Retour

Explorez tous les épisodes du podcast Beyond the Prescription

Plongez dans la liste complète des épisodes de Beyond the Prescription. Chaque épisode est catalogué accompagné de descriptions détaillées, ce qui facilite la recherche et l'exploration de sujets spécifiques. Suivez tous les épisodes de votre podcast préféré et ne manquez aucun contenu pertinent.

Rows per page:

1–50 of 112

TitreDateDurée
What I Wish Every Woman Knew About Breast Cancer07 juil. 202600:44:26

My book, Beyond the Prescription, comes out on August 11! I wrote it with you in mind.

Episode Summary

Dr. Lucy McBride sits down with Dr. Amy Commander, breast oncologist at Mass General Brigham and author of Paving Your Path Through Breast Cancer and Beyond, to cut through the fear and misinformation around breast cancer. They cover who is actually at risk, what the screening guidelines mean in practice, what lifestyle factors move the needle, and how to make sense of the HRT and breast cancer conversation — including what the evidence actually says about hormone therapy for survivors.

Risk: Genetics, Bad Luck, and Everything In Between

* Only 5–10% of breast cancers in the U.S. are due to identifiable inherited gene mutations — BRCA1 and BRCA2 account for roughly half of those

* Another 10–15% involve familial patterns without a single identifiable gene; the remaining majority are sporadic, meaning they occur without an inherited cause we can currently explain

* Having breast cancer in your family doesn’t mean you have a genetic mutation — given that one in eight women will develop breast cancer in her lifetime, sometimes it just means you have women in your family

* A strong pattern — grandmother, mother, and sister all with breast cancer — is a signal worth discussing with a doctor; a single relative is not necessarily a reason for genetic testing

Screening: Mammograms, Dense Breasts, and MRI

* Mammograms do not cause breast cancer — annual screening starting at 40 is recommended for average-risk women, with the end point determined by a shared conversation with a doctor

* Dense breast tissue makes mammograms harder to read — finding a tumor in extremely dense tissue is like finding a snowman in a snowstorm; about 10% of women have extremely dense tissue and most should add an annual breast MRI staggered six months from their mammogram

* Heterogeneously dense tissue is common — up to 40% of women under 50 — but not everyone with it needs an MRI; the decision depends on other risk factors and should incorporate a validated risk model like the Tyrer-Cuzick calculator

* Breast MRI catches more, but also generates more false positives, particularly on the first scan; the downstream anxiety and biopsies are real costs that belong in the conversation

Lifestyle and Prevention

* Alcohol is the most consistent and modifiable lifestyle risk factor for breast cancer — even one drink per day carries a small but real increased risk, and the relationship is dose-dependent

* Maintaining a healthy weight and engaging in regular physical activity reduce risk — partly by reducing circulating estrogen in post-menopausal women and by improving metabolic health overall

* Soy is not a risk factor for breast cancer — this is a persistent myth; soy foods are a good source of plant-based protein and the evidence is clear that they are safe

* Risk factors divide into fixed (age, sex, genetics) and modifiable (alcohol, weight, exercise, metabolic health); the goal is to lean into what can be changed without catastrophizing what cannot

HRT and Breast Cancer: Separating Fear from Evidence

* The fear around HRT and breast cancer stems largely from the 2002 Women’s Health Initiative study, which used synthetic progestins — not the bioidentical hormones most commonly prescribed today

* In the WHI, women who took estrogen alone — those who had undergone hysterectomy — actually had a reduced risk of breast cancer, a finding that was not widely reported

* The overall increased risk from combined hormone therapy is small, and causation has not been established; a family history of breast cancer is not an automatic disqualification from HRT

* HRT is a tool in the toolkit, not a solution for everyone — the right answer depends on individual risk factors, symptom burden, and what a woman is willing to weigh

Vaginal Estrogen and Breast Cancer Survivors

* Vaginal estrogen is considered safe for virtually all women, including most breast cancer survivors, because systemic absorption is minimal

* It is distinct from systemic HRT and should not be lumped in with it — women who have had breast cancer and are suffering from genitourinary symptoms should know this option exists

* For women on systemic HRT who also use vaginal estrogen, the two can be used together; the patch is not a substitute for vaginal estrogen because the tissue itself needs local treatment

* Oncologists are increasingly getting educated on menopause management — the divide between oncology and women’s health is closing, and patients benefit when their cancer doctor and primary care doctor are working from the same playbook

Survivorship: Thriving Beyond a Diagnosis

* Too many women feel defined by their diagnosis, or guilty that they somehow caused it — neither is warranted, and neither serves the goal of getting better

* Breast cancer is not one disease; genomic tools like the Oncotype DX and ProSigna help determine whether chemotherapy is even necessary, sparing many women from treatment that won’t help them

* The pillars of thriving after breast cancer mirror the pillars of health generally — sleep, movement, stress management, social connection, and a sense of purpose

* Patients have more agency than they often believe: where genetics and diagnosis are fixed, how a woman shows up for her body, her relationships, and her care is not

Upshot

Breast cancer is common, but fear and misinformation make it harder to navigate than it needs to be. Most cases have nothing to do with inherited genes. Screening saves lives. HRT is not the villain it was made out to be. And a diagnosis, however frightening, is not the whole story — patients have more agency than they think, and thriving after breast cancer is a real and achievable goal.

And, if you liked this episode, check out my conversations on Hormone Therapy, Hot Flashes and Sexual with Dr. Laura Streicher and Menopause and More with Dr. Sharon Malone!



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
The Silent Killer: What Everyone Should Know About Blood Pressure26 mai 202600:43:53

Dr. Lucy McBride sits down again with Dr. Greg Katz, cardiologist at NYU, to tackle the questions patients ask most about blood pressure: what the numbers actually mean, why a single reading in the doctor’s office can mislead, what drives hypertension in the first place, and how to think about treatment.

Tune in for practical, plainspoken advice, grounded in the reality of everyday patient care.

What Blood Pressure Actually Measures

* Blood pressure is the force your blood vessels experience as the heart contracts and relaxes

* Optimal depends on who you are — but is roughly 115 over 75

* Blood pressure is supposed to fluctuate — for example it goes up with exercise, stress, and other drivers of adrenaline; it goes down with deep breathing and rest

White Coat Hypertension and the Case for Home Monitoring

* Elevated readings in the doctor’s office don’t always reflect a diagnosis of hypertension

* Getting more data points by assessing home blood pressure readings is almost always the right call before making a treatment decision

* White coat hypertension is real, but so is the converse: people whose numbers are genuinely high regardless of setting, and who benefit from earlier intervention

What Drives High Blood Pressure

* High blood pressure is due to a combination of genetics, age, lifestyle, and underlying conditions

* Controllable contributors include weight, alcohol, sleep apnea, sodium intake, and chronic stress; uncontrollable ones include family history, age, and sex

* The blood pressure “serenity prayer” is a useful frame: accept what can’t be changed, lean hard into what can, and if blood pressure stays high after all of that, medication is not a defeat

The Consequences of Untreated Hypertension

* Stroke, heart attack, kidney failure, heart failure, and dementia are the major downstream consequences of untreated hypertension

* Dr. Katz calls it the “boring killer” — doctors see it so constantly it stops feeling urgent, but the cumulative damage of even mildly elevated pressure over years is not trivial

* The good news: blood pressure medications are cheap, well-tolerated, and effective; the hard part is implementing the right solution for each individual patient

How Blood Pressure Is Treated Pharmacologically

* ARBs like telmisartan or candesartan are often first-line, especially for patients with diabetes.

* Calcium channel blockers like amlodipine are a strong alternative and require no lab monitoring

* Beta blockers, once standard first-line treatment, have largely fallen out of favor for uncomplicated hypertension

* Importantly, medication is never a life sentence; it can be adjusted as circumstances change

Blood Pressure, Cholesterol, Blood Sugar aka the Cardiovascular Trifecta

* Blood pressure, cholesterol, and blood sugar are independent risk factors for vascular disease

* Metabolic syndrome (elevated blood pressure, large waist circumference, high triglycerides, low HDL) is a single condition that dysregulates all three simultaneously

* Getting all three under control is the most reliable way to reduce cardiovascular risk for the vast majority of patients

Upshot

High blood pressure doesn’t make headlines, but it drives some of the most serious and preventable health outcomes there are. The science and the tools to treat it exist. What requires more attention is the human context — who this patient is, what their life looks like, and which solution will actually work for them.

📣 Don’t miss out! You’ve got a few more days to join me this summer for the official Beyond the Prescription Book Club! It’s open exclusively to Substack readers and gives you early access to the book, pre-publication. 👀 We’ll get into the nitty gritty of health and wellness and what it all means for YOU.

Just a few days left! Sign-ups are open in May only.



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
Can People Actually Change?13 mai 202600:49:44

Dr. Lucy McBride sits down with Benoit Denizet-Lewis, longtime writer for the New York Times Magazine and bestselling author of You’ve Changed: The Promise and Price of Self-Transformation, for a wide-ranging conversation about how people actually transform.

What Transformation Actually Means—and How It Happens

* The self-help industry focuses on habit change and optimization; Denizet-Lewis was interested in something deeper: shifts in identity, perspective, and personality that make people feel genuinely different

* Change happens in multiple ways: sometimes it’s intentional and goal-directed, sometimes it arrives uninvited through illness, aging, or a moment of unexpected awe

* People are deeply conflicted about change: they want it for themselves and are simultaneously threatened by it in the people they love

* The narrative of transformation is almost always tidier in retrospect than it was in the living of it

Identifying What is Fixed vs. What Is Dynamic

* Core personality traits can be tweaked with real effort, but wholesale personality transformation is rare

* Genetics and childhood shape us in ways that are largely fixed, but how we relate to those things is not

* Trauma can be repaired; relationships fractured by the past can, with sustained work, become the closest ones we have

* The serenity prayer captures something clinically true: distinguishing between what is fixed and what is dynamic is the definition of wisdom

Self-Compassion as the Engine of Change

* The transformation Denizet-Lewis describes most personally wasn’t a dramatic identity shift: it was learning gentleness toward himself

* Ram Dass’s approach to jealousy—welcoming it in, naming it, refusing to let it run the show—illustrates what it looks like to observe a feeling without being consumed by it

* Honest self-observation is essential to change, but it has to be paired with compassion; without it, the mirror is too painful to look into

* An apology that ends with a period is one of the clearest expressions of self-awareness and change

Shame vs. Guilt—and Why the Difference Matters

* Guilt says “I did something bad”; shame says “I am bad”—and the distinction has real consequences for whether change is possible

* Research on young people who committed crimes found that guilt was a positive predictor of rehabilitation; shame, counterintuitively, increased the likelihood of reoffending

* The shame of failing to change—of breaking a resolution, relapsing, or falling short of a goal—is under-appreciated and causes many people to stop trying altogether

* Shining a light on shame, naming it, and normalizing it is often the first step toward dismantling it; living in it while organizing behaviors around it is one of the most reliable ways to stay stuck

Change as a Social Act

* We like to think of transformation as private and interior, but it happens in community—getting buy-in from others, having change witnessed and reflected back, is part of how it becomes real

* Social media has complicated this: performing transformation publicly creates skepticism, making it harder for genuine change to be legible to others

* Asking people close to you whether they’ve noticed a change—awkward as it is—can be one of the most grounding forms of accountability

Technology, Distractions, and Reclaiming Space

* The phone has become the first place most people go when anxiety surfaces — which means it’s both a cause of anxiety and the default coping mechanism for it

* Denizet-Lewis and McBride argue that the best thinking—in writing, in medicine, in life—tends to happen in stillness

Upshot

Transformation is messier, slower, and more social than many before-and-after stories suggest. The question isn’t whether change is possible—it is—but whether we’re willing to do the unglamorous work of honest self-observation, shame reduction, and showing up differently over time.

📣 HELLO READERS! Please join me this summer for the official Beyond the Prescription Book Club! It’s open exclusively to Substack readers and gives you early access to the book, pre-publication. 👀 We’ll get into the nitty gritty of health and wellness and what it all means for YOU.

Sign-ups are open in May only.



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
Mattering: An Overlooked Determinant of Human Health & What To Do About It07 mai 202600:27:39

Dr. Lucy McBride sits down with award-winning journalist Jennifer Wallace, author of the New York Times bestseller Mattering: The Secret to a Life of Deep Connection and Purpose, to explore why feeling valued—and adding value—may be one of the most powerful and overlooked determinants of health. They discuss the physiology of mattering and what you can do today to feel more grounded in their own worth.

What Mattering Actually Means

* Mattering is defined as feeling valued by family, friends, community, and society—and having the opportunity to add meaningful value back

* After food and shelter, it is the motivation to matter that most drives human behavior

* When people feel they matter, they contribute, engage, and show up pro-socially; when they don’t, they suffer and can act out in ways that harm themselves and their communities

* Mattering isn’t simply a feel-good concept; it’s physiologically measurable and directly linked to behaviors, blood pressure, and chronic stress

The Body Keeps Score on Mattering

* Feeling worthless or useless registers in the body as chronic stress, i.e., cortisol stays elevated and the nervous system does not feel safe

* In a study of suicidal men, the two words most commonly used to describe their suffering were “useless” and “worthless”

* The social proof that we matter—once delivered through neighbors, religious communities, and stable workplaces—has been quietly outsourced to the market, leaving a gap that Uber Eats and Amazon cannot fill

How Modern Life Is Eroding Our Sense of Mattering

* Signals of mattering used to be embedded in daily life—neighbors relied on each other, communities were interdependent; that infrastructure is dissolving

* The Dutch theologian Henri Nouwen’s three great lies—“I am what I have,” “I am what I do,” “I am what others think of me”—condition people to believe their worth is entirely conditional on external forces

* Workplaces have broken the loyalty contract; social media algorithms reward outrage over connection; AI threatens to make human contribution feel obsolete

* We’ve become less interdependent, and in losing that interdependence, we’ve lost one of the most reliable sources of feeling needed and valued

Mattering to Yourself First

* One of the hardest lessons: you cannot sustainably matter to others if you don’t matter to yourself

* A simple daily practice: while brushing your teeth each morning, ask what one small need you can meet for yourself

* The cultural message—especially for women and caregivers—that prioritizing your own needs is selfish is precisely backwards; burnout serves no one

* Sturdy adults need sturdy adults: surrounding yourself with even one or two people who remind you of your importance is a legitimate health intervention

Making Mattering Actionable

* Researchers identify four core ingredients of mattering, organized by Jennifer as SAID: Significant, Appreciated, Invested in, Depended on

* Feeling significant doesn’t come from life’s big moments; it comes from being remembered in the details, like a colleague checking in after a hard week

* Appreciating the doer behind the deed—not just thanking someone for what they did, but naming who they are—feeds mattering more deeply than gratitude alone

* A nightly practice: ask what one small need you filled today, one small way you added value, and one small way you felt valued—this works against the brain’s negativity bias and reinforces a sense of mattering over time

Upshot

The question isn't whether mattering affects your health — the research is unambiguous that it does. The question is whether you're tending to it with the same seriousness you bring to your labs.

📣 I’m starting an official Beyond the Prescription Book Club. We’ll get into the nitty gritty of health and wellness and what it all means for YOU. It’s open exclusively to Substack readers and gives you early access to the book. Sign-ups are open in May only.

Learn how to join here!



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
Health & Human Connection: A Conversation with Former U.S. Surgeon General, Dr. Vivek Murthy21 avr. 202600:33:39

Episode Summary

Dr. Lucy McBride sits down with Dr. Vivek Murthy, the 19ths and 21st U.S. Surgeon General and the founder of the Together Project, to talk about why the “achieve, acquire, optimize” model of success leaves so many people empty, and what actually fills the gap. They explore the science of social connection, the hidden costs of optimization culture, social media’s complex role in our lives, and why relationships matter for human health.

The Limits of “Achieve, Acquire, Optimize”

* When Dr. Murthy asked young people across the country how they defined success, the answer was remarkably consistent: money, power, and fame. Yet many who had all three were deeply unhappy.

* The real triad of fulfillment isn’t money, power, and fame; it’s relationships, purpose, and service

* Over-optimization culture sells false certainty; the three-, five-, and seven-step programs over-promise and often obscure the fact that what we actually need is community, not a protocol.

* We weren’t built to navigate life’s challenges alone. The myth of rugged individualism as a proxy for strength is a harmful story modern culture tells.

The Four Dimensions of Health

* Physical health is only one piece; mental, social, and spiritual health are equally important dimensions that medicine has been slow to embrace. (Read Dr. McBride’s two-part series, Mental Health is Health, here and here.)

* Someone can have perfect vital signs and a clean lipid panel and still be profoundly unhealthy if they’re isolated, purposeless, or disconnected from meaning.

* Dr. McBride wrote a prescription for human connection for an isolated patient during the pandemic—not a medication, but an instruction to reconnect with old friends.

* Expanding the lens through which we look at health isn’t soft or quaint; it’s what the evidence demands.

The Data on Social Connection

* The WHO Commission on Social Connection, co-chaired by Dr. Murthy, synthesized decades of research in a June 2025 report showing that social disconnection nearly doubles the risk of depression.

* Physical health consequences are equally striking: a roughly 30% increased risk of heart disease and stroke, and a 50% increased risk of dementia among older adults.

* The overall mortality impact of social disconnection is on par with obesity and smoking, yet we treat it as a lifestyle preference, not a public health priority.

* People often need explicit permission to prioritize relationships; both doctors here agree that medicine needs to “prescribe” it.

Social Media and the Erosion of Real Connection

* Social media was designed to maximize time on platform. Addictive features are not accidental but intentional.

* Movements like Logoff are helping peers take deliberate breaks and reclaim their attention.

* Practical starting points include tech-free dinner tables, devices charged in the kitchen overnight, and designated offline windows—none of which require waiting for a legislative fix or accountability from tech companies.

The Together Project and What to Do Today

* The Together Project focuses on three things: telling the story of connection and its science, supporting community builders who are often isolated in their own work, and expanding the research base.

* Dr. Murthy’s framework for a good day asks not how many to-do items were completed, but whether he loved, served, and grew.

* His single practical prescription: spend five minutes every day reaching out to someone you care about, just to check in.

Upshot

Human connection is as essential to health as any biomarker. The question isn’t whether relationships matters, it’s what we do every day to center them in our lives.

My book, Beyond the Prescription, comes out on August 11! I wrote it with you in mind.



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
What the New Cholesterol Guidelines Mean for You: A Conversation with NYU Cardiologist Dr. Greg Katz 01 avr. 202600:50:08

Episode Summary

Dr. Lucy McBride sits down with Dr. Greg Katz, cardiologist and educator at NYU, to make sense of the new 2026 cholesterol guidelines — and what they actually mean for real patients. Together, they cut through the noise on coronary artery calcium scores, Lp(a), statins, GLP-1s, and the lifestyle factors that matter most for heart health. The upshot: we treat people, not numbers.

The New Cholesterol Guidelines — Goals and Limits

* The 2026 guidelines were released in March, endorsed by eleven groups of medical experts, and they reflect a synthesis of existing cardiovascular evidence, not new data.

* The goal of updated guidelines isn’t for doctors (or patients) to treat them as the Bible, but rather to help assess cardiovascular risk, estimate the benefit of various interventions, and help patients understand how medical evidence applies to them.

* Guidelines are built on large populations; they can’t account for the individual patient sitting in front of you. For example, two people with identical LDL levels can have entirely different risk profiles, family histories, reasons their cholesterol is elevated, and therefore completely different treatment pathways.

* Read more on what the new guidelines don’t tell you here.

Coronary Artery Calcium Scores — What They Can and Can’t Tell You

* A calcium score looks for calcified, hardened plaque in the coronary arteries — it tells you about the “plumbing,” not the whole story of a patient’s heart health.

* A score of zero doesn’t mean you have no plaque; soft plaque is invisible on this test and can still cause blockages.

* A non-zero score doesn’t mean a heart attack is imminent — age, sex, and the rest of your risk profile matter enormously.

