Explore every episode of the podcast Catholic Answers Live
Dive into the complete episode list for Catholic Answers Live. Each episode is cataloged with detailed descriptions, making it easy to find and explore specific topics. Keep track of all episodes from your favorite podcast and never miss a moment of insightful content.
Rows per page:
50
1–50 of 276
Title
Pub. Date
Duration
#12984 How Do We Pray in Jesus’ Name? Annulments and Testimonies - Karlo Broussard
18 nov. 2026
“How do we pray in Jesus’ name?” This question opens a discussion on the significance of invoking Jesus in prayer, alongside a heartfelt testimony from a new Catholic about their journey through annulments. Other topics include managing pride in evangelization and the reasoning behind the traditional prayer formula that includes the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.
05:32 – I just came into the Church after annulments were finalized!!!! I want to share a testimony!!
12:08 – How does one handle pride in evangelizing? How do I make this from a personal win into a win for Jesus?
38:17 – I just became Catholic. Why do we pray in Jesus’ name but it’s always completed with “in the name of the Father Son and Holy Spirit”? No one ever explained this to me.
#12983 How Do I Understand the Dogmas of Mary and Angels? - Karlo Broussard
17 nov. 2026
“How do I understand the dogmas of Mary?” This question opens a discussion on the complexities of Marian dogmas and how to approach them with faith. Additionally, the episode addresses the role of angels beyond protection and whether it’s appropriate for Catholics to receive prayer from a Methodist pastor, showcasing a variety of theological insights.
13:42 – I’m in OCIA. I struggle with the dogmas of Mary. They seem like a bit of a stretch. How do I move forward with this?
34:45 – I’m looking into the Catholic view of angels. Why are angels needed apart from protection? I hear Catholics communicate more with angels.
49:35 – Is it ok for a Catholic to be prayed over by a Methodist pastor?
#12982 Is Isaiah 22 a Good Argument for the Papacy? - William Albrecht
17 nov. 2026
“What is the response to Isaiah 22 and papacy arguments?” This question addresses common claims that these biblical passages do not support the papacy. Additionally, the discussion touches on whether the statue of the pope in Peru is idolatry, the historical challenges of bad popes, and how to engage with sedevacantist views.
01:30 – People claim Isaiah 22 and Matthew 16 are not good arguments for the papacy. What is the response?
10:30 – Regarding the statue of the pope in Peru. Is this idolatry? Is this a sign of the end times?
20:28 – How do you explain the bad pope through history?
31:39 – Thoughts on Robert Bellarmine and his writings on if the pope becomes a heretic? How do I respond to sedevacantists?
39:32 – Whats the red line on agreeing with the pope?
#12981 Has Deut 17:8-13 Proved the Papacy? Saints and Canonization - Brayden Cook
16 nov. 2026
“Has Deut 17:8-13 proved the papacy?” This question opens a discussion on the biblical foundations of papal authority, alongside inquiries about the infallibility of saint canonization and the role of the pope compared to other church leaders. The conversation also touches on the implications of canonization and personal journeys to faith in the papacy.
02:30 – Has Deut 17:8-13 been used as evidence for the papacy?
21:42 – Is the canonization of saints an infallible declaration by the pope?
30:26 – Why do we look towards a pope instead of a priest or pastor and how do we explain that to a protestant?
44:45 – Does the pope send people to heaven if he canonizes them?
48:12 – You didn’t always believe in the papacy. What convinced you?
#12980 What Makes a Baptism Valid? Priestly Celibacy and Scripture - Jimmy Akin
14 nov. 2026
“What makes a baptism valid?” This question opens a discussion on the essential elements of baptism, particularly for those unsure about their own baptism’s validity. Other topics include the biblical basis for Latin priestly celibacy and the sufficiency of Scripture in faith. Additionally, insights are shared on lesser-known Apostles and the biblical account of Jesus sweating blood.
01:51 – Regarding valid Baptism: What is it that makes a baptism valid? (is in OCIA, got baptised in another church but was told his baptism was invalid). He looked online and according to his research he has a valid baptism, but his parish will not give him an answer. Does not want to commit sin if his baptism was valid by getting baptized again.
17:25 – How is Latin Priestly celibacy biblical? To be saved do I only need the Bible or is there something else along with the Bible?
28:15 – Jimmy had mentioned a musician that he likes to hear for Christian music. Middle school kids- he is a teacher: The kids are asking how come we do not know more about the Apostles that we do not hear much about in scripture. We hear about the 12 but we only know about 5-6 of them in detail, and how can they learn more?
36:01 – Passage in bible talking about “Jesus has drops of sweat like blood”. How does this get translated into Jesus actually sweating blood?
44:00 – Sufficiency of scripture and how St. Paul addresses this? (when he discusses scripture with his friend the friend takes a stance of Sola Scriptura and they come to an impasse on their conversations and he wants to know how to navigate that)
#12979 How Can Catholics Win Bible Disputes? Exodus and James 2 - Jimmy Akin
13 nov. 2026
“How can Catholics win Bible disputes?” This episode addresses strategies for Catholics engaging in discussions with Protestants about Scripture. The conversation also touches on the historical timing of the Exodus and the complexities of justification as discussed in James 2:14-26, providing a well-rounded exploration of these important topics.
02:12 – Catholics and Protestants argue about Bible passages. From your years of experience, any advice for Catholics who get involved in these disputes?
21:15 – The historical timing of the exodus. What century did it most probably occur? (Jimmy had a podcast video about this topic and this is a follow-up question from that)
44:00 – James 2; 14-26- Is it just ongoing justification or initial and ongoing justification?
#12978 Is Once Saved Always Saved Accurate? Assurance and Denominations - John Martignoni
13 nov. 2026
“Is salvation a one-time thing that cannot be lost?” This question opens a discussion on the nature of salvation and assurance across different denominations. Other topics include navigating family dynamics with parents of differing faiths, the reliability of the disciples’ writings, and the challenges posed by the multitude of Protestant denominations.
01:30 – Is Salvation a one time thing that cannot be lost?
15:40 – My mother is Catholic and my Dad is protestant. But my mother goes to my Dad’s church. How do I deal with having parents who have different churches, and love them both?
21:58 – If the disciples weren’t there, how did they know what to write — did Jesus tell them what to write?
24:10 – Protestants have something like 10,000 different denominations. With so many different beliefs and different variations, which one is correct? How can they be right when they’re all different?
30:28 – You said a reason to not believe in once saved always saved is there is no reason to not sin. But I believe in once saved always saved and I have lots of reasons I try not to sin.
45:38 – Why are there so many Catholics that don’t understand the Bible, especially Ephesians 2:8-10 which says we are saved by faith?
53:12 – Can a person have assurance of their eternity?
