Explore every episode of the podcast Broadway with AJ and Sarah

In this enchanting episode, we head to the redwoods to catch Into the Woods at Santa Cruz Shakespeare! 🌲✨ Before the show, we sat down with some of the incredible artists behind the magic: Ciarra Stroud (Rapunzel/Cinderella), Elliot (Cinderella’s Prince and more!), and Music Director Luke. We chat about their unique takes on the Sondheim classic, performing in an outdoor amphitheater, and what it means to tell fairy tales under the stars.

Whether you’re a Sondheim superfan or new to the woods, this episode is full of behind-the-scenes gems you won’t want to miss!

In this episode, we're headed to Silicon Valley Shakespeare to catch their charming outdoor production of Emma, Jane Austen’s classic story of matchmaking and self-discovery. We loved the clever direction, sharp performances, and all the delightful Austen wit brought to life under the stars.

We also had the pleasure of chatting with director Erin Southard about the process of adapting Emma for the stage and what makes this version stand out.

To top it all off, we played a fun Jane Austen-themed game that tested our knowledge and had us laughing in true Regency style. Join us for theater talk, behind-the-scenes insight, and a little Austen-inspired fun!

In this episode, we chat with Rachel Simone Webb, star of the & Juliet North American tour. She shares her journey from ensemble member to leading lady, the bold move that landed her the role, and what it means to bring a modern, empowered Juliet to life. We dive into tour life, representation in theater, and the pop songs that make this show a fan favorite.

AJ’s back from New York and ready to spill all the theatrical tea! In this episode, they recap their whirlwind Broadway adventure, including a hauntingly glamorous take on Sunset Boulevard, a powerhouse revival of Gypsy, and the hilariously campy musical adaptation of Death Becomes Her. From standing ovations to standing in line at the stage door, AJ shares all the highlights, hot takes, and unforgettable moments from their trip to the Great White Way.

🎭 This week, we stepped into the world of The Drowsy Chaperone at WVLO! After enjoying the show, we caught up with two standout cast members—Melissa (Janet Van De Graaff) and Tony (Adolpho)—to chat all things musical theater. From lightning-fast quick changes to their ultimate dream roles, this behind-the-scenes peek is full of laughs, insight, and Broadway dreams. Whether you’re a theater fan or just love a good interview, you won’t want to miss this one!

This week, we’re chatting with Ruby Day! Recently starting in Waitress at SF Playhouse and now currently closing out the month at the San Jose Stage in Sweet Charity! We talk about her theater journey, some dream roles, and rhyming game leaving us wondering if we should quit our day jobs.

This week, we’re diving into SVS’s thrilling new production of The Tempest—a fantastical reimagining where Shakespeare meets Dungeons & Dragons.

We share our thoughts on the show’s creative world-building, standout performances, and how this magical island adventure gets a tabletop twist. Plus, we sit down with director Drew Benjamin Jones to talk about his bold DND-inspired vision, turning Prospero into a dungeon master, and how the cast embraced this imaginative approach to storytelling.

We’re breaking down Broadway’s biggest night—the Tony Awards! 🎭✨ Tune in as we share our favorite show-stopping performances, gush (and side-eye) over red carpet fashion moments, and dive into the win that truly stole our hearts. From standing ovations to style statements, we’ve got all the glittering highlights and hot takes you need.

This week, we’re headed off from Sacramento with the electrifying Billy Rude, who’s currently tearing up the stage as Jerry Lee Lewis in Million Dollar Quartet at Broadway At Music Circus! 🎹🔥

We chat all about the unique experience of performing in the iconic theater-in-the-round, what it takes to bring the “wild child” of rock ‘n’ roll to life, and how the energy of the tent fuels the performance. Billy also opens up about his path to the role and the magic of live musical theatre.

Plus, we play a theater-themed game that gets very visionary—and Billy reveals his dream roles. Don’t miss this fun and heartfelt conversation with one of the most dynamic talents working in regional theatre today!

