Pick This Show – Details, episodes & analysis

Podcast details

Technical and general information from the podcast's RSS feed.

Pick This Show

Ryan Rotner, Michael Ham, Scott Lee

Tv & Film

Frequency: 1 episode/13d. Total Eps: 15

Welcome to Pick this show where this season we're trying to find that show that you'll love. Join along as the 3 of us draft a new show, trying to convince each other to start that show together. We'll keep watching that new show until 2 of us vote to stop. Enjoy the fun as we discover new shows for you to try and suffer along with us as we inevitably run into some duds along the way.

Read moreCollapse

Site

RSS

Apple

Data updated on 04/07/2026

Recent rankings

Latest chart positions across Apple Podcasts and Spotify rankings.

Apple Podcasts

Spotify

No recent rankings available

Shared links between episodes and podcasts

Links found in episode descriptions and other podcasts that share them.

See all

https://www.buzzsprout.com/twilio/text_messages/2363218/open_sms
15 shares

RSS feed quality and score

Technical evaluation of the podcast's RSS feed quality and structure.

See all

RSS feed quality

To improve

Score global : 63%

Publication history

Monthly episode publishing history over the past years.

Year

Latest published episodes

Recent episodes with titles, durations, and descriptions.

See all

Wellness Week- Dr. Odyssey Ep. 4

Season 2 · Episode 7

Friday, November 8, 2024 • Duration 25:37

Send us a text

It’s “Wellness Week” on Dr. Odyssey which make Ryan, Mike, and Scott go deep on own their personal wellness journeys. The hosts discuss their experiences of trying to stop feeling like mid-forties adults through a combination of acupuncture, smoothies, and vitamins. The guys also talk about how they would want Don Johnson to captain them through a hurricane and question who was enjoying that all male (and one lesbian) strip poker scene. As usual find out if they vote to continue with Dr. Odyssey!

00:21 Initial Reactions to Wellness Week

01:33 Discussion on Acupuncture

05:46 Exploring Other Wellness Treatments

09:09 Personal Wellness Routines

11:25 Exploring Wellness Routines

11:39 Body Hacking and Experimental Therapies

12:38 Vitamins and Supplements Discussion

14:58 Wearable Devices and Biomarkers

17:49 Dramatic Hurricane Plot

19:37 Bizarre Poker Scene Analysis

22:56 Episode Ratings and Final Thoughts

Read moreCollapse

We Just Can’t Quit…A Nostalgic Revisit of Trackin’ Tracker - Tracker Season 2 Ep. 1

Season 2 · Episode 6

Monday, November 4, 2024 • Duration 28:13

Send us a text

The boys go against their vow and host a special episode of “Trackin’ Tracker.” Unable to quit Tracker completely, Ryan, Mike, and Scott go down the rabbit hole of the Season 2 opener “Out of the Past,” and discuss the surprising items that actually improved the show, how Justin got jacked for this new season, why Colter is tormented by this particular cold case, and will small town Colorado affect Rennie’s profit margin.

00:39 Season Two Opener Recap

01:24 Initial Reactions and Improvements

02:33 Character Dynamics and Storyline Shifts

04:01 Plot Holes and Inconsistencies

08:43 Budget and Production Quality

09:47 Colter's Character Development

13:44 Amateur Mistakes of the Best Tracker

14:50 The Marshall's True Identity Revealed

15:37 Colter's Inconsistent Approach

16:19 The Grid Search Critique

18:40 Reenie's Move to Colorado

20:29 Financial Mysteries of Reenie's Practice

23:52 Final Thoughts and Ratings

27:48 Nostalgic Recap and Farewell

Read moreCollapse

Will You Be Having Liquids or Solids? - Dr. Odyssey Ep. 3

Season 2 · Episode 5

Monday, October 28, 2024 • Duration 25:18

Send us a text

It’s Plastic Surgery Week on the Odyssey and hosts Ryan, Scott, and Mike get grossed out immediately. The guys were hoping for a Nip Tuck world on a boat, but seems Ryan Murphy may have pushed it a little to far for these avid TV watchers. Come listen as the hosts discuss what the fuck is oozing out of Tristan’s mother’s head, how putting on a tuxedo is not the first thing they would want to do after surgery, and that Ryan Gosling is and forever will be the real life Ken Doll. Tune in to find out if this episode pushed them to continue or stop watching!

