Real Life. Real Faith. Real Conversations.
The Lighten Up Podcast with Hannah Crews is powered by Truthly, the #1 most downloaded Catholic AI app in the world! Protect your soul and identity while using Truthly Catholic AI. For a Catholic perspective on ANY response, download Truthly today - available on mobile and desktop. https://web.truthly.ai/login
Join the Book Club on Patreon where we read and discuss books on original Christianity! "Elite" members unlock more bonus content from the podcast episodes!
https://www.patreon.com/cw/TheLightenUpPodcast/membership
Site
RSS
Apple
Data updated on 14/10/2026
Recent rankings
Latest chart positions across Apple Podcasts and Spotify rankings.
Shared links between episodes and podcasts
Links found in episode descriptions and other podcasts that share them.
The Story of Susanna is Missing from Protestant Bibles. SO LET'S READ IT!
Episode 39
Monday, October 12, 2026 • Duration 16:59
There’s a powerful story in the Catholic Bible that many Protestant and evangelical Christians have never read: the Story of Susanna in Daniel 13. It’s a story of false accusations, abuse of authority, unwavering faith, and God’s justice—and it may be exactly the encouragement someone needs to hear today.
In this episode of the Lighten Up Podcast, Hannah Crews reads the full story of Susanna and explores why this portion of the Book of Daniel appears in Catholic Bibles but is often absent from Protestant Bibles.
This is a story about trusting God when you are falsely accused, standing firm in your faith when the truth seems hidden, and remembering that God sees what others cannot.
Hannah also shares why this ancient biblical account deeply resonates with her own testimony, including the painful experience of facing a lawsuit for speaking the truth. Although our experiences may differ from Susanna’s, her story reminds us that we can turn to God in seasons of trauma, injustice, and despair.
🎙️ IN THIS EPISODE:
00:00 — Why Catholic Bibles Are Different From Protestant Bibles
03:20 — Hannah’s Testimony: Faith Through Injustice and Suffering
04:15 — Introducing the Story of Susanna in Daniel 13
06:25 — The Story of Susanna Begins: Two Corrupt Elders
08:00 — Susanna Refuses to Compromise Her Faith
09:40 — False Accusations and an Unjust Trial
11:00 — Susanna Cries Out to God
12:45 — Daniel Exposes the Elders’ Lies
14:20 — God Delivers Susanna From Injustice
15:00 — What Susanna’s Story Teaches Us About Faith and Suffering
How Scripture Made Him CATHOLIC: Dr. John Bergsma’s Story
Episode 38
Monday, October 5, 2026 • Duration 58:16
In this powerful episode of the Lighten Up Podcast, Hannah Crews sits down with Dr. John Bergsma, author of Stunned by Scripture: How the Bible Made Me Catholic, to talk about his remarkable journey from a deeply anti-Catholic Calvinist background to the Catholic Church.
Dr. Bergsma shares how questions about sola scriptura, Scripture and Tradition, the papacy, the Eucharist, Church history, and the early Church Fathers began challenging everything he thought he knew about Christianity.
Together, Hannah and Dr. Bergsma explore… where did the concept of sola scriptura come from? What is the meaning of binding and loosing in the biblical and Jewish context? And how can the Catholic understanding of redemptive suffering transform the way Christians understand suffering?
Whether you're Catholic, Protestant, evangelical, considering conversion, or simply curious about the historical roots of Christianity, this conversation is an invitation to go deeper into Scripture, Church history, and the faith of the earliest Christians.
🎙️ IN THIS EPISODE:
00:00 - Dr. Bergsma's background
06:23 - Where did sola scriptura come from?
12:13 - Why Scripture needs an authoritative interpretation
18:09 - Is the papacy biblical?
25:20 - The Paradox of Sola Scriptura
27:05 - Does the Bible affirm Tradition?
32:10 - The cost of becoming Catholic
37:33 - Scripture AND Tradition
39:41 - Protestant traditions we don't always recognize
41:32 - Books to read when exploring Catholicism
45:46 - Redemptive suffering; taking up our cross
Commitment and Conflict: Finding Love in Today’s World with Emily Dinneny
Episode 37
Monday, September 28, 2026 • Duration 44:48
Why is dating so hard today? Why are fewer people getting married, and why do so many people struggle to find lasting love?