Double episode week! This time, we journey into the misty Highlands with South Bay Musical Theatre’s production of Brigadoon. We unpack the timeless charm of Lerner and Loewe’s classic, from its lush score to the romantic, otherworldly tale of a village that appears once every hundred years. Tune in as we share our thoughts on the local cast, standout musical numbers, and what made this production feel like stepping into a dream.

This week, we're headed to San Francisco’s Orpheum Theatre to experience the Tony-winning revival of Parade. From the haunting score to the powerhouse performances, we break down what makes this production so emotionally gripping and historically resonant. Join us as we dive into the story of Leo Frank, the musical’s timely themes, and our personal takeaways from the show. Plus, a few behind-the-scenes tidbits from the BroadwaySF experience!

We’re back! Did you miss us? We’re here to discuss our latest adventure with special guest Renee!

This week, we’re taking you along for the ride from Jersey Boys at Palo Alto Players! From the harmonies to the heartbreak, we’re breaking down everything we loved about this high-energy production of the Tony Award-winning musical.

Plus, we’ve got an exclusive treat for our listeners: use promo code BILLBOARD for a special discount on tickets!

Hit play, and let’s walk like a man through one of Broadway’s biggest jukebox hits!

Follow us:

Instagram | @broadwaywithajandsarah

Website | BroadwaywithAJandSarah.com

This week, we’re chatting with AJ’s castmates in his latest show, Eshani (Billie) and Raelaine (Assistant Director). Join us as we share our shenanigans thus far from our rehearsal progress and what we’re looking forward to the audiences enjoying!

Use code ERIC for a discount on tickets, available now at SVCT.org

This week, we’re diving into the darkly hilarious world of Heathers: The Musical with Korsa Musical Theater! From powerhouse vocals to jaw-dropping moments, we’re breaking down what made this production so “very.” We’ll talk about the show’s bold themes, standout performances, and whether this Heathers had us saying “How very!” or reaching for a slushie. Tune in for our full review—it’s gonna be Big Fun!

This week, we’re heading back to Rydell High as we check out Grease at Altarena Playhouse! We got the chance to chat with cast members Liam, Seana, Kitt, and Luc about bringing this iconic musical to life, their favorite moments on stage, and what makes this production stand out. From slicked-back hair to high-energy dance numbers, we’re breaking down all the magic happening at Altarena. So grab your leather jackets and poodle skirts—it’s time to hand jive!

This week, we’re diving into The Cher Show! We saw the musical celebrating the Goddess of Pop herself and have thoughts. From dazzling costumes to powerhouse vocals, we break down what worked, what didn’t, and whether this show does justice to Cher’s legendary career. Tune in as we discuss the highs, the lows, and everything in between—because, as Cher would say, the beat goes on!

This week, we take a magical journey into WVLO’s production of Pippin! From dazzling choreography to standout performances, we break down what made this production shine. Plus, we reveal our final rating and, most importantly, Sarah adds a brand-new joke to her ever-growing Rolodex of comedy. Don’t miss this one—it’s got spectacle, laughs, and a little bit of existential crisis.

We’re back! This week, we’re diving into ACT’s stellar production of Nobody Loves You, the sharp and hilarious musical that takes reality TV romance to the stage. We break down the show’s witty book, infectious score, and standout performances that had us both laughing and fully invested. Plus, we discuss how this underrated gem brilliantly satirizes modern dating culture while delivering plenty of heart. Tune in as we share our favorite moments and why this production is a must-see!

Another straight play! This week we’re returning to our lovely Half Moon Bay theater to support our director Allie with her latest endeavor. Join us as we chat with cast members Chloe, Shann, and Devin!

It's a show about peeing! Join us this week as we chat with Andrew (Bobby) and Michelle (Hope) about South Bay's latest production, Urinetown, running until February 16th at the Saratoga Civic Theater.

This week, we’re seeing another straight play! Join us in our review of PAP’s latest production and an exciting story time with Sarah to leave you laughing.

This week, we travelled to Livermore to see Rock of Ages and we got to chat with Robert (Dennis Dupree), Liam (Stacee Jaxx), Kinsey (Sherrie), Ben (Drew), and Larri (Justice). The show runs through January 26th at the Bankhead Theater!

