Back

Explore every episode of the podcast Squared Circle Spotlight

Dive into the complete episode list for Squared Circle Spotlight. Each episode is cataloged with detailed descriptions, making it easy to find and explore specific topics. Keep track of all episodes from your favorite podcast and never miss a moment of insightful content.

Rows per page:

1–50 of 79

TitlePub. DateDuration
The Secret Curse of WWE's Next Hulk Hogan | Make It Make Sense27 Aug 202600:47:15

Hulk Hogan wasn't just WWE's biggest star — for an entire generation, he was professional wrestling.So when the Hogan era began coming to an end, Vince McMahon faced an enormous question:Who could possibly replace him?In this episode of Make It Make Sense, the Squared Circle Spotlight crew looks back at the wrestlers who were expected to become wrestling's next massive superstar.From the incredible "what if" of Magnum T.A., to Vince McMahon reportedly seeing superstar potential in Tom Magee, the all-out push of Lex Luger, the controversial championship run of Diesel, and finally the rise of Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels.Were these wrestlers really failures?Did WWE fail them?Or was the real problem believing that another Hulk Hogan could ever exist?Maybe there was a curse surrounding "The Next Hulk Hogan" after all — just not the one we thought.🥤 DUBBY ENERGY: Use promo code SCS for 10% off your order!Subscribe to Squared Circle Spotlight for more wrestling debates, stories and deep dives.#WWE #aew #wweraw #smackdown #aewdynamite #HulkHogan #LexLuger #Diesel #BretHart #ShawnMichaels #WWF #WrestlingHistory #ProWrestling

Blackheart Lio Rush: Bad Gimmick or Brilliant?20 Aug 202600:29:11

Is Blackheart Lio Rush a bad gimmick… or one of the most interesting character reinventions in wrestling right now?Lio Rush has completely transformed himself with the Blackheart — white contacts, blood, a darker presentation and a character unlike anything we've seen from him before.But while some of us LOVE what Lio is doing, there are questions about just how far this character can actually go.Is Blackheart a brilliant reinvention? Is it more style than substance? Can the character evolve enough to have long-term potential?On this episode of Bad Gimmicks, Better Merch, the Squared Circle Spotlight crew debates Blackheart Lio Rush and ultimately answers one question:BAD GIMMICK… OR BRILLIANT?🔥 Use promo code **SCS** at Dubby Energy for 10% off your order!#AEW #LioRush #Blackheart #AEWDynamite #Wrestling #wwe #wweraw #smackdown

No Holds Barred: The Craziest Wrestling Movie Ever Made? | Hulk Hogan vs Zeus01 Jun 202600:55:43

Hulk Hogan. Zeus. Tiny Lister. Exploding TV sets. The infamous "DOOKIE!" scene.This week on Make It Make Sense, we're diving into No Holds Barred—the 1989 wrestling movie that somehow became a cult classic despite critics absolutely destroying it.Want to watch the movie before or after listening to our discussion?👉 Watch No Holds Barred here:https://youtu.be/V9VOkwjWh90?si=jNGoQN4LbwJ4AGDrWas this movie a disaster? A masterpiece? Or both?Join the Squared Circle Spotlight crew as we break down the wildest moments, the over-the-top characters, the ridiculous plot, and why wrestling fans still can't stop talking about it decades later.💩 What's that smell?💪 Hulk Hogan at peak Hulkamania😡 Zeus terrorizing everyone📺 Mr. Brell losing his mind🎬 Wrestling movie madness at its finestLet us know in the comments:Is No Holds Barred a terrible movie... or a wrestling masterpiece?🔔 Subscribe for weekly wrestling discussions, bad gimmicks, bizarre wrestling stories, and everything happening in the world of professional wrestling.#WWE #HulkHogan #NoHoldsBarred #Zeus #WrestlingMovies #SquaredCircleSpotlight

The Tragic Downfall Of WWE’s First Diva | Sunny | Make It Make Sense26 May 202600:53:33

This week on Make It Make Sense, we cover one of the most tragic stories in wrestling history:The rise… and complete downfall… of WWE’s first diva, Sunny.Before the Divas era, before social media influencers, and before WWE fully understood the power of personality and sex appeal, Sunny became one of the biggest stars in wrestling — and one of the first true internet celebrities.But over the years, the story spiraled into arrests, addiction, controversy, public meltdowns, and eventually real-life tragedy.How did one of wrestling’s biggest success stories become one of its darkest cautionary tales?💬 Let us know in the comments:Was Sunny failed by wrestling culture… or were the bad decisions ultimately her own?