* When doctors overreact to elevated scores, it can set off a cascade of unnecessary tests and procedures and lead to patient anxiety. As always, context and appropriate communication matter when transmitting information to patients.

Blood Pressure: The Underappreciated Risk Factor

* Blood pressure is probably the most underappreciated driver of cardiovascular risk — contributing to heart disease, heart failure, kidney failure, and dementia.

* If someone has an elevated calcium score and imperfect blood pressure, controlling the blood pressure often matters more than starting a statin.

* Most heart disease prevention comes down to three things: blood pressure, cholesterol, and metabolic health (Read more on what your blood pressure is telling you here).

Statins — Who Needs Them, and What the Side Effects Actually Mean

* Statins reduce cardiovascular risk by about 20-25% on average — but if your baseline risk is very low, 20% of near-zero is still near-zero!

* Side effects are real but manageable: about 8-10% of people get muscle aches that are predictable and reversible when the medication is stopped.

* Claims that statins cause diabetes are overblown — the blood sugar rise is not inevitable and often is small and predictable.

* Non-statin options give patients who can’t tolerate statins real alternatives.

Lp(a) — What It Is and What to Do With It

* Lipoprotein(a) is a genetically driven particle that accelerates plaque formation, promotes inflammation, and makes blood more likely to clot.

* It is not modifiable by lifestyle, and statins actually raise it slightly — the LDL remains the primary therapeutic target.

* A very high Lp(a) combined with a strong family history of early heart disease is a red flag that should sharpen clinical decision-making across the board.

* Drugs to directly lower Lp(a) are in late-stage trials and look promising, but aren’t yet on the market.

Exercise, Diet, and the Case Against Prescriptive Protocols

* The best exercise is the one you’ll actually do — movement matters more than which movement.

* Strength training is especially important in midlife to preserve muscle mass, but the barriers are real; YouTube body weight workouts are a legitimate starting point.

* Most people know what junk food is; the best dietary strategy is the one that fits your actual life — and only a real conversation reveals which approach will stick.

Upshot

The new cholesterol guidelines are a useful framework — not a personal prescription. Whether the question is statins, calcium scores, or Lp(a), the answer almost always depends on who you are, what your family history looks like, and what you’re willing to do. Numbers need context, and good medicine means treating the human behind the chart.

Drop your comments here!

Pre-order Beyond the Prescription — out August 11!



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
Cutting Through Wellness Noise: 6 Rules for a Long & Healthy Life with Dr. Zeke Emanuel17 mars 202600:49:31

Dr. Lucy McBride sits down with Dr. Zeke Emanuel — physician, bioethicist, and key architect of the Affordable Care Act — to discuss his new New York Times bestseller Eat Your Ice Cream: Six Simple Rules for a Long and Healthy Life. They explore the challenges of navigating our fragile medical system alongside a bustling wellness industry, what the data show about longevity, and why a living meaningful life is the best health strategy of all.

The “Wellness Industrial Complex”

* The wellness industry is flourishing in part because people lack access to primary care and they want to be well, but they don’t know who to trust with their health — their doctor? ChatGPT? the online guru?

* Biohacking, optimizing, and obsessive self-tracking are marketing terms — whereas biology is built for moderation, not extremes

* Both doctors cautioned against wellness influencers who may have conflicts of interest or whose advice is aspirational, extrapolated from animal studies, and not evidence-based

Zeke Emanuel’s Six Rules to Live a Long & Healthy Life

* Don’t be a schmuck, socialize, eat well, sleep, exercise, and stay cognitively engaged — all well-supported by evidence, none requiring expensive protocols

* The goal isn’t perfection; it’s a sustainable routine you enjoy, because you’ll need to maintain it for decades

* Missing a workout or a healthy meal once isn’t the problem — what matters is the overall pattern

Social Connection Is Not Optional

* Social isolation is one of the most dangerous and least-discussed health risks — chronic loneliness carries risks comparable to smoking 15 cigarettes a day

* Among 50-year-olds followed over eight years, those without close friendships had a 25% higher mortality rate

* Nearly 20% of Americans now have zero or one friend, up from about 5-6% in prior decades — and more than half of meals in the U.S. are eaten alone

Meaning and Purpose as Medicine

* Getting outside yourself — directing attention outward toward others — is both the antidote to modern narcissism and the foundation of genuine fulfillment

* Meaning doesn’t have to be grand; a school bus driver who made it his purpose to help each child start the day well illustrates how ordinary roles can be deeply sustaining

* People who have a sense of meaning tend to live longer — and unlike supplements or cold plunges, cultivating curiosity about others costs nothing and is accessible to everyone

The Primary Care Crisis

* The U.S. spends nearly 18% of GDP on healthcare, yet 95% goes to hospitalizations and procedures — only 5% to primary care

* Research shows that adding primary care doctors to a community lowers mortality; adding specialists, counterintuitively, raises it

* To fix the system, patient panels need to shrink, administrative burden needs to drop, and primary care physicians need to be paid comparably to specialists

AI, Aging, and the Quality-of-Life Question

* Dr. Emanuel has reviewed the full published literature on AI in medicine since January 2024 and is more bullish than many expect

* AI holds particular promise for expanding access in rural and underserved areas where providers and facilities are scarce

* His pre-pandemic essay arguing against aggressive medical intervention past 75 wasn’t policy — it was a provocation designed to get people thinking seriously about the life, and death, they actually want

Upshot

A long and healthy life doesn’t require biohacking or obsessive self-monitoring — it requires a sustainable routine built around things that actually work. The hard part isn’t the science. It’s building a culture that makes those things accessible to everyone.

Pre-order Beyond the Prescription — out August 11!



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
Rethinking Hormone Therapy, Hot Flashes & Sexual Health with Dr. Lauren Streicher, MD10 mars 202600:46:59

Episode Summary

Dr. Lucy McBride sits down with Dr. Lauren Streicher, Northwestern University professor and sexual medicine expert, to untangle two decades of fear-based messaging about hormone therapy in the wake of the Women’s Health Initiative. They revisit what the WHI actually showed (and didn’t show) and make the case for individualized, evidence-based menopause care across hot flashes, sleep, bone health, genitourinary symptoms, and sexual health.

The WHI: A High-Quality Study That Was Badly Misread

* The WHI was the first randomized controlled trial on menopausal women and hormone therapy — well-designed, but its early termination generated fear-based messaging clinicians are still undoing

* The women who took estrogen only showed a reduced risk of breast cancer; the combined arm showed an increase of one case per thousand women, with breast cancer mortality still reduced

Hot Flashes Are Not Harmless

* The average duration of hot flashes is seven years — 10 years in Black women, lifelong for 10%

* Each hot flash triggers a spike in heart rate, blood pressure, cortisol, and inflammation that accumulates real cardiovascular damage over time

* Chronic sleep disruption from menopause compounds that cardiovascular risk significantly

Local Vaginal Estrogen: Safe and Woefully Underused

* Genitourinary syndrome of menopause — urgency, recurrent UTIs, pain with intercourse, pelvic floor dysfunction — is treatable at any age, including in women on aromatase inhibitors

* The FDA recently removed the black box warning from vaginal estrogen; it was never warranted and existed only due to blanket class labeling tied to oral estrogens (listen to more discussion about the removal of the FDA black box warning here)

The 10-Year Window Is Not a Stop Sign

* Women who start hormone therapy within 10 years of their last period tend to do better at a population level — it does not mean therapy must stop after 10 years

* A woman still symptomatic at 62 is a very different conversation than a symptom-free woman who feels she missed the boat (read about options you may have after the 10 year window here)

Hormone Therapy and Breast Cancer: What the Science Actually Shows

* For women with BRCA mutations, multiple studies — including a large 2025 prospective analysis — show no increased breast cancer risk on hormone therapy after oophorectomy. Breast cancer incidence was actually significantly lower in HRT users, with the protective effect concentrated in estrogen-only formulations.

* For women with a prior breast cancer diagnosis, the evidence on HRT risk is limited and formulation-specific: older trials showed increased recurrence risk with combined estrogen-progestin (particularly in ER+ disease), but modern formulations are understudied, vaginal estrogen appears safe, and a 2025 expert consensus endorsed shared decision-making for women with severe symptoms. Existing data are too outdated and heterogeneous to apply universally.

Perimenopause Requires a Different Playbook

* During perimenopause, estrogen levels surge and crash erratically — standard menopause-dose hormone therapy often does nothing; a low-dose birth control pill is frequently the better tool

* The decision to start, continue, or stop hormone therapy should be driven by symptoms and medical history — not arbitrary rules or influencers

Upshot

The fear that followed the WHI left generations of women under-treated and misinformed, and many are still paying the price. Hormone therapy is not right for everyone, but the decision should be driven by symptoms, history, and honest risk-benefit conversation, not by outdated warnings, arbitrary timelines, or wellness culture overcorrections. Women deserve accurate information about their own bodies, and that starts with clinicians who know the evidence and are willing to have a nuanced conversation.



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
The Real Reason You're Googling Facelifts 03 mars 202600:09:40

Episode Summary Dr. Lucy McBride uses a patient's obsession with getting a facelift to explore what aging well actually requires — and why the $60 billion anti-aging industry is designed to ensure you never feel like you're winning. She breaks down the four areas where aging actually shows up in your health and offers a more honest framework for deciding where to focus your time, energy, and money.

- The anti-aging industry profits from a moving goalpost — you get older every day, and the message that aging is a failure of discipline ensures you never feel like enough

- A patient's fixation on her neck and jowls turned out to be a proxy for loneliness, grief, and fear about her memory — concrete, "fixable" feelings standing in for things that felt unfixable

- Aging well isn't about your telomeres or your biological age score — it's about identifying which parts of your health ecosystem are actually under strain

- The four areas where aging shows up: your medical data, what you're putting in your body, your physical infrastructure (muscle, balance, strength), and your inner landscape (grief, loneliness, fear)

- Muscle loss accelerates in midlife — especially in women not on hormone therapy — and affects metabolism, confidence, and literally how you carry yourself through a room

- The questions worth asking before booking a consultation: What are you actually trying to fix? Is it your face, or your sense of agency? Is it fatigue, or loneliness?

For weekly insights on taking charge of your health—beyond the prescription—subscribe to Are You Okay? at https://lucymcbride.substack.com/



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
Can AI Fix Healthcare? A Conversation Dr. Bob Wachter, Chair of Medicine at UCSF & Author of A Giant Leap20 févr. 202600:34:33

Subscribe to Dr. McBride's Substack: lucymcbride.substack.com.

Episode Summary

Dr. Lucy McBride sits down with Dr. Bob Wachter, chair of the Department of Medicine at UCSF and bestselling author of A Giant Leap to discuss artificial intelligence in healthcare. They explore the current frustrations with electronic health records that don't communicate with each other, the unprecedented rapid adoption of AI scribes and tools among clinicians, and how AI can free doctors from documentation burden to focus on patient relationships. The conversation addresses the promise of democratizing healthcare access through AI, but also the critical need for oversight of tech companies whose profit motives may not align with patient welfare.

The Electronic Health Record Problem

Both patients and doctors are frustrated with fragmented EHRs—multiple patient portals that don’t communicate with each other create disparate care and wasted time

Doctors spend huge amounts of time documenting in EHRs but get very little useful intelligence out of them

AI as Documentation Solution, Not Relationship Replacement

The act of caring for another human being is relationship-based, rooted in trust, rapport, and understanding the whole person

AI can make the paperwork and documentation side more efficient, giving doctors more time to care for the person, not just their lab data

The Rapid Adoption of AI Tools in Medicine

The uptake curve of AI scribes and knowledge tools among clinicians has been astounding

This rapid adoption reflects the superpowers of the tools and the desperation clinicians feel to better manage administrative burdens of care

Patient Access to Information vs. Understanding

Federal statute now requires patients to see doctors’ notes, lab results, and x-ray results through patient portals

Patients see abnormal results but the portal gives them absolutely no assistance understanding what it means

Portal access has created an average of three hours of after-hours work for physicians

The Promise of Scalable Healthcare Access

AI offers potential for patients to get fast, fact-based information

The scalability and access to information that AI provides could democratize healthcare beyond just those who can afford to pay for a doctor

This accessibility represents a significant opportunity to expand quality medical guidance to more people

The Perils of Profit-Driven AI in Healthcare

AI companies building healthcare tools didn’t take the Hippocratic Oath and will be trying to maximize revenue

AI without physician oversight, training, and guidance is unlikely to prioritize patient welfare over economic advantage

If stewarded by physicians who understand the human elements of care, AI holds promise to help elevate, not eliminate, the patient-doctor relationship (read Dr. McBride’s article about why AI won’t be able to replace doctors here)

Upshot

The question isn't whether to adopt AI tools (doctors already do), but how to shape them so they serve patients and preserve the human elements of care. Doctors and patients alike must be part of the solution—ensuring AI becomes a tool for democratizing quality healthcare rather than creating new barriers driven by profit motives disconnected from the Hippocratic duty to put patients first.



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
Rethinking GLP-1s & Metabolic Health with Ashley Koff, RD06 févr. 202600:46:27

Episode Summary

Dr. Lucy McBride sits down with registered dietitian Ashley Koff, best-selling author of "Your Best Shot," to discuss metabolic health, GLP-1 medications, and why the medical profession needs to shift from weight loss to weight health. They explore why BMI is just one data point, debunk the myth of the non-compliant patient, and examine how GLP-1s teach us about hunger and fullness. The conversation addresses why personalized healthcare that addresses trauma, family dynamics, and individual biology matters more than any single medication or diet approach when tackling America's metabolic health crisis.

Shifting From Weight Loss to Weight Health

Weight is a symptom, not a diagnosis, and the goal should be weight health—making the hormones and biological systems that regulate weight—rather than pursuing weight loss through willpower.

The Myth of the Non-Compliant Patient

Patients who struggle with weight aren't lazy or noncompliant—they've been dismissed and shamed by a medical system that lacks time to address the complex factors driving metabolic health.

Understanding Metabolic Health Beyond BMI

BMI is just one metric and doesn't indicate metabolic health—body composition, genetics, hormones, and social determinants all matter more than a number on the scale.

GLP-1 Medications as Teachers About Health

GLP-1s teach people to recognize actual hunger versus emotional eating, helping them establish sustainable eating patterns they can maintain even after tapering off the medication.

The Non-Linear Journey of Metabolic Health

Taking GLP-1s often means unpacking childhood trauma, navigating family disapproval, and gaining agency over your body—it's not just about losing weight.

Ending Judgment Around Bodies and Medication Choices

Society readily judges others' bodies and medication choices, but acceptance of what you can't control frees up mental energy for genuine empowerment.



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
How to Protect your Health When the World Feels Like It's Falling Apart27 janv. 202600:11:26

EPISODE SUMMARY: In this week's episode, Dr. Lucy McBride reads from her newsletter addressing how witnessing collective trauma affects our physical and mental health. Through patient stories, she introduces her "3 A's" framework (Awareness, Acceptance, Agency) for navigating anxiety during turbulent times and offers practical guidance for knowing when distress signals a need for help.

KEY CONCEPTS:

1. EVERYONE HAS MENTAL HEALTH—NOT JUST "THE MENTALLY ILL"

Mental health is not a diagnosis for a small percentage of people; it's a universal aspect of being human.

Mental health has been treated as the "stepchild of physical health"—when in reality, it's ground zero of health.

Physical symptoms (racing heart, jaw tension, abnormal bloodwork) often reflect underlying mental health struggles.

Your genetic predispositions, personal history, and past traumas shape how you respond to crisis.

2. THE 3 A'S: A FRAMEWORK FOR MENTAL HEALTH

Mental health is a lifelong process built on three steps: Awareness → Acceptance → Agency.

Awareness: Understanding the facts of your story and recognizing your mental health patterns.

Acceptance: Making peace with what you cannot control—genetic vulnerabilities, past trauma, current crises.

Agency: Taking action over the thoughts, feelings, habits, and relationships you can change.

3. KNOW YOUR PATTERN: CATASTROPHIZING, INTELLECTUALIZING, OR NUMBING

Catastrophizers imagine worst-case scenarios; they need reality checks.

Intellectualizers can explain every policy failure but can't sleep; they need to feel their feelings.

Numbifiers stop watching entirely because it's overwhelming; they need to stay connected.

Self-awareness about your pattern is more important than having the most resources.

4. WHY WELLNESS AND TRADITIONAL MEDICINE BOTH FALL SHORT

The wellness industry offers oversimplified solutions: meditation apps, "limit news consumption," "practice self-care."

Traditional medicine screens for anxiety disorders and offers prescriptions without addressing complexity.

Both approaches miss what's actually happening and are disempowering to patients.

Medication can quiet anxious thoughts, but there's no pill for insight; therapy builds awareness but can't alone reverse anxiety spirals.

5. PRACTICAL STEPS FOR PROTECTING YOUR MENTAL HEALTH NOW

Get honest about your baseline: Are you eating, sleeping, taking medications? Disruption signals something important.

Notice your pattern: Identify whether you catastrophize, intellectualize, or go numb—then compensate accordingly.

Set boundaries: Check news twice daily, call friends instead of doom-scrolling, turn off phones at 9pm, allow yourself to cry.

Awareness of your limits is not weakness—it's wisdom.

6. WHEN TO ASK FOR HELP

The signal: difficulty functioning—not sleeping, not eating, not taking medications, not showing up for work or family.

This isn't about being "mentally ill"; it's recognizing when your mental health needs support right now.

The real questions: How aware are you of your patterns? Where do you live on the continuum of anxiety and resilience?

Call your doctor not because something is "wrong with you," but because mental health sometimes needs professional support.

-

For weekly insights on taking charge of your health—beyond the prescription—subscribe to Are You Okay? at https://lucymcbride.substack.com/



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
The New USDA Food Pyramid: Wacky or Well Done?10 janv. 202600:34:51

Episode Summary

Dr. Lucy McBride sits down with behavioral economist Emily Oster, PhD, to discuss the newly released USDA dietary guidelines. They explore what the guidelines actually say, debunk common misconceptions, and examine the problematic framing that suggests individual dietary choices alone can solve America’s health crisis. The conversation addresses the USDA’s appropriate emphasis on whole foods, but why access to quality healthcare and nutritional guidance matters more than specific recommendations when tackling America’s chronic disease epidemic.

The Guidelines Are Mostly Unchanged

* The new USDA guidelines are largely similar to previous versions, contrary to fears or hopes that they would radically shift dietary recommendations

* Key advice remains consistent: prioritize protein, fiber, and healthy fats while limiting sugars, alcohol, and processed foods

* One notable improvement is that the guidelines are shorter, tighter, and more digestible than previous iterations

* The guidelines reflect evidence-based advice that most primary care doctors already give their patients daily

The Real Problem: Most Americans Don’t Eat This Way

* The biggest issue isn’t whether the guidelines emphasize protein enough or get saturated fat recommendations perfect—it’s that most American diets look nothing like what’s recommended

* The average American diet contains a tremendous amount of ultra-processed, high-salt, high-sugar foods that aren’t satiating

* Habit change around food is incredibly difficult, making implementation far more important than guideline details

* Even previous sensible guidelines didn’t translate into widespread dietary improvements

* The gap between recommendations and reality highlights why access to personalized nutrition guidance matters

The Problematic Framing of Individual Responsibility

* While the content of the guidelines is generally sound, the framing places disproportionate emphasis on personal dietary choices as the solution to health problems

* The framing ignores systemic barriers including food deserts, economic constraints, lack of healthcare access, and limited time for meal preparation that are often the biggest barriers to healthy eating

* The presentation creates a “blame the victim” mentality that suggests America’s chronic disease epidemic is primarily due to poor food choices when, in reality, obesity and metabolic diseases stem from a combination of genetic, environmental, biological, social-emotional, and behavioral factors

* Effective nutrition change requires relationships with healthcare providers, not just information on a poster

The Beef Tallow Controversy

* The inclusion of beef tallow in the guidelines raised eyebrows and generated confusion among the public

* Beef tallow is not a common cooking fat for most Americans and is less accessible and practical than butter, olive oil, or avocado oil

* The emphasis on beef tallow appeared to reflect someone’s personal agenda rather than evidence-based nutritional guidance

* For most people, traditional cooking fats like olive oil and avocado oil remain better, more practical choices

* The controversy highlighted how specific recommendations can sometimes reflect ideological positions rather than public health priorities

The Healthcare System Failures Behind Dietary Struggles

* Nutrition is a foundational pillar of health, but meaningful dietary change requires supportive relationships with healthcare providers, not just guidelines

* The current healthcare system often limits doctors to five-minute visits, making it impossible to address complex nutritional needs (Read my article on our broken primary care system here.)

