Explore every episode of the podcast Between Two Pumps

What cars actually live up to the hype—and which ones don't?

In this episode of Between Two Pumps, we get into the cars that surprised us, the ones that completely let us down, and why some vehicles prove you should never meet your heroes. From unexpected standouts like classic Alfa Romeos to iconic disappointments like the Turbo Trans Am, this episode is all about real-world driving experiences and honest enthusiast takes.

We also talk about which cars have aged well, which haven't, and how expectations can shape the way we experience a car behind the wheel.

If you've ever chased a dream car—or been surprised by something you didn't expect—this one's for you.

What would you buy with $1 million to spend on cars?

In the debut episode of Between Two Pumps, hosts Terry Shea, Mike Musto, and Terry McGean tackle the ultimate enthusiast question: go all-in on one dream car or build a diverse garage. From attainable performance picks to collector-grade icons, the conversation dives into what actually makes a car worth owning—and why the "best" choice isn't always the most expensive.

This episode sets the tone for the show: candid debate, deep automotive knowledge, and real-world perspective from decades of experience in the collector car market.

IN THIS EPISODE

• • One car vs. collection debate
  • Building a $1M dream garage
  • Best value enthusiast cars
  • What makes a car truly enjoyable
  • Real insights from the collector car market

Between Two Pumps is a Hemmings podcast hosted by Terry Shea, Mike Musto, and Terry McGean—bringing together decades of automotive experience, honest opinions, and real marketplace insight to help enthusiasts better understand the cars they love.

Explore cars for sale: Hemmings.com
Join Hemmings Motor Club: HMN.com/HMC