
Episode 308
Thursday, January 1, 2026 • Duration 59:45
In Episode 308, the Reel Debaters sit down with the DirectorFinn McCager, Actor and Stunt performer Kristen Sawatzky and CinematographerJesse de Rocquigny of Give a Chad a Spot for a deep dive into the making of the film. This conversation pulls back the curtain on indie filmmaking, creative collaboration, and the choices that shaped the final product you see on screen.
We cover:
The origin of Give a Chad a Spot and how the story came together
Writing the script and shaping the film’s tone
Casting, performances, and character development
Visual style, cinematography choices, and lighting choices
The challenges and rewards of independent filmmaking
Lessons learned from production and what’s next for the team
(The audio in this and a few previous episodes has suffered due to hidden gremlins in our mixer; it has been sorted and should no longer be an issue as we advance. Thank you for your patience)
Next Reel Debaters Trivia+ Night
Jan 29th @ The Handsome Daughter 61 Sherbrook Ave, Wpg, MB
5 rounds of Themed Trivia, a colouring contest and cosplay challenge all in the theme of........... THE GILMORE GIRLS
Tickets on sale now on Eventbrite and thereeldebaters.ca
Rush and Limited Seating
Doors open at 645, Register at 7, Trivia starts at 730
Episode Sponsors:
#309 Sinners, Witches and Alien(s) The 2025 Year In Review
Episode 309
Thursday, January 1, 2026 • Duration 01:52:46
“Can’t go back and keep making same mistakes. Must keep moving forward and make new ones.”
Thanks, Bridget.
Before we officially close the book, the Reel Debaters hit rewind one last time.
In Episode 309, we look back at the beautiful chaos that was 2025. The movies we loved. The shows we binged. The decisions that left us staring at the screen asking, “Who approved this?”
We debate what ruled the year, what completely missed the mark, and what surprised us for better or worse. Film, streaming, industry nonsense. Nothing escapes the recap.
Old arguments resurface. Closure is not guaranteed.
Next Reel Debaters Trivia+ Night
January 29th, at The Handsome Daughter IS THE GILMORE GIRLS Trivia+
Doors open at 645, Register at 7, Trivia starts at 730
Episode Sponsors:
Smash N Axe Throwing & Arcade.
Unleash your inner action hero with walk-in axe-throwing, classic arcade games, and cold drinks to celebrate your victories. Whether you’re blowing off steam or settling a movie debate the old-fashioned way, Smash N Axe is Winnipeg’s go-to spot for big throws and high scores.
Central Canada Comic Con (C4) returns to the Caboto Centre in Winnipeg on April 10 and 11 for two full days, celebrating Collectibles, Creators, Comics, and Cards.
Built by local collectors and supported by Manitoba vendors and artists, C4 is a community-driven show featuring vintage comics, rare cards, toys, original artwork, and hard-to-find collectibles. The event continues to grow as a prairie-based comic and collectibles show that brings fans of all ages together under one roof.
Credits
Executive Producer:Michael Petrow
Produced by: Emily Clark Jimmy Skinner Charles Fernandes
Recorded and Mixed at: Sick Bad Panda Podcast Studios
Episode Description:
The Reel Debaters Podcast combines movie debates, reviews, and interviews with filmmakers, actors, and creatives from across Canada and beyond — all from the heart of Winnipeg’s growing film community.
Proudly made in Manitoba, where Canada makes movies
Email Crystal Johnson at rudsfundraising@gmail.com
Credits
Executive Producer: Michael Petrow
Produced by: Jimmy Skinner Charles Fernandes
Recorded and Mixed at: Sick Bad Panda Podcast Studios
Episode Description: Best Hollywood What-If Moments
The Reel Debaters Podcast combines movie debates, reviews, and interviews with filmmakers, actors, and creatives from across Canada and beyond — all from the heart of Winnipeg’s growing film community.
Proudly made in Manitoba, where Canada makes movies
Listen on: Spotify | Apple Podcasts | YouTube | Amazon Music | Google Podcasts
Executive Producer: Michael Petrow
Produced by: Jimmy Skinner, Emily Clark
Recorded and Mixed at: Sick Bad Panda Podcast Studios
Episode Description: Create a brand new character for The Fast and The Furious franchise.