#12977 Why Does the Church Reject Contraception? Chastity and Sin - Emily Dinneny
12 nov. 2026
“Why does the Church reject contraception?” This question opens a discussion on the Church’s teachings regarding family planning and the sanctity of life. Other topics include the morality of kissing before marriage, the distinction between chastity and celibacy, and the implications of living together before marriage.
03:05 – Why does the Church reject contraception if there’s no life that is actually lost. Wouldn’t prevention be better than having an abortion anyway?
14:50 – For someone who left the homosexual lifestyle, what if when you wake you you start down the road of pleasuring yourself but then you stop. Is that a sin?
29:01 – Is it wrong to kiss before marriage?
35:14 – Is contraception alright when spacing children?
42:35 – What is the difference between chastity and celibacy?
45:15 – What is the Church’s teaching on living together before marriage?
52:00 – In the Bible when it talks about spousal submission, does that include ancillary bodily decisions like piercings, tatoos, hairstyles, etc.?
#12976 Can the Church Decide Who Goes to Heaven? Eucharist Explained - Joe Heschmeyer
12 nov. 2026
“Can the Church decide who goes to heaven?” This question opens a discussion on the Church’s role in salvation, alongside varied topics such as the faith of the Oriental Orthodoxy and the implications of attending Mass. The conversation also touches on explaining the Eucharist to non-Catholics and the belief in justification by faith alone.
03:32 – I am convinced of the faith of the Oriental Orthodoxy.
22:50 – I don’t think that the Catholic church should be able to decide who goes to heaven or hell. I also think that Catholic teaching of attending Mass is damning people to hell.
41:09 – How do I explain Luke 22:19 (in remembrance) as it relates to the eucharist to my dad who isn’t Catholic.
47:50 – I believe in justification on Faith alone.
#12975 How John 6 Points to the Eucharist – Pope Leo Statue - Joe Heschmeyer
11 nov. 2026
“How Does John 6 Point to the Eucharist ?” This question opens a discussion on addressing misconceptions about Catholicism, including a friend’s assertion about the Church’s appearance. The conversation also touches on the interpretation of John 6:63 and its implications for understanding the Eucharist, providing a well-rounded exploration of faith and scripture.
11:49 – My friend said the Catholic church looks satanic. How can I respond?
35:16 – I studied a structure of John 6:63 is referring to 51-57 reveals to respond to them rather than the Catholic Eucharist.
#12974 Can Orthodox and Catholics Unite? Sacraments and Schism - William Albrecht
11 nov. 2026
“Can Orthodox and Catholics unite?” This episode addresses the complexities of unity between these two traditions, including the role of Eastern Catholics in bridging the divide. Other questions explore the interpretation of Isaiah 22:19-22 regarding the papacy, and the implications of differing sacramental views in mixed-faith families.
00:43 – Questions on Orthodoxy and objections to Orthodoxy
01:47 – What does unity actually look like within the Eastern and Oriental Orthodox? How did it look before any schism? I feel like Eastern Catholics will be key to breaking the schism.
06:53 – One child is raising his family in the Latin rite and the other in Greek Orthodox; my son’s family was advised not to go to my granddaughter’s Greek Orthodox baptism because it wouldn’t really be bearing witness to a true sacrament—what do you think of that?
14:15 – How do the Orthodox interpret Isaiah 22:19-22 in the context of the papacy?
20:33 – Would you recommend young men such as me to read this newly published Orthodox Christian Bible, or should I have a spiritual director to guide me through it; and how much authority should I look into the Catechism when reading it?
41:02 – For a fellow who’s been divorced and remarried, what is the argument for Roman Catholicism over an Orthodox Church that would accept him and still give him valid sacraments and not have him explode his whole life?
52:30 – Is there a possibility for a reunion with Greek Orthodoxy but allow the differences to remain, in light of the 2007 Ravenna document?
#12973 What Documents Challenge Papal Primacy? Filioque and More - William Albrecht
10 nov. 2026
“What documents challenge papal primacy?” This episode addresses key texts cited by Orthodox Christians and the Catholic responses to them. Additionally, the discussion touches on the filioque controversy, examining scriptural support and insights from the Church Fathers, as well as the differences between Oriental Orthodoxy and Roman Catholicism.
02:24 – What are the documents Orthodox quote against papal primacy, and what is the Catholic response?
09:09 – Have these documents led to any steps toward reunification with the Eastern Orthodox?
12:52 – Are there any verses that we can point to that support our view for the filioque?
15:44 – What about the Fathers? Are there anything from the Church Fathers that support the filioque?
17:45 – What’s the difference between Oriental Orthodoxy and Roman Catholicism, and how do I explain the difference between what she believes in Christology and what we believe?
23:09 – Why do we Catholics allow the Eastern Orthodox churches to own the Orthodox label when Catholics are most literally Orthodox Christians?
29:11 – I see so many priests living lives of privilege, and as a young man I’m having difficulty reconciling what I read and what I see.
42:34 – If the very least all Eastern Orthodox say that the bishop of Rome was the first among equals, doesn’t that show a certain level of historic primacy?
#12972 Should We Raise Hands During the Our Father? Priesthood - Tom Nash
10 nov. 2026
“Should we raise hands during the Our Father?” This question leads to a discussion on liturgical practices, including a recent directive from Bishop Samples regarding hand gestures. Other topics include how to address apostolic arguments with non-denominational Christians and the complexities of honoring priests and bishops despite personal grievances.
01:55 – Bishop Samples diocese says people need to stop extending their hands during the “Our Father.”
13:56 – How do I talk about the apostolic argument when talking to non-denominational?
21:16 – What if you get mad at a priest or bishop who is less than honorable? Do you have to honor them? How can you justify following them?
37:37 – I had a bad experience with a bishop and I know we are not allowed talking bad about them. But what do you do in a situation where a priest or bishop treats us individually badly?
46:50 – What is the scriptural basis for confession to a priest?
#12971 Why Do Christians Struggle with Emotions? Anger, Forgiveness - Gregory Popcak
09 nov. 2026
“Why do Christians struggle with emotions?” This question opens a discussion on the complexities of emotional experiences in the Christian life. The conversation also touches on the godly purpose behind feelings like anger and resentment, how to navigate friendships after betrayal, and the challenges of maintaining connections with loved ones who choose different paths.
01:00 – Why do Christians have such a complicated relationship with emotions?
06:43 – You argue that there is a godly purpose to even unpleasant emotions like anger, resentment, frustration and other emotions Christians often feel guilty for even having much less acting on. How can these feelings serve godly ends?
19:57 – I feel a mix of emotions. I have a friend who committed adultery and my roommate is now friends with the woman whom my friend committed adultery with. How do I handle this from a Catholic perspective? My roommate is not Catholic?
