Lights off? Flashlight on? Then it’s time for The Creepover, the weekly creepy slumber party podcast, hosted by wives Kathryn & Alli Ormsbee. Tune in every Friday night as we gab about your favorite horror movies, scary shows, & true crime documentaries. It's basically the same vibe you'd get on a late October night in a suburban basement, circa 1999, cozied up with your close friends for a spooky sleepover.
Take your spot in the blanket fort as we discuss all things macabre, supernatural, and bone-chilling—with just the right amount of comedy and cozy nostalgia. And remember: When the ghoulin' gets tough, don't be afraid to scream like a girl.
Site
RSS
Apple
Data updated on 22/09/2026
Recent rankings
Latest chart positions across Apple Podcasts and Spotify rankings.
Shared links between episodes and podcasts
Links found in episode descriptions and other podcasts that share them.
Hello, dear listeners! We’re back from our summer hiatus with an announcement: After three amazing years, we’ve decided to bring The Creepover to an end. But we’re not clicking off our flashlights without one final farewell episode! GHOST STORIES: Listener Abby recounts her visit to the purportedly haunted Crescent Hotel. CREEPED OUT: Kathryn checks in with one final update on the infamous murder hornets of Washington State. STRANGER THAN FICTION: Alli & Kathryn share their six favorite memories and movies from Creepover history. BUMP IN THE NIGHT: The Smiling Gentleman. The Beach, Part III. BONUS: Noisemakers, haunted water energy, the buzzy buzzies, and deep cut Parent Trap references.
Join the Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/thecreepoverpodcast
Follow us on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/thecreepoverpodcast/
Visit our website: https://thecreepover.com/
Artwork by Blake Anderson
Theme Music by Luca Francini
Goldfish Are Forever (The Bluebelle Murders)
Friday, July 16, 2021 • Duration 58:18
Got you life preserver safely fastened and secured? Because we're diving back into the deep end of True Crime Harbor for this week's episode. Join us as we finish up our coverage of Nautical Nights and announce a summer hiatus. CREEPED OUT: Alli shares the recent news of Minnesotan football-sized goldfish. STRANGER THAN FICTION: Kathryn tells the harrowing story of the Bluebelle murders. BUMP IN THE NIGHT: Glass Bottom Boat. BONUS: Hibernation cheese, seaman talk, chicken cacciatore, sinkholes, and life insurance vending machines.
Come on in, the water's fine! Unless that's . . . a sea serpent right there. Beneath your feet. In the murky waters. Yep. This week we're gabbing about two of the world's FAVE nautical cryptids. GHOST STORIES: A special promo from Tara and Jessica at 3 Spooked Girls! CREEPED OUT: Alli gives an encouraging update on the Hailey Dunn case. STRANGER THAN FICTION: Kathryn takes Alli on an underwater adventure as they talk sea serpents and krakens. BUMP IN THE NIGHT: Night Fishing. BONUS: The Lifting of the Cat, the Great American Sea Serpent, and the Circle of Poop.
Dunn family private investigator claims Scurry County law enforcement stalled Shawn Adkins arrest for years by Shane Battis via CBS7
Great White Turd (Jaws)
Sunday, July 4, 2021 • Duration 01:17:23
In this special 4th of July episode, we’re paying a visit to Amity Island, AKA the perfect feeding ground! Join us as we talk Mayor Ted Reagan, bad seaman accents, bunny knots, clenched butts, Michael Douglas, mooore corporate greed, and Bruce the Musical.
Send us a note at: thecreepoverpodcast@gmail.com
Join the Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/thecreepoverpodcast
Follow us on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/thecreepoverpodcast/
The HMS Creepover (The Disappearance of Amy Lynn Bradley)
Friday, July 2, 2021 • Duration 01:19:20
Look, everyone. This episode is not a cruise, but once again, it DOES have something to do with our Nautical Nights theme. Care to come aboard? GHOST STORIES: Listener Celine shares a tale of childhood doll horror. CREEPED OUT: The mysterious wheezing kazoo on the Golden Gate Bridge. STRANGER THAN FICTION: Kathryn shares the infuriating story of Amy Lynn Bradley’s 1998 cruise ship disappearance. BUMP IN THE NIGHT: Intruders Can Hug Too. BONUS: Alli’s Midnight Howl, Kathryn’s calves, little lambs ears, butt pillows, crappy captains, and full body chills.