Did you miss us? We hope you had a wonderful holiday season. Come listen to us banter for 40 minutes and talk about some upcoming shows we’re looking forward to seeing!

This week, we’re headed to SF to see a pantomime? Come hear our fun chat with Corey (Peter Pan) and Rotimi (Captain Hook) for the beloved musical with a modern, quirky twist!

This week, we're bringing the excitement of our cast party straight to you! Join us as we sit down with Allie Bailey (Director) and Andy Kline (Vocal Director) to reflect on the journey of bringing this production to life. From their favorite moments to behind-the-scenes stories, we dive into what made this show truly special. Don’t miss this lively and heartfelt conversation!

We trekked up to the city this week to see one of AJ’s favorite musicals. Plus hear about our recent experiences so far at Legally Blonde!

We’re back! And here to talk about the long awaited movie musical adaptation that has taken over the world. Plus you don’t want to miss Sarah’s story time this week.

Happy Halloween! We're headed to the California Theater for Symphony San Jose's spooky concert filled with classic spooky pieces and modern movie scores.

This week, we're headed back to Foster City and we're chatting with Sarah (Susan) and Coop (Roat) in Hillbarn's latest production, Wait Until Dark.

This week, we trekked up to Berkeley to see Choir Boy! We also got to chat with Wesley, William, and Omar who star in the production!

This week, we're headed back to South Bay MT to see this classic musical about... nothing?!

This week, we traveled back to the Pear and were transformed to the beach! We got to chat with cast members Nique, Naomi, and Kristy about their experience so far. This show runs until October 13th.

This week, we’re chatting with some of our cast mates from our upcoming production, Legally Blonde!

This week, we’re headed back to Berkeley, this time to see this wonderfully colorful piece about love and acceptance!

This week, we’re chatting with a Bay Area lighting legend as she details what got her into the field of lighting as well as her experience with the ever changing technology!

We’re heading back to Hillbarn to see this story of friendship and listen to some classic country tunes!

This week, we made the trek to SF to see Evita! Plot twist- we’re trying virtual pods again.

This week, we’re talking with cast members Karen and Bart of City Lights’ latest iconic show.

It’s a double episode week! We’re seeing Hunchback again! This time we caught the closing performance at TMC Arts and were spilling all our thoughts!

This week, we’re returning to Coastal Rep in Half Moon Bay to see this movie-turned musical! The show runs until August 18 and tickets are available at coastalrep.com

Surprise! Sarah and Kris (returns!) for a bonus episode, chatting with Angie and Alika on the latest production to perform at the beautiful outdoor Sanborn Park!

Join us this week with a returning guest, Ric, as we talk about a plethora of things including of course, theater! Plus a special John Denver tune to lift your spirits.

This week, Sarah got a chance to see AJ as Motel in the classic Fiddler on the Roof. We're joined by returning guest host Bryan, Evalina (Tzeitel), and Sarah E (Hodel). The show runs until August 3rd at the Hammer Theater and tickets are available now at lyrictheatre.org. Use the code SUMMER for a discount.

This week, we're sitting down with two theater pals to discuss gender inclusivity within our theater community and some of their personal experiences/perspectives as non-binary performers in the Bay Area.

This week, we're returning to WVLO and we're chatting with Justin (Robbie), Andrew (Sammy), and David (George)!

Our plans this week got de-railed but we're here and ready to update everyone!

This week, we're giving you all our opinions on Broadway's big night.

Link to the fashions we were critiquing: https://www.usmagazine.com/stylish/pictures/the-best-red-carpet-fashion-from-the-2024-tony-awards/

Murder On the Orient Express runs at Palo Alto Players until June 30th. Get your tickets now at paplayers.org

Sorry! Re-uploaded due to technical difficulties: This week, we attended the original Sondheim revue and got to chat with Solona Husband and Melissa WolfKlain!

We're back for a double episode week, this time reviewing the latest musical performed at The Stage in San Jose! This show runs until June 30th and tickets are available at TheStage.org