Asking a simple question
Iâve been pondering a deceptively simple question: What makes a photograph good as part of my book club this month? But, before diving into that, a couple of quick announcements! Iâve got some new workshops lined up in 2027 at Badlands, Adventures in the Palouse, and the Oregon Coast and Redwoods. Check out the details on my website. Plus, Iâll be teaching a masterclass called âThe Landscape is Languageâ at the Photographic Center Northwest in November 2026.
As for the topic of episode 596, the source of this question comes from re-reading The View from the Studio Door by Ted Orland. In the section Art & Society, Ted comes up with an interesting answer that we will get to at the end of the podcast. Sure, the what is a good photography questionseems like it should have a straightforward answer. We could list out a bunch of qualities: composition, light, color, timing, technical skill, originality, emotion. Maybe a photo resonates because it communicates something important or makes us pause and reflect. So, what are we really talking about when we say a photograph is good?
First off, we need to distinguish between âgoodâ and âbeautiful.â A photograph can be stunning without really offering much depth. Gorgeous light, perfect composition, beautiful colorsâsure, but does it say anything? Conversely, a photograph can be rough around the edges but still pack an emotional punch.Â
Good isnât necessarily beautiful
First off, we need to distinguish between âgoodâ and âbeautiful.â A photograph can be stunning without really offering much depth. Gorgeous light, perfect composition, beautiful colorsâsure, but does it say anything? Conversely, a photograph can be rough around the edges but still pack an emotional punch.
Who gets to decide?
Who determines what makes a photograph good? Is it because I like it? A critic? Other photographers? Does it matter if itâs hanging in a museum or selling at auction? Or is it simply about whether the creator feels they achieved what they set out to do? The more I reflect, the more I realize there isnât a universal standard for artâand maybe thatâs just fine.
What if we judged the âgoodnessâ of a photograph by its impact?
â Does it make me stop?
â Does it hold my gaze?
Can a Bad Photograph Still Be Good?
We donât make masterpieces one at a time
Tedâs key point with the photograph as a stepping stone