28:15 – How do I handle the emotions of me and my bestfriend as we grow up? I went the Catholic route and she went down the LGBTQ+ route and am having a hard time connecting with?
36:05 – My youngest son just revealed where he was in his relationship with a girl. I unloaded my feelings on how I felt about her. What do I do?
44:35 – How do I reconcile when your brother sins against you and eventually cut him after you’ve taken it to the Church and the verse where it says to forgive your brother 7 times 70?
49:48 – Regarding Peter and Paul in the bible and their difference in temperament and how they were both dealt with by God to become great follower. How can we use them as examples on how to handle our temperaments?
#12970 Are We Less Ourselves Before Final Judgment? Lust and Fatima - Jimmy Akin
07 nov. 2026
“Are we less ourselves before final judgment?” This question leads to a discussion on the nature of our body-soul composite and what it means for our identity after death. The conversation also touches on overcoming lust and the societal repentance required for Mary’s request at Fatima, along with the inclusion of the book of Tobit in the Bible.
03:52 – If we are supposed to see ourselves as a body soul composite, then are we less of ourselves before the final judgment when we die?
20:24 – How do you overcome lust?
42:50 – What would have been the level of societal repentance needed to satisfy Mary’s request at Fatima before the wars?
49:30 – Why is the book of Tobit included in the bible if it’s a source of fiction?
#12969 Why Do We Need Indulgences If Christ Died for Us? Bishops, Voting - Jimmy Akin
06 nov. 2026
“Why do we need indulgences if Christ died for us?” This question opens a discussion on the role of the Church in distributing Christ’s merits, especially during November when we remember the dead. Other topics include the Vatican’s record-keeping of bishops and priests, the implications of false oaths on salvation, and the moral responsibilities of voting in elections.
02:35 – November is the month when Catholics especially remember the dead, and one of the things we can do for them is gain an indulgence by visiting a cemetery and praying for them. But here’s something I’ve wondered: If Christ’s merits are infinite and freely available to us, why do we need the Church to distribute them through indulgences?
20:24 – Does the Vatican keep records of which bishop ordained which priest and which apostolic lineage they come from?
28:45 – I have ocd and during my recent ocd attacks below bizzare thoughts were bothering me. I just want to know if below things are possible so that i dont have to fight these thoughts and I’ll be relieved. 1)What if one tells God , i keep my salvation as a collateral, instead help me with something, for example, a job. Post that I’ll donate something to the church and you can give back my salvation, else im ok to go to hell 2) If one takes a false oath on ones soul saying he’s ok with the consequences or promises on the soul, to not do something and still does it, can he still be saved or is this binding.
42:34 – Where did the 3 days of darkness come from and who promotes it?
50:09 – I did not vote in the most recent election because I believe both sides promote intrinsic evil. The Catechism says it is our duty to vote. What should I have done?
#12968 Should We Stop Evangelizing to Other Religions? Secularism and the Gospel - Tim Staples
06 nov. 2026
“Should we stop evangelizing to other religions?” This question arises amid discussions on secularism and the Gospel. The episode also addresses Bishop Barron’s critique of cardinals on conversion, strategies for engaging with Jehovah’s Witnesses, and how to connect with Catholics who may not fully embrace their faith.
00:34 – Bishop Barron criticized two cardinals who say the Church isn’t there to convert people. What do you make of it?
16:11 – In prosperous societies like Australia, New Zealand and Europe, how do we answer the rampant secularism?
21:30 – Two Jehovah’s Witnesses came to my house and want to come back. Do you have any tips on how to share the Gospel with them?
28:28 – My Muslim Uber driver tried to do dawah on me on my way to Mass. I told him conversion to Christianity is a spiritual, heart conversion, but I felt I was too abrupt.
45:19 – I’m Catholic, but not all the way Catholic. How can I reach Catholics who aren’t really into the Bible and live like the world the rest of the week?
#12967 What Are the Five Solas? Salvation, Baptism, and Mary - Brayden Cook
05 nov. 2026
“What are the five solas of Protestantism, and how does a Catholic respond to them?” This question opens a discussion on key theological differences, while also addressing the rich young ruler’s inquiry about eternal life and the role of baptism in salvation. Additionally, the conversation touches on Marian dogmas and the implications of unconditional election in Catholic teaching.
01:39 – What are the five solas of Protestantism, and how does a Catholic respond to them?
15:24 – When the rich young ruler asked Jesus, “What must I do to inherit eternal life?” was that a salvation question?
18:43 – When someone asks me, “Brother, are you saved?” I say yes — baptism saves us, I was baptized as an infant, so I’m saved unless I lose it. What would you say?
21:07 – How would you answer the Protestant theology of unconditional election from Church teaching?
34:21 – I’m going through OCIA. I don’t disagree with the Marian dogmas, I just don’t understand them. Can I still have assurance of salvation if I accept the Church’s teaching and authority?
46:09 – Why does the opportunity for salvation end at death?
#12964 How to Convince Joyce Carol Oates on Real Presence? Eucharist, Mass - Tom Nash
04 nov. 2026
“How would you convince Joyce Carol Oates that we truly believe in the real presence?” This question opens a discussion on the significance of the Eucharist in Catholic faith. Other topics include the proper approach for those considering conversion, the reasons behind the different Eucharistic prayers, and the role of Extraordinary Ministers of Holy Communion.
01:17 – How would you convince Joyce Carol Oates that we truly believe in the real presence?
15:02 – I’m not Catholic yet. I want to convert but I’m a leader of my church community. When I go to mass to I go up to receive a blessing, or should I stay in the pew? If I go through OCIA, why would I get pulled from mass to go to a class during the consecration?
28:47 – Why are 4 different eucharistic prayers and who chooses which prayer to pray? It’s hard to follow.
34:08 – Who is supposed to lead the Entrance Antiphon and Communion Antiphon. Is it the priest of the congregation?
41:21 – What is the Church’s stance of receiving communion from Extraordinary Ministers of Holy Communion? Is there a difference in receiving communion from them and a priest or deacon?
45:53 – When offering prayers before mass, how many offerings can you offer up?
49:41 – No question, but something about language. What don’t you understand about metaphor? All language has some form of it. That includes Hebrew, Greek and English. Get real
#12963 What’s the Earliest Evidence for Transubstantiation? Eucharist, Mass - William Albrecht
03 nov. 2026
“What’s the earliest evidence for transubstantiation?” This question opens a discussion on the historical foundations of the Eucharist, including insights into the evidence for the Eucharist itself and the theological implications of whether Catholics are re-sacrificing Jesus. The conversation also touches on why certain individuals are denied communion and the protective nature of the Mass for those who may not attend regularly.