In this episode, Hannah Crews and Emily Dinneny get brutally honest about Catholic dating, modern relationships, marriage, dating apps, cohabitation, and what it really means to find true love. If you're single, dating, engaged, newly married, or struggling in your relationship, this conversation is for you.
Emily Dinneny joins the Lighten Up Podcast to unpack why modern dating can feel so complicated — even though we have more ways than ever to meet someone. From dating apps and unrealistic expectations to fear of commitment, past wounds, and confusion about what love actually is, Hannah and Emily tackle the questions so many people are afraid to ask.
They also discuss YouCat Love Forever, a Catholic book that answers practical questions about dating, relationships, marriage, sexuality, and preparing for a lifelong commitment.
🎙️ IN THIS EPISODE:
00:00 - Emily's experience as a newlywed
04:46 - Why are people getting married later?
06:32 - Dating apps and “analysis paralysis”
08:24 - Introducing YouCat Love Forever
15:02 - What does real love actually mean?
20:29 - Cohabitation, sex, and commitment
29:50 - The questions people are afraid to ask
32:54 - Healing from past wounds before marriage
40:32 - Emily's best marriage advice
43:05 - Where to find Emily
“Oh no! They’re becoming CATHOLIC!” How to Have Faith Conversations w/o Ruining Relationships
Episode 36
Monday, September 21, 2026 • Duration 32:25
What do you do when someone you love is considering becoming Catholic?
In this episode of the Lighten Up Podcast, Hannah Crews shares practical advice for both sides of the Catholic conversion conversation: Protestants who are concerned about a family member becoming Catholic and Protestants or Christians who are personally exploring the Catholic faith but aren't sure how to tell their friends and family.
These conversations can be emotional and difficult, especially when Catholicism feels completely unfamiliar or even threatening to someone raised in a Protestant or evangelical tradition. But they don't have to destroy relationships.
Whether you're Catholic curious, considering converting to Catholicism, worried about a loved one becoming Catholic, or simply trying to understand the Catholic-Protestant divide, this episode is about pursuing truth while continuing to love and respect the people closest to you.
🎙️ IN THIS EPISODE:
00:00 Understanding the Protestant Perspective on Catholicism
03:38 Advice for Protestants: Listening with love
07:33 Question Gently BEFORE Debating
09:05 Personal Research & One Thing at a Time
13:27 Don’t be afraid to lay down your pride
15:17 A Perfect Example: My Mom
18:00 Advice for Catholics & the Curious: Share with Joy
22:52 Know Your WHY & Breaking the News
25:15 Be Prepared for backlash
28:06 Consider Joining OCIA
A Conversation on Birth Control & Becoming Catholic w/ Kimberly Hahn
Episode 35
Monday, September 14, 2026 • Duration 45:08
What happens when you discover that the Catholic Church may be far more biblical, historical, and beautiful than you ever imagined?
In this powerful episode of the Lighten Up Podcast, Hannah sits down with Kimberly Hahn, co-author of Rome Sweet Home, for an honest and deeply personal conversation about her journey from evangelical Protestantism to the Catholic Church.
Kimberly shares what it was like to watch her husband, Scott Hahn, become convinced that the Catholic Church was the Church established by Jesus Christ—and then spend four long years wrestling with the truth herself. She opens up about the emotional weight of the conversion process, her convictions surrounding contraception and openness to life, and encourages people to share the faith with joy.
🎙️ IN THIS EPISODE:
00:00 Kimberly Hahn and Scott Hahn's conversion story
04:14 The Hardest Doctrine: Mary
10:23 PATREON Q: Reconciling Faith and Family Challenges
19:10 Discovering the Church's Teaching on Contraception
24:23 Natural Law and the Purpose of Life
26:44 Lordship of Jesus and Responsible Sexuality
27:49 Natural Family Planning and what it really means
31:12 The Consistency of Catholic Teaching
35:22 Sharing the faith with joy
42:56 Kimberly's Final Words and Contact Info
📌Episode Resources:
Rome Sweet Home by Scott & Kimberly Hahn -
Catholic Stuff the Protestant Reformers ALSO Believed! (I HAD NO CLUE)
Episode 34
Monday, September 7, 2026 • Duration 25:41
Did the Protestant Reformers actually believe what most modern Evangelicals believe today? In this episode of the Lighten Up Podcast, Hannah Crews takes a surprising look at what the Reformers really believed about baptism, the Eucharist, Mary, and the early Christian Church.