How Ricochet Became Wrestling’s Most Hated Man | Bad Gimmicks Better Merch22 May 202600:33:53

This week on Bad Gimmicks Better Merch, we dive into one of the weirdest stories in modern wrestling:How did Ricochet — one of the most athletic wrestlers on the planet — become one of the most polarizing and hated names in wrestling discourse?From his rise as an untouchable indie superstar and Prince Puma in Lucha Underground… to the awkward promos, internet backlash, AEW/WWE tribalism, and nonstop social media discourse… we break down how Ricochet somehow became wrestling’s favorite punching bag.Is the hate deserved?Or did Ricochet become a victim of modern wrestling fandom?🔥 Topics Covered:Ricochet’s indie/NXT risePrince Puma and Lucha UndergroundWhy fans turned on RicochetAEW vs WWE discoursePromo criticismModern wrestling fandomSocial media backlash“Great wrestler, no character?” debate

WWE Actually Thought This Was A Good Idea?! | Make It Make Sense 19 May 202600:30:07

In 1998, WWE decided to take scripted wrestling… and turn it into a real fighting tournament.What could possibly go wrong?In this episode of Make It Make Sense, we break down the infamous Brawl For All tournament — the backstage politics, the real knockouts, the injuries, Vince Russo’s role in creating it, JBL’s involvement, Bart Gunn accidentally ruining WWE’s plans, and the infamous Butterbean fight that somehow made the entire thing even worse.This wasn’t just a bad idea…It may have been WWE’s dumbest idea EVER.🔥 Topics Covered:Why Vince Russo created the Brawl For AllJBL and backstage “tough guy” cultureDr. Death Steve Williams being the planned winnerBart Gunn shocking everyoneReal knockouts and injuriesThe Butterbean WrestleMania disasterWhy the tournament completely backfired

The Plane Ride From Hell Was Even Worse Than You Remember | Make It Make Sense11 May 202600:32:53

This week marked the anniversary of one of the wildest—and darkest—stories in wrestling history: The Plane Ride From Hell.

From Brock Lesnar and Mr. Perfect nearly fighting through the plane… to Ric Flair walking the aisle in nothing but his robe… to Goldust singing over the intercom while Scott Hall passed out in his seat… this flight sounded less like a WWE charter and more like complete chaos at 30,000 feet.

In this episode of Make It Make Sense, we break down:

  • what actually happened on the infamous flight
  • how the locker room culture spiraled out of control
  • why so many people treated this insanity as “normal”
  • and how the story became one of wrestling’s most controversial legends

🔥 Topics Covered:

  • Brock Lesnar vs Mr. Perfect
  • Ric Flair controversy
  • Goldust’s drunken singing
  • Scott Hall during the flight
  • WWE locker room culture in the early 2000s
  • Dark Side of the Ring’s Plane Ride From Hell episode

💬 Let us know in the comments:
What’s the craziest Plane Ride From Hell story you’ve ever heard?

How Did WWE Slam Attax Have More Personality Than Jack Swagger?07 May 202600:26:37

Jack Swagger had the push, the look, the “Real American” gimmick… and somehow it still never clicked.

In this episode of Bad Gimmicks, Better Merch, we break down why WWE’s attempt to turn Jack Swagger into the next big patriotic star completely fell flat—and why the WWE Slam Attax card game somehow had more personality than the gimmick itself.

We also open up a pack of WWE Slam Attax cards and revisit one of the weirdest and most nostalgic pieces of WWE merch from the 2010s.

🔥 In this episode:

  • Why the “Real American” Jack Swagger gimmick failed
  • WWE trying to force Swagger into the main event scene
  • The history of WWE Slam Attax
  • Opening WWE Slam Attax cards live
  • Why the merch was honestly more entertaining than the character

💬 Let us know in the comments:
What’s your favorite weird piece of WWE merch… and was Jack Swagger ever going to work?

Make It Make Sense: What Went Wrong With The Wyatt Sicks?04 May 202600:33:33

WWE had something special with the Wyatt Sicks… so how did it fall apart so fast?In this episode, we break down everything that went wrong—from confusing storytelling and lack of direction to the impossible expectations tied to Bray Wyatt’s legacy. This wasn’t just another gimmick that failed… this was something that should have worked.So what happened?Welcome to Make It Make Sense—where we try to figure out why wrestling does the dumbest things possible.🔥 Topics Covered:Why the Wyatt Sicks never found a clear identityWWE’s obsession with mystery over payoffThe pressure of following Bray WyattHow inconsistent booking killed the momentum💬 Let us know in the comments:Did WWE drop the ball with the Wyatt Sicks… or was this doomed from the start?