02:30 – What’s the earliest evidence outside the Bible for transubstantiation?
14:29 – What’s the evidence for the Eucharist?
19:17 – Are Catholics re-sacrificing Jesus?
22:02 – Why do people get denied communion like politicians or gay couples when Jesus didn’t even deny communion to Judas?
36:25 – How much protection does the mass provide to a person who doesn’t always attend but feels like their childhood Catholicism holds them safe?
45:26 – Catholics claim that the Road to Emmaus is about eucharist but Jesus told the followers to touch him knowing he is real. If you take this same logic to the eucharist, the host feels nothing like Jesus therefore the story cannot be about the eucharist. Thoughts?
#12962 How Do Protestants Justify the 5 Solas? Catholic Differences - Stephen Boyce
03 nov. 2026
“How do Protestants justify the 5 Solas?” This question opens a discussion on the foundational beliefs that shape Protestant theology, while also addressing the implications of adding other elements to these principles. The conversation further explores the differences between nominalism and realism, recommendations for Lutherans considering Catholicism, and the need for a modern reformation among Protestants.
01:00 – How do protestants justify the 5 solas? if you use other things it does away with the sola part, doesn’t it?
13:48 – Are the differences in nominalism and realism a way to explain the theological differences between Catholics and Protestants?
23:57 – I’m Lutheran looking to come into the Catholic faith. What reading material do you recommend?
40:40 – Do you think today’s modern-day protestants are in need of a reformation?
48:29 – I don’t think the issue of the reformation is black and white. Is it possible the Church admitted its own shortcomings during the conflict?
#12961 Did the Protestant Reformation Fail? Luther and Atonement - Stephen Boyce
02 nov. 2026
“Did the Protestant Reformation fail?” This question opens a discussion on the Reformation’s goals and outcomes, including insights on whether it succeeded. The conversation also touches on Penal substitutionary atonement versus St. Anselm’s model, and reflections on Luther’s trial and the implications of his teachings.
04:14 – Did the Protestant Reformation succeed in its goal?
19:43 – I’m in OCIA from a reformed background. Can you explain Penal substitutionary atonement compared to St. Anselm’s model?
29:39 – I think it’s a shame that the conversation wasn’t had with Luther but instead he was put on trial. What are your thoughts on this?
42:01 – I grew up MO synod Lutheran and believe that the reformation was not successful at all. I think that all teaching was completely undermined and led to disaster. What are your thoughts on that?
48:11 – What prompted Luther’s journey in the wrong direction?
#12958 What Did the Church Fathers Teach About the Eucharist? - Mike Aquilina
30 oct. 2026
“How did the Church Fathers teach about the Eucharist?” The early Church Fathers provided profound insights into Jesus’ real presence in the Eucharist, even during His earthly ministry, as seen at the Last Supper. Additionally, the discussion touches on the diversity among the Fathers and their perceived radicalism compared to modern interpretations, as well as the relationship between the Fathers and the Protestant Reformers.
12:30 – How did the Church Fathers explain Jesus’ real presence in the Eucharist when Jesus was still alive (like at the Last Supper)?
24:00 – In the early centuries of Christianity there seems to be a great diversity of persons among the Church fathers, and that got lost somewhere along the line in the West. It seems like the Fathers were a bit more radical, then they became a bit more “clean cut.” I feel like the modern Church could use a bit more of that original radicalism. What do you think?
33:18 – It seems like the Church Fathers were so obviously Catholic. Did the Protestant Reformers just ignore them?
44:15 – What is your opinion on why the Church Fathers are so ignored by modern Protestants?
49:45 – The Church Fathers can be surprisingly easy to read, and they are great teachers.
#12957 Does Jesus Allow Divorce for Adultery? Hope for Marriage - Rose Sweet
29 oct. 2026
“Does Jesus allow divorce for adultery?” This question opens a discussion on the complexities of marriage and fidelity in the light of faith. Other topics include the implications of same-sex attraction in cases of infidelity, personal stories of healing after infidelity, and the challenges faced by those in long-term marriages affected by past divorces.
01:40 – Does Jesus permit divorce in cases of adultery?
29:03 – What if the adultery was happening with a person of the same sex? Would the fact that the person is gay make it an illicit marriage?
33:15 – I have experienced infidelity. My husband and I have been getting help in saving our marriage. I just want to give hope and encouragement to others who might be struggling.
44:31 – I’ve been married for 31 years. My husband had been married before and was divorced (adultery played a part on both sides). They thought they were divorced, but there was a clerical error, so we just found out they are still married. We have been living as roommates for 15 years. Can I leave him?
49:50 – My husband was unfaithful in the beginning of our marriage but God turned it around and our marriage is so much stronger because of it now.
#12956 What Do Oriental Orthodox Believe? Saints and Purgation - William Albrecht
29 oct. 2026
“What do Oriental Orthodox believe?” This episode delves into their views on Christ’s nature and the significance of saints, while also addressing the misunderstandings surrounding terms like “monophysitism.” Additionally, the discussion touches on Marian dogmas and the beliefs regarding post-death purgation, providing a comprehensive look at these rich theological perspectives.
04:20 – All these beliefs that end in “-physitism” – what’s that all about?
10:19 – What do Oriental Orthodox believe about the nature of Christ?
16:00 – How do we understand the saints and condemnations on each side?
18:00 – Do Catholics and Oriental Orthodox agree on Marian dogmas?
23:00 – What do young Oriental Orthodox men argue about with Catholics online?
29:30 – Why would it be wrong to call an Oriental Orthodox a monophysite?
33:17 – What do they believe about post-death purgation?
44:00 – Do they have a valid Eucharist?
50:30 – Do they baptize and confirm at the same time?
53:30 – How about communion in an emergency?
54:13 – How do we get the band back together?
#12955 Who Are the Oriental Orthodox? History and Key Differences - William Albrecht
28 oct. 2026
“Who are the Oriental Orthodox?” This question opens a discussion on the distinct churches within this family and their differences from Eastern Orthodox churches. The conversation also touches on their shared history with Rome, the significance of the Council of Chalcedon in 451, and the theological distinctions between “miaphysitism” and “monophysitism.”
03:30 – Who are the Oriental Orthodox? Which churches belong to this family, and how do they differ from the Eastern Orthodox churches most Catholics are more familiar with?
04:45 – What is our shared history? Before the separation, how were these churches connected to Rome, and what contributions did they make to early Christianity?
06:23 – What happened at Chalcedon in 451?
12:00 – What role did the pope play in the controversy? Why was Pope Leo the Great’s Tome accepted at Chalcedon but rejected by its opponents?
16:00 – What is the difference between “miaphysitism” and “monophysitism”? Why do Oriental Orthodox Christians object to being called monophysites, and do they affirm that Jesus is fully God and fully man?