* Health is about relationships, not transactions—yet many Americans lack access to doctors who can spend adequate time with them

* People’s relationships with food are deeply ingrained and often begin in childhood, making simple advice to “eat better” ineffective without strategic planning and support

* Doctors frequently lecture patients about diet and exercise without addressing barriers like body shame, food access, financial constraints, or fear of change

* Until every American has access to quality primary care that addresses nutrition, behavioral health, and whole-person wellness, dietary guidelines will have limited impact

Upshot

The new USDA dietary guidelines offer sensible, evidence-based nutritional advice that aligns with what most doctors already recommend. However, the real challenge isn’t refining what goes on the food pyramid—it’s ensuring Americans have access to the healthcare relationships and systemic support necessary to make meaningful dietary changes. Without addressing food access, economic barriers, and the broken healthcare system that limits meaningful doctor-patient interactions, even the most well-designed guidelines will remain just a poster on a wall.



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
Making Sense of Hormone Therapy & the FDA’s Removal of the Black Box Warning ⛔️12 nov. 202501:04:44

Episode Summary

Dr. Lucy McBride discusses hormone replacement therapy (HRT) and menopause, breaking through the noise of conflicting medical information. She explains the science behind menopause, addresses common misconceptions about HRT risks, and examines the recent FDA announcement about removing black box warnings on estrogen products. Throughout the episode, she advocates for evidence-based, individualized decision-making that considers a woman’s complete health profile rather than fear-based restrictions.

Key Concepts

Understanding Menopause and Perimenopause

* Menopause occurs when the ovaries stop producing consistent, robust amounts of estrogen and progesterone

* Perimenopause is the 7-10 year lead-up to menopause, characterized by irregular periods, hot flashes, night sweats, mood instability, sleep interruption, and vaginal dryness

* The average age of menopause in the United States is 51, but symptoms and experiences vary dramatically among women

* Testosterone decline in women is age-related rather than menopause-related, beginning in a woman’s 20s and 30s (Listen to Dr. McBride’s conversation on testosterone for women with New York Times journalist Susan Dominus here.)

* Every woman who lives long enough will experience menopause, affecting 50% of the population

The WHI Study and Its Lasting Impact

* The Women’s Health Initiative (WHI) study was the largest-ever randomized controlled trial studying menopause and hormone therapy. It was halted abruptly in 2002 and created widespread fear about HRT by linking it to increased breast cancer and cardiovascular disease risks

* The study had significant design flaws: participants were older (average age 63), used synthetic hormones (Premarin and Provera), and the timing hypothesis wasn’t considered

* McBride argues the study measured “harm of late initiation” rather than harm of HRT itself

* The study led to black box warnings on estrogen products that persisted for over two decades

* These warnings resulted in generations of women being denied information and treatment options for menopausal symptoms

Health Implications of Estrogen Deficiency

* Estrogen deficiency increases cardiovascular disease risk, with women losing their protective advantage over men after menopause

* Bone density loss accelerates during perimenopause and menopause, increasing osteoporosis and fracture risk

* Genitourinary syndrome of menopause causes vaginal dryness, painful intercourse, and increased urinary tract infection risk (Listen to Dr. McBride’s conversation on sexual health with Dr. Rachel Rubin here.)

* Cognitive changes and dementia risk may be associated with long-term estrogen deficiency

* Quality of life impacts include disrupted sleep, mood changes, and diminished sexual function that shouldn’t be dismissed as “just part of aging”

The Science of HRT Benefits

* Transdermal estrogen (patches, creams, gels) carries lower risks than oral estrogen by avoiding first-pass liver metabolism

* Micronized progesterone is preferred over synthetic progestins for women with a uterus to protect the uterine lining

* Early initiation of HRT (within 10 years of menopause onset) shows cardiovascular benefits rather than risks

* HRT can reduce fracture risk, improve genitourinary health, and potentially offer cognitive protection

* Local vaginal estrogen is topical (i.e, not the same as systemic hormone therapy) and is highly effective for genitourinary symptoms with minimal absorption into the bloodstream

Breast Cancer Risk in Perspective

* One in eight women will develop breast cancer over the course of their life; most breast cancers are sporadic (i.e., not hereditary or due to an inherited genetic mutation)

* The absolute risk increase of breast cancer from HRT is approximately 1 additional case per 1,000 women per year; data from the WHI showed that women who took estrogen-only HRT had a reduced risk for breast cancer

* Alcohol consumption (one drink per day) carries comparable or higher breast cancer risk than HRT

* Obesity presents a significantly higher breast cancer risk than HRT

* Having a family history of breast cancer doesn’t preclude HRT use

* Dr. McBride emphasizes viewing women’s health holistically rather than solely through the lens of breast cancer risk

Reframing Medical Decision-Making

* The question to ask your doctors isn’t “Can I take HRT?”; it’s “What are the potential risks and benefits of taking hormone therapy given my unique health profile?”

* Doctors should provide evidence-based information and guidance that honors patients’ unique health issues, tolerance for risk, and ability to understand tradeoffs inherent in any medical decision

* Risk exists on a continuum; it’s not monolithic. Risk cannot be reduced to zero—it’s about weighing competing risks and benefits which will very person to person

* Fear is real and valid, but shouldn’t be the sole driver of medical decisions

* Women deserve comprehensive information about their bodies and treatment options, regardless of age or time since menopause onset

* Read more of Dr. McBride’s article on vaginal hormone therapy and importance of empowering women to make informed decisions about their own health here.

Upshot

The conversation challenges decades of gatekeeping around hormone replacement therapy by emphasizing evidence-based, individualized care. Dr. McBride advocates for removing the stigma and fear surrounding HRT, encouraging women to ask better questions and doctors to provide evidence-based guidance that considers the whole person. Her central message: HRT isn’t right for every woman, but every woman deserves comprehensive information about her body and the right to make informed decisions.



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
Testosterone for Women: What You Need to Know with NYT Journalist Susan Dominus04 nov. 202500:46:43

In this conversation, Dr. Lucy McBride sits down with New York Times journalist Susan Dominus to discuss her recent article “‘I’m on Fire’: Testosterone Is Giving Women Back Their Sex Drive—and Then Some” on testosterone supplementation in women. With testosterone use surging among midlife women, they explore the gap between recommendations from the medical establishment and the wellness industry, examining why women are turning to testosterone for sexual health, energy, and vitality—and what the limited evidence really tells us about risks and benefits.

Key Concepts

Women Actually Make Testosterone (And More Than Estrogen)

* The common misconception is that testosterone is purely a male hormone

* Most women don’t realize they naturally produce testosterone—and in higher quantities than estrogen

* Women’s bodies produce testosterone from three sources: 25% from ovaries, 25% from adrenal glands, and 50% from peripheral tissues

* Testosterone plays a role in libido, energy, metabolic health, and muscle tone throughout women’s lives, however the role of supplemental testosterone for issues other than low sexual desire remains unclear

The Decline in Testosterone Levels Starts Earlier Than You Think

* Testosterone levels in women begin declining around age 30, dropping to approximately 50% by age 60

* This is a gradual, age-related process, not a sudden menopausal crash

* Menopause doesn’t cause testosterone to plummet; it coincides with the end of a depletion that’s been happening all along

* Women in their mid-40s can feel the effects of low testosterone long before they’re perimenopausal

* Understanding this timeline challenges the narrative that testosterone issues are specifically about menopause

The Testosterone Surge: From UK Trend to US Phenomenon

* Just a few years ago, testosterone therapy for women was primarily a UK conversation; the US medical establishment was dismissive

* In the past six to eight months, testosterone use has exploded across the US

* Women are discussing it on streaming feeds, social networks, and with their friends, indicating a cultural moment

* The treatment has moved from relative obscurity to mainstream conversation at remarkable speed, and the wellness industry is seizing the moment

The Evidence Gap: What We Know and What We Don’t

* The medical establishment has been cautious about testosterone in women due to limited research and because supplemental testosterone is not currently approved by the FDA

* Existing studies support the use of supplemental testosterone in women only for libido and sexual function (i.e., hypoactive sexual desire disorder)

* Anecdotal evidence suggest that testosterone can help women with energy, muscle mass, metabolic health, cognitive “clarity,” and overall wellbeing; however more research is needed to understand where these are true effects versus placebo

* The potential downsides are real (especially if given at high doses): voice changes, irritability, hair loss, hyper-arousal

* Long-term effects remain unknown, particularly regarding cardiovascular health, metabolic changes, and other systemic impacts

* Doctors face the challenge of counseling patients when definitive evidence is lacking, creating tension between patient demand and evidence-based medicine

* This uncertainty leaves both physicians and patients navigating uncharted territory

Navigating the Gray Zone Between Medicine and Wellness

* Women find themselves caught between traditional medical systems that historically have not made space to discuss sexual health and wellness practitioners who proselytize products without adequate evidence

* This dynamic mirrors other areas of women’s health where quality-of-life concerns have been historically undervalued compared to longevity metrics

* The conversation reflects a broader cultural shift toward prioritizing women’s subjective experiences as legitimate healthcare goals

* There’s a growing concern about polypharmacy: using multiple pharmaceutical interventions to address interconnected symptoms, then needing additional treatments for side effects

* The question remains whether people are reaching for pharmaceutical solutions too quickly instead of evidence-based lifestyle interventions like exercise, sleep, and stress management

* Both Dr. McBride and Ms. Dominus stress the importance of seeking care from practitioners who are well versed in medical evidence—for example those who are certified by the Menopause Society—and addressing testosterone levels in context, ruling out other causes for issues like fatigue and brain fog before jumping to testosterone as a quick fix, while acknowledging the lack of access to evidence-based care to address the nuances of patients’ health

Upshot

The conversation about supplemental testosterone represents a pivotal moment in women’s health—where patient demand for quality-of-life improvements collides with limited evidence. This moment underscores the need for nuanced, individualized discussions between patients and providers that honor women’s subjective experiences while acknowledging medical uncertainties, a challenge that extends far beyond testosterone to many aspects of midlife women’s healthcare.



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
How to Manage Anxiety When It Feels Like the World is Falling Apart with Dr. Jessi Gold17 sept. 202500:45:57

Episode Summary

In this conversation, Dr. Lucy McBride sits down with psychiatrist Dr. Jessi Gold to discuss how to manage emotional wellbeing during times of political upheaval. With the country feeling unsettled by ongoing violence and crisis, they explore practical strategies for emotional regulation, the importance of naming feelings without judgment, and why small daily acts of self-care aren't indulgent—they're essential for functioning in a chaotic world.

Key Concepts

The Importance of Naming What's Really Happening

* Pretending the external world doesn't affect you is both unrealistic and counterproductive

* Avoiding the "grief Olympics"—comparing your struggles to others' and dismissing your own feelings

* Everyone exists in the same messy world, and acknowledging its impact creates space for authentic connection

* Naming feelings reduces the underlying current of stress that affects work performance and relationships

* You don't have to fix the world's problems to acknowledge they're affecting you

Feelings as Information, Not Pathology

* Social media makes it easy to conflate normal human emotions with clinical diagnoses

* All emotions serve a purpose and provide valuable information about your needs and circumstances

* The continuum approach: you don't need to meet clinical criteria to deserve self-compassion and support

* Feelings are temporary and meant to be experienced, not immediately eliminated or "fixed"

Acceptance vs. Resignation: Reallocating Your Resources

* True acceptance means redirecting energy from things you can't control to areas where you have agency

* The serenity prayer framework: identifying what you can and cannot change provides clarity and reduces helplessness

* Acceptance isn't giving up—it's strategic resource allocation of time, energy, and mental bandwidth

* Small acts of self-efficacy can counter overwhelming feelings of powerlessness

* Control-seeking behaviors often increase anxiety rather than providing the relief we're seeking

Dialectical Thinking: Holding Two Truths Simultaneously

* Both difficult realities and moments of joy can coexist without negating each other

* Social media algorithms push people toward emotional extremes

* You can care deeply about global suffering while still finding meaning in daily life

* Examples like Viktor Frankl demonstrate that hope can survive even in the most dire circumstances

* Dialectical thinking protects against all-or-nothing emotional spirals

Practical Micro-Strategies for Daily Emotional Regulation

* Small, discrete coping tools work better than major lifestyle overhauls for most people

* Fidget tools, breathing exercises, and physical grounding techniques provide in-the-moment relief

* Gratitude practices counter the brain's evolutionary bias toward remembering negative experiences

* Body awareness (like noticing jaw clenching while scrolling) provides early warning signals for stress

Digital Boundaries and Media Consumption

* "Mindless scrolling" is actually highly stimulating and often traumatic content consumption

* Watching repeated footage of traumatic events creates secondary trauma, especially for vulnerable populations

* Moving phones out of bedrooms and avoiding immediate morning phone checking reduces anxiety activation

* Setting specific times and limits for news consumption prevents information overwhelm

* Parallel activities with friends (working quietly together) can provide connection without amplifying distress

Upshot

Dr. McBride and Dr. Gold emphasize that managing anxiety during chaotic times requires both self-compassion and practical action. Their message: you don't need to be clinically depressed or anxious to deserve support, and tiny daily interventions can make a significant difference in emotional resilience.



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
Cutting Through the Noise Around COVID Vaccines with Shira Doron MD03 sept. 202500:53:18

Episode Summary

In this episode, Dr. Lucy McBride sits down with Dr. Shira Doron, Chief Infection Control Officer and Hospital Epidemiologist at Tufts Medical Center, to cut through the confusion surrounding COVID vaccines and public health policy. With the CDC in upheaval and patients calling with urgent questions about protecting their families this winter, they tackle the messy reality of vaccine access, institutional breakdown, and what it all means for your health decisions. Dr. Doron explains why getting clear answers feels impossible right now—and offers practical guidance for navigating the chaos.

Key Concepts

The Regulatory Meltdown

* FDA approved new COVID vaccines but only for high-risk groups, creating access barriers at major pharmacies

* Entire ACIP advisory committee was gutted—all 17 members replaced at once—leaving no clear decision-making authority

* CDC leadership departures and delayed meetings mean the usual vaccine rollout process has completely broken down

* Retail pharmacies like CVS can't administer vaccines without ACIP recommendations, forcing patients to get prescriptions

* The dust may settle by late September, but institutional trust has been severely damaged

The Backstory Nobody's Talking About

* A little known fact: the Biden-era ACIP was already planning to shift away from universal annual vaccines toward risk-based recommendations

* Internal polling of that committee showed 76% support for targeting high-risk groups rather than everyone over six months old

* Current policy direction mirrors what the previous committee intended, but the chaotic process has destroyed confidence

* Medical and scientific community feels betrayed by political interference in normal advisory processes

* Reform was needed, but "slash and burn" approach leaves the country vulnerable to future health crises

Making Sense of Who Should Get Vaccinated

* Dr. Doron suggests talking with your doctor but in general she recommends waiting for the new formulation rather than rushing to get the current vaccine during this summer's wave

* Dr. Doron notes that “high risk” for COVID is broadly defined—and includes sedentary lifestyle, history of smoking, anxiety, ADHD—such that most Americans will qualify for a shot. Plus, self-attestation of risk is likely to continue (rather than requiring medical documentation at pharmacies), and she predicts it will not be difficult to get a shot if you want one (though cannot be sure, and insurance coverage is up in the air)

* Professional medical societies are creating their own guidelines to fill the regulatory void

* Individual risk assessment with your doctor beats one-size-fits-all recommendations

What Vaccines Actually Do (And Don't Do)

* Modest protection against any infection for 2-3 months, more like "wearing a raincoat in a rainstorm" than a force field

* Strong, durable protection against severe disease (due to cellular immunity i.e., T cells) is the real benefit for high-risk individuals

* Limited impact on transmission, so getting vaccinated to protect others isn't particularly effective

* Timing matters: Dr. Doron suggests waiting 6 months to get vaccinated after a COVID infection, 3 months after previous vaccine for most people

* Novavax may offer better side effect profile and longer-lasting protection than mRNA options

Beyond Vaccines: Testing and Treatment

* Paxlovid remains effective for high risk patients when started within 5 days for people at risk of severe disease but is not a standard recommendation for healthy, vaccinated people; we live in a data-free zone on the degree of benefit (if any) for lower risk individuals

* Test for COVID or flu only when results would change your management—mainly for those who might benefit from antivirals

* Home rapid tests can help gauge contagiousness as you recover

* Basic rule: stay home until fever-free for 24 hours without medication

* Early testing and treatment of high-risk household members beats trying to prevent transmission through vaccination

Trust, Messaging, and Moving Forward

* Current chaos represents backlash against heavy-handed pandemic messaging that ignored individual risk differences

* Public health authorities lost credibility by overpromising vaccine effectiveness and dismissing legitimate concerns

* Acknowledging uncertainty and meeting people where they are builds trust better than blanket mandates

* Need institutional reform, not destruction of essential public health infrastructure

Upshot

Dr. McBride and Dr. Doron emphasize that navigating this regulatory chaos requires working closely with your healthcare provider for individualized risk assessment rather than relying on one-size-fits-all guidance. They stress that while patients must advocate for themselves in the current fragmented system, the real solution lies in rebuilding trustworthy public health institutions that prioritize transparent communication and evidence-based recommendations over political interference.



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
How to Get What You Need from Our Broken Healthcare System27 août 202501:00:31

Episode Summary

In this episode, Dr. Lucy McBride tackles the crisis facing American healthcare and provides practical strategies for navigating a broken system. She explores a fundamental disconnect between what patients need and what the current system delivers: while patients require comprehensive, relationship-based healthcare that addresses their whole story, the system provides fragmented, rushed medical care that focuses solely on immediate symptoms.