All Elite Wrestling Blood & Guts Figures… and Why Matt Riddle Can’t Stay Out of His Own Way23 Apr 202600:36:09

This week on Bad Gimmicks, Better Merch, we’re diving into the wild world of All Elite Wrestling collectibles—specifically the Blood & Guts figures 👀

Are they awesome… or just a little TOO much?

But things really heat up when we shift gears to Matt Riddle. There’s no denying the talent—but at what point does it get overshadowed by everything else?

👇 In this episode:
🔥 Breaking down the AEW Blood & Guts figure line
😬 Where these figures hit (and miss)
👀 The ongoing saga of Matt Riddle
💀 Why it feels like he just can’t stay out of his own way

Is it bad gimmicks… or better merch? And is Riddle his own biggest problem?

Drop your thoughts in the comments 👇

WrestleMania 42: The Good, The Bad & The Ugly 🤠21 Apr 202600:55:56

This week we break down everything from WrestleMania 42… the good, the bad, and the downright ugly.Not every moment can be a classic—and we’re calling it like we see it 👀👇 In this episode:🔥 The BEST matches and standout performances😬 The moments that didn’t quite hit💀 The booking decisions that left us questioning everything🤠 Our full breakdown of WrestleMania 42 from top to bottomWho stole the show? What flopped? And what had us completely divided?Drop your thoughts below—what was YOUR good, bad, and ugly from WrestleMania? 👇#WWE #WrestleMania42 #WrestleMania #WrestlingPodcast #WrestlingReview

WrestleMania 42 Picks Got HEATED… Did Someone Quit?! 😳17 Apr 202600:42:21

Things got out of control this week...

We’re breaking down the full card for WrestleMania 42 and making our official predictions—but what starts as a normal preview turns into an all-out argument 😬

Picks got personal. Takes got LOUD. And by the end of it… someone might’ve actually walked out 👀

👇 In this episode:
🔥 Full WrestleMania 42 match-by-match predictions
🔥 Bold takes and major disagreements
🔥 Potential show-stealers and shock winners
🔥 The moment everything went off the rails 😳

Did someone really quit… or was it all part of the show?

Drop your picks in the comments and let us know who YOU’ve got winning at WrestleMania 👇

Ultimate Warrior Held Up Vince McMahon... Was He Right?05 Aug 202600:50:06

In one of the most controversial backstage stories in WWE history, Ultimate Warrior delivered a letter to Vince McMahon just before SummerSlam 1991—demanding hundreds of thousands of dollars or he wouldn't wrestle.Was Warrior holding the company hostage... or simply standing up for himself after years of broken promises?This week on Make It Make Sense, we break down every side of the story. We examine Warrior's frustrations, Vince McMahon's perspective, what really happened behind the scenes, and ask the question wrestling fans have debated for over 30 years...Who was right?Was Ultimate Warrior justified? Or did he cross a line that no top star should ever cross?Let us know where you stand in the comments!⚡ Fuel your next wrestling binge with Dubby Energy!Save 10% on your order with promo code SCS at checkout.Use code SCS and support the channel while getting clean, jitter-free energy!👍 Like the video if you enjoyed it.🔔 Subscribe for weekly wrestling documentaries, debates, deep dives, and podcasts from Squared Circle Spotlight.#WWE #UltimateWarrior #VinceMcMahon #SummerSlam91 #WrestlingHistory

AEW Dynasty 2026 Review: MOTY Contender?! …And a Letdown 😬15 Apr 202600:37:16

AEW Dynasty 2026 is in the books—and we’ve got some STRONG takes. This week on Bad Gimmicks, Better Merch, we break down the full show, including one match that might already be a Match of the Year contender… and another that didn’t quite live up to the insane hype.👇

In this episode:

🔥 Darby Allin vs Andrade El Idolo = EARLY MOTY candidate?!😬 Jon Moxley vs Will Ospreay… what went wrong?

🔥 Full AEW Dynasty 2026 review and reactions

🔥 Hits, misses, and surprises from the card

Was Dynasty a success overall? And are we being too harsh on Mox vs Ospreay?Drop your thoughts in the comments and let us know your match of the night 👇

WWF S.T.O.M.P. Figures Were WILD… And Danhausen Isn’t a Bad Gimmick 😤 | Bad Gimmicks, Better Merch13 Apr 202600:39:46

This week on Bad Gimmicks, Better Merch, we’re diving into one of the strangest toy lines ever—WWF S.T.O.M.P figures 💥

Were these military-style wrestling figures actually cool… or just completely unhinged? We break down the history, the designs, and whether they hold up today.