21:50 – Having a little grace with each other.
29:45 – Areas of agreement.
31:35 – How central is the papacy to the remaining disagreement? What authority do Oriental Orthodox Christians recognize in the bishop of Rome, and where do they reject Catholic claims about primacy and infallibility?
35:30 – Rejection of universal jurisdiction
37:40 – How did it become a permanent division?
43:19 – How did the spread of Islam affect the division?
52:35 – Do you think we’re getting closer on the ground level? Or is it just on the Vatican commission level?
#12954 Is There Salvation Outside the Church? Mary and Mormonism - Karlo Broussard
28 oct. 2026
“Is there salvation outside the Church?” This question leads to a discussion on the Church’s teachings, including why the understanding shifted after Vatican II. Other topics include the implications of divorce and remarriage for becoming Catholic, the Protestant perspective on Mary, and how to engage with a new Mormon neighbor about the faith.
01:48 – I’m a traditional Catholic who goes to an FSSP Mass. Why did the Church always teach there’s no salvation outside the Church until they changed in at Vatican II?
16:23 – Doesn’t divorce and remarriage preclude a person from becoming Catholic? Someone could just go to the Orthodox Church and get the Eucharist there.
29:00 – Why are Protestants so against Mary?
40:30 – I have a new Mormon neighbor. Any tips on how I can engage him about the faith? And what topics might I be prepared to discuss with him?
#12953 How Should Catholics Respond to Non-Catholics? Indulgences, Faith - Karlo Broussard
27 oct. 2026
“How should Catholics respond to non-Catholics?” This episode addresses the essential question every Catholic should be prepared to answer, while also tackling how to engage with friends from different faith backgrounds, the role of faith in salvation, and the Church’s teaching on indulgences.
03:18 – What’s the one question every Catholic should be ready to answer?
16:33 – My grandparents are JWs. A friend is a Oneness Pentecostal. What would be the best way to convince them to become Catholic?
29:30 – I am a member of a baptist Church, but I am also in OCIA. How should I respond to friends to ask why be Catholic — isn’t faith in Jesus enough?
39:40 – I am moving to the deep south. How can I be prepared to defend the faith there where there are not a lot of Catholics?
44:41 – Why does the Church offer plenary indulgences when one of the conditions is complete detachment from venial sin, and nobody can really know if they have attained that? Doesn’t the Church have a responsibility to equip people to know when they have attained the indulgence?
#12952 Can Salvation Be Conditional? Mortal Sin and Good Works - Tom Nash
27 oct. 2026
“Can salvation be conditional?” This question opens a discussion on the Catholic understanding of salvation in relation to mortal sin and good works, contrasting it with Protestant views. Other topics include the perceived contradictions in church teachings from the council of Ephesus, and the implications of church discipline regarding family members with same-sex attraction.
01:56 – Struggling with the view of Salvation. How does the protestant view of salvation contradict and make sense with the view of a Catholic that there is mortal sin and venial sin and salvation is conditional and how does it tie in good works?
12:49 – Believes the Catholic church contradicted the council of Ephesus…( his sources: Isaiah 19, and counsel of Ephesus and council of Chalcedon. Does not understand the connection between Christology regarding Isaiah 19 and prophecy on the church.)
31:09 – Is in OCIA- What does church teaching have to do with cutting family members off due to sexual orientation. Can people enact church discipline? Her understanding that only a church body can do that not people individually.
44:28 – John 6 is used in favor of the Catholic view of the Eucharist. However he is unsure of this. And would contend that John 6 is an argument against the Catholic view of the Eucharist.
#12951 Is Catholicism Just Extra Steps for Christianity? Faith, Grace, and Morality - Brayden Cook
26 oct. 2026
“Is Catholicism just extra steps?” This question opens a discussion on the unique aspects of Catholic faith, grace, and morality. Other topics include the interpretation of the Queen of Heaven in Jeremiah, the nature of the Church as the Biblical community, and concerns about Catholic moral teachings regarding consent and natural law.
03:00 – I think Catholicism is just Christianity with extra steps.
14:36 – Is the Catholic Church the Biblical church or are the people the Biblical church? 1 Cor 3: 16-17
31:53 – Has a problem with the Catholic Moral teaching. Caths remove consent from Moral theology and use the excuse of natural order as a way to excuse bigotry and the things the church supports.
43:32 – We are saved by faith through grace. He does not know anything that contradicts that. He does know that being saved is conditional in Catholicism and this is why he is not a Catholic.
#12950 Akita, Fatima and More | Ranking Marian Apparitions (Encore) - Jimmy Akin
24 oct. 2026
Catholic Answers Live continues its ranking of Marian apparitions by examining some of the most significant and widely discussed cases, including Kibeho, Akita, Fatima, and Zeitoun. The episode explains how the Church evaluates each apparition, what level of approval they have received, and what spiritual lessons Catholics can legitimately draw from them while remaining rooted in Church authority and doctrine.
#12949 La Salette, Mejugorje and More | Ranking Marian Apparitions (Encore) - Jimmy Akin
23 oct. 2026
This Catholic Answers Live episode explores how the Church evaluates and ranks Marian apparitions, explaining the official categories used to judge reported visions and whether Catholics are required to believe them. The discussion also examines specific and controversial cases, including Fr. Michel Rodrigue, La Salette, and Medjugorje, helping listeners understand how the Church discerns authenticity, safeguards the faithful, and distinguishes approved devotion from private revelation.
04:50 – What categories does the Church classify apparitions into?
11:25 – Are we required to believe them?
16:19 – Fr. Michel Rodrigue
38:31 – La Salette
49:05 – Mejugorje
#12948 Every Objection to The Papacy Answered – Part 2 (Encore) - Joe Heschmeyer
23 oct. 2026
“Every Objection to The Papacy Answered” This episode dives into the role of Peter and the significance of Rome in the context of papal authority. Explore questions like whether the Bible indicates Peter’s presence in Rome and how 1 Peter 5:13 supports this claim, along with discussions on the implications of Paul rebuking Peter and the nature of papal fallibility.
03:00 – Is the papacy unbiblical or a temporary office?
07:30 – Does the Bible ever say Peter went to Rome?
11:30 – How does 1 Peter 5:13 support Peter’s presence in Rome?
14:30 – Did Peter and Paul really found the church in Rome together?
16:30 – Does Paul rebuking Peter disprove papal authority?
19:30 – Can a pope be fallible or rebuked for his actions?
23:00 – Is the real Protestant objection that we don’t need structure, sacraments, or hierarchy?
25:30 – What does the temple veil really mean for Christian worship?
29:00 – If Jesus is the only mediator, why do we have priests or popes?