Send us a note at: thecreepoverpodcast@gmail.com
Join the Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/thecreepoverpodcast
Follow us on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/thecreepoverpodcast/
Well, hey there, Creepover Fam! Why don’t you hop onboard the HMS Creepover this fine Friday evening for yet another voyage into our summer series, Nautical Nights? GHOST STORIES: Listener Geniene shares a terrifying encounter with a cicada. CREEPED OUT: Taxidermy frogs and the wild world of amphibian ethics. STRANGER THAN FICTION: Kathryn and Alli discuss the controversial drowning of Hollywood star Natalie Wood. BUMP IN THE NIGHT: The Doppel Test. BONUS: Jason’s backstory, a murder of crows, Froggyland, Stage Moms from Hell, starter marriages, the Princess of Olive Garden, and plenty of dinghies.
Send us a note at: thecreepoverpodcast@gmail.com
Join the Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/thecreepoverpodcast
Follow us on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/thecreepoverpodcast/
Visit our website: https://thecreepover.com/
Artwork by Blake Anderson
Theme Music by Luca Francini
This Week’s Sources:
Creeped Out:
Welcome To Froggyland, The Croatian Taxidermy Museum That May Soon Come To The U.S. by Rob Schmitz via NPR
Not Professionals (The Haunting of the Queen Mary)
Friday, June 18, 2021 • Duration 01:20:47
Ding, ding! All aboard, ‘cause we’re introducing a shiny new summer series: Nautical Nights! Join us as we cruise the high seas in our next several episodes, exploring the frights and terror of the deep blue sea. GHOST STORIES: Listeners Olivia & Jonah share their frightful coastal Walpurgisnacht experience. CREEPED OUT: A Humpback Whale of a Tale. STRANGER THAN FICTION: Kathryn takes Alli on a wild ride through the Queen Mary’s history and hauntings. BUMP IN THE NIGHT: Beachside Surprise. BONUS: Magic School Bus wound splashing, mermaid witches, calls to all marine biologists and lobster divers, boat lingo, rogue waves, eccentric local millionaires, deadly drinks, poison control PSA, and the seven dwarves boy band.
Send us a note at: thecreepoverpodcast@gmail.com
Join the Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/thecreepoverpodcast
Follow us on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/thecreepoverpodcast/
A Head of Cole Slaw (I Know What You Did Last Summer)
Tuesday, June 15, 2021 • Duration 01:16:08
Hey. You. We know what you did last summer. Jk! That’d be creepy. But if you want something to do THIS summer, you can always tune in to our coverage of the 90s teen scream extravaganza that haunted many a youth. Join us as we talk straw bucket hats, D.A.R.E. Moms gone wrong, an excess of male aggression, crab cars, missed punny department store name opportunities, and Captain Hook’s origin story.
Send us a note at: thecreepoverpodcast@gmail.com
Join the Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/thecreepoverpodcast
Follow us on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/thecreepoverpodcast/
In this, our final patron-suggested episode, we're headed Down Under to discuss some legendary Aussie spooky tales—in particular, the haunting of Monte Cristo Homestead in Junee. GHOST STORIES: Fred Fisher's Ghost. CREEPED OUT: UFOs, alien autopsy auctions, Brood X updates, and mutant magnetism. STRANGER THAN FICTION: Kathryn tells the sordid, sadistic tales from one of Australia's most haunted houses. BUMP IN THE NIGHT: Deep Dive. BONUS: Inner Eeyores and Outer Tiggers, Speech Pathology Corner with Henry Higgins, storm drain ghosts, hot weather air balloons, minimum raise, bark digestion, and 8,000 dolls.
Send us a note at: thecreepoverpodcast@gmail.com
Join the Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/thecreepoverpodcast
Follow us on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/thecreepoverpodcast/
Demon Baby Hold Onto Me (The Conjuring: The Devil Made Me Do It)
Tuesday, June 8, 2021 • Duration 01:22:33
It’s finally here, everyone! The 2021 summer horror blockbuster we’ve all been waiting for: the third installment of the Conjuring series. Join us as we talk dino disappointments, bumbling priests, demon antibiotics, cereal rat killers, holy water drive-bys, humanus sacrificus, ship-in-bottle witch totems, and crushed 4-H dreams.
Send us a note at: thecreepoverpodcast@gmail.com
Join the Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/thecreepoverpodcast
Follow us on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/thecreepoverpodcast/
Discover shows related to The Creepover, based on actual content similarities. Explore podcasts with similar topics, themes, and formats, backed by real data.