But that’s not all—
We also make the case that Danhausen might NOT be a bad gimmick after all 😳

Is he misunderstood genius? Sports entertainment gold? Or are we reaching?

👇 In this episode:
🔥 The truth about WWF S.T.O.M.P figures
🔥 Why they were so weird (and kinda awesome)
🔥 Our full defense of Danhausen
🔥 What actually makes a “bad gimmick”

Sound off in the comments—are we right about Danhausen or completely cursed? 😈

#WWE #WWF #WrestlingFigures #Danhausen #AEW #WrestlingPodcast #BadGimmicksBetterMerch

AEW Dynasty Predictions: Our OFFICIAL Picks & Upsets 👀09 Apr 202600:22:37

It’s prediction time for AEW Dynasty 🔥This week on Bad Gimmicks, Better Merch, we’re breaking down the full card and giving our official picks, bold predictions, and potential upsets for one of AEW’s biggest shows.Who’s walking out on top? Who’s getting shocked? And where could AEW surprise us? We cover it all.👇 In this episode:🔥 Full match-by-match predictions🔥 Locks vs risky picks🔥 Potential show-stealers🔥 Where AEW could swerve the fansDrop your picks in the comments and let us know where we’re right (or totally off 😅)

Pat McAfee’s WWE Return Made NO Sense… Fans Let Him Hear It 😬06 Apr 202600:36:21

This week we break down the return of Pat McAfee to WWE… and why fans weren’t having it.Did the comeback feel random? Forced? Poorly timed? We get into why the reaction was so negative and what WWE might’ve missed.Plus, we dive into:🔥 Why a potential Oba Femi vs Brock Lesnar match at WrestleMania could deserve the main event spot🔥 What makes a true WrestleMania main event in today’s WWE🔥 And… is WWE low-key watching our clips and taking ideas?! 😳Let us know—are fans right about McAfee, and should Oba vs Brock close the show?

TL Hopper Was BAD… But Were the Bend-Ems Any Better? 😂 | Bad Gimmicks, Better Merch04 Apr 202600:26:13

This week on Bad Gimmicks, Better Merch, we’re diving into one of the weirdest gimmicks of the New Generation era—TL Hopper 🪠💀Was the wrestling gimmick as bad as we remember? And more importantly… did the iconic Bend-Ems figures actually deliver, or were they just as questionable?We break it all down with nostalgia, laughs, and some harsh truths about one of WWE’s strangest creations.👉 Was TL Hopper overhated?👉 Were Bend-Ems secretly goated… or just trash?👉 And what made these toys so memorable anyway?Let us know your thoughts in the comments!#WWE #TLHopper #WrestlingFigures #WWF #BendEms #WrestlingPodcast #BadGimmicksBetterMerch

Kenny Omega vs MJF at AEW Dynasty?! Wrestling God vs. The Devil + FTR Chaos & Where's Rush Been?01 Apr 202600:20:38

The stage is set for a massive showdown as Kenny Omega steps into the spotlight as the “Wrestling God” against MJF, the self-proclaimed Devil, at AEW Dynasty… but can this dream match actually live up to the hype?We break down everything surrounding Omega vs MJF, what it means for AEW, and whether this could steal the entire show.Plus:FTR collide with Adam Copeland (Cope) & Christian Cage in a match loaded with history, tension, and potential chaosThe big question everyone’s asking… where has Rush been?Hot takes, bold predictions, and everything you need to know heading into AEW’s next big event.

Sami’s Controversial Win, Bloodline Rumors & Chaos at WrestleMania?!30 Mar 202600:50:15

This week we dive into all the chaos shaking up WWE 🔥Did Sami Zayn deserve that controversial United States Title win… or did WWE drop the ball?Are we really on the verge of seeing the OG Bloodline reunite? 👀And what does an unsanctioned match between Drew McIntyre and Jacob Fatu mean for WrestleMania?!We break it all down with our takes, predictions, and the potential fallout heading into the biggest show of the year.👉 Drop your thoughts in the comments — are things heating up or going off the rails?