32:30 – Does the Eucharist show that Christian priesthood is still valid?
36:00 – What’s the real difference between Catholicism and Orthodoxy on the papacy?
39:30 – Is the Pope really just “first among equals”?
42:00 – What does Irenaeus say about Rome’s authority and apostolic succession?
45:00 – Did Pope John Paul II suggest the papacy could look different in the future?
47:30 – Is the complexity of the modern papacy a sign of corruption or growth?
50:00 – Does celibacy contradict Peter’s example?
53:00 – Was Peter actually married during his apostleship?
55:00 – Is the Pope the Antichrist and the Church the Whore of Babylon?
#12947 Every Objection to The Papacy Answered – Part 1 (Encore) - Joe Heschmeyer
22 oct. 2026
“Every Objection to The Papacy Answered” This episode explores the complexities of papal authority, addressing questions like whether the papacy is unbiblical and if Peter was ever in Rome. Tune in as we also delve into the implications of Paul’s relationship with Peter and the significance of “Babylon” in 1 Peter 5:13.
03:22 – Why do people object to the Pope’s role in the Church?
06:40 – Isn’t the papacy unbiblical and not meant to persist beyond Peter?
10:35 – Does the Bible ever say Peter was in Rome?
14:20 – What does “Babylon” mean in 1 Peter 5:13, and how is that connected to Rome?
17:15 – Didn’t Paul co-found the Church in Rome with Peter?
20:05 – Paul rebuked Peter—doesn’t that undermine papal authority?
25:18 – Was Peter’s behavior in Antioch heretical or just scandalous?
30:40 – Doesn’t Galatians 2 show Peter as just another apostle, not a leader?
34:25 – Why do Protestants say we don’t need a Pope if Jesus tore the temple veil?
39:12 – Does Jesus as sole mediator mean there’s no place for the Pope or priests?
43:50 – Why is Hebrews 10 crucial to properly understanding the torn temple veil?
47:00 – Is priesthood abolished in the New Testament?
50:10 – What does 1 Corinthians 10 tell us about sacrifice, the Eucharist, and priests?
54:45 – Why is there a structural Protestant objection to the papacy?
#12946 Proving Every Catholic Sacrament from the Bible – Part 2 (Encore) - Karlo Broussard
22 oct. 2026
“What is the role of the Holy Spirit in the sacraments?” This episode explores the vital connection between the Holy Spirit and the sacraments, while also addressing how to explain their significance to non-Catholics, the necessity of certain sacraments for salvation, and the relationship between sacraments and the Church’s authority.
03:00 – What is the role of the Holy Spirit in the sacraments?
12:15 – How can we explain the importance of the sacraments to someone who is not Catholic?
22:45 – Are there any sacraments that are not necessary for salvation?
35:30 – How do the sacraments relate to the concept of faith and works?
47:00 – Can you discuss the relationship between the sacraments and the Church’s authority?
#12945 Proving Every Catholic Sacrament from the Bible – Part 1 (Encore) - Karlo Broussard
21 oct. 2026
“Are Sacraments Biblical?” This episode tackles the claim that the Catholic Church’s seven sacraments lack biblical support, addressing foundational questions about God’s grace through outward signs. Discover the scriptural basis for baptism’s saving power, the distinct nature of Confirmation, and the authority behind Confession, all rooted in Scripture.
07:00 – Some Christians claim the Catholic Church’s seven sacraments aren’t in the Bible at all. How do you respond to that broad objection?
17:00 – Let’s start at the foundation — where in Scripture do we see the idea that God communicates grace through outward signs?
23:40 – Baptism is accepted by most Christians, but Catholics see it as more than a symbol. What’s the biblical evidence for baptism actually saving us?
42:28 – Many people say Confirmation is just a Catholic “add-on.” What are the scriptural roots for a sacrament distinct from baptism?
06:23 – When it comes to the Eucharist, the biblical debate can get intense. How do you show from Scripture that Jesus meant His words—“This is my body”—literally?
16:50 – But what about when Jesus says, “Do this in remembrance of me”? Doesn’t that prove that the Eucharist merely a meal in which we recollect on the tings that Jesus did?
29:20 – Confession to a priest is one of the hardest for non-Catholics to accept. Where does the Bible show that God gave men the authority to forgive sins?
32:50 – Anointing of the Sick is sometimes seen as “Last Rites” only. How do the Scriptures present this sacrament, and does it match Catholic practice?
41:42 – Marriage as a sacrament—some say the Bible just sees it as a natural institution. How do you show from Scripture that it’s a channel of grace?
48:10 – Holy Orders—where in the Bible do we see a distinct, ordained priesthood in the New Covenant?
#12944 What Does God Mean by Tragedy? The Trinity and Grace - Karlo Broussard
21 oct. 2026
“What does God mean by tragedy?” This question opens a discussion on the nature of suffering and divine purpose, especially in light of recent events like the tragic death of Father Sánchez Molinari. The conversation also addresses the logical coherence of the Trinity and how to reconcile Old Testament references with New Testament revelations, alongside the requirements for receiving the Eucharist.
01:00 – I don’t know if you heard about Father Sánchez Molinari. He was a priest in Ecuador who unfortunately passed away this Sunday because a crucifix hanging from the church ceiling fell on top of him. My atheist friends are asking, what did God mean by this? What should I say to them?
17:20 – How can the trinity be logically coherent/consistent? How can the contradictions about the Trinity with the Old Testament be reconciled? Isaiah 45:5. In 10 commandments “I” Hebrew Singular in all these instances what is written is the Hebrew singular
33:48 – If there is no way to prove that the Apostles were in a state of Grace during the Last Supper how can the Catholic church require people to be in a state of Grace to receive the Eucharist?
#12943 What Is Needed for Salvation? - Karlo Broussard
20 oct. 2026
“What is needed for salvation?” This question opens a discussion on the relationship between faith, works, and grace in the Catholic understanding of salvation. The conversation also addresses the Protestant view on salvation by faith, the Catholic Church’s teachings on what it means to be saved, and the contrasting perspectives of Paul and Aquinas on human nature.
03:08 – The protestants are correct in saying that salvation is received by faith.
19:15 – What is needed for salvation according to the Catholic Church? What do you think it means to be saved and is salvation Eternal?
36:05 – Paul in one Epistle says- man is evil from the start and man in eternity is evil. Aquinas is stating man in essence is good. How do both relate? If Aquinas claims man in essence is good, but Paul states no man is good, then is the only good one God?
51:51 – How are we saved by our works as stated by James- not just faith alone?
#12942 Why Do We Reject “Gay Marriage?” Morality, Scandals, and Love - Tom Nash
20 oct. 2026
“Why do we reject ‘Gay Marriage’?” This question opens a discussion on the Church’s teachings regarding marriage and sexuality, addressing the distinction between sin and chastity for homosexuals. The conversation also touches on the Church’s moral authority amid scandals and seeks clarity on the definition of marriage, balancing compassion with doctrinal beliefs.
