Three egg donors, a failed embryo transfer, and a wildfire threatening their frozen embryos. Justin Ziegler and his husband Michael's journey to becoming gay dads was anything but straightforward.
Justin is a gay dad, ordained pastor, and founder of Very Gay, Very Busy. He joins Jaimie to share the emotional, financial, and logistical realities of building a family through surrogacy, including why they chose an agency, how they navigated heartbreaking setbacks, and the importance of finding your village.
They also dig into the double standards of LGBTQ parenting, and how Justin found acceptance in his Christian faith while embracing his identity as a gay man.
It's a conversation about family building, resilience, faith, and the extraordinary lengths we go to become parents.
π³οΈβπ About the guest(s)/ Resources Mentioned
Justin Ziegler is a gay dad, ordained pastor, entrepreneur, and founder of Very Gay, Very Busy, a LGBTQ gift and merchandise business. He lives in Connecticut with his husband, Michael, and their son, Bennett, whom they welcomed through gestational surrogacy.
π³οΈβπ Interested in advertising? Email thequeerfamilypodcast@gmail.com
π³οΈβπ Resources Mentioned
- Very Gay, Very Busy β Justin's LGBTQ gift and merchandise business, featuring totes, mugs, stickers, and more. You can also reach out to Justin through his website.
π§ Loved this episode?
Support The Queer Family Podcast on Patreon for exclusive bonus content and help keep these stories alive!
Β
π³οΈβπ What resonated most with you? Drop a comment, DM us, or email thequeerfamilypodcast@gmail.comβwe love hearing your stories!
π³οΈβπ Letβs Connect! Find us on IG, TikTok, Bluesky, & YouTube: @thequeerfamilypodcast π³οΈβπ Watch full episodes on YouTube
π³οΈβπ Order the If These Ovaries Could Talk book
π³οΈβπ Edited by: Jerson BarajasΒ π³οΈβπ Theme Song by: Tiffany Topol π³οΈβπ Logo by: Daneen Stevenato
π³οΈβπ Shop merch here. π³οΈβπ Full transcript & episode info available on our website
π³οΈ VOTE. π³οΈβππ³οΈββ§οΈ ADVOCATE. πΌ BUILD QUEER FAMILIES.
The information shared in this episode is for educational purposes only and not a substitute for professional advice. Always consult a trusted professional for your specific situation!
π³οΈβπ Chapters:
00:00 β The emotional toll of fertility treatments and building empathy
00:41 β Jaimie's introduction and her NYC construction nightmare
04:45 β Meet Justin Ziegler: gay dad, pastor, and entrepreneur
07:20 β Knowing he wanted to be a dad since childhood
08:31 β Growing up gay in rural Iowa without LGBTQ role models
09:54 β Coming out and choosing surrogacy as a path to parenthood
12:17 β Choosing a surrogacy agency and navigating the legal process
13:50 β When the LA wildfires threatened their frozen embryos
15:22 β Fertility clinics and the loss of privacy in LGBTQ family building
18:39 β Three egg donor setbacks before finding the right match
22:15 β Finding their gestational carrier
25:27 β Failed embryo transfer, grief, and supporting your partner
26:47 β How surrogacy changed Justin's understanding of infertility
27:00 β A Father's Day pregnancy surprise
29:12 β Bringing baby Bennett home on a 20-hour road trip
30:56 β Do gay dads get more parenting support than moms?
32:21 β Why aren't there changing tables in men's bathrooms?
35:46 β Reconciling Christianity, faith, and LGBTQ identity
38:47 β Facing discrimination on the path to becoming a pastor
41:09 β Finding God through love, acceptance, and community
44:12 β Agency vs. independent surrogacy: Is the cost savings worth it?
47:09 β Why emotional support matters throughout the surrogacy journey
48:51 β Very Gay, Very Busy: Turning queer merchandise into a business
50:01 β Justin's message to prospective LGBTQ parents
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.