Weil, Gotshal & Manges wasn't losing money. Its profits per partner were still going up when, on October 28, the 95-year-old firm told its partners it would wind down. Delta and General Motors went through bankruptcy and kept flying planes and building cars. No partner-owned law firm has ever done that. In this episode, recorded the day Weil made its announcement, Joel turns the tables and puts co-host John Morley in the guest chair. Years ago John wrote Why Law Firms Collapse, a study of three dozen law firm failures, and he says Weil followed the pattern “almost uncannily according to script.”
John explains why law firms are “less likely to fall off the table, but more likely to shatter when they hit the ground.” Law firms are owned by their workers, and the workers can walk out the door. When one rainmaker leaves, revenue falls faster than costs, profits per partner drop, and the next partner now has a reason to go. It's a run on the bank. Bankruptcy law speeds it up: partner pay is a distribution on equity, and distributions made while a firm is insolvent can be clawed back, so a partner who sees a 50 percent chance of collapse should value every dollar of pay at fifty cents.
So why Weil? What matters, John argues, isn't absolute profit but profit relative to peers. Weil came out of the financial crisis strong on the back of its debtor-side bankruptcy practice, didn't invest in private equity the way its rivals did, and slid down the rankings for two decades. Then came the classic triggers: business concentrated in a few hands, the departure of corporate chair Mike Aiello and a group of partners for Cravath, a centralized governance culture, a leadership succession that fell through, and a merger search that went nowhere. John compares Wachtell, which held together, and Slater & Gordon, a publicly traded firm that went through bankruptcy and kept operating, and explains how ethics Rules 5.4 and 5.6 make American firms uniquely brittle.
He also walks through what happens now to Weil's partners, associates, and staff, from unfinished-business claims to decades of lease obligations; what every other firm should do before the pattern reaches them; and why Weil's fall shows that the 2025 executive orders against firms like Paul Weiss posed a real, existential risk.
Guest: John Morley is the Augustus E. Lines Professor of Law at Yale Law School, where he teaches Business Organizations, Securities Regulation, and Trusts and Estates, and co-hosts New Law Order with Joel Cohen. His article Why Law Firms Collapse, published in The Business Lawyer, studied three dozen law firm failures.
For more conversations with the titans changing the legal business, subscribe to New Law Order. For a lawyer CLE version of this interview and other legal insights, visit www.talksonlaw.com. For questions or comments about the show email us at newlaworder@talksonlaw.com.