13:54 – I understand that the physical act of homosexuality is a sin. Why is it okay to be a chaste homosexual?
22:40 – How can the Catholic church with all the scandals, dictate morality in marriage?
29:57 – Can you clarify what the definition of a marriage is?
37:03 – How does the moral aspects of sexuality integrate with the doctrines and dogmas that Catholics must agree to?
42:48 – How do we balance compassion with saying this is disorder?
48:18 – What can I do because in reality I can’t say anything? How can I respond when samesex couples share news of pregnancy?
#12941 Response to Joe Rogan Guest Slandering Mother Teresa – JPII and More! - Patrick Novecosky
19 oct. 2026
This show including a response to criticisms from a Joe Rogan guest and the complexities surrounding John Paul II’s teachings, such as the luminous mysteries and his interactions with minority groups. The conversation also touches on the impact of personalism on JPII’s papacy and the nuances of Mother Teresa’s legacy.
02:00 – Response to Joe Rogan guest slandering Mother Teresa
15:23 – John Paul II instituted the luminous mysteries, but some traditional Catholics won’t pray them. Is refusing to pray them disobedient to him as a Pope?
22:21 – John Paul II met with every group except for homosexuals or those with AIDS. Am I correct on this?
32:38 – I heard a story that JPII sent a pope mobile to Mother Teresa. I heard she sold it, is this true?
43:04 – I wonder how the philosophy of personalism affected JPII’s teachings and papacy?
50:53 – Mother Teresa did care for the people, but she did nothing to change their suffering and situation. How do you reconcile this?
#12940 Who Should Read About Catholic Marriage and Prayer? - Jimmy Akin
17 oct. 2026
“Who should read about Catholic marriage and prayer?” Understanding the resources available for modern Catholic marriage can be crucial, especially when navigating disputes and the complexities of communication with your spouse. Additionally, questions arise about the efficacy of prayer and whether the reality of hell should be used in evangelization efforts.
04:49 – Who would you recommend reading on successful modern Catholic marriage? What is the proper way to handle disputes or disagreements? Secular marriage advice is pretty awful. Are you supposed to just suffer and pray? Isn’t it lying to just bear all things without saying anything to your spouse when you are hurt or repeatedly upset about things? That is the advice I get from my priest: to pray and bear all things. But who can bottle things up over and over? I make it about three to four weeks and then crack.
19:30 – Jimmy, this is a bigger question, I suppose, but I have been thinking about the efficacy of prayer. Not that praying doesn’t matter, but asking for things to happen in prayer seems complex: “Why isn’t my prayer answered?” “Thank God, my prayer was answered.” “Pray harder.” “She’s a saintly person, and God listens to her prayers.” I think that, in the big picture, God isn’t cashing checks or picking winners and losers like that. To me, prayer is more about us and our relationship with God and less about winning or losing some spiritual game. I’m interested in your thoughts.
30:26 – Should Catholics try to use the reality of hell to get people to convert to the faith? I heard a traditional priest advocating that we should, but it seems ineffective and even counterproductive to me.
36:28 – This is probably stupid, but how do I know I’m supposed to join the religious life? What are the steps to join? This is driving me crazy.
42:55 – Why do so many people say “grevious” (GREE-vee-ous) instead of “grievous” (GREE-vus) during the general confession at Mass?
#12939 How Do I Heal from Trauma? Spiritual Direction and More - Jimmy Akin
16 oct. 2026
“How do I heal from trauma?” Healing from psychological wounds can be challenging, especially when support is limited. This episode addresses how to navigate this journey with God’s help, while also discussing when to seek spiritual direction and the role of spiritual directors. Additionally, the conversation touches on the interpretation of Jesus’ “whatever” question in Matthew and the distinctions between Catholicism and Eastern Orthodoxy.
01:19 – If I’m trying to heal from trauma and psychological wounds (with no access to therapy, no friends, and only God to help), how do I go about it? How do I make sure I don’t dig myself in deeper, for example by misunderstanding a teaching because of that trauma? In any case, it makes it hard to see things clearly. Slightly related: When, if ever, should one meet with a spiritual director? Who benefits from a spiritual director? Who are spiritual directors (for example, a layperson, a priest, a nun)?
15:50 – How should Catholics treat the “whatever” question? In Matthew 16:19 Jesus says whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven and whatever you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven. There are no apparent terms, conditions, or limitations on what this “whatever” is in the surrounding text. If you look at Matthew 18:18, it’s pretty clear Jesus is talking specifically about sin, but in addition to being its own can of worms, that leaves out important things like ritual and sacramental practices, church disciplines, governance, canon, etc. And if you look at the Council of Jerusalem in Acts, the Church makes some pretty big changes when it comes to not applying Old Testament practices to Gentiles. So this suggests “whatever” goes beyond what is and isn’t a sin.
39:41 – Well, since you asked: Although I’m aware you’ve touched on this point before, a major question I often hear, particularly from young men, is why Catholicism over Eastern Orthodoxy? I’m aware of many young people who want a liturgical Christian life but are straddling the fence between East and West. I would like to hear a cogent argument, freshly given, about the need for the papacy and the magisterium, in a way that young Americans can grasp.
48:50 – In his recent encyclical, Pope Leo made a brief reference to just war theory being outdated. Can you elaborate on what he meant by that and what he’d replace it with?
#12938 Why Does the Church Reject Penal Substitution? Indulgences, Demons - Karlo Broussard
16 oct. 2026
“Why does the Church reject penal substitution?” This question opens a discussion on the Catholic understanding of atonement, alongside inquiries about indulgences and their relationship to works, as well as the Church’s teachings on the power of demons. Other topics include the debate on women’s ordination and the role of prayer in the Rosary.
02:40 – Why does the Catholic Church reject the idea of penal substitutionary atonement?
14:14 – I don’t understand indulgences. It seems like that is being saved by works.
21:35 – What does the church teach about the power of demons? It seems like compared to the power of the Lord it would be hardly anything.
29:45 – I disagree with the prohibition against women’s ordination. There was an early deaconess named Julia and the Church changed her name to Julian to try to pretend she was a man. And I hear Catholics cite the idea that Jesus was a male so priests must be male, but we also use the language of the Church being a bride — well, there are men in the bride, so why couldn’t a woman be a priest?
41:52 – I’m in OCIA. But I don’t think we should be praying the Rosary because it’s not in the Bible.
48:29 – I’m a baby catechist. I have a problem believing in the supernaturality Jesus, like hearing about him appearing places and walking through walls.