Many of us were taught that the Protestant Reformation completely rejected Catholic beliefs—but the historical record is more complicated. Martin Luther and John Calvin continued to hold several beliefs that are often considered distinctly Catholic today, including infant baptism and, in Luther’s case, the real presence of Jesus in the Eucharist.
So what did the early Christians actually believe? How did their understanding of Scripture compare with modern Evangelical Christianity? And what can we learn from Christians who lived much closer to the apostles?
🎙️ IN THIS EPISODE:
00:00 We should want the truth
04:49 Baptism: From the perspective of the Reformers
07:58 They believed in the Real Presence in the Eucharist
12:47 Mary: Perpetual Virginity and Conception
17:56 The Communion of Saints and Prayers to Mary
18:57 Why Do These Beliefs Matter?
23:35 The Importance of Historical Christian Doctrine
📌Episode Resources:
Jesus and the Jewish Roots of the Eucharist — Brant Pitre
Jesus and the Jewish Roots of Mary — Brant Pitre
🔔 SUBSCRIBE to the Lighten Up Podcast and help us reach 50,000 subscribers!
Are Catholic Icons Idolatry? A Former Protestant & Iconographer Explains
Episode 33
Monday, August 31, 2026 • Duration 42:38
Are Catholics idolaters for using icons, statues, and sacred images? What does the Bible actually teach about “graven images,” and why does the Catholic Church distinguish between worship, veneration, and prayer?
In this episode of the Lighten Up Podcast, Hannah Crews sits down with Garrett Hines, a former Protestant and evangelical missionary who became Catholic and now works as an iconographer. Garrett shares his conversion story, explains the ancient Christian tradition of iconography, and answers some of the biggest Protestant objections to Catholic images, statues, and praying with the saints.
If you've ever wondered “Are Catholic icons idolatry?”, “Do Catholics worship statues?”, or “Is praying to saints biblical?”, this conversation is for you.
🎙️ IN THIS EPISODE:
00:00 Why Garrett left Protestantism and became Catholic
08:15 What an icon actually is
11:55 Why icons are “written” rather than simply painted
19:22 Idols vs. Icons: The Theological Distinction
23:12 Why Catholics venerate icons without worshiping them
27:53 The Catholic distinction between prayer and worship
34:52 The history of Christian iconography and the Iconoclasm
Guardian Angels Protected Family in Horrific Car Crash: Addi’s Story
Episode 32
Monday, August 24, 2026 • Duration 30:46
What happens when a horrific car accident leaves you convinced you and your children should not have survived?
In this episode of the Lighten Up podcast, Hannah Crews sits down with Addi Christensen, host of the Voices of Conversion podcast, to talk about her incredible journey from a Protestant upbringing to the Catholic Church—and the life-changing experience that deepened her faith forever.
Addi shares the story of a devastating car accident she experienced while 28 weeks pregnant, with her one-year-old son in the car. She believes all 3 of their guardian angels intervened in a miraculous way. We also talk about how Addi discovered the early Church, apostolic succession, the Brown Scapular, and why keeping our eyes fixed on eternity can completely change the way we live.
🎙️ IN THIS EPISODE:
00:00 Addi's journey from Lutheran/Protestant Christianity to Catholicism
04:08 The Moment of Conversion and Realization of Jesus' Love
08:13 The Life-Changing Experience with Holy Water
13:02 The Car Accident and Guardian Angel Encounter
The Moment My Heart Changed about Mary and the Eucharist
Episode 31
Monday, August 17, 2026 • Duration 24:08
What happens when your heart finally catches up with what your mind already knows? In this deeply personal episode of the Lighten Up Podcast, I’m sharing the powerful experience that changed the way I see Mary, the Eucharist, and the Catholic Church during the Defend the Faith Conference at Franciscan University of Steubenville.
After months of researching Catholicism, wrestling with difficult questions, and navigating the challenges of leaving the Protestant church, I arrived at the conference intellectually convinced—but still asking God to reveal the truth to my heart.