Read moreCollapse

Searching for that D (Deck perhaps?) on Singles Week - Dr. Odyssey Ep. 2

Season 2 · Episode 4

Friday, October 18, 2024 • Duration 17:22

Send us a text

It’s Singles Week on the Odyssey and hosts Ryan, Scott, and Mike jump right into the fun. The guys discuss how Tristan is stuck in the friends zone with Avery (especially since he will never be able to compete with Pacey Witter/Charlie Conway/Max Bankman), are condoms bad for the environment, Syphilis Sam’s deep bench of hookups for a week, and how the humorous tone adds to the big deck energy hype of the show. Is the show sailing in the right direction for the guys to continue? Tune in to find out!

00:00 Introduction and Episode Recap

00:37 Guest Star and Initial Impressions

01:35 Character Development and Plot Critique

03:52 Bro Code and Gym Scene Analysis

07:07 Medical Mysteries and Humor Highlights

12:18 Ratings and Final Thoughts

15:36 Closing Remarks and Next Week's Teaser

Read moreCollapse

Big Deck Energy with Dr. Odyssey

Season 2 · Episode 3

Tuesday, October 15, 2024 • Duration 20:56

Send us a text

Hosts Ryan, Scott, and Mike, dive into the premiere of “Dr. Odyssey,” ABC’s new medical drama on a luxury cruise ship. A modern-day “Love Boat,” the show features Joshua Jackson as Dr. Max Bankman, a Yale-trained doctor looking to add more leisure to his hectic life. The hosts discuss life’s important topics such as what is the recovery time for a penile fracture, how many shrimp you have to eat in one sitting to get iodine poisioning, and how many people fall overboard on an annual basis. Will the hosts vote to continue to watch? Listen in!

00:40 First Impressions of Dr. Odyssey

01:10 Episode Highlights and Medical Mysteries

01:53 Character Deep Dive: Dr. Max Bankman

02:29 Unusual Medical Cases and Their Realism

05:57 Guest Stars and Overboard Incidents

08:28 Cruise Life and Personal Experiences

10:05 Final Thoughts and Ratings

19:56 Looking Ahead: What's Next?

Read moreCollapse

Let's Get Physical?

Season 2 · Episode 2

Tuesday, October 8, 2024 • Duration 20:59

Send us a text

In this episode of Pick This Show, hosts Scott, Mike, and Ryan dive into their thoughts of the first episode of “Physical.” The hosts discuss their surprise at the show being more dark than funny, the potential trajectory of the show with a dud of a husband, the already seen transformation of hippies to Reaganites, and the awesome 80s soundtrack that may keep the hosts continuing to watch. See if they vote to continue!

00:00 Introduction and Welcome

00:30 First Impressions of 'Physical'

01:50 Diving Deeper into Characters and Themes

03:33 Nostalgia and 80s References

05:23 Debating the Show's Future

15:31 Final Votes and Next Show Preview

20:32 Closing Remarks

Read moreCollapse

Welcome to Pick This Show

Season 2 · Episode 1

Friday, October 4, 2024 • Duration 34:18

Send us a text

Welcome to "Pick This Show" with hosts Scott, Mike, and Ryan. Off their global hit “Trackin’ Tracker,” this season finds the hosts kicking off a fresh new format. This year, they'll each nominate a new show and convince the other hosts why their pick should be the one they all watch. After discussions, they'll vote to determine which show to watch. They will continue watching and discussing the chosen show until at least two hosts decide to stop, prompting a new round of nominations. Listen in as Scott, Mike, and Ryan battle it out on which show should be picked (Physical - AppleTV, Doctor Odyssey - ABC, or All American - CW) and discuss what makes Rose Byrne unstoppable, how Charlie Conway and Pacey Witter will make a deadly combo at sea, and can All-American live up to the holy grail of teenage football dramas Friday Night Lights.

00:00 Introduction to Season Two Format

01:06 Scott's Show Nomination: Physical

08:55 Mike's Show Nomination: Doctor Odyssey

16:19 Ryan Murphy's Signature Style

16:38 Comparing '911' and 'Dr. Odyssey'

17:15 The Love Boat Meets Grey's Anatomy

17:26 Speculating on 'Dr. Odyssey's' Format

18:12 Popularity of '911'

19:22 Introducing 'All American'

20:05 Plot and Themes of 'All American'

23:26 Pros and Cons of 'All American'

29:31 Voting and Final Thoughts

Read moreCollapse

We Made It Through The 1st Season of Tracker!

