What if philanthropy’s biggest blind spot is the power it already holds? In this episode, co-hosts Ralph Lewin, Executive Director of the Peter E. Haas Jr. Family Fund, and Glen Galaich sit down with Shane Murphy Goldsmith, President and CEO of the Liberty Hill Foundation, to examine what Shane calls philanthropy’s “power blindness.” Drawing on Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.'s Letter from Birmingham Jail, Shane challenges the contradiction of championing social change while expecting community organizations to operate within funders’ rules, timelines, and definitions of success.
Shane draws on Liberty Hill’s decades of supporting grassroots organizing in Los Angeles to make the case that the people closest to the pain should also be closest to the power. She shares how community-led organizing has uncovered solutions that institutions overlooked, and why she believes organizing is essential to the practice of democracy. Together, Shane, Ralph, and Glen examine philanthropy’s complicated relationship with power, including its reliance on the very systems it seeks to change. Their conversation challenges a fundamental fake rule: that grantees must answer to foundations rather than the communities they serve. If philanthropy wants to strengthen democracy, Shane argues, it must reconsider who holds power, who makes decisions, and who gets to hold organizations accountable.
💡 Shane Murphy Goldsmith: “I believe community organizing is the antidote to authoritarianism, precisely because of how community organizing creates the practice of democracy. It animates democracy. It teaches people how to be in a democracy.”
Explore the Liberty Hill Foundation and its work supporting grassroots community organizing and building community power across Los Angeles.
Listen to Shane's podcast, Conversations from the Frontlines, and hear Glen's conversation with her on the episode, Who Controls Change?
Discover More Perfect Union and its approach to reporting on the issues affecting working people.
Read Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.’s Letter from Birmingham Jail, which Shane draws on to question philanthropy’s preference for moderation and maintaining the status quo over meaningful social change.
Order your copy of Glen’s book, CONTROL: Why Big Giving Falls Short.
Learn about the Stupski Foundation.
Co-Hosts: Ralph Lewin & Glen Galaich
Guests: Shane Murphy Goldsmith
Production Team: Podfly
Graphic Design: Middle MGMT