Guests:
The Reel Debaters Podcast combines movie debates, reviews, and interviews with filmmakers, actors, and creatives from across Canada and beyond — all from the heart of Winnipeg’s growing film community.
Proudly made in Manitoba, where Canada makes movies
Listen on: Spotify | Apple Podcasts | YouTube | Amazon Music | Google Podcasts
A Colouring Contest, A Cosplay Challenge, 4 rounds of Themed Trivia.
Prizes for all 3
Fandom Celebrates
On sale now Eventbrite.ca | Link in bio | thereeldebaters.ca
Credits
Executive Producer: Michael Petrow
Produced by: Charles Fernandes
Recorded and Mixed at: Sick Bad Panda Podcast Studios
Guests: Jeff Churchill
The Reel Debaters Podcast combines movie debates, reviews, and interviews with filmmakers, actors, and creatives from across Canada and beyond — all from the heart of Winnipeg’s growing film community.
Proudly made in Manitoba, where Canada makes movies
Listen on: Spotify | Apple Podcasts | YouTube | Amazon Music | Google Podcasts
Subscribe to find out about the next trivia night. We have 2 in the works and will be announcing soon!
Credits
Executive Producer: Michael Petrow
Produced by: Emily Clark Jimmy Skinner Charles Fernandes
Recorded and Mixed at: Sick Bad Panda Podcast Studios
Episode Description: Invent a teen heartthrob-inspired fan fiction idea
The Reel Debaters Podcast combines movie debates, reviews, and interviews with filmmakers, actors, and creatives from across Canada and beyond — all from the heart of Winnipeg’s growing film community.
Proudly made in Manitoba, where Canada makes movies
Listen on: Spotify | Apple Podcasts | YouTube | Amazon Music | Google Podcasts
Produced by:
Recorded and Mixed at: Sick Bad Panda Podcast Studios
Episode Description: 2026 film and tv preview
The Reel Debaters Podcast combines movie debates, reviews, and interviews with filmmakers, actors, and creatives from across Canada and beyond — all from the heart of Winnipeg’s growing film community.
Proudly made in Manitoba, where Canada makes movies
Listen on: Spotify | Apple Podcasts | YouTube | Amazon Music | Google Podcasts
Smash N Axe Throwing & Arcade.
Unleash your inner action hero with walk-in axe-throwing, classic arcade games, and cold drinks to celebrate your victories. Whether you’re blowing off steam or settling a movie debate the old-fashioned way, Smash N Axe is Winnipeg’s go-to spot for big throws and high scores.
Listener Deal:
Get $15 off your first hour of walk-in axe throwing and $5 off a Transcanada Bluebeary Beer when you mention Dr. Smashington.
Smash N Axe Throwing & Arcade – Winnipeg
Throw hard. Game harder.
Credits
Executive Producer: Michael Petrow
Recorded and Mixed at: Sick Bad Panda Podcast Studios
Episode Description: If you give a chad a spot review and interview
Guests: Finn McCager, Kristen Sawatzky, Jesse De Rocquigny
The Reel Debaters Podcast combines movie debates, reviews, and interviews with filmmakers, actors, and creatives from across Canada and beyond — all from the heart of Winnipeg’s growing film community.
Proudly made in Manitoba, where Canada makes movies
Listen on: Spotify | Apple Podcasts | YouTube | Amazon Music | Google Podcasts
Listener Deal:
Get $15 off your first hour of walk-in axe throwing and $5 off a Transcanada Bluebeary Beer when you mention Dr. Smashington.
Smash N Axe Throwing & Arcade – Winnipeg
Throw hard. Game harder.
Credits
Executive Producer: Michael Petrow
Produced by: Emily Clark Jimmy Skinner Charles Fernandes
Recorded and Mixed at: Sick Bad Panda Podcast Studios
Episode Description: Year IN Review 2025
The Reel Debaters Podcast combines movie debates, reviews, and interviews with filmmakers, actors, and creatives from across Canada and beyond — all from the heart of Winnipeg’s growing film community.
Proudly made in Manitoba, where Canada makes movies