Season 1 · Episode 8

Wednesday, July 10, 2024 • Duration 48:11

Send us a text

Ryan, Mike, and Scott have made it through a full season of Tracker! The gang breaks down how you can't fool Colter Shaw, who's batting a 1,000. Colter finds a missing storm chaser and breaks down a criminal sex trader. The hosts examine how fucked up the Shaw family is, why all surfers have to be Australian, what elements can improve the show, and their love of the show's use of high-budget oldies rock songs. The gang also pitch their ideas for future storylines and says goodbye to the global phenomena that has become Trackin' Tracker.

00:00 Introduction and Episode Overview
01:32 Discussion on Episode's Simplicity
11:31 Family Dynamics and Season 2 Setup
23:54 Final Thoughts and Season Recap
24:32 Debating the Worst Episode
24:56 Favorite Episodes and Missed Opportunities
31:12 The Need for Better Side Characters
33:38 Suggestions for Season Two
44:31 Final Thoughts and Ratings
46:18 Looking Ahead to Season Two

Read moreCollapse

Rambo 6: Blood Brothers

Season 1 · Episode 7

Tuesday, July 2, 2024 • Duration 44:38

Send us a text

In this episode of Trackin’ Tracker, Scott, Ryan, and Mike celebrate the long-awaited appearance of Russell Shaw, the enigmatic brother who supposedly killed the Shaw family patriarch. The gang tries to understand if it’s possible to overcome a complex 20 year absence in 10 minutes, which brother is better for Reenie, why the director cut out all of the action scenes, and if they could run a family business with their own sibling.

00:36 Character Analysis: Russell Shaw
02:59 Plot Breakdown: Colter and Russ Reunite
04:52 Action and Banter: The Brothers' Dynamic
06:04 Russell's Flirtations and Character Depth
06:50 Critique of the Episode's Plot and Execution
13:40 The Absurdity of the Action Scenes
20:32 Russell and Colter's Bonding
23:41 Rating the Episode
26:00 Discussion on Sibling Dynamics
28:52 Hypothetical Family Business Ventures
39:21 Russell's Backstory and Family Conflict
43:45 Predictions and Conclusion

Read moreCollapse

Bobby Gets Stuck In the Friend Zone

Season 1 · Episode 6

Wednesday, June 26, 2024 • Duration 42:52

Send us a text

In this episode of Trackin' Tracker, the gang dives into Colter's first case in a major city: Chicago. The hosts debate if Bobby will ever escape the friend zone with Sun Mai, Colter's potential political leanings, and whether he's an adventure seeker, some well-off wealthy do-gooder, or just bad at business economics. Ryan, Mike, and Scott also wonder how did Colter train to become an amazing fighter and magician.

00:16 Episode Summary: Chicago
01:50 Discussion: Episode Impressions
03:02 Character Analysis: Bobby's Role
05:20 Speculations: Colter's Political Views
10:28 Character Analysis: Rennie's Legal Expertise
17:32 Financial Breakdown: Colter's Business Model
24:51 Living Expenses and Financial Struggles
27:41 Colter's Risky Lifestyle and Financial Model
34:06 Unanswered Questions and Theories
39:04 Character Dynamics and Future Predictions
41:44 Episode Review and Final Thoughts

Read moreCollapse

Pick This Show – Details, episodes & analysis

Podcast details

Recent rankings

Apple Podcasts

Spotify

Shared links between episodes and podcasts

RSS feed quality and score

Publication history

Latest published episodes

Related Shows Based on Content Similarities

Apple Podcasts

Spotify

Related Shows Based on Content Similarities

Pick This Show – Details, episodes & analysis

Podcast details

Recent rankings

Apple Podcasts

Spotify

Shared links between episodes and podcasts

Buzzsprout1

RSS feed quality and score

Publication history

Latest published episodes

Similar podcasts and content

Related Shows Based on Content Similarities

Apple Podcasts

Spotify

Related Shows Based on Content Similarities

Buzzsprout1