Festus & WWE Maximum Sweat Figures… What Were They Thinking?!27 Mar 202600:27:26

This week on Bad Gimmicks, Better Merch, we dive into one of the weirdest combos in wrestling history — Festus and the infamous WWE Maximum Sweat figures. From questionable gimmicks to even more questionable toy features, we break down what made these so bizarre… and somehow still kind of amazing.Was Festus actually underrated? And who thought “sweating action figures” was a good idea in the first place? 😂We’re talking nostalgia, ridiculous concepts, and whether this merch was genius or just plain cursed.Drop your thoughts in the comments — did you own one of these?!#WWE #Festus #WrestlingFigures #WWEToys #BadGimmicksBetterMerch #RuthlessAggression #WrestlingPodcas

Chaos Unleashed: Oba Femi & Brock, Orton’s Viper Mode, and Fatu vs. McIntyre24 Mar 202601:07:09

Wrestling just went off the rails! We break down the jaw-dropping Oba Femi & Brock segment, Randy Orton embracing full Viper mode, and the ongoing saga between Drew McIntyre and Jacob Fatu. Plus, by fan request, we rewind to the 1990 Royal Rumble and relive all the unforgettable moments that made it legendaryGet vidIQ to grow your channel faster! 🚀https://vidiq.com/SQUAREDCIRCLE

Bad Gimmicks, Better Merch: Eugene & WCW’s Wild Vibrating Figures20 Mar 202600:28:02

In this episode of Bad Gimmicks, Better Merch, we dive into one of the most unique (and questionable) characters in wrestling history—Eugene—and how his gimmick translated into merch.Then we take a turn into the absurd with some of the strangest collectibles ever released by World Championship Wrestling… including the infamous vibrating action figures that somehow made it to store shelves.Were these ideas ahead of their time… or just plain ridiculous?From forgotten toys to head-scratching gimmicks, this episode is all about the weird side of wrestling history you didn’t know you needed.

Jeff Jarrett: Ain't I Great... Or Just Overrated?22 Jul 202600:35:36

For over 30 years, Jeff Jarrett has been one of the most polarizing names in professional wrestling. From his country music superstar gimmick in WWE to multiple world title reigns in WCW and TNA, Double J has built a career that fans still argue about today.Joe thinks Jeff Jarrett was consistently overpushed and never belonged at the top of the card.Charlie says he's one of the most underrated performers of his generation.Who's right?In this episode of Bad Gimmicks, Better Merch, we break down Jeff Jarrett's gimmick, revisit the biggest moments of his career, and see if his merch was actually better than the character itself.👇 Let us know in the comments:Is Jeff Jarrett underrated, overrated, or exactly where he belongs in wrestling history?⚡ Fuel your next watch with Dubby Energy!Use promo code SCS at checkout to save on your order and support the channel!👍 Like the video if you enjoyed it.🔔 Subscribe for weekly wrestling debates, deep dives, and Bad Gimmicks, Better Merch episodes.🎙️ Follow Squared Circle Spotlight on all major podcast platforms.

Did AEW Revolution Deliver? + Randy Orton Goes Full Viper!18 Mar 202600:57:34

This week we break down everything that went down at AEW Revolution and ask the big question: did the show actually deliver?We dive into the biggest matches, the standout moments, and what it all means going forward in All Elite Wrestling.Plus, we react to the shocking heel turn from Randy Orton and what it means on the road to WrestleMania. Is this the start of a new “Viper” era, and how will Cody respond?All that and more as we break down the latest week in wrestling.Get vidIQ to grow your channel faster! 🚀https://vidiq.com/SQUAREDCIRCLE

AEW Revolution 2026 Preview & Predictions | Full Card Breakdown13 Mar 202600:21:54

In this episode we break down the full card and give our official predictions for AEW Revolution 2026.The biggest match of the night sees MJF defend the AEW World Championship against Hangman Adam Page in a brutal Texas Death Match. We debate who walks out champion and whether this feud could steal the entire show.We also preview the huge tag team showdown between FTR and The Young Bucks, plus discuss potential show-stealers like Jon Moxley vs Konosuke Takeshita.From title matches to surprise picks, we give our full predictions for every match on the card and debate which moments could define the event.

Cody’s SHOCK Title Win… Is He Turning Heel? | Punk vs Roman Gets Personal + Luigi Primo 🍕10 Mar 202600:51:26

In this episode we break down one of the wildest weeks in wrestling.We start with the shocking title win by Cody Rhodes and ask the big question: was this just a huge moment… or the start of a heel turn? Will we see a face Cody take on a face Randy Orton, or a shocking twist?We also dive into the heated promo battle between CM Punk and Roman Reigns. Did things get a little too real, or was it just great storytelling? We break down the lines that had fans buzzing and debate whether the tension felt personal.And of course we had to talk about the internet’s newest wrestling sensation: Luigi Primo, the viral pizza-spinning wrestler who’s suddenly everywhere online. Is he the next great viral gimmick or just a fun moment for wrestling fans?All that and more as we reminisce, debate, and react to everything happening in wrestling this week.

