Alright, alright, alright! Joy abounded regarding this episode, Best Medicine Season 2, Episode 7, "Love Is a Battlefield," in which we see the American doctor defeating the Brit (or so we hope), just like the historic battle of Port Wenn.
Gabriela, Doug, Carol, and Mel are back. First up: was Louisa Gavin (Abigail Spencer) ever really happy with Parker (Jack Cutmore-Scott)? The house he's buying, the "I love you" with no "I love you too"... I’ll have to watch again after all this discussion. We have a loooong chat on Parker vs. Martin Best (Josh Charles). Is Parker a villain, or just selfish? Can we excuse him at all for going after what he wants, thinks Louisa wants, and thinks Martin wants? With Martin’s medical license up in the air, could Parker take any revenge on Martin, who called him mediocre and unmemorable? Could Parker's own Maine-vs-Massachusetts license come back to bite him?
Plus: is Sheriff Mark Mylow (Josh Segarra) really over Louisa? What is going on with Mark and his mom? The unsubtle redcoat symbolism, a medical-bag size contest, and Aunt Sarah (Annie Potts) in full colonial costume... with sneakers.
Meanwhile, the town is getting sick, and the ergot poisoning mystery leads straight to poor Geneva (Didi Conn). Martin's compassion (and growth!) gets a shout-out, Mel connects it all to a historical dancing plague, and we meet Ned (Jay Klaites), the stitch-counting reenactor who annoys everyone (well done, sir).
Al Large (Carter Shimp) and Elaine Denton (Cree) are headed to New York. Or are they? Bert Large (John DiMaggio) gives them a reality check, and the group votes on who actually leaves. And a blink-and-you-miss-it line finally tells us how long Bert's been in Al's life.
After a clear segue (Doc Martin spoilers ahead!), Chris joins Gabriela and Carol for a Doc Martin comparison. Is Parker Danny Steel (Tristan Sturrock) and Adrian Pitts (Rupert Young) rolled into one? Does Aunt Sarah seem a lot like Aunt Joan (Stephanie Cole)? Is Martin Best a more “normal” man than Martin Ellingham (Martin Clunes)? Are Best and Gavin a better-matched couple than Ellingham and Louisa Glasson (Caroline Catz)?
Did YOU see that kiss coming? Will Al and Elaine leave Port Wenn? Do you think Parker really thought Martin wanted to head back to Boston?
Tell me in the comments and subscribe so you don't miss next week!
Chapters:
[0:00] Cold open: "Did not see that coming"
[0:18] Welcome + hats off to the reenactment production
[1:02] Parker, Martin, Louisa: was she ever happy?
[2:42] Louisa's "open heart" line: a low blow?
[5:37] The shoving match & "unmemorable, mediocre"
[6:14] Villain arc, or just selfish?
[8:22] The ick: heat of the moment or low integrity?
[10:17] Is Parker gone? Plus the Maine license question
[12:03] "You make me want to be a better man"
[13:01] Angst ahead? Louisa, the license & blood phobia
[14:25] Is Mark over Louisa? Plus Mark and his mom
[17:00] Redcoats vs. colonists: the symbolism
[19:00] Martin protecting Louisa (thanks, Ami S.!)
[21:06] Parker treating Louisa like a prize
[23:39] Geneva & the ergot poisoning mystery
[24:28] Stitch counters & that fork
[25:57] Martin's growth: beer, mothballs & the festival snub
[26:39] Al & Elaine: really leaving for New York?
[31:15] 20 years: a blink-and-you-miss-it reveal
[32:39] What's next for Aunt Sarah & Louisa?
[34:40] Final thoughts: who saw the kiss coming?
[39:07] Segue: Doc Martin comparisons (spoilers!)
[39:47] Who is Parker? Danny Steel + Adrian Pitts
[42:46] Aunt Sarah vs. Aunt Joan
[45:38] Martin Best vs. Martin Ellingham
[49:51] Can they just be a normal couple?