#12937 Pastor Makes Kids Destroy Statues of Mary – Response & AMA - Karlo Broussard
15 oct. 2026
Dr. Karlo responds to a recent incident, where a pastor has kids destroy statues of Mary. The discussion also touches on how to pray to saints without crossing into idolatry, the peculiarities of displaying relics, and the complexities surrounding the infallibility of the pope amidst differing approaches from recent leaders.
00:30 – Reaction to video: Protestant pastor has kids smash statues of Mary
17:55 – I’m in OCIA, converting from a lot of Protestant churches. How do I pray to the saints without accidentally making it idolatrous?
22:51 – I have a tough time seeing Fulton Sheen’s jaw out on parade. It just seems weird.
35:30 – Religions were our first attempts to explain the universe. Then we invented science and realised how wrong we were.
44:18 – Is it a desecration to remove body parts from deceased saints and put them reliquaries?
50:25 – I’m in OCIA. I’m struggling with the idea of the infallibility of the pope. The last several popes had such different approaches to leading the church — how could they all be infallible?
#12936 How Do You Justify Replacing Holy Days? Apostles and Mary - Joe Heschmeyer
15 oct. 2026
“How do you justify replacing Holy Days?” This question leads to a discussion on the evolution of celebrations and supposed connections to pagan roots. Additionally, the conversation touches on how the Catholic Church fulfills the fivefold ministry of Ephesians 4:11 in the absence of the Apostles and explores historical evidence regarding the journeys of Apostles like Peter and John.
04:55 – As a “Primitive Christian,” how do you justify replacing 1st-century Holy Days with modern celebrations that have pagan roots?
29:00 – If Apostles no longer exist, how does the Catholic Church fulfill the fivefold ministry of Ephesians 4:11?
40:12 – Is there historical evidence of where Apostles like Peter and John went to spread Christianity?
45:12 – Are there any early church writings regarding Mary?
#12935 What Is the Earliest Christian Document? Church Fathers, Saints - Joe Heschmeyer
14 oct. 2026
“What is the earliest Christian document outside of the Bible?” This question opens a discussion on the foundational texts of Christianity, including insights into early Church Fathers and their teachings. The conversation also touches on the perspectives of early church fathers regarding sola scriptura, the Catholic view on the death penalty in light of Genesis 9:6, and the practice of praying to saints in the early Church.
03:16 – What is the earliest Christian document outside of the Bible?
11:30 – Were there early church fathers that taught sola scriptura? St. Ambrose wrote “how are we to have recourse to things that are not in Holy writ?”
15:09 – How do Catholics view the death penalty as it relates to Genesis 9:6? Why do Catholics not require non-resistance, given that it was taught by the Pre-Nicene Fathers?
30:42 – How did the early Church and its bishops view praying to the saints in the first few centuries?
42:26 – Recommended Church Fathers Reading for New Catholics
48:11 – Does the Modern “Way International” Have Any Relation to the Early Church’s “The Way”?
#12934 Why Do Catholics Believe in the Real Presence and Saints? - Karlo Broussard
14 oct. 2026
“Why do Catholics believe in the Real Presence?” This question opens a discussion on the literal interpretation of the Eucharist, contrasting with symbolic views held by others. Additionally, the conversation addresses doubts stemming from differing ministries and provides clarity on the role of saints in Catholic faith, including responses to misconceptions about their intercessory power.
01:32 – I am experience doubt, specifically Fr. James Martin ministry. I am coming from a protestant background so I am shocked.
15:10 – Why do Catholics take the Real Presence literally while others take it as symbols?
21:00 – She said that praying to the Saints is giving them the power of God. How can I respond?
#12933 Do Saints Go to Purgatory? Infallibility and Ministry - Karlo Broussard
13 oct. 2026
“Do saints go to purgatory?” This question is addressed alongside discussions about the implications of becoming Catholic for one’s ministry and the definition of saints in scripture. The episode also touches on the relationship between the narrow way Jesus described and the Catholic Church’s size and wealth, as well as the concept of infallibility and its reasoning.
11:48 – My OCIA class shared that Saints don’t go to purgatory. Is this true?
21:26 – I don’t know what would happen to my ministry if I became Catholic.
28:45 – According to scripture, saints are all believers in Christ, not just people the pope decided were special.
35:35 – If Jesus said the way is narrow, how does that relate to the Catholic church. It is a large and wealthy institution.
49:10 – I am confused about circular reasoning behind the infallibility of the catholic church.
#12932 Doesn’t the Thief on the Cross Prove Sacraments Are Optional? - Karlo Broussard
13 oct. 2026
“Doesn’t the thief on the cross prove sacraments are optional?” This question raises important considerations about the necessity of sacraments in the Catholic faith. Other topics discussed include the origins of private confession and concerns about the seal of confession potentially protecting criminals, as well as the relationship between penance and the concept of grace.
01:20 – Doesn’t the thief on the cross prove the whole sacramental system is optional? So why should any of us bother with the sacrament?
06:16 – Isn’t private confession a medieval invention, not something apostolic? (Doesn’t history show the confessional isn’t apostolic at all?)
15:01 – Isn’t the seal of confession a dangerous rule that shields criminals? (How is that not dangerous — protecting criminals and endangering the public?)
22:37 – Isn’t assigning penance works-righteousness that denies ‘Christ paid it all’? (Isn’t penance just topping up a payment Jesus already made in full?)
41:51 – But confession, penance, absolution sounds like works you perform to earn your way back. Isn’t that the opposite of the gospel?
#12931 Why Confess to a Priest? The Priesthood and Forgiveness - Karlo Broussard
12 oct. 2026
“Why confess to a priest?” This question addresses the role of the priesthood in the sacrament of reconciliation. Other topics include the concept of the priesthood of all believers and whether John 20 implies that apostles merely announce forgiveness rather than absolve sins. The discussion also touches on the continuity of apostolic authority and the necessity of the sacrament.
01:51 – Why do I have to confess to a priest — can’t I go straight to Jesus?
07:45 – Why a special priest at all — aren’t all believers priests? (The priesthood of all believers — doesn’t that make every Christian a priest, with no need for an absolving clergy-caste?)
18:30 – Doesn’t John 20 just mean the apostles announce forgiveness, not absolve? (Couldn’t that just mean they PROCLAIM God’s forgiveness — preach it — rather than personally absolve?)
24:50 – Even if it’s real absolution power God gave the Apostles, why think it passed on after the apostles died? (Where does Scripture say it passes on, instead of dying with the Twelve?)
38:38 – When the Bible instructs us to confess our sins isn’t that a reference to mutual accountability among believers — not kneeling before an ordained man?
49:31 – If perfect contrition already forgives, isn’t the sacrament unnecessary?