The 2026 Elimination Chamber was SOMETHING....and then Danhausen Debuted03 Mar 202600:46:20

💀 Danhausen DEBUTS?! Was anyone expecting that?!🔥 The Chamber results flipped everything heading into WrestleMania.😬 And yes… our official picks did NOT survive the night.We break down:The Danhausen moment and what it means going forwardThe biggest swerve of the nightMatches that delivered (and the ones that… didn’t)Why our predictions aged terribly in real timeWas this genius booking? Chaos? Or pure madness?

OMEGA vs SWERVE SHOCKER?! MJF & HANGMAN GO NUCLEAR + VINCE FOOTAGE & WWE MYSTERY BOX!25 Feb 202600:51:18

This week’s wrestling news is WILD.⚡ Kenny Omega vs Swerve Strickland just hit another level — are we witnessing the start of something bigger… or a full heel shift?🎤 MJF and Hangman Page absolutely unloaded in a promo that felt way too real. Was that scripted… or personal?📦 A mysterious box delivered to WWE has fans spiraling. Who sent it? What’s inside? Is this a return, a debut, or something completely different?🚔 And yes… we’re talking about the Vince McMahon body cam footage from the car accident. What does it show — and why is everyone buzzing about it?Plus hot takes, arguments, and probably at least one rant!

Mordecai & The Wrestling Album: Holy Wrath and Vinyl Heat20 Feb 202600:31:49

This week on Bad Gimmicks, Better Merch, we dive into one of WWE's most short-lived supernatural experiments - Mordecai. The glowing eyes, the white robes, the Old Testament vengeance. How did something so visually intense flame out so fast?Then we pivot to the complete opposite energy - The Wrestling album. Bad singing, wild personalities, and peak 80's excess.Failed character pushes to vinyl gold, we break down how sometimes the gimmick bombs.... but merch lives forever!

AEW Grand Slam Fallout, & Elimination Chamber Updates, and Wrestlemania Ticket Sales Down17 Feb 202600:53:53

This week we break down all the biggest wrestling stories across AEW and WWE.On the AEW side, we cover the fallout from Grand Slam Australia, the major results coming out of the show, and what it means moving forward.On the WWE side, we dive into:CM Punk vs Finn Balor and the Elimination Chamber buildCody Rhodes qualifying for ChamberThe latest on Bron Breakker’s injuryThe discussion around WrestleMania ticket salesNo debate format this week — just real reactions, analysis, and honest takes on everything happening in wrestling right now.Which company had the bigger week?Is WrestleMania season heating up or slowing down?Drop your thoughts in the comments.

AEW vs WWE: The Ultimate Debate | Super Show 211 Feb 202601:13:03

The Super Show is back.This week on Squared Circle Spotlight, we return with Super Show II, our latest AEW vs WWE Debate, with two teams going head-to-head over the biggest questions in wrestling today.We debate:Star Power – Who really has the bigger names?Storytelling – Long-term booking vs moment-driven chaosThe Forbidden Door – Game changer or overrated?Fan Dedication – Which fanbase truly rides harder?The Future – When it’s all said and done… which brand ends up on top?No scripts. No middle ground. Just passionate wrestling fans defending their side and calling out the other — and yes, it gets heated.👇 Drop your take in the comments and let us know who won the debate: AEW or WWE?

ROMAN WINS. AJ RETIRES?! Royal Rumble Fallout & Wild WrestleMania Predictions04 Feb 202600:56:38

The Royal Rumble is in the books and there’s a LOT to unpack. Roman Reigns punches his ticket to WrestleMania by winning the Rumble, AJ Styles calls it a career, and the road to WrestleMania just got chaotic.

We break down everything that mattered from the Rumble, what Roman’s win really means, how AJ’s retirement impacts WWE going forward, and we jump way too early into our WrestleMania predictions. Debates get heated, opinions fly, and nothing is off limits.

Bad Gimmicks, Better Merch | Episode 2 – Seven & Kurt Angle31 Jan 202600:23:26

In Episode 2 of Bad Gimmicks, Better Merch, we dive headfirst into one of the strangest and most short-lived gimmicks in wrestling history: Seven. From creepy vignettes to a debut that imploded on live TV, we break down what WCW was thinking, why the character failed instantly, and how Dustin Rhodes famously pulled the plug himself.

On the flip side, we take a look at something that actually worked — the Kurt Angle Mattel Legends figure. We talk sculpt, attire choice, accessories, nostalgia factor, and whether this figure belongs in your collection or on the shelf.

Bad ideas. Great merch. Plenty of debate, banter, and laughs along the way.