Key Concepts

The Systemic Breakdown of Primary Care

* Root causes: Pressures from insurance companies and large hospital systems force doctors to see high patient volumes in brief increments, creating unsustainable working conditions and suboptimal care

* Consequences: Primary care has evolved from comprehensive problem-solving into rapid referrals and prescription writing, leaving doctors feeling burned out and unable to provide the care they trained to give

* Scale of crisis: Millions of Americans currently lack access to a primary care provider, with shortages expected to worsen significantly in coming years

* Financial reality: Only 5% of U.S. healthcare spending goes toward primary care, while the vast majority addresses damage control rather than prevention

* Professional exodus: Primary care physicians are leaving medicine due to burnout, time constraints, and inability to practice the comprehensive care they were trained to provide

Medical Care vs. Healthcare: Understanding the Critical Distinction

* Medical care defined: Problem-specific, episodic, transactional treatment focused on immediate symptoms (what urgent care and emergency rooms provide)

* Healthcare defined: Patient-centered, relationship-based care involving shared decision-making, understanding of individual health risks and goals, and comprehensive whole-person treatment

* The integration challenge: True healthcare requires connecting physical symptoms with biographical data, social determinants of health, and emotional well-being

* Relationship foundation: Healthcare depends on trust, rapport, and a provider's understanding of the patient's complete story and context

* Access inequality: While medical care is available through urgent care and ERs, comprehensive healthcare is increasingly accessible only to those who can afford it

Primary Care Options in the Current System

* Insurance-based care: Traditional approach using provider networks, though often limited by short appointment times and restricted access

* Federally Qualified Health Centers (FQHCs): Community-based centers providing comprehensive care regardless of ability to pay, often with shorter wait times (findahealthcenter.hrsa.gov)

* Direct Primary Care (DPC): Membership-based model allowing doctors smaller patient panels and longer appointment times to provide more comprehensive care, though not universally accessible due to cost

* Nurse practitioners and physician assistants: Can provide excellent primary care when well-trained and aware of their knowledge limitations

* Telehealth services: Options like One Medical and MD Live meet specific needs but have limitations in providing comprehensive relationship-based care

How to Evaluate & Select a Primary Care Provider

* Access assessment: Inquire about wait times for routine appointments, same-day sick visits, and between-visit communication methods

* Care philosophy evaluation: Understand appointment lengths, approach to preventive and whole-person care, mental health integration, and specialist coordination methods

* Logistical considerations: Verify insurance acceptance, understand membership details for DPC practices, and clarify after-hours coverage and prescription refill processes

* Red flags to avoid: Providers who lack time for building relationships, demonstrate defensive behavior when questioned, or fail to provide adequate access when needed

* Fit assessment: Recognize that doctor-patient relationships require mutual trust and respect; switching providers when the relationship isn't working is acceptable and necessary

Self-Advocacy Strategies & Appointment Preparation

* Priority setting: Prepare the most urgent issues for each appointment, understanding that comprehensive care may require multiple visits

* Rapport building techniques: Acknowledge providers' time constraints, share personal details to establish connection, and express understanding of systemic pressures while maintaining care standards

* Documentation responsibility: Keep personal medical records since electronic health records are fragmented across different healthcare systems and make sure they are updated with medications, dosages, allergies, family history, vaccination records, and specialist information

* Follow-up planning: Schedule subsequent appointments proactively rather than waiting for problems to arise, ensuring continuity of care

The Future of Healthcare Technology and Innovation

* Electronic health record limitations: Current systems serve primarily as billing tools rather than patient-centered care coordination platforms, with each healthcare system maintaining separate, incompatible records

* Technology's potential: AI and digital innovation (if done well) could create centralized, real-time health records shared across all providers, improving care coordination and reducing redundancy

* Innovation priorities: Successful healthcare technology must elevate—not eliminate—the patient-doctor relationship. Tech entrepreneurs who understand this principle are most likely to achieve meaningful reform

* Patient empowerment through data: Individuals must maintain their own comprehensive health records until systems improve, including all provider visits, medication changes, and test results

* Systemic reform needs: Long-term solutions require centering primary care in the healthcare system, ensuring universal access to medical homes, and prioritizing prevention over damage control

The Upshot

Dr. McBride encourages everyone to advocate fiercely for comprehensive relationship-based care rather than settling for episodic medical transactions. She emphasizes that while individual self-advocacy is essential for navigating current realities, true reform requires investing in primary care and ensuring universal access to medical homes that address the whole person.



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
Top Tips for Brain Health: A Conversation with cognitive neuroscientist Dr. Julie Fratantoni20 août 202500:49:12

Episode Summary

In this episode, Dr. Lucy McBride welcomes cognitive neuroscientist Dr. Julie Fratantoni to discuss practical strategies for protecting and improving cognition. There’s a fundamental disconnect between modern lifestyle patterns and optimal brain health: while our culture celebrates multitasking, passive consumption, and constant stimulation, the neuroscience reveals that our brains thrive on focused attention, active engagement, and purposeful challenge.

Key Concepts

Active vs. Passive Engagement with Information & Technology

* Dr. Fratantoni discusses recent research showing passive AI use creates "cognitive debt" by bypassing memory encoding and reducing creativity

* Study found 15 of 18 participants who used ChatGPT couldn't recall a single sentence from essays they'd just written with AI assistance

* Using your brain first before incorporating tools requires engaging through critical thinking and connecting new knowledge to existing information

* Always close down and repeat back what you learned, either aloud or in writing, to consolidate information

Emotion Regulation & Stress Recovery

* Dr. Fratantoni advocates for stress “recovery" rather than stress management, focusing on bouncing back to keep the prefrontal cortex online

* The “physiological sigh” involves one full inhale, pause, extra sip of air, then full exhale through mouth to activate parasympathetic nervous system

* Reappraisal strategies include reframing anxiety as excitement or considering alternative explanations for ambiguous social situations

* Studies show reappraisal reduces amygdala activity, increases prefrontal cortex activity, and improves heart rate variability and telomere length

* Breathing patterns directly affect blood oxygen/carbon dioxide ratios, modulating norepinephrine production and focus levels

Focus & Attention Training in a Distracted World

* Modern digital environments work against natural attention patterns, requiring strategies to rebuild focus capacity

* Multitasking is actually rapid task-switching that increases brain stress and reduces performance

* Simple tally systems to track interruptions build consciousness of attention patterns and reduce their frequency through awareness

* Start with 5-10 minutes of focused work without distractions, then incrementally build this "focus muscle" over time

* Memory formation requires both attention and encoding time, so constant busyness prevents proper memory consolidation

“Hormesis” & Finding the Right Level of Challenge

* Dr. Frattantoni introduces hormesis for cognitive health—moderate stress benefits the brain while extremes become detrimental

* Research with 12,000+ people found low to moderate stress induces cognitive benefits that promote resilience

* The right challenge level varies by individual interests, capabilities, and circumstances, requiring self-assessment over universal prescriptions

* Examples include learning languages, dance classes, martial arts, or hobbies requiring ongoing skill development

* Neither overwhelming stress nor complete lack of challenge serves cognitive health

Flexible Thinking & Perspective-Taking

* This executive function involves shifting between viewpoints, adapting to circumstances, and maintaining curiosity about others' experiences

* Cognitive flexibility functions like physical flexibility—enough structure to be sturdy but adaptable enough to avoid breakage

* Taking different perspectives activates multiple brain regions and reduces inflammation in healthcare interactions

* Learning to disagree while maintaining emotional regulation and curiosity strengthens multiple cognitive systems simultaneously

* Having difficult conversations while disagreeing represents one of the most challenging tasks for the brain

Purpose and Meaning as Cognitive Protection

* Longitudinal research shows having life purpose provides significant protection against cognitive decline

* Study of 11,000+ older adults found purpose protective against cognitive decline regardless of other health variables

* Purpose doesn't require grand accomplishments—can be simple as tending gardens or contributing to community

* Dr. Fratantoni suggests a two-minute "personal manifesto" exercise to clarify core values and life direction

The Upshot

Dr. McBride and Dr. Fratantoni make the case that conscious attention to cognitive health isn't just personally beneficial—it's essential for redefining how we age and challenging the assumption that cognitive decline is inevitable.



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
Is a "Good Death" Possible? 30 juil. 202500:57:29

Episode Summary

In this episode, Dr. Lucy McBride welcomes Dr. Sunita Puri for an intimate conversation about death, dying, and what it means to have a "good death." Dr. Puri, author of the critically acclaimed memoir "That Good Night: Life and Medicine in the 11th Hour," shares her expertise on palliative care while addressing the critical gap in how modern medicine approaches end-of-life conversations. The discussion explores the historical context of dying well, the problematic medicalization of death in contemporary healthcare, and practical guidance for both patients and families navigating end-of-life decisions. Dr. McBride brings a personal dimension to the conversation, sharing how Dr. Puri supported her through the sudden loss of her brother the previous year, illustrating the profound impact of compassionate end-of-life care.

Key Concepts

Redefining "Good Death" Beyond Idealized Visions

* The concept of "good death" has historical roots dating back to medieval Europe's "Ars Moriendi" (The Art of Dying) and ancient Buddhist and Hindu contemplations of impermanence

* Modern expectations often center on dying at home surrounded by loved ones, but this idealized vision can create unnecessary guilt and stress for families

* Financial and practical constraints make home death unrealistic for many families, as hospice doesn't provide 24-hour caregivers

* Good deaths are possible in hospitals, ICUs, and nursing homes when focused on dignity, comfort, and honoring the patient's values

* Flexibility and acceptance of circumstances, rather than rigid adherence to a "perfect" death plan, leads to better outcomes for patients and families

The Crisis of Medicalized Dying in Modern Healthcare

* The 1960s explosion of medical technology (iron lungs, CPR, ventilators) shifted medicine toward extending life at all costs, regardless of quality

* Healthcare systems default to aggressive interventions without adequate discussion of alternatives or patient values

* The "conveyor belt of technology" operates independently of what patients actually want or what would serve their best interests

* Medical training fails to prepare doctors for honest end-of-life conversations, leading to inherited patterns of avoidance and euphemism

* The gap between cure-focused medicine and compassionate end-of-life care leaves patients and families without adequate support for decision-making

Transforming Medical Communication Through Radical Honesty

* Traditional medical communication often provides facts without explaining their significance or implications for the patient's life

* Effective palliative care requires moving beyond "checklist" approaches (Do you want CPR? Feeding tube?) to understanding what gives the patient's life meaning

* Dr. Puri's approach involves explaining that "reversing a death is not the same as restoring a life," helping patients understand the reality of interventions like CPR

* Doctors must learn to sit with discomfort, witness suffering, and acknowledge uncertainty rather than defaulting to medical interventions

* Authentic communication requires doctors to examine their own reactions and fears about death, as "95% of doctoring is an inside job"

Practical Framework for Advance Care Planning

* Individuals should reflect on deaths they've witnessed, considering what seemed acceptable or unacceptable about those experiences

* Choosing a surrogate decision-maker requires careful consideration beyond automatic family hierarchies - sometimes friends understand one's values better than spouses or children

* The MOLST (Medical Orders for Life-Sustaining Treatment) form provides a concrete starting point for documenting wishes and should be displayed prominently for emergency responders

* Advance directives should be revisited after major health events, hospitalizations, or significant life changes rather than treated as one-time documents

* Effective planning requires honest conversations with primary care doctors, not just legal documentation, and patients should specifically request these discussions

Embracing Uncertainty and Impermanence as Spiritual Practice

* Buddhist and Hindu concepts of impermanence offer frameworks for accepting life's inevitable changes, including death

* Learning to "sit with uncertainty" becomes essential for both patients and healthcare providers in end-of-life situations

* Death anxiety can be addressed through traditional therapy, medications, and emerging research on psychedelics such psilocybin

* The practice of observing impermanence in everyday life (seasonal changes, relationship evolution) builds capacity for accepting larger uncertainties

* Healthcare providers must model comfort with uncertainty rather than promising false certainty or avoiding difficult conversations

Mercy and Dignity as Core Medical Values

* The concept of "mercy" encompasses both aggressive curative care when appropriate and allowing natural death when intervention would cause suffering

* Modern medicine must balance technological capabilities with recognition of human dignity and individual values

* The phrasing "allow natural death" reframes end-of-life care as supporting a natural process rather than withholding treatment

* Psychedelic-assisted therapy shows promising results for death anxiety in terminal patients, offering profound spiritual experiences that reduce fear

* Healthcare encounters become acts of love when providers center patient values and offer their authentic presence during vulnerable moments

About Dr. Sunita Puri

Dr. Sunita Puri is an Associate Professor of Medicine at the University of California, Irvine School of Medicine, where she serves as Director of the Inpatient Palliative Care Service. A Rhodes Scholar and Yale University graduate, she is the author of the critically acclaimed memoir "That Good Night: Life and Medicine in the Eleventh Hour," which examines her journey into palliative medicine and quest to help patients and families redefine what it means to live and die well. Her writing has appeared in publications including the New Yorker, Atlantic, New York Times, and Wall Street Journal. A sought-after international speaker, she has delivered lectures around the world on compassionate end-of-life care. In 2019, the Guardian created a mini-documentary about her work that has been viewed over 3.5 million times. You can follow her on Instagram and Twitter, and you can hear her previous conversation with Dr. Lucy McBride here.



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
[B]oldly exploring old age, from the blessings to the b******t, with writer Debbie Weil23 juil. 202500:56:17

Episode Summary

In this conversation, Dr. Lucy McBride speaks with author and journalist Debbie Weil about the surprising truths of aging. Weil, who writes the [B]old Age newsletter on Substack, shares insights from her journey of self-discovery in her 70s, challenging common narratives about aging as inevitably terrible. The conversation explores the unexpected freedoms that come with age and the importance of vulnerability in building community—plus the broken healthcare system's impact on trust, and practical health topics including GLP-1 medications. Both women discuss how authentic storytelling creates meaningful connections and how aging can be a time of continued growth rather than just loss.

Key Concepts

The Surprising Gift of Self-Discovery in Aging

* Weil describes discovering that aging involves getting to know your essential self better, rather than losing yourself

* Contrary to anti-aging messaging that suggests everything goes downhill, she found increased self-acceptance and authenticity

* The process involves recognizing you're fundamentally the same person while becoming more comfortable with who you are

* This self-knowledge becomes a foundation for making better decisions about health, relationships, and life choices

Freedom from Others' Opinions and Social Expectations

* Many older adults experience liberation from constantly seeking approval or worrying about others' judgments

* Weil notes the common refrain among older women: "I don't give a s**t anymore" about trivial social pressures

* This freedom manifests in practical ways: not wearing makeup if you don't want to, saying no to obligations that don't serve you

* The shift allows for more authentic relationships and choices aligned with personal values rather than external expectations

The Power of Vulnerability in Building Community

* Weil's most popular writing pieces are those where she shares personal struggles and physical challenges

* Vulnerability creates connection by allowing readers to feel seen and understood in their own experiences

* Both women discuss how sharing imperfections and uncertainties makes them more relatable and trustworthy as voices in health and aging

Healthcare System Failures and the Crisis of Trust

* Dr. McBride explains that only a small percentage of healthcare spending goes to primary care, with the vast majority focused on disease management and hospitalizations

* The average patient has just seven minutes with their doctor, creating transactional rather than relationship-based care

* This broken system has given rise to the wellness industry, which attempts to fill gaps but cannot replace proper medical care

* Trust in healthcare providers requires authentic listening, understanding of individual circumstances, and collaborative decision-making

GLP-1 Medications: Sophisticated Weight Management Tools

* Dr. McBride describes GLP-1 medications (like Ozempic) as the most sophisticated medical technology in her lifetime for weight management

* These medications work through multiple mechanisms: improving insulin efficiency, suppressing appetite, reducing "food noise," and slowing digestion

* Contrary to popular belief, not everyone who stops the medication regains all weight, especially when properly tapered with medical supervision

* The medications can help people break cycles of food restriction and emotional eating, leading to healthier long-term eating patterns

Creating Authentic Communities Through Shared Stories

* Both women have built engaged communities by sharing personal experiences rather than just dispensing advice

* Weil is launching a "No Guilt [B]old Women Book Club" featuring memoirs by older women writers

* The power of storytelling lies in helping people feel less alone in their experiences of aging, health challenges, and life transitions

* Writing and sharing stories becomes a way to process personal experiences while creating connection with others facing similar challenges



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
Fired Up 🔥 A Conversation with Shannon Watts about Turning your Spark Into Flame at Any Age16 juil. 202500:40:44

Episode Summary

In this conversation, host Dr. Lucy McBride sits down with Shannon Watts, founder of Moms Demand Action and author of NYT bestselling book, Fired Up, to explore how women can break free from societal pressures and pursue their authentic desires. Watts shares insights from her 11 years leading the largest grassroots gun safety organization and her interviews with 70 women for her new book. The discussion covers the psychological barriers that prevent women from "living on fire," the inevitable blowback that comes with stepping outside traditional roles, and the transformative power of female community. Both women examine how age can become a superpower for authenticity, the importance of redefining success beyond traditional metrics, and practical strategies for identifying and pursuing one's values, abilities, and desires.

Key Concepts

The "Living on Fire" Formula: Values + Abilities + Desires

* Living on fire is a metaphor for combining your core values, unique abilities, and authentic desires in meaningful action

* Most women are taught to fulfill obligations rather than desires, creating a fundamental barrier to authentic living

* The formula requires ongoing practice - sometimes it leads to big changes, sometimes small ones, but all matter equally

* Women often underestimate their abilities and need exercises to catalog their skills and seek outside perspective on their strengths

* Values evolve throughout life stages - Watts' values of protecting family and community when starting Moms Demand Action at 41 have shifted now that she's an empty nester

Blowback: The Primary Barrier to Women's Authentic Expression

* Fear of blowback (criticism, social disapproval) emerged as the number one limiting factor for women across all demographics

* Women are socialized to be people-pleasers, making criticism particularly painful and likely to trigger retreat behaviors

* Three strategies for managing blowback: evaluate the source, reframe the temporary nature of uncomfortable feelings, and remember you're modeling courage for others

* Blowback is predictable but not personal - it's a systemic response to women challenging traditional roles

* Learning to endure difficult emotions without numbing behaviors (alcohol, social media, isolation) builds resilience and agency

The “Deathbed Regret” Paradox: Motherhood vs. Authentic Living

* While the most common deathbed regret globally is "not living authentically," mothers in the study feared their regret would be "pursuing desires at the expense of children"

* This internalized guilt prevents women from recognizing that pursuing their own fulfillment actually benefits their children

* Children need to see mothers as whole people with interests beyond parenting to avoid unhealthy pressure and learn healthy life modeling

* Experts consistently affirm that children benefit when mothers pursue meaningful work and interests outside the family

* The fear reflects deep societal conditioning around women's roles and self-sacrifice expectations

Community and Female Friendship as Essential Infrastructure

* Watts discovered at 50 that despite leading a large women's organization, she lacked close personal friendships

* Female friendship requires intentional cultivation and vulnerability - it doesn't happen automatically in midlife

* The "five people you can call at 3 AM" test revealed how many accomplished women lack deep support networks

* Women's collaborative approach differs fundamentally from male competitive patterns, creating opportunities for mutual elevation

* Building authentic community requires moving beyond scarcity mindset and embracing the belief that supporting other women strengthens everyone

Avoiding "False Fires": Redefining Success and Fulfillment

* False fires include the commodification of purpose (turning every passion into profit), chasing ephemeral happiness, and equating busyness with fulfillment

* Society pressures women to monetize their interests rather than allowing pure pleasure and personal satisfaction

* The pursuit of perfection and the fear of public failure keep women from taking necessary risks

* True success means pursuing fulfillment over external validation, allowing for pleasure without productivity requirements

* Understanding the difference between temporary emotions and lasting values helps distinguish authentic desires from societal expectations

Age as Superpower: Wisdom, Self-Awareness, and Fearlessness

* Women over 50 develop crucial abilities: wisdom, self-awareness, and reduced concern about others' opinions

* The Serenity Prayer concept - knowing what you can and cannot control - becomes more accessible with age and experience

* Acceptance becomes a superpower when women learn to focus energy on areas where they have agency

* Later-life authenticity allows women to challenge the narrative that their productive years end when children leave home

* Generation X is rewriting rules around aging, menopause, and post-maternal identity, creating new possibilities for older women

The Upshot

This conversation illuminates a fundamental tension in women's lives: the conflict between societal expectations to prioritize others' needs and the human necessity of pursuing authentic desires. Watts and McBride make the case that women's liberation isn't just personally beneficial - it's essential for modeling healthy adulthood to the next generation and addressing society's most pressing challenges.



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
A Conversation with Dr. Mary Claire Haver about menopause, perimenopause & HRT 🔥25 juin 202500:51:16

Episode Summary

In this conversation, Dr. Lucy McBride hosts Dr. Mary Claire Haver, the renowned board-certified OBGYN from Galveston, Texas. Dr. Haver, author of the bestselling book The New Menopause, discusses the current menopause moment, the complexities of hormone replacement therapy, and why women have been deprived of essential information about their hormonal health for decades. The conversation covers everything from the misinterpretation of the Women's Health Initiative study to practical prescribing guidelines for estrogen, progesterone, and testosterone. Both doctors emphasize that menopause care requires a nuanced, individualized approach that treats the patient, not just the symptoms or lab values.