Then, during my first Eucharistic Adoration procession, something happened… I felt my heart shift in a profound way.
If you're a Protestant or evangelical Christian asking questions about Catholicism, know that you're not alone. This podcast is a place to explore those questions honestly, openly, and without fear. And I encourage you, if you’re feeling caught between what you believe intellectually and what you are struggling to accept emotionally… Surrender your heart to Jesus and ask Him to lead you into the truth.
Thank you to our sponsors!
✨Truthly: Catholic ai
Any question. Instant clarity.
Use the link below to try it yourself! First week's free.
Was the Early Church Catholic? Orthodox? Protestant? Joe Heschmeyer Explains!
Episode 30
Monday, August 10, 2026 • Duration 49:06
What did the early Church really believe? Was it Catholic or Orthodox? Was it a loose, anything-goes version of modern Protestantism like we see today? Joe Heschmeyer, the host of the Shameless Popery Podcast and apologist at Catholic Answers, argues that it was unmistakably Catholic. In this episode, Joe sits down with Hannah to unpack the evidence from Scripture, church history, and the early Church Fathers. He explains why the Christian story makes far more sense when you follow the visible Church Jesus actually established, rather than trying to reconstruct the faith from private interpretation alone.
Joe also tackles one of the biggest questions for Catholic-curious Christians: if Protestantism doesn't match the early Church, why not Orthodoxy? He walks through the leadership structure of the Church, the role of Rome, and the historical case for apostolic succession in a way that is clear, direct, and deeply thought-provoking.
If you’ve been wrestling with church history, Catholic identity, or what “original Christianity” really means, this episode gives you a compelling framework for moving forward without waiting to have every answer first.
📖 BOOK CLUB: We're almost done reading Stunned by Scripture: How the Bible Made Me Catholic by Dr. John Bergsma. Join us for our weekly Friday discussions through Patreon or YouTube Memberships.
📖 BOOK CLUB: We're currently reading Stunned by Scripture: How the Bible Made Me Catholic by Dr. John Bergsma. Join us for our weekly Friday discussions through Patreon or YouTube Memberships.
📖 BOOK CLUB: We're currently reading Stunned by Scripture: How the Bible Made Me Catholic by Dr. John Bergsma. Join us for our weekly Friday discussions through Patreon or YouTube Memberships.
📖 BOOK CLUB: We're currently reading Stunned by Scripture: How the Bible Made Me Catholic by Dr. John Bergsma. Join us for our weekly Friday livestream through Patreon or YouTube Memberships.
📖 BOOK CLUB: We're currently reading Stunned by Scripture: How the Bible Made Me Catholic by Dr. John Bergsma. Join us for our weekly Friday discussions through Patreon or YouTube Memberships.
📖 BOOK CLUB: We're currently reading Stunned by Scripture: How the Bible Made Me Catholic by Dr. John Bergsma. Join us for our weekly Friday discussions through Patreon or YouTube Memberships.
📖 BOOK CLUB: We're currently reading Stunned by Scripture: How the Bible Made Me Catholic by Dr. John Bergsma. Join us for our weekly Friday discussions through Patreon or YouTube Memberships.
00:00 Joe Heschmeyer on how Shameless Popery got its name
04:37 Why the early Church matters for Protestant listeners
07:08 How Christians know the Gospels belong in the Bible
10:50 The claim that the Reformation restored the early Church
14:56 Why the Protestant Old Testament was not fixed in Jesus’ day
17:05 Why not Orthodox instead of Catholic?
19:36 Acts 15 and the authority of the apostles and elders
24:25 Peter’s role and the keys of the kingdom
26:38 Catholic, Orthodox, and Protestant models of authority
31:28 Objections about Vatican corruption and scandal
33:27 Schism, Israel’s failures, and bad leaders in sacred office
39:52 Don’t wait to know everything before becoming Catholic
43:40 Theology as love, not trivia
46:57 Where to find Joe Heschmeyer and Shameless Popery
Related Shows Based on Content Similarities
Discover shows related to The Lighten Up Podcast, based on actual content similarities. Explore podcasts with similar topics, themes, and formats, backed by real data.