The Montreal Screwjob: The Betrayal That Changed Wrestling Forever14 Jul 202600:49:01

November 9, 1997 changed professional wrestling forever.Was Bret Hart betrayed by Vince McMahon? Was Shawn Michaels in on the plan? Did Earl Hebner have any choice?In this episode of Squared Circle Spotlight, we investigate every piece of the Montreal Screwjob—from the contract negotiations to the backstage conspiracy, the infamous finish, and the aftermath that changed wrestling forever.Was it business?Was it betrayal?Or was it the greatest work in wrestling history?Join us as we reopen one of wrestling's biggest mysteries.👇 Who really screwed Bret Hart? Let us know in the comments.#WWE #BretHart #MontrealScrewjob

Sami Zayn Earns His Shot, AEW’s Deathriders Explained & Royal Rumble Picks Get HEATED27 Jan 202601:12:11

We break down Sami Zayn earning the #1 contendership and what his upcoming WWE Championship match could mean — is this finally his moment, or just another obstacle in the title picture? Opinions are split, and things get heated fast.

On the AEW side, we dive into what’s really going on with the Deathriders, what their presence means for the roster, and whether this storyline is clicking or creating more questions than answers.

Plus, we lock in our official Royal Rumble picks, including some surprise choices that lead to real debate around the table.

Strong takes, disagreements, and no fence-sitting — this episode brings the heat.

Bad Gimmicks, Better Merch Episode 123 Jan 202600:23:21

This week, we take a hard (and honest) look at one of the most infamous WWF gimmicks ever — Akeem the African Dream. We break down how the character came to be, why it failed, and how it’s remembered today through a modern lens.

On the merch side, we shift gears to something done right as we review the Mattel Elite Piper’s Pit Roddy Piper figure. From presentation to accessories, we discuss whether this release lives up to one of wrestling’s most iconic segments — and if it belongs in your collection.

Awkward gimmicks, great figures, and plenty of banter — welcome to Bad Gimmicks & Better Merch.

Cody Entering the Rumble Just Blew Up WWE’s Entire Title Picture21 Jan 202601:04:04

Cody Rhodes officially entering the Royal Rumble could change WWE’s entire road to WrestleMania. We break down the #1 contender tournament, the escalating tension with Drew McIntyre and Jacob Fatu, and what this all signals for the title picture.
On the AEW side, we discuss Brody King possibly lining up for MJF, Mercedes Moné stepping away, and the growing speculation that Powerhouse Hobbs may be WWE-bound.

Calling It Now: Wrestling in 2026 Will Look Like THIS13 Jan 202600:46:19

We’re calling our shot.
This week on Squared Circle Spotlight, the crew throws out our boldest and hottest predictions for 2026 across WWE, AEW, and the wrestling world at large.
Title runs, heel turns, surprise returns, and career-defining moments — we’re putting it all on record now so it can be clipped, argued over, and thrown back in our faces next year.

Agree? Disagree? Bookmark it now.

When Titles Stop Meaning Something | Wrestling’s Biggest Storytelling Problem06 Jan 202601:04:42

This week, we dive deep into one of the biggest questions in modern wrestling: are championships still meaningful, or have they become storytelling props? We break down how titles are used today, when they elevate stories, and when they feel completely hollow.

Plus, our Gimmick of the Week takes us back to one of WWE’s most controversial factions — Right to Censor. Did it work as satire, or was it doomed from the start?

Smart debate, strong opinions, and classic wrestling callbacks — let’s get into it.

What We Got Right (and Wrong) at AEW World’s End30 Dec 202501:22:36

AEW World’s End is officially in the books, and we’re breaking it all down. This week on Squared Circle Spotlight, we review the full card, react to the biggest moments from the night, and compare our predictions to what actually went down.
Who exceeded expectations, which results surprised us, and what does the fallout mean for AEW heading into the new year? Let’s get into it.

AEW World’s End Preview | Wrestling’s Strangest Christmas Characters Ever!23 Dec 202501:00:24

This week on Squared Circle Spotlight, the crew makes their official predictions for AEW World’s End — who walks out the final AEW show of the year on top?Then, we deck the halls of wrestling history with our Gimmicks of the Week: the bizarre, short-lived holiday legends The Christmas Creature and Xanta Claus.Grab some eggnog, because this one’s a mix of festive chaos, hot takes, and classic wrestling weirdness.Get vidIQ to grow your channel faster! 🚀https://vidiq.com/SQUAREDCIRCLE

Saturday Night’s Main Event Review, Cena’s Retirement Match & Kerwin White!16 Dec 202501:04:21

The Spotlight crew is BACK! We’re talking WWE’s brand new LJN figures, reliving Saturday Night’s Main Event, and maybe shedding a tear over John Cena’s retirement match. And if that wasn’t enough chaos… our Gimmick of the Week is none other than Kerwin White. Yeah. That Kerwin White. Let’s go.