Key Concepts

The Current "Menopause Moment"

* Social media as catalyst: Dr. Haver explains that social media has become a powerful platform where women share their menopause experiences, creating unprecedented awareness and demand for better care

* Generational shift: Gen X women are refusing to "quietly suffer" through symptoms like vaginal atrophy, bone deterioration, and cognitive decline

* Health span focus: Patients are increasingly concerned with quality of life and preventing the trajectory of decline they witnessed in their mothers and grandmothers

* Caregiver burden awareness: Women are motivated by not wanting to burden their children with preventable chronic illnesses and disabilities

The Women's Health Initiative Legacy and Medical Education Gaps

* Flawed interpretation: The 2002 Women's Health Initiative study wasn't inherently flawed, but its interpretation and media coverage created decades of fear around hormone replacement therapy

* Medical school inadequacy: Both doctors received minimal menopause education—Dr. Haver recalls just one hour in medical school with outdated information

* "Bikini medicine" concept: Dr. Haver describes OB-GYN as focusing primarily on "breast, uterus, vagina" rather than comprehensive women's health

* Guideline conflicts: Current conflicting guidelines between ACOG and the North American Menopause Society create confusion for practitioners

* Systemic healthcare bias: The medical system struggles to address symptoms that can't be measured in blood tests or imaging

Hormone Replacement Therapy: Estrogen Formulations and Prescribing

* Oral vs. transdermal delivery: Oral estrogen carries a small increased risk of blood clots (7 in 10,000) due to first-pass liver metabolism, while transdermal forms (patches, gels, sprays) avoid this risk entirely

* Cardiovascular benefits: Oral estrogen may offer slightly better cardiovascular protection and LDL reduction due to liver metabolism

* Bone protection thresholds: Different estrogen levels provide different benefits—some stop bone degradation while higher levels can actually build bone

* Individual absorption variability: Patients absorb hormones differently, requiring personalized dosing and monitoring

* Cost considerations: Generic patches are often the most affordable option, while newer formulations like gels and rings can be expensive

Progesterone: Beyond Endometrial Protection

* Mandatory for uterus owners: Women with a uterus must take progesterone with estrogen to prevent endometrial overgrowth and cancer risk

* Sleep and anxiety benefits: Progesterone converts to allopregnenolone, which binds to GABA receptors and provides sedative effects

* Multiple delivery options: IUDs can provide local progesterone for endometrial protection while oral progesterone can be added for sleep benefits

* Individual tolerance: Some women experience paradoxical stimulation or next-day grogginess from progesterone

* Newer options: Duavee combines conjugated estrogen with bazedoxifene, a SERM that blocks estrogen receptors in breast and uterine tissue

Testosterone: The Overlooked Hormone

* Age-related decline: Testosterone levels begin declining at age 30 in women, reaching about 50% of peak levels by age 50

* FDA approval gap: Despite multiple medical societies supporting testosterone for low libido treatment, the FDA has not approved any testosterone products specifically for women

* Evidence for libido: Strong evidence supports testosterone use for hypoactive sexual desire disorder in women

* Potential broader benefits: While not definitively proven, observational data suggests women with higher natural testosterone levels have better bone density, muscle strength, and lower frailty scores

* Dosing challenges: Women must use compounded or modified men's formulations due to lack of FDA-approved options

The Zone of Chaos: Understanding Perimenopause

* Clinical diagnosis: Perimenopause is diagnosed based on symptoms and patient history, not blood tests, due to wildly fluctuating hormone levels

* 7-10 year process: The transition from regular cycles to menopause typically takes 7-10 years as egg supply dwindles

* Unpredictable patterns: Unlike the predictable monthly cycle of reproductive years, perimenopause involves erratic hormone fluctuations

* Multiple system effects: Estrogen affects every body system—brain, bones, heart, vagina, mood—making perimenopause symptoms diverse and complex

* Treatment complexity: Managing perimenopause often requires different approaches than treating postmenopausal women, including considerations about contraception needs

The Upshot

This conversation illuminates why menopause care represents one of medicine's most significant gaps in women's health. The combination of inadequate medical education, misinterpreted research, conflicting guidelines, and time-constrained healthcare visits has left millions of women without access to evidence-based treatment. Dr. Haver's work, along with other menopause advocates, is helping to change this narrative by emphasizing that menopause is not just about hot flashes—it's about optimizing health span and preventing the cascade of age-related diseases that disproportionately affect women after menopause.

The key takeaway is that menopause care requires a toolkit approach where hormone replacement therapy is one important tool among many, including nutrition, exercise, stress management, and sleep optimization.

For women who missed the opportunity for hormone therapy during their menopause transition, it's never too late to focus on building better health through lifestyle interventions and appropriate medical care. The goal isn't just living longer—it's about maintaining vitality, independence, and quality of life throughout the aging process.

Most importantly, this conversation underscores the need for women to become educated advocates for their own health, to seek out menopause-knowledgeable providers, and to make decisions based on current evidence rather than outdated fears. As Dr. Haver emphasizes, women armed with good information make great decisions for themselves.



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
Sexual health is health: a conversation with urologist & sex med expert Dr. Rachel Rubin about menopause, HRT, & genitourinary health18 juin 202500:47:13

Episode Summary

In this comprehensive discussion, Dr. Lucy McBride interviews urologist and sexual medicine expert Dr. Rachel Rubin about the critical but often overlooked aspects of sexual health, hormone replacement therapy, and genitourinary syndrome of menopause. Dr. Rubin shares her holistic approach to patient care, explaining why sexual health should be treated like any other organ system and providing evidence-based solutions for common issues affecting both women and men. The conversation covers the biology of hormones, the safety and efficacy of various treatments, and the urgent need for better education among healthcare providers about these vital health topics.

Key Topics Discussed

The Importance of Comprehensive Sexual Health Care

* Drs. Rubin and McBride emphasize treating sexual health as a vital sign, just like checking blood pressure or cholesterol

* They advocate for creating nonjudgmental spaces where patients feel comfortable discussing intimate concerns

* The conversation highlights how taking time with patients and asking the right questions can transform care

* Dr. Rubin notes that sexual health problems are more common than diabetes, heart disease, or osteoporosis

The Bio-psycho-social Approach to Low Libido

* Low libido affects approximately 40% of women, but only 10% are bothered enough to seek treatment

* Treatment requires addressing both biological factors (hormones, medications) and psychosocial factors (therapy, education, relationship dynamics)

* Antidepressants, while often necessary, can significantly impact sexual function for both men and women

* The approach must be individualized, meeting patients where they are and addressing their specific goals

Testosterone: The Forgotten Hormone for Women

* Ovaries produce significantly more testosterone than estrogen—about 10 times more when measured in equivalent units

* Testosterone decline begins in a woman's 30s, contributing to low libido, urinary symptoms, and loss of muscle mass

* Despite extensive safety data, no FDA-approved testosterone exists for women due to regulatory barriers and moved goalposts

* Transdermal testosterone gel can be life-changing for women and for men, often taking 3-6 months to show full effects

Hormone Replacement Therapy: Safety and Efficacy

* Transdermal estrogen (patches, gels, rings) is superior to oral estrogen for sexual function due to lower impact on sex hormone binding globulin

* The Women's Health Initiative actually showed estrogen decreased breast cancer risk—it was never the problem

* For the majority of women, the benefits of HRT outweigh the risks of HRT—if, that is, HRT is started within the first 10 years after a woman’s last menstrual period

* The combination of estrogen, progesterone, and testosterone often provides optimal results for menopausal symptoms

Vaginal Estrogen: A Life-Saving Treatment

* Low-dose vaginal estrogen reduces UTI risk by more than 50% and prevents hospitalizations and sepsis

* The treatment costs only $13 per tube and lasts 2-3 months, potentially saving Medicare $6-22 billion annually

* Proper application requires using a full gram of cream rubbed into vaginal walls, not just a pea-sized amount

* The American Urological Association recently released guidelines confirming vaginal estrogen's safety and efficacy

Building a Healthcare "Pit Crew" for Sexual Health

* Patients may need multiple specialists: sex therapists, menopause doctors, physical therapists, and sexual medicine experts

* Dr. Rubin focuses on four key areas: libido, arousal, orgasm, and pain

* The field of sexual medicine is rapidly evolving with new research, treatments, and educational opportunities

* Healthcare providers need continuing education to stay current with evidence-based sexual health treatments

Key Takeaways

Dr. Rubin's advocacy work has led to significant policy changes, including new guidelines from the American Urological Association that explicitly state vaginal hormones are safe and effective. Her mission extends beyond individual patient care to systemic change through research, education, and mentorship. The conversation underscores that sexual health problems are treatable medical conditions, not inevitable parts of aging, and that patients deserve knowledgeable, compassionate care that addresses all aspects of their wellbeing.

The discussion emphasizes that while the field of sexual medicine has made tremendous advances, there's still significant work to be done in training healthcare providers and changing cultural attitudes about sexual health. Dr. Rubin's approach demonstrates that with proper education and tools, any clinician can effectively address these common but often overlooked health concerns.

You can find Dr. Rubin at www.rachelrubinmd.com!



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
Gut Health: Practical Solutions for Common GI Issues11 juin 202500:34:01

Episode Summary

In this episode, Dr. Lucy McBride addresses the most common gastrointestinal complaints she encounters in her primary care practice. She emphasizes that most GI issues aren't mysterious and often have simple solutions when approached systematically. The conversation covers five main digestive problems—IBS, GERD, bloating and gas, constipation, and colon cancer prevention—while highlighting the important connection between emotional health and digestive symptoms. Dr. McBride advocates for a holistic approach that considers everything patients consume, their stress levels, and lifestyle factors, rather than relying solely on lab tests for common complaints.

Key Concepts

IRRITABLE BOWEL SYNDROME (IBS): IT'S REAL AND IT'S MANAGEABLE

* IBS is a functional disorder where the colon becomes spastic and irritable, causing alternating diarrhea and constipation, bloating, gas, and abdominal discomfort - it's not dangerous but can be very distressing

* Common trigger foods include alcohol, caffeine, sugar, dairy, and gluten, plus FODMAP foods (short-chain fermentable carbohydrates like beans and certain fruits and vegetables)

* The gut is literally the "home of many of our emotions" - stress, anxiety, and emotional distress often show up as digestive symptoms, which is why travel causes constipation and anxiety can trigger diarrhea

* Treatment involves systematically identifying your personal trigger foods, managing stress through exercise or therapy, and addressing underlying emotional health rather than just taking tests

GERD: WAY MORE THAN JUST HEARTBURN

* GERD happens when stomach acid travels upward into the esophagus instead of downward - it can cause chronic cough, sore throat, sinus symptoms, and morning nausea, not just chest burning

* Common culprits include NSAIDs (Advil, ibuprofen), acidic foods and drinks (wine, coffee, vinegar, tomatoes, citrus), certain medications, and emotional stress that increases acid production

* Simple fixes include reducing acidic foods, elevating the head of your bed with wedge pillows, eating earlier in the evening, and reviewing your medication list with your doctor

* Dr. McBride recommends the book "Dropping Acid" as a practical guide to reducing dietary triggers

Bloating and Gas: The Usual Suspects

* Primary triggers include sugar-free gum and sweeteners, NSAIDs, too much fiber (yes, you can have too much of a good thing), eating too quickly, and not moving your body enough

* Many gas-producing foods are FODMAPs, but don't eliminate everything on the list at once - pin it to your refrigerator and notice correlations between what you eat and your symptoms

* Your gut needs movement to function properly - if your body isn't moving, your gut sits there "too quiet" and needs motion to get things going

* Focus on gradual identification of your personal triggers rather than wholesale dietary restrictions that leave you feeling restricted

CONSTIPATION: FIBER IS YOUR FRIEND (PLUS A FEW OTHER HELPERS)

* The most common cause is simply not getting enough dietary fiber from fruits, vegetables, leafy greens, and whole grains - "fiber, fiber, fiber, fiber, fiber"

* GLP-1 medications like Ozempic, Mounjaro, and Wegovy commonly cause constipation as a known side effect

* Dr. McBride's go-to recommendations include Colace (docusate) as a safe stool softener, magnesium supplements (400-500mg) for muscle relaxation, and Swiss Kriss - however hers is not a substitute for advice from your personal physician

* Don't forget the basics: regular exercise, adequate hydration, and stress management all support healthy bowel motility

COLON CANCER SCREENING: THE GOALPOST HAS MOVED

* Screening colonoscopy is now recommended starting at age 45 (down from 50), or earlier if you have a family history of colon cancer, especially in first-degree relatives

* Colonoscopy is both diagnostic and therapeutic - it can detect cancers and polyps while removing polyps during the procedure to prevent future cancer

* Cologuard stool tests are "pretty amazing" technology but aren't as sensitive as colonoscopy and can't remove polyps if found

* Red flags requiring immediate medical attention include rectal bleeding, persistent changes in bowel habits lasting weeks or months, unintentional weight loss, and severe abdominal pain

THE GUT-MIND CONNECTION: YOUR EMOTIONS LIVE IN YOUR STOMACH

* Stress, anxiety, and emotional distress commonly express themselves through digestive symptoms - some patients use their gut as a "check engine light" for when they need better self-care

* Address mental health through therapy, exercise, journaling, and stress management alongside dietary changes for the most effective treatment

Upshot

Common digestive complaints often have straightforward solutions that don't require extensive testing or complex interventions. The key lies in taking a systematic inventory of everything consumed, recognizing the profound connection between emotional health and gut function, and addressing lifestyle factors like movement and hydration and behaviors around eating. She advocates for patients to become detective-like in tracking their symptoms and triggers, while also ensuring appropriate medical evaluation to rule out serious conditions.



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
Navigating COVID in 2025: A Conversation with Adam Cifu, MD04 juin 202501:00:54

Episode Summary

In this live (unedited!) discussion, Dr. Lucy McBride sits down with Adam Cifu, MD to examine the evolving COVID landscape in 2025. This conversation explores recent FDA and CDC guidance, the challenges of medical decision-making under uncertainty, and the broader implications for how Americans navigate health information in an era of politicized science. Both physicians emphasize the importance of humility, nuanced thinking, and the irreplaceable value of the patient-doctor relationship in making complex health decisions.

Key Concepts

The New COVID Vaccine Landscape

* The FDA's recent recommendations target specific populations: those over 65 and those under 65 with underlying conditions should receive COVID vaccines

* The guidance represents a shift toward more targeted, evidence-based recommendations rather than universal vaccination

* Initial proposals to remove COVID vaccines from pediatric schedules and discourage use in pregnant women were later moderated by CDC intervention

* Both physicians noted the transparency of the new approach, which clearly states what studies would be needed to expand recommendations

Risk Assessment and Trade-offs in Medicine

* Every health decision involves trade-offs; there are risks of taking action and risks of not taking action

* COVID vaccines are safe but, like all medical interventions, carry small risks that must be weighed against benefits

* The benefit-to-risk ratio varies significantly based on individual factors like age, health status, and previous COVID exposure

The Limits of Scientific Certainty

* Current COVID vaccine recommendations operate in a "data-free zone" compared to earlier pandemic guidance

* Unlike established treatments where physicians know precise benefit numbers, COVID vaccine efficacy in 2025 populations remains unclear

* The absence of updated clinical trials in highly vaccinated/previously infected populations creates uncertainty for practitioners

* Both physicians acknowledged frequently having to say "I don't know" when patients ask about COVID interventions

Long COVID: Perspective and Reality

* Post-viral syndromes have existed throughout medical history; COVID's uniqueness lies in the scale of infections, not necessarily the phenomenon itself

* With widespread immunity from vaccination and previous infections, new cases of debilitating long COVID appear to be rare

* Fear of long COVID may now cause more harm than actual long COVID infections

* The term "long COVID" has become a catch-all for various post-illness symptoms that may have different underlying causes

Medical Misinformation and Trust

* The current era represents a "snake oil salesman renaissance" where certainty sells better than nuanced advice

* Algorithms reward confident messengers over those who acknowledge uncertainty

* The most valuable medical advice for healthy people is often "boring basics": exercise, sleep, nutrition, avoiding smoking

* Longevity and optimization influencers often oversell marginal interventions while ignoring fundamental health practices

The Irreplaceable Value of Primary Care

* Individual medical decisions require understanding the whole person, not just population-level data

* The fragmentation of healthcare means that specialists don’t always see the whole person—they can’t—and too many Americans lack a medical home

* Primary care relationships built over time allow for the most important conversations about values, goals, and everyday health decisions

* Both physicians advocate for expanding access to primary care as the foundation of good healthcare

Key Takeaway

As the COVID pandemic transitions to an endemic phase, the conversation highlights medicine's fundamental challenge: making decisions under uncertainty while maintaining trust with patients. Dr. McBride and Dr. Cifu argue that the path forward requires embracing humility about what we don't know, focusing on proven fundamentals of health, and preserving the sacred relationship between patients and their primary care providers. Rather than seeking certainty in an uncertain world, Americans need physicians who can acknowledge limitations while providing thoughtful, individualized guidance based on the best available evidence and understanding of each person's unique circumstances and values.



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
How to manage stress & improve your mental health: a conversation with best selling author and physician Dr. Aditi Nerurkar16 mai 202500:53:52

Join Dr. McBride every Friday at 3 pm ET for her live Q&As in the app!

Episode Summary

Dr. Lucy McBride speaks with physician and bestselling author Dr. Aditi Nerurkar about managing stress and vulnerability in times of uncertainty. Dr. Nerurkar shares her personal journey with stress-related health issues and discusses practical strategies from her book "The Five Resets" to help people rewire their brains for resilience. Both physicians emphasize that mental health is universal, not optional, and offer actionable advice for managing stress amidst life's challenges.

Understanding Mental Health as Universal

* Dr. Nerurkar emphasizes that mental health is a universal phenomenon that everyone has, just like cardiovascular health

* Many physical symptoms (migraines, jaw tension, back pain, stomach issues) can be manifestations of stress

* 60-80% of all primary care visits have a stress-related component, yet only 3% of doctors counsel for stress

* Both doctors share personal experiences of physical symptoms caused by stress during their medical training

* Mental and physical health are inseparable; there's no partition between the brain and the rest of the body

The Five Resets Framework

* Reset 1: Get clear on what matters most using the MOST goal-setting framework (Motivating, Objective, Small enough to virtually guarantee success, Timely)

* Reset 2: Get quiet and find calm in a noisy world

* Reset 3: Sync your brain to your body

* Reset 4: Bring your best self forward

* Reset 5: Come up for air

* Creating a "backwards plan" to visualize steps from current state to desired goal

* Each reset includes 3-4 science-backed strategies for implementation

Practical Stress Management Techniques

* "Stop, Breathe, Be" - a 3-second brain reset to get out of "what if" thinking and back to the present moment

* 4-7-8 breathing technique (inhale for 4, hold for 7, exhale for 8) to activate the parasympathetic nervous system

* Digital boundaries: keeping phones off nightstands, switching to grayscale mode, using alarm clocks instead of phones

* Combating "revenge bedtime procrastination" - the tendency to delay sleep despite knowing better

* Using accountability partners for both digital boundaries and exercise commitments

The Science of Stress

* Understanding amygdala activation (fight-or-flight) versus prefrontal cortex functioning (planning, organization)

* The delayed stress response: keeping it together until you feel psychologically safe, then experiencing symptoms

* How scrolling impacts brain chemistry and primes the brain for stress

* The relationship between anxiety and insomnia creates a self-reinforcing cycle

* Stress from the pandemic and current events creates a collective delayed stress response

The Importance of Social Connection

* Research shows both deep relationships and casual interactions ("weak ties") benefit mental health

* Weak ties (brief interactions with strangers or acquaintances) build community without requiring emotional depth

* Finding community through shared activities like exercise classes

* Digital life has made isolation easier and social connection more challenging

* An accountability partner can help bridge the gap between intention and execution

The Gap Between Knowledge and Action

* Most people know what they should do for better mental health, but struggle with implementation

* Self-compassion is essential during the process of forming new habits

* It's normal to fall off track and get back up during habit formation

* Asking for help is a strength, not a weakness

* Recognizing we're living through a "perfect storm" of stressors that the human brain wasn't designed to handle

Upshot

Both Dr. McBride and Dr. Nerurkar underscore that improving mental health isn't about a knowledge deficit but about closing the gap between intention and action. Through practical strategies like the MOST framework, breathing techniques, and intentional social connections, everyone can build resilience even amid ongoing challenges. As Dr. Nerurkar quotes Pema Chödrön: "You are the sky, everything else is just the weather" – a powerful reminder that while we can't control external circumstances, we can develop tools to navigate them more effectively.