The 2025 Spotlight Awards: Our Most Controversial Picks Yet!10 Dec 202501:05:47

Get vidIQ to grow your channel faster! 🚀https://vidiq.com/SQUAREDCIRCLEIt’s that time of year again!The gang breaks down the best of 2025 in our annual Spotlight Awards—where we honor the wrestlers, matches, and moments that kept us glued to the screen all year long.Laugh with us, argue with us, and let us know YOUR winners in the comments!

WWE WarGames Breakdown: What Worked… and What Definitely Didn’t02 Dec 202501:04:04

Get vidIQ to grow your channel faster! 🚀https://vidiq.com/SQUAREDCIRCLE


WarGames delivered chaos, surprises, and a few downright ugly moments — and we’re breaking down ALL of it! In this episode, we dive into the GOOD (the standout performances and booking wins), the BAD (questionable choices and weird pacing), and the UGLY (yep… those moments you already know). We also cover all the winners, shocks, and fallout. PLUS — our Gimmick of the Week returns as we dive into the unforgettable, unstoppable, and undeniably unappetizing Bastion Booger. Buckle up — this one gets wild!

Who Really Killed WCW? The Final Verdict08 Jul 202600:36:28

The investigation is almost over. In Part 2 of our biggest "Make It Make Sense" episode yet, we reopen the remaining case files to answer one of wrestling's greatest mysteries: Who really killed WCW?

This week, we're putting the spotlight on the final suspects:

🔎 Eric Bischoff – The man who led WCW to 83 weeks of dominance... but did the empire he built ultimately collapse under its own weight?

🔎 AOL Time Warner – Did corporate executives pull the trigger, or was WCW already beyond saving?After examining every suspect, every motive, and every major mistake, we deliver our final verdict on the downfall of one of the biggest wrestling companies in history.

Did Vince Russo really deserve all the blame? Was Hulk Hogan protecting the old guard? Did bad creative slowly poison the company? Or was the death of WCW inevitable?

💬 We want to hear your verdict.

Who do you think killed WCW?

Our WWE Wargames Picks Are IN | Bold Predictions!28 Nov 202500:58:58

Get vidIQ to grow your channel faster! 🚀https://vidiq.com/SQUAREDCIRCLE

This week on Squared Circle Spotlight, we're breaking down everything from AEW Full Gear 2025! Was it worth the hype? Plus, we're making our bold predictions for WWE Wargames - who's walking out victorious? And for our Gimmick of the Week, we're lacing up the skates to discuss one of wrestling's most bizarre characters: The Goon! 🏒

WWE Survivor Series’ Most Controversial Moments + The Booty Man Exposed!18 Nov 202501:04:31

Get vidIQ to grow your channel faster! 🚀https://vidiq.com/SQUAREDCIRCLE

This week on the Squared Circle Spotlight, things get weird fast. Jeremy kicks off the show with a fully committed, absolutely unauthorized Slam Master J birthday cameo for Kathy — and it is somehow both beautiful and horrifying. Then we break down the Top 5 most controversial Survivor Series moments of all time: screwjobs, betrayals, shocking swerves, you name it. Finally, our Gimmick of the Week dives deep into the legend himself… The Booty Man. Yes, that one. Strap in — this episode is full of chaos, controversy, and cheeks.

WWE Survivor Series Fantasy Draft & Slam Master J Lives Again!12 Nov 202500:52:03

Get vidIQ to grow your channel faster! 🚀https://vidiq.com/SQUAREDCIRCLE


It’s draft season, baby! The crew builds their ultimate Survivor Series teams — past and present — and things get heated as alliances crumble faster than a 90’s tag team. Then Jeremy takes things to the next level, stepping into the shoes (and durag) of Slam Master J himself for a one-on-one interview you didn’t know you needed.Can Slam Master J save the show… or will he get drafted last?

WWE Saturday Night’s Main Event Reactions | Cody Wins, Jey Loses, and Mideon Loses His Pants!11 Nov 202501:06:26

The crew dives into Saturday Night’s Main Event and things get heated over Cody’s latest win. Is Jey Uso really “Main Event” material, or just along for the ride? Plus, our Gimmick of the Week is one that can’t be unseen — the legend himself, Naked Mideon!It’s chaos, controversy, and cheeks — only on Squared Circle Spotlight!

© My Podcast Data · Independent project · Data from Apple & Spotify