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
Brain Care is Self Care: Practical Strategies for Cognitive Health09 mai 202500:50:47

Join Dr. McBride every Friday at 3 pm ET for her live Q&As in the app!

Episode Summary

In this episode, Dr. McBride explores the critical topic of brain health and cognitive function, addressing common concerns about dementia while providing evidence-based strategies for protecting brain health. She discusses the different types of dementia, explains the diagnostic process, and outlines six essential pillars for maintaining cognitive health. With a focus on empowering listeners with actionable information, Dr. McBride emphasizes that individuals have more control over their cognitive destiny than previously believed and offers practical advice for incorporating brain-healthy habits into daily life.

Key Concepts

THE TWO TYPES OF DEMENTIA YOU SHOULD KNOW ABOUT

* There are two main "buckets" of dementia: vascular dementia (when your brain isn't getting enough blood flow) and neurodegenerative dementia (like Alzheimer's, where there's an intrinsic brain problem)

* Those everyday moments like forgetting where you parked aren't usually dementia - they happen because you weren't paying attention when you parked or because you're stressed and overwhelmed

* Having dementia in your family doesn't mean you'll automatically get it - genetics may set the stage but lifestyle factors play a huge role in determining cognitive health

WHAT REALLY HAPPENS DURING A DEMENTIA EVALUATION

* A proper workup includes brain imaging (focusing on memory centers called hippocampi), vascular health checks (blood pressure, cholesterol, diabetes screening), and testing how blood flows to your brain

* Neuropsychiatric testing works like a "stress test" for your brain - it's like taking your brain to the gym to see how well it's functioning

* There's no simple "dementia test" - diagnosis requires putting together many pieces of the puzzle, and genetic tests like APOE4 aren't usually helpful without specific treatments available

MOVEMENT: YOUR BRAIN'S BEST FRIEND

* Exercise literally waters your brain garden by improving blood flow, reducing inflammation, and helping control blood pressure and blood sugar

* The best exercise is simply the one you'll actually do consistently - walking, dancing, swimming, or cycling with a friend makes it more likely you'll stick with it

* Start small with realistic goals (like 20 minutes twice weekly) rather than aiming for perfection - a little movement is significantly better than none

KEEP YOUR BRAIN CHALLENGED AND GROWING

* Our brains remain adaptable well into middle and older age - forming new connections when challenged with novel activities

* Learning something new (like a language, instrument, or game) creates cognitive reserve - Dr. McBride's dad uses Duolingo for French and it's keeping his mind sharp

* Mental stimulation means engaging your brain differently than scrolling or passive TV watching - try puzzles, crosswords, Wordle, or learning to cook new recipes

SLEEP AND STRESS: THE HIDDEN BRAIN DRAINS

* Sleep isn't a luxury - it's when your brain cleans up metabolic waste, preparing you for the next day

* Chronic stress and worry can actually mimic dementia symptoms - when we're anxious or overwhelmed, our attention and memory naturally suffer

* Social connection acts as both stress relief and brain stimulation - isolation during the pandemic showed how quickly cognitive health can decline without regular human interaction

FEEDING YOUR BRAIN: WHAT REALLY MATTERS

* Focus on antioxidant and anti-inflammatory foods like blueberries, nuts (especially walnuts), avocados, and salmon rich in omega-3s

* Alcohol isn't doing your brain any favors - Dr. McBride notes that while she occasionally enjoys a glass of wine herself, there are now excellent non-alcoholic options like specialty beers and kombucha for those looking to cut back

* It's not just what you eat but when - your brain goes "hungry" if you only have coffee for breakfast and eat most calories at night, so maintain regular eating patterns throughout the day

Upshot

Dr. McBride's message is clear: you have significant power to protect your brain health. By implementing the six pillars—physical movement, mental challenges, quality sleep, stress management, social connection, and brain-friendly nutrition—you can take meaningful steps toward cognitive protection. The key is making sustainable changes rather than pursuing perfection. As Dr. McBride reminds listeners, "You have more agency over your health than you might think."



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
My Live Video about Sleep: Why it Matters & How to Get It04 mai 202500:50:01

Join Dr. McBride every Friday at 3 pm ET for her live Q&As in the app!

EPISODE SUMMARY

In this week’s episode, Dr. McBride dives deep into one of the most underappreciated yet essential pillars of health: sleep. Drawing from scientific evidence and her experience caring for patients medical practice, she explores why sleep isn’t a luxury but a biological necessity. She breaks down what’s really going on in the brain while we sleep, why so many people are struggling with sleep in modern life, and what we can do—without shame or gimmicks—to reclaim restful, restorative sleep. Whether you struggle to fall asleep, wake up in the middle of the night, or just want to improve the quality of your rest, this episode offers practical, evidence-based insights to help you tune in to your body’s natural rhythms and get the sleep you need.

KEY CONCEPTS

WHY SLEEP IS A BIOLOGICAL NEED, NOT A LUXURY

* Sleep is foundational for mental, physical, and cognitive health—impacting everything from immune function to emotional regulation.

* It’s not downtime or “me time”—it’s when your brain clears metabolic waste, consolidates memory, and resets for the next day.

* Lack of sleep is linked to mood disorders, metabolic dysfunction, immune suppression, and even increased risk of dementia.

THE “NOISY BRAIN” AND MODERN LIFE

* Many patients suffer from insomnia because their minds are overloaded with darting thoughts, worries, and to-do lists.

* The analogy of surface waves (busy thoughts) vs. the calm ocean beneath (deep stillness) helps explain how meditation or mindfulness practices like Transcendental Meditation (TM) can be helpful.

* Quieting the noisy brain requires intentional stillness throughout the day—not just at bedtime.

SLEEP APNEA AND PHYSICAL DISRUPTORS

* Sleep apnea is common and underdiagnosed; it’s more than snoring—it’s interrupted breathing that can affect cognition, blood pressure, and mood.

* Common culprits include alcohol, sedatives, back-sleeping, and anatomical features like a small oropharynx.

* A proper diagnosis and treatment (like CPAP) can dramatically improve quality of life—even reversing symptoms misattributed to dementia or depression.

STIMULANTS, SCREENS, AND SLEEP DISRUPTION

* Caffeine can linger in your system for 12 hours or more, quietly sabotaging your sleep even if consumed in the morning.

* Alcohol reduces REM sleep and fragments sleep architecture—creating a deceptive sense of relaxation.

* Screens stimulate both visually (via light exposure) and cognitively (via content), making it harder to access natural sleepiness.

BEHAVIORAL STRATEGIES FOR BETTER SLEEP

* Sleep hygiene matters: cool room (65–68°F), dark environment, white noise, and screen-free wind-down time are all simple but effective.

* Build a bedtime ritual—stretching, bathing, journaling, gratitude practice, or breathing exercises like 4-7-8 can cue your body and mind for rest.

* Regular sleep-wake timing helps anchor your circadian rhythm—even on weekends (though I admit I don’t always follow that one!).

WHEN TO CONSIDER SLEEP AIDS (AND WHICH ONES)

* Over-the-counter options like magnesium glycinate, CBD, and melatonin can be helpful—but shouldn’t mask underlying issues like anxiety or apnea.

* Prescription medications like Trazodone may be appropriate in some cases, especially when insomnia is part of a larger anxiety or mood picture.

* Medications like Ambien or Benadryl may work short-term but carry cognitive risks if used nightly or long-term.

UPSHOT

Sleep is not a bonus or an indulgence—it’s a requirement for your health, resilience, and emotional well-being. By recognizing what’s standing in the way—whether it’s anxiety, lifestyle habits, medical conditions, or external disruptions—you can begin to approach sleep with the respect it deserves. And the good news? Most sleep problems are figure-outable. Small shifts in awareness and daily routines can unlock deeper rest, greater clarity, and a more grounded version of you.



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
Live Q&A about cardiovascular disease—cholesterol, blood pressure, & how to protect your heart25 avr. 202500:59:22

Join Dr. McBride every Friday at 3 pm ET for her live Q&As in the app!

EPISODE SUMMARY

This week’s conversation is all about your heart—how cardiovascular disease develops, how to think differently about cholesterol and blood pressure, and what you can actually do to prevent problems before they start. Heart disease is still the leading cause of death worldwide, but the good news? You have far more agency over your heart health than you might realize. In this episode, we break it down in plain English: the numbers that matter, the tests that are worth it, and the simple steps that make a big difference.

KEY CONCEPTS DISCUSSED

What Cardiovascular Disease Actually Means

* Cardiovascular disease includes conditions of both the heart (cardio) and blood vessels (vascular).

* It’s not just heart attacks—it can also mean strokes, valve disease, arrhythmias, and more.

* Women are especially vulnerable, and heart disease kills more women annually than all cancers combined.

Cholesterol 101: What Matters and Why

* LDL ("bad" cholesterol) is the main target when we talk about lowering risk.

* Genetics, age, hormonal changes (like menopause), diet, and lifestyle all influence cholesterol levels.

* Your LDL goal depends on who you are—not everyone needs super low cholesterol.

* Lifestyle changes come first, but when needed, cholesterol medications (statins) are safe, effective, and sometimes lifesaving.

The Role of Coronary Artery Calcium (CAC) Scans

* CAC scans help determine if cholesterol is visibly sticking to the arteries—a crucial decision-making tool, especially for people at intermediate risk.

* A score of 0 is very reassuring; a higher score suggests the need for more aggressive treatment.

* The test carries a small amount of radiation risk, so decisions about ordering it should be personalized based on your risk factors.

Blood Pressure: Why It’s So Important

* High blood pressure can silently damage the heart, leading to heart attacks, strokes, arrhythmias, and heart failure.

* Risk factors include genetics, aging, diet, alcohol use, sleep apnea, stress, and certain medications.

* Lifestyle changes can have a huge impact, but medications are crucial when blood pressure stays high despite your best efforts.

Newer Blood Tests You Might Hear About: Lp(a) and ApoB

* Lipoprotein(a) and apolipoprotein B are newer markers that can add additional information about heart disease risk.

* Lp(a) is mostly genetic and usually only needs to be checked once.

* ApoB is dynamic and can be monitored along with regular cholesterol panels.

* Research is ongoing into treatments targeting these markers specifically.

How to Prevent Heart Disease

* You have more control than you think—but it's not about chasing perfect numbers.

* Keys to prevention:

* Daily movement and strength training

* A high-fiber, heart-healthy diet (think: plants, healthy fats, fewer processed foods)

* Limiting alcohol and eliminating smoking

* Prioritizing sleep and managing stress

* Regular, personalized checkups—including discussions about your cholesterol goals and whether a CAC scan makes sense for you

UPSHOT

You don’t need perfect cholesterol numbers, a flawless diet, or a gold-star exercise routine to protect your heart. You need good information, clear goals tailored to you, and sustainable habits that respect your real life. Cardiovascular disease may be the leading cause of death — but with the right tools and mindset, you can be firmly in the driver’s seat of your own health.

SEEKING YOUR FEEDBACK, PLEASE 🙏

I’d love to hear from you!

* Do you like 3 pm ET for the time of this weekly show? Or would 8 pm on a Tuesday or Wednesday work better for you?

* Do you prefer an hour, or is 30 minutes better?

* Do you prefer I do a deep dive into one organ system each week, or a hodgepodge of topics each week?

* What other topics do you want to hear about most?

I’m all ears! Drop me a comment!



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
A live video: Managing Anxiety During Times of Uncertainty 18 avr. 202500:45:41

Join Dr. McBride every Friday at 3 pm ET for her live Q&As in the app!

Episode Summary

In this week’s episode of Are You Okay?, Dr. Lucy McBride tackles a subject that touches every one of us: anxiety. In the midst of political upheaval, global conflict, climate change, and personal unpredictability, it's no wonder many of us are feeling unmoored. Dr. McBride offers a framework for understanding and managing anxiety—not as a pathology, but as a normal human response to an abnormal world.

Drawing from clinical experience and personal insights, she explores how anxiety shows up in the body and mind, how to listen to its messages, and how to build a coping toolkit that supports long-term health. She reminds us that the goal is not to eliminate anxiety but to calibrate it to reality—and to reclaim our agency in the process.

Key Concepts Discussed

Anxiety Is Not a Flaw—It’s a Feature

* Anxiety is a normal, adaptive human response to stress and uncertainty.

* It becomes a problem only when it interferes with physical health, relationships, or quality of life.

* Our brains haven’t evolved to distinguish between real-time threats and headline-driven stressors, so the same fight-or-flight response gets activated either way.

The Physical, Emotional, and Behavioral Manifestations of Anxiety

* Physical: Elevated blood pressure, jaw tension, back pain, digestive issues, disrupted sleep.

* Emotional/Cognitive: Rumination, catastrophizing, inability to concentrate, persistent worry.

* Behavioral: Avoidance, procrastination, substance use, overworking, binge behaviors.

The Five-Step Framework for Managing Anxiety

* Name it: Identifying anxiety helps restore the rational brain and reduces its power.

* Normalize it: Feeling anxious doesn't mean you're broken—it means you're human.

* Listen to it: Anxiety often signals unmet needs—like sleep, nutrition, or connection.

* Take action: Small steps like deep breathing, sleep, nature walks, and journaling can re-regulate the nervous system.

* Seek support: Therapy, social connection, and medical guidance can be critical, even before anxiety becomes debilitating.

Knowing Your Anxiety Baseline and Triggers

* Each person lives at a different point on the anxiety continuum (0–10); knowing your “set point” helps you track and manage your symptoms.

* Identifying what spikes your anxiety (e.g., health concerns, news cycles, loneliness) enables targeted coping strategies.

* Avoiding self-shame for feeling anxious is crucial—your suffering doesn’t have to be the worst to be valid.

Coping Tools That Actually Work

* 4-7-8 Breathing: A simple breathing technique to engage the parasympathetic nervous system.

* Grounding in Nature: Walking barefoot outside, connecting to the earth, and observing the present moment.

* Writing: Journaling allows for cognitive defusion—separating thoughts from identity.

* Food and hydration: Recognizing hunger and avoiding overuse of caffeine or alcohol as they amplify anxiety.

When to Ask for Help

* Anxiety is universal, but when it interferes with functioning, it’s time to seek professional support.

* Anxiety disorders are among the most common medical conditions, though often invisible and under-treated.

* Calibrating anxiety—not eradicating it—is the goal of treatment and emotional growth.

The Upshot

Anxiety is a normal response to an abnormal world. It’s not a personal failing—it’s your body’s built-in alarm system trying to keep you safe. By learning to name it, normalize it, listen to it, and take small, deliberate steps to manage it, you can begin to feel more in control—even when everything around you feels uncertain. The goal isn’t to eliminate anxiety, but to calibrate it. That’s how we reclaim agency in chaotic times.



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
A conversation with Dr. Sharon Malone on menopause, hormone therapy, & how to be your best self-advocate in the doctor's office11 avr. 202501:03:41

Join Dr. McBride every Friday at 3 pm ET for her live Q&As in the app!

For too long, women have been left to navigate menopause in the dark—without facts, without context, and without a roadmap.

In this episode, Dr. McBride is joined by Dr. Sharon Malone—OBGYN, menopause expert, and best-selling author of Grown Woman Talk—to bust myths about hormone therapy, unpack the history of medical misinformation, and talk plainly about what women deserve to know about their bodies.

We cover:

* What really happened with the 2002 Women’s Health Initiative study

* The truth about hormone therapy and breast cancer risk

* Why quality of life is health

* How to advocate for yourself in the doctor’s office

* And why context, nuance, and individualized care matter more than ever

Key Concepts Discussed

The Cultural Silence Around Menopause is Breaking

* A generational shift—Gen X and Millennial women are demanding better information and care.

* The internet and social media (Instagram, Substack) have democratized access to menopause conversations.

* Women are no longer willing to settle for a diminished quality of life or misinformation about their health.

* What was once confined to private doctor’s offices is now in the public discourse.

The 2002 Women's Health Initiative (WHI) Study—What Really Happened

* The WHI was designed to explore if HRT reduced cardiovascular disease—not to assess menopause symptoms.

* The media misrepresented the study's results, causing widespread fear of HRT, especially linking it to breast cancer.

* Crucial context was lost:

* The increase in breast cancer risk was less than 1 in 1,000 women per year.

* No increase in breast cancer deaths was found.

* The WHI included women ages 50-79—skewing results because older women were more vulnerable to risks that don’t apply to younger menopausal women.

Rethinking Hormone Therapy: Benefits, Risks & The Power of Context

* Estrogen remains the most effective treatment for menopausal symptoms like hot flashes, night sweats, sleep disruption, and vaginal dryness.

* Newer studies show that estrogen-only therapy (in women without a uterus) may decrease breast cancer risk.

* The timing of HRT initiation matters:

* Starting HRT within 10 years of menopause offers the most benefit and least risk.

* Risks of not taking HRT—including osteoporosis, cardiovascular disease, and cognitive decline—are often under-discussed.

* Breast cancer risk, while real, must be understood in context alongside these other risks.

Estrogen and Brain Health—What We Know & What We Don't

* Estrogen plays a profound role in brain function, mood regulation, memory, and cognition.

* Early menopause (before 45) increases dementia risk—HRT is standard care to mitigate that risk.

* There’s strong observational evidence (but no definitive RCT) suggesting HRT may help prevent vascular dementia.

* Science is evolving—but waiting for absolute certainty means women may unnecessarily suffer.

Quality of Life is Health

* Health should not be defined solely as the absence of disease.

* Improving sleep, reducing brain fog, alleviating painful sex, and managing mood swings are essential components of wellbeing.

* The medical system often centers longevity without addressing how people feel.

* There are risks in taking HRT—but there are also significant risks in not taking it, especially for some women.

How to Advocate for Yourself in the Doctor’s Office

* Many doctors are still practicing based on outdated information from 2002.

* Women need to come prepared to advocate for themselves:

* Ask direct questions about HRT.

* Know that family history of breast cancer is not an automatic contraindication.

* Understand that cardiovascular disease is a far greater threat to women’s health than breast cancer.

* Vaginal estrogen is safe and effective for almost every woman at any age—especially for urinary symptoms and vaginal dryness.

* Consider virtual care platforms like Alloy Health for evidence-based menopause treatment if access to informed physicians is limited.

Final Takeaway

This conversation is about reframing the narrative around menopause and women’s health. HRT is not for everyone—but informed choice, context, and patient agency should be the standard. Women deserve nuanced, science-backed care that addresses their full humanity—mind, body, and spirit.



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
Pre-diabetes & metabolic health!04 avr. 202500:52:50

Thank you for tuning into my live video! Join me each week on the Substack app at 3 pm ET!

In this week’s episode of the Q&A live from the office, Dr. Lucy McBride takes a deep dive into metabolic health. She unpacks the often-misunderstood concept of “prediabetes,” explains how blood sugar regulation works, and offers practical tools for improving insulin sensitivity and overall health—without obsessing over the scale. The conversation also includes a nuanced look at medications like Metformin and GLP-1 agonists (e.g. Ozempic), continuous glucose monitors, and the mental health aspects of our relationship with food.

KEY CONCEPTS:

1. RETHINKING “PREDIABETES”

* The term "prediabetes" often implies inevitability, which Dr. McBride challenges.

* Hemoglobin A1C levels between 5.7% and 6.4% signal elevated blood sugar but not guaranteed diabetes.

* This gray zone presents an opportunity for intervention and agency, not fear.

* Metabolic health should be viewed as a continuum—not a binary state.

2. UNDERSTANDING INSULIN AND BLOOD SUGAR REGULATION

* Type 1 diabetes = not enough insulin production.

* Type 2 diabetes = insulin resistance (insulin is produced but doesn’t work efficiently).

* Insulin helps move sugar from the bloodstream into tissues for fuel.

* Prolonged high blood sugar can damage organs and lead to serious health issues.

3. LIFESTYLE AS MEDICINE: EXERCISE AND DIET

* Cardio and strength training both improve insulin sensitivity.

* More muscle mass = more efficient carbohydrate processing.

* Diet tips:

* Reduce simple sugars and alcohol.

* Opt for high-fiber, protein-rich foods.

* Don’t skip meals—especially lunch.

* Trade-offs matter more than perfection.

4. WHY BMI IS NOT THE WHOLE STORY

* Weight and BMI are just one part of a person’s health picture.

* Some people with higher BMIs are metabolically healthy; others with “normal” BMI are not.

* The goal is not thinness—it’s functional metabolic health and agency.

* Personalized care trumps cookie-cutter weight goals.

5. TOOLS IN THE TOOLKIT: METFORMIN, GLP-1s, AND CGMs

* Metformin helps insulin work better but isn’t a weight loss drug.

* GLP-1 medications like Ozempic improve insulin sensitivity, reduce appetite, and can reset relationships with food.

* Continuous Glucose Monitors (CGMs) help clarify real-time blood sugar trends, revealing hidden issues or test inaccuracies.

* These tools must be used judiciously and with clear goals.

6. MENTAL HEALTH, STRESS, AND THE METABOLIC CONNECTION

* Chronic stress releases cortisol, which raises blood sugar.

* Emotional eating is common; food often functions as reward or comfort.

* Managing stress, improving sleep, and fostering satiety are essential components of metabolic health.

* Agency—not perfection—is the ultimate goal.

NEXT WEEK’S EPISODE PREVIEW:

Dr. McBride will be joined by OBGYN and women’s health advocate Dr. Sharon Malone to discuss menopause, hormone therapy, and how to get what they need out of our medical system.



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
Friday Q&A: topics include healthy weight loss, “normal” vs. unhealthy anxiety, when to seek a 2nd opinion, sleep tips & more!22 mars 202501:00:06

EPISODE SUMMARY

In this week’s live Q&A, Dr. Lucy McBride dives deep into the complex and often misunderstood topics of weight loss, anxiety, and how to navigate medical advice in a noisy health landscape. With her signature warmth and clarity, she explores what it means to approach health from a place of awareness, acceptance, and agency—not shame or quick fixes. This episode is a must-listen for anyone feeling overwhelmed by wellness culture or confused about how to pursue sustainable well-being in real life.

KEY CONCEPTS DISCUSSED

1. THE TRUTH ABOUT WEIGHT LOSS

* Weight loss is not a moral issue—it’s a medical one when appropriate.

* The first question to ask isn’t how, but why you want to lose weight.

* The number on the scale is only one small piece of the puzzle; context matters.

* Effective weight loss centers on sustainable behaviors, not restriction or shame.

* She challenges diet culture’s toxic messaging and emphasizes a whole-person, bio-psycho-social approach.

2. WHAT ACTUALLY WORKS FOR SUSTAINABLE HEALTH

* Exercise is critical for mental, metabolic, and cardiovascular health, but it’s not the magic bullet for weight loss.

* Eating enough—especially during the day—is often more helpful than eating less.

* Small, sustainable habits trump crash diets or extreme regimens.

* Accountability (walking buddies, scheduled classes, support systems) can help make habits stick.

3. HOW ANXIETY SHOWS UP IN OUR BODIES AND LIVES

* Anxiety is normal and adaptive—but becomes problematic when it overtakes emotional, cognitive, or physical functioning.

* She defines “healthy anxiety” versus harmful anxiety, using personal and clinical examples.

* Chronic stress and vigilance can wreak havoc on metabolism, sleep, and well-being.

* Dr. McBride encourages listeners to identify their personal “coping kit”—strategies that have worked in the past—and build from there.

4. WHEN TO GET A SECOND OPINION

* If you don’t feel heard, that’s reason enough to seek another perspective.

* A doctor may have the credentials—but if they aren’t treating you, the person, they’re missing the mark.

* Trust and communication are essential to good medical care.

5. SLEEP AS A HEALTH STRATEGY

* Screens, stimulants, alcohol, and chronic stress interfere with restorative sleep.

* She shares practical, real-life tips: nighttime stretching, magnesium, guided meditation, and creating a calm bedtime routine.

* Exercise during the day (even a walk!) supports better sleep quality.

6. WHO TO TRUST IN MEDICINE AND WELLNESS

* Dr. McBride urges skepticism of anyone selling simple solutions to complex problems.

* Health is not an outcome—it’s a process.

* Your best tool is not a supplement or gadget, but your own awareness, questions, and support system.

UPSHOT

This week, Dr. McBride unpacks the messy truths about weight loss, anxiety, and health advice overload. She reframes wellness as a practice rooted in awareness—not shame—offering real-life strategies for sustainable health, better sleep, and knowing when to seek a second opinion.



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
Live Q&A discussing pre-diabetes, thyroid disease, gastro-esophageal reflux, treatments of arthritis & more14 mars 202500:55:31

EPISODE SUMMARY

In this episode of our weekly live Q&A, I answer your pressing health questions, covering a range of topics from measles outbreaks to arthritis treatments. We discuss how to navigate common health conditions, identify where you have agency over your well-being, and make informed choices about your care.

KEY CONCEPTS DISCUSSED

MEASLES: UNDERSTANDING IMMUNITY AND PROTECTION

* Measles is a highly contagious respiratory virus causing fever, cough, congestion, and a characteristic rash.

* Outbreaks are occurring in various parts of the U.S., including the Southwest and the DMV (DC, Maryland, Virginia).

* The MMR (measles, mumps, rubella) vaccine is highly effective, offering 97% protection with two doses.

* If unsure about immunity, options include a blood test for measles antibodies or getting a booster dose, particularly before travel to outbreak areas.

* People born between 1957 and 1989 may need to check their immunity since vaccine efficacy was lower during that time.

PREDIABETES: WHAT IT MEANS AND HOW TO TAKE CONTROL

* Prediabetes is defined by an elevated hemoglobin A1C (5.7-6.4), indicating higher-than-ideal average blood sugar.

* Unlike diabetes (A1C of 6.5+), prediabetes doesn’t always progress to diabetes and can often be reversed.

* Key risk factors include genetics, age, metabolic inefficiency, diet, and physical activity levels.

* Stress and poor sleep can elevate blood sugar by increasing cortisol levels.

* Strategies for lowering A1C: reducing processed carbohydrates, increasing fiber, building muscle mass, and improving cardiovascular fitness.

CONTINUOUS GLUCOSE MONITORS: WHO SHOULD USE THEM?

* CGMs provide real-time blood sugar data, which is invaluable for people with diabetes.

* Non-diabetics sometimes use CGMs for insight into how food, stress, and lifestyle affect their blood sugar.

* While CGMs can be empowering, they should be used with a clear purpose—self-awareness, not unnecessary optimization.

* Many learn that stress, sleep deprivation, and alcohol significantly impact glucose levels.

* The rise of health tracking tech reflects people’s desire for control over their health but should be balanced with medical guidance.

ARTHRITIS: MANAGING JOINT PAIN AND INFLAMMATION

* Osteoarthritis (wear-and-tear arthritis) is common, especially in weight-bearing joints like hips and knees.

* First-line treatments include anti-inflammatory medications (NSAIDs like ibuprofen), ice, and physical therapy.

* Strengthening surrounding muscles (quads for knees, glutes for hips) can reduce joint strain.

* Cortisone injections may be needed for severe cases, but frequent use suggests the need for a joint replacement.

* When pain and disability become significant, a knee or hip replacement can dramatically improve quality of life.

THYROID HEALTH: UNDERSTANDING HYPOTHYROIDISM AND HYPERTHYROIDISM

* The thyroid is a butterfly-shaped gland in the neck that regulates metabolism, energy, digestion, and more.

* Hypothyroidism (underactive thyroid) symptoms include fatigue, weight gain, constipation, swelling, and slow metabolism.

* Hyperthyroidism (overactive thyroid) can cause jitteriness, weight loss, and heart palpitations.

* The TSH and free T4 blood tests determine thyroid function.

* Many symptoms of thyroid dysfunction overlap with other conditions, so proper testing is crucial before assuming a thyroid problem.

GASTROESOPHAGEAL REFLUX DISEASE AND BARRETT’S ESOPHAGUS

* GERD occurs when stomach acid refluxes into the esophagus, causing heartburn and chest discomfort.

* Triggers include stress, certain foods (acidic, spicy, alcohol), eating too fast, and medications like NSAIDs.

* Lifestyle adjustments such as elevating the head of the bed, reducing acidic foods, and using acid-blocking medications (e.g., pantoprazole) can help.

* Chronic reflux can lead to Barrett’s esophagus, a precancerous condition where the esophageal lining changes due to prolonged acid exposure.

* Not everyone with GERD develops Barrett’s, but it’s important to monitor symptoms and consult a doctor if needed.

Final Thoughts

This episode covers a broad spectrum of health concerns, emphasizing the importance of understanding your body, knowing where you have control, and making informed decisions about prevention and treatment. If you have questions for next week’s Q&A, send them in!

Thanks for tuning in, and see you next time!!



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
Live Q&A discussing measles, cancer prevention, Lipoprotein (a), preventing heart disease & more07 mars 202500:59:18

Thank you Kathy Fish, Luci, Jen Danish, Terry Matlen, LMSW, and many others for tuning into my live video! Join me for my next live video in the app.



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
How To Make Sense of Medical News03 mars 202500:45:41

Join Dr. McBride every Friday at 3 pm ET for her live Q&As in the app!

EPISODE SUMMARY

In this episode, Dr. Lucy McBride is joined by Professor Emily Oster to discuss the overwhelming flood of medical information, how to interpret health news, and how to determine whom to trust. They explore how context, communication, and risk assessment play critical roles in understanding health-related topics. From pandemic-era confusion to hormone therapy debates, this conversation is packed with insights to help listeners become more discerning consumers of health information.

KEY CONCEPTS DISCUSSED

THE IMPORTANCE OF CONTEXT IN INTERPRETING MEDICAL NEWS

* Headlines often lack necessary context, making it easy to misinterpret the significance of new studies.

* A single study rarely overturns decades of existing research; step back and assess how it fits into the larger body of evidence.

* Understanding the background of a medical claim can help avoid unnecessary fear or overreaction.

* Science communication should explain not just the facts but also the limitations of what is known.

HOW TO DETERMINE TRUSTWORTHY SOURCES OF HEALTH INFORMATION

* Seek experts with relevant credentials who acknowledge both the knowns and unknowns.

* Be wary of sources that claim absolute certainty, especially when discussing complex or evolving medical topics.

* Avoid health advice from influencers or practitioners outside their area of expertise (e.g., chiropractors advising on cancer risk).

* Trust is built on humility, transparency, and an ability to communicate uncertainty effectively.

THE FAILURE OF SCIENCE COMMUNICATION DURING THE PANDEMIC AND BEYOND

* Overconfident messaging and abrupt reversals in public health recommendations eroded trust in institutions.

* Many doctors and scientists communicated with authority but failed to provide accessible explanations of why recommendations changed.

* Social media and news outlets amplified polarization, leading to a black-and-white understanding of complex issues.

* The best communicators are those who explain the reasoning behind medical recommendations, not just the recommendations themselves.

THE WELLNESS INDUSTRY AND THE DANGERS OF OVERSIMPLIFIED HEALTH ADVICE

* The wellness industry often capitalizes on fear and uncertainty, promoting solutions without sufficient scientific backing.

* While lifestyle factors (exercise, nutrition, mindfulness) matter, they are sometimes framed as cure-alls.

* Overselling optimization strategies can create a false sense of control and blame individuals when health issues arise.

* True health empowerment comes from balancing personal agency with an understanding of biological, environmental, and systemic factors.

UNDERSTANDING RISK: THE CONCEPT OR HARM REDUCTION MATTERS

* There is no such thing as zero risk; every decision involves trade-offs.

* Whether considering vaccines, hormone replacement therapy, or COVID precautions, individuals must weigh risks and benefits.

* Public health messaging often fails when it does not acknowledge the risks of both action and inaction.

* Patients should be encouraged to ask better questions, frame their concerns clearly, and seek expert guidance rather than falling into all-or-nothing thinking.

HOW TO CURATE A HEALTHY “INFORMATION DIET”

* Avoid doom-scrolling and consuming health news in an emotional state.

* Choose a few reputable sources and resist the temptation to react to every alarming headline.

* Use strategies like “future-dating” articles to revisit later in a more rational frame of mind.

* Recognize that just because a piece of information is true does not mean it is relevant to your individual health situation.

THE UPSHOT

Dr. McBride and Emily Oster emphasize the need for nuanced, context-driven health communication. The path to better understanding medical news involves critical thinking, seeking trusted sources, and managing anxiety in response to health risks. In a world full of conflicting advice, the key is to embrace uncertainty while making informed decisions based on the best available evidence.

QUOTES FROM THE EPISODE

- “Certainty is at a premium in an era of information overload—but certainty is rarely possible in medicine.” – Dr. Lucy McBride

- “All options have risks. The idea that there is a perfectly safe choice is an illusion.” – Emily Oster

- “Wellness culture sometimes gives the illusion of control, but true health is about balance and trade-offs.” – Dr. Lucy McBride

- “Good science communication isn’t about telling people what to do—it’s about giving them the tools to make informed decisions.” – Emily Oster



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
Live Q&A now! Topics include cholesterol, statins, full body, MRIs, how to talk to a family member with mental health problems21 févr. 202500:51:02

Thank you Sally Satel, Carl S., MERRIE BREITENFELDT, Claire F., Wisdom, and many others for tuning into my live video! Join me for my next live video in the app.



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
Free live Q&A starting now! Answering your questions about weight loss medications, aging, cognitive health, cancer screenings, & managing blood pressure.💊14 févr. 202500:57:37

Thank you Eric Maierson, AUTHOR KRISTEN STAFFORD -HOWE, Kathleen, jackie sand, and many others for tuning into my live video! Join me for my next live video in the app.



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
Looking for calm amid chaos? Me too 😩😭 join me now for a conversation with Shannon Watts10 févr. 202500:45:27

Thank you Sarah Hartley, Integrate! Network, Pamela Cox | Author, Principaled And Unyielding, Betsey Apple, and many others for tuning into my live video with Shannon Watts! Join me for my next live video in the app.



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
Join my live Q&A. It’s free! All are welcome07 févr. 202500:57:47

Thank you Kathy Fish, Leslie Bienen, Luci, Olwen Assheton, Kathleen BONK, and many others for tuning into my live video! Join me for my next live video in the app.



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
Our first live Q&A! Greetings from my bedroom! 😆31 janv. 202500:56:16

Thank you Camilla, mitch, bobby dubois, Karen Duarte, Helen Pudlin, and many others for tuning into my live video! Join me for my next live video in the app.



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
Post-Election Distress: How to Move Forward with Purpose & Hope (Regardless of your Politics)12 nov. 202400:31:37

ICYMI 👉

* Need Better Sleep? Start here.

* Make Kindness Great Again

* How Much Alcohol is Okay?

Hundreds of you tuned into my live conversation with Shannon Watts on Saturday. While neither of us claims to have all the answers, we discuss some coping strategies to manage distress. You can watch the full conversation above.

👉 Let me know in the comments what you found most helpful from the conversation and how you’ve been coping in the week following the election.

If you enjoyed this post, please share it widely! Also click the ❤️ or 🔄 button below so that more people can discover it 🙏

Disclaimer: The views expressed here are entirely my own. They do not reflect those of my employer, nor are they a substitute for advice from your personal physician.



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
When the Kids Leave Home: A Conversation with NPR's Mary Louise Kelly03 sept. 202400:39:43

Life transitions are sprinkled with possibility. They invite adventure and hope. They can also force us to look inward, to reevaluate our life choices. They can beget sadness and regret, a mourning over the passage of time.

There’s nothing like kids getting older to remind us how it goes so fast.

Mary Louise Kelly writes out these very issues in her memoir It. Goes. So. Fast. It is a heartfelt chronicle of her eldest child’s final year at home, the death of her father, and other curve-balls in her life that forced her to reckon with her evolving roles as a parent, mother, daughter and wife. On this very special episode of Beyond the Prescription, Mary Louise describes the emotional and physical manifestations of grief, the bittersweet moment of sending a child to college, and the heartbreak of losing a parent and ending a marriage.

It turns out that even a woman who “has it all” isn’t immune to feelings of regret and sadness over the passage of time. Mary Louise’s authentic voice provides reassurance and hope that we are all caregivers at heart, doing the best we can with the time we are given.



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
How Worried Should You Be About COVID & Winter Viruses? 🦠15 janv. 202400:34:52

ICYMI 👉

* 4 Steps Toward Reclaiming Your Health

* It’s Okay to Not Be Okay

* How to Care For Your Body with Kindness & Respect

A note to paid subscribers: Join me for our next Zoom hangout on Tuesday, Feb 6 at 8:30 pm ET. The topic: Reclaiming Your Health in 2024. Bring your questions! Click here to register. 🎉

In a special video episode of today’s newsletter, my friend Shira Doron, MD, and I discuss the state of COVID—new variants, testing, treatment, boosters, and long COVID.

Shira is the Hospital Epidemiologist at Tufts Medical Center, an infectious diseases doctor, and Professor of Medicine at Tufts School of Medicine. She is a nationally recognized expert in antimicrobial stewardship and infection control. During the COVID-19 pandemic, she played a key role in helping the general public separate fact from fiction. 

I hope you take a listen above!

In addition, here is Dr. Doron’s take on the current state of COVID & respiratory viruses in the U.S.:

Respiratory viral season is upon us. It’s likely that you know several people who are sick right now. These days, it can be hard to figure out how worried to be. Is this a “normal” flu season? Is COVID-19 “surging”? The media is paying more attention to respiratory infections than they did before the pandemic, and the headlines are often designed to garner clicks, which is to say they are sensationalist. Let’s cut through the hype.

Here are a few things to know:

Current state

There are many respiratory viruses circulating right now, most of which are always more prevalent in the winter. You cannot tell the difference between them without a test. Health authorities track a metric called “ILI” which stands for “influenza-like illness.” This metric encompasses all of the respiratory viruses including but not limited to COVID-19, influenza (“flu”) and COVID-19. Right now, where you live determines how much ILI you are seeing.

source: CDC.gov

Trends show that ILI peaked in the last week of 2023 and is coming down. The peak this season was lower than the year before, and comparable to the year before the pandemic, despite the fact that we have a new virus in the mix. In other words, this is a “normal” respiratory virus season in terms of severity.

This is an ad-free, reader-supported newsletter. Consider supporting this work with a paid subscription!

Testing and treatment

Health authorities still recommend that everyone test themselves for COVID-19 even if they have mild symptoms. That’s because everyone is still advised to stay home for 5 days if they have COVID-19 infection (plus another 5 days of mask wearing). Testing is especially important for people with risk factors for progression to severe disease (such as those over 65 years of age, who have multiple medical problems, are immunosuppressed, or are pregnant), because there are highly effective antivirals like Paxlovid for those who qualify. You should be aware that, while the accuracy of home tests hasn’t changed, widespread population immunity means that the levels of virus in your nose might not reach the detectable threshold until later in your illness, as late as day 4, so keep testing.

If you haven’t gotten the latest round of free tests from the government (announced November 20, 2023), they can be obtained at https://special.usps.com/testkits.

Testing for influenza is indicated if you are within 48 hours of symptom onset and have risk factors for severe disease. Antivirals for influenza can shorten the duration of symptoms. Talk to your doctor if you think you have the flu, which is characterized by sudden onset fever, body aches, fatigue and cough.

It is rarely necessary to test for other respiratory viruses, including RSV, because there are no available treatments for them.

Prevention

Updated annual vaccines are available for COVID-19 and influenza. For the first time, we now have immunizations for RSV too.

COVID-19 vaccines

No longer to be referred to as a “booster,” the 2023-2024 annual vaccine was reformulated to target more recently circulating strains of the virus. Everyone age 5 and older who is not moderately to severely immunocompromised is recommended to receive one annual dose. While vaccination is recommended for all individuals over the age of 6 months, those at highest risk stand to benefit the most. There are three options: the Pfizer vaccine, the Moderna vaccine, and the Novavax vaccine which is a good option for people who need or want an alternative to the mRNA vaccines.

RSV immunizations

Almost overnight, an entire arsenal of preventative strategies have been approved for RSV. They are:

* The Pfizer and GSK vaccines for adults over age 60—public health authorities recommend that people in this category discuss with their doctor whether the RSV vaccine is right for them.

* The Pfizer vaccine for pregnant women—all women should receive this vaccine if they are between weeks 32 and 36 before the end of January. This will protect their newborn baby from RSV infection. Fortunately, the RSV season is almost over for the year.

* The monoclonal antibody, Nirsevimab, for newborns—this preventative treatment has been in very short supply. Talk to your pediatrician if your baby’s mother did not receive the RSV vaccine during pregnancy.

Influenza

Annual flu vaccination is recommended for everyone over the age of 6 months. Patients age 65 and older should receive a high-dose, recombinant or adjuvanted vaccine for greater potency. People with egg allergy may now receive any vaccine (egg-based or non-egg-based) that is otherwise appropriate for their age and health status without the need to be vaccinated in a medical setting. 

Other preventative measures

If you are high-risk or risk-averse, you may want to avoid crowded indoor spaces where the risk of respiratory virus transmission is higher. You can protect yourself with a well-fitting high-quality mask.

Maintaining your general health will go a long way to helping you successfully weather a respiratory infection, as it is inevitable that everyone will catch one at some point. Remember to eat well, get plenty of sleep, exercise, manage your stress, and optimize your underlying medical conditions like diabetes and high blood pressure.

-Shira Doron, MD

If you enjoyed this post, click the ❤️ or 🔄 button on this post so more people can discover it on Substack 🙏



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
Is There a Link Between BMI & Health?20 nov. 202300:30:07

You can also listen to this episode on Spotify!

The new weight loss drugs such as Ozempic are stunningly effective at helping patients lose weight and improve their metabolic health. Their existence also seems to have intensified polarizing rhetoric around weight, health and BMI. 

On one end of the ideological spectrum, there is the “Healthy at Every Size” (HAES) movement that aims to decouple weight from worthiness—and argues that doctors who recommend weight loss to their patients with obesity do more harm by enabling body shaming without evidence to support the benefits of weight loss on health. On the other end of the spectrum is the camp that believes obesity is a result of poor health and life choices—and that patients with obesity should simply eat better and exercise more rather than succumb to the pharmaceutical industry’s latest fad. 

Emily Osteris a Professor at Brown University, a best-selling author, and a leading voice in health economics. In her wildly popular newsletter, ParentData , she tackles pressing health issues of the day, helping people frame risk in order to make everyday decisions. Dr. Oster joins Dr. McBride on this week’s episode of Beyond the Prescription to discuss the data on BMI and health, and how to empower readers and listeners with nuanced information to be healthy, inside and out.

They review the data on the health benefits of exercise, independent of weight loss; the arbitrariness of BMI cut-offs; and the importance of focusing on health habits over a specific target weight. They agree that doctors do harm when they narrowly define health as a number on a scale—and the metabolic health involves addressing the medical, nutritional, behavioral or social-emotional elements of people’s health. As Dr. McBride says, “Sometimes that includes weight loss medication. Sometimes it’s a prescription to stop dieting and start eating lunch.”

The transcript of our conversation is here!

[00:00:00] Dr. Lucy McBride: Hello, and welcome to my office. I'm Dr. Lucy McBride, and this is Beyond the Prescription, the show where I talk with my guests like I do my patients, pulling the curtain back on what it means to be healthy, redefining health as more than the absence of disease. As a primary care doctor, I've realized that patients are more than their cholesterol and their weight.

[00:00:31] We are the integrated sum of complex parts. Our stories live in our bodies. I'm here to help people tell their story and for you to imagine and potentially get healthier from the inside out. You can subscribe to my free weekly newsletter at lucymcbride.substack.com and to the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts.

[00:00:57] So let's get into it and go Beyond the Prescription. Today we have an amazing guest joining us, my friend Dr. Emily Oster. Emily is a renowned economist, a bestselling author, and a professor at Brown University. Emily is one of the leading voices in health economics. Her superpower is applying data to some of society's thorniest health questions, including why people don't always make rational health decisions.

[00:01:30] In her wildly popular newsletter called Parent Data, Emily tackles pressing issues about pregnancy and parenting, helping decisions. I grabbed Emily today because I wanted to talk with her about her recent piece on body weight and health: What is the relationship between BMI and health? She pulled together a lot of data, and because weight is something I talk about with my patients every day, I thought I'd grab her for a chat. Emily, thank you so much for joining me today.

[00:02:03] Emily Oster: Thank you so much for having me. It is a delight as always to see you. It's such a treat.

[00:02:09] LM: Emily, you are no stranger to controversy. In fact, I was with you in the proverbial bunker during COVID, hiding from the haters who didn't like that you and I were trying to help message about risk. We were trying to help people better calibrate their degree of anxiety around COVID to their level of actual risk.

[00:02:31] By the way, I stand by everything I said and wrote. I hope you do too. And it was so fun to work with you then as it is now. So when I think about sensitive subjects, I think also about weight. And so, why did you want to write about weight? Is it just that you like putting your finger in the electrical socket? Or, did you have something to say?

[00:02:49] EO: So I've actually written about weight a bunch of times. So it is a topic that I work on in my academic work. So as a professor in economics, the work that I do is about health economics and statistical methods. And I actually work a lot on diet and dietary choices and why people make the dietary choices they do.

[00:03:07] And so it's not specifically about weight, but it really is about food. And so this is a kind of source of data that I think about a lot. And as a result, I've written about a lot in many different ways. And every time I come at this and I've come at it from all of the angles. So I wrote a piece once called what's the best diet?

[00:03:31] And it was just like the diet that you can stick to which is a sort of standard finding. But the frame was, you know, a lot of people are interested in diet. And when I write that, many people are very angry. They're sort of like, no diet works, we should never talk about dieting, is kind of what comes back.

[00:03:48] I did an interview with Virginia Sol Smith, who I really like, and we don't always agree but is just one of my favorite people to talk to. She always makes me think about her book Fat Talk, which is very much in the other direction, sort of very much in the space of, we should definitely not be talking about BMI, we should throw away our scales, all foods are neutral.

[00:04:10] And when I published that interview, I got it from the other side. I got the, you know, how could you possibly say this, cake and apple are not the same, like this is, this is insane. And I've written about Ozempic, so just anything, I mean, you know this—anytime you write about it in this space, there's really, really strong feelings from both sides.

[00:04:26] So this piece was trying, as I always do, more or less, sometimes more successfully than others, is to try to thread the needle and say, look, let’s look at the data and see between the view of BMI is completely meaningless and correlated with nothing, and the view that your BMI is completely deterministic of your health and that is the only information we should use.

[00:04:49] Where is the truth? And how can we use the data to get to that?

[00:04:52] LM: It is such a crucial question because everybody who's paying attention reads the headlines and understands from their doctor even that weight and weight management is good for your health. We have diet culture seeping into our pores. I mean, it's sort of in the air we breathe, everything you look at on the covers of magazines, on Instagram, and in doctor's offices is about weight, or it feels like it's about weight.

[00:05:20] I see people all the time who have avoided coming to see me, even if I've known them for decades, because they thought they would feel better about themselves, and I would feel more proud of them if they had just lost weight before they came in. And as I say to patients all the time, weight is one piece of a larger puzzle.

[00:05:36] It is not a reflection of your value, your worth. And it certainly doesn't tell us everything about your health. So I'd love to hear about your findings about the relationship between BMI and actual health.

[00:05:50] EO: In my mind, the most, the sort of most important thing to note here is that something can be correlated and can have some explanatory power and not be all of the explanatory power. So one version of this question is to say, on average, if your weight is higher, are you more likely to have other health conditions?

[00:06:13] And I should say, that's actually different from the question of whether weight causes other health conditions. But purely taking this from like a correlational standpoint, if you saw one piece of data about someone, you saw their BMI, would you learn anything about their health? And the answer is, yes. On average, there is a relationship, particularly at the upper end of BMI, between increasing BMI and worse health.

[00:06:41] And in particular, worse metabolic health. So things like, there's a strong correlation between high weight and diabetes. That's just true in the data. Now, those relationships... are there, but they're actually not as big, I think, as many people think. And that's sort of the other thing that comes out of this.

[00:06:58] And that, that has two parts. So one is actually, even to the extent that there's a positive relationship there, it doesn't show up until you start getting to sort of higher levels of BMI. So sometimes we talk, we talk about overweight being 25 BMI versus 24. Actually, the health differences between people with a BMI in the 25 to 30 versus 20 to 25, if anything, probably favor the 25 to 30, but you're certainly not seeing much in that range.

[00:07:30] As you get into a BMI of 35-40 you do see some of those, some of those correlations. But it's also true that in almost any health outcome you look at there is variation within a group and that's the thing I was sort of trying to illustrate in the piece is you look at something like diabetes or the distribution of blood pressure, like the distribution of blood pressure, it's shifted up for people who are higher BMI, but there's a lot of overlaps.

[00:07:56] Plenty of people with high blood pressure whose BMI is 19 and plenty of people with low blood pressure whose BMI is 38. And so that's the sense in which like this number Tells you maybe a little bit, but really not that much.

[00:08:12] LM: let's talk about what BMI is. BMI, I mean, you define it for us here, Emily.

[00:08:17] EO: BMI is a weight in kilograms divided by your height in meters squared. It's just a number.

[00:08:22] LM: So what you pointed out so beautifully in your piece is that medicine does this weird thing where we say that a normal BMI, body mass index, is between 20 and 24.9, and overweight is 25-29. 9

[00:08:37] EO: You guys love a sharp cutoff. It's your, it's your favorite. You love it.

[00:08:42] LM: I don't, but fine. The medical establishment loves these arbitrary cutoffs. There's nothing magical or particularly different between somebody who has a BMI of 24.9 and 25 and moreover, there are so many different elements that go into this whole person's health. That to call it a diagnosis point X and not a diagnosis at X minus .1 is ridiculous. So, you know, herein lies why we're here to talk about pulling back the curtain on what this actually means.

[00:09:18] EO: Right. And, and so I should say, like, you might wonder why have any cutoffs in this at all? I think the answer to that is that when people are describing, not even doctors, when population health scientists are describing characteristics of populations, it can sometimes be useful to define categories.

[00:09:40] So, you see this in weight, you also see it in something like low birth weight is another good example which has some cut-offs, right? So when we talk about baby weight, there's a number, 2,500 grams. And if a baby is below 2,500 grams, they're classified as low birth weight, and if they're above 2,500 grams, they're not.

[00:09:56] There's nothing special about 2,500 grams, obviously, but it’s helpful when we sort of describe a population. You want to say, does this, you know, is the low birth weight share in this population bigger than this population? We want to have a common language. And so saying, like, that's the cutoff we're going to use, so we have some number to compare, is helpful, it can be helpful. The same thing happens here. You want to describe characteristics of a population. I think the problem, and it actually shows up in the birth weight also, but the problem comes when we start, we take that, which is just away to use a number to make some descriptive statements about some population.

[00:10:35] When we take that number and we decide it's meaningful. It's like a somehow a meaningful number that we would, that would tell us something if you were on either side of it. Of course it's not. And when you're using it for populations, for individuals and populations on which it was not based, I mean, this is a much deeper issue, but when we talk about BMI in particular, this is something, these are sort of cutoffs that were developed with reference to like a white European population, they may have very different meanings and relationships with health for different populations off of which they are not based. So there's a sort of whole other can of worms there.

[00:11:14] LM: Totally. It's, I mean, to make an analogy briefly that you and I are familiar with is, you know, COVID risk, right? It's not that a 65-year-old, every 65 year old is at so much higher risk for outcomes. Then every 64-year-old, but there is truth to the fact that older people tend to get sicker on a population level when I'm talking to a patient who has just turned 65 and who is generally very healthy and active. I'm not going to counsel them in the same way. I'm going to talk to a 64 year old who's technically not at higher risk, who has myriad health problems. So population level data is one thing and then individual risk calibration and counseling.

[00:11:58] EO: Yeah, and I think the piece of this that my senses provoke so much anxiety and discomfort in people is that it is true that, and I don't think you do this, but it is, I think, an experience people either have or fear having in their doctors. They'll be weighed, their BMI will be calculated, and then they'll be told, you know, well, you just, you edged up above, you know, 20, now you're 25.1, and like this is how we're going to define you, and that becomes such an important, like, number in the conversation, and so salient, and the words, I mean, the words we use, overweight versus normal weight, obese, those take on an attention and a meaning, and they didn't just label them BMI category one, BMI category two, which, Maybe would have been more helpful.

[00:12:46] You're really using words that suggest that there's a way to be, which is normal, and then other ways to be. And that, that's, it's just not helpful. It's not, I don't think it's a helpful part of counseling. It starts people off on, on a bad, on a bad foot.

[00:13:00] LM: Yeah, I mean, I think people, for better or worse, look at doctors as authority figures and people who, whose judgment matters. And if you have a doctor who is doing a little tsk, tsk, tsk, ooh, you're getting up there, that has real power in many ways. And so I think that has real power and can do real harm.

[00:13:20] Which is not to say that doctors shouldn't be honest about the data in that patient's situation and what they could do and help to arm them with tools and information to be healthier. It's to say that shame is not appropriate or meaningful in any space, not to mention

[00:13:37] EO: Yeah, and I think the other, the other piece that I sort of spent some time on in, in this, and is actually quite closely related to stuff I work on, is that it's actually, It's very hard for most people to lose weight. Like, we know, I mean, we can sort of put Ozempic, Wegovy aside, but for people just changing diet, changing habits, consistent long term weight loss happens for a very small share of the population.

[00:14:04] And so, when we sort of start with the advice, you should lose weight, which people get, you know, in these situations, often that's just not possible. So it's like giving people a set of advice that they just... They're just going to fail on and then giving it as if, well, if only you could have this kind of willpower, if only you could achieve this, like that would be so important.

[00:14:24] I think the whole dynamic ends up in a place where you're giving people advice they can't follow based on a number that may or may not be that meaningful and isn't very nuanced, and you can easily see why that generates frustration, sadness, discomfort, lack of productive conversation with your doctor.

[00:14:43] And then by the way, turns off your ability to have a productive conversation because now we're like in defensive. Now you're like, well, you know, screw you, don't tell me what to do. What do you know?

[00:14:54] LM: Right? If we learned nothing else during the pandemic, that trust is precious. And when you don't have trust between the doctor or patient, and there's a moralization of human behavior, we're just at a standstill. And so how do you see the data that you've pulled together in this piece and before this piece helping people, individuals who are reading your stuff and then going to the doctor's office, understand better what their weight.

[00:15:21] EO: The piece I pulled out at the end that I thought was really meaningful was, in this piece I'm actually pulling data from the NHANES, the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey, which is a very big survey of, of people, it weighs them, it measures them, collects a lot of biomarkers, which is why we can say all this stuff about, about health.

[00:15:39] They also collect information about their exercise. And so if you look at people, if you sort of take a, a second, uh, almost a second metric of health and you ask like, okay, does this person do like some, some moderate amount of exercise a week and it's like some cutoff and you look at that relationship.

[00:15:57] One of the things I show in the piece is that doing more exercise is correlated with better metabolic outcomes, better kind of health outcomes in various ways. And it's quit informative on top of BMI, and so people who are doing sort of exercise who have a BMI of like 40 actually have sort of similar metabolic health to people who like aren't doing any exercise and have a BMI that we would consider, you know, normal or, or thin.

[00:16:26] And so I think for me that has sort of two pieces of it. One is that it just again emphasizes like this is one other thing you could like if you said like you can only learn two things about people It's like well, how much more could I add with a second thing? Well, actually like quite a lot the characteristic knowing somebody's BMI and whether they have exercised rigorously or moderately in the last week that tells you a lot more about their health than knowing their BMI alone You could add on top of that smoking… it's just one simple illustration of like how much more you could learn if you ask some more questions The other thing, and here I'm going to reveal what my husband is always saying, it's just like, just because you like to exercise, fine.

[00:17:08] But like, actually, I think we should tell people to exercise. I think that we spend too much time telling people to lose weight with their diet, which is something we know is really difficult, and I think we should spend more time telling people, like, you should go take a walk after, like, try to walk for ten minutes every day.

[00:17:27] You know, actually, it's not saying, like, you need to go run a marathon. But just some aerobic exercise. I think we have a lot of evidence from a lot of different places that that's associated with better health. And I think if we started telling people that and talking about that, we would then get to the questions like, well, how can we make it possible for everyone to do that?

[00:17:45] How can we make there be safe places for people to do that? How can we increase access to sports? How can we be in a position where everybody is welcome to... to go running no matter what, you know, their race or body size or anything? And I think that's, you know, for me, that's something that's pretty, that's pretty important. And I think we're kind of missing with this focus on food.

[00:18:08] LM: I totally agree. And what I love about the NHANES data is what you earlier said, which is that there's an incredibly tight correlation between the amount of exercise and health outcomes, even more than BMI and health outcomes. So when I'm talking to a patient who wants to lose weight or, you know, Needs to lose weight, perhaps I often tell them, let's not think about the number.

[00:18:35] In fact, I commonly say, let's not think about the number. That's not our end point. And, and I'm not saying that to be politically correct, to pussyfoot around hard conversations is because the number on the scale is immaterial. When we were talking about this whole person, we are the complex sum of these integrated parts.

[00:18:57] And you can, as you said have a BMI of 40, which is technically obese. But if you are exercising on a regular basis, first of all, your mood is better, your sleep is going to be more efficient, your blood sugar control is going to be better, your blood pressure is going to be better, most likely. And so, I focus, with my patients, less on the number and more on the behaviors.

[00:19:21] The relationship with food, not just what you're eating. The cadence of how you're eating. Sometimes you don't need a fancy diet, you just need to have lunch. I just wrote a piece about that. Lunch is an underrated food group, like eat lunch. Honestly, that is huge. Sometimes we don't need to, you know, go to the doctor and be told that our weight is technically higher than it should be.

[00:19:43] We need to be given materials and information on the benefits of exercise. Not just on our weight, but on our mental health, our metabolic health, our cognition, and not just... Are you told to exercise, but to help people figure out where to put it and how to incorporate it in their everyday life. Because as you know, telling someone to exercise is one thing, helping them figure out what to do is another.

[00:20:10] So I think you're absolutely right, Emily. We need to treat people, not just as a set of metrics and data, but as people. And as you know, from your research, human behavior is complicated. We do things that don't serve us all day long. Even doctors do, which is again, ridiculous, why I would shame anybody for a behavior that's part of the human nature.

[00:20:30] So to do a lot of shooting with patients or to say you should do this is less productive than to say like, how do you think you could incorporate a little more movement because of the data on the benefits of regular movement into your whole health?

[00:20:44] EO: I actually think, you know, when we do this kind of counseling and when people hear this counseling and they hear, they sort of hear the phrase diet and exercise, like you should improve your diet and exercise. They think of that as improve your diet and exercise so you'll weigh less. And that's the link we should sever.

[00:20:59] It would be, I think there's a place to say, improve your, let's think about are there changes you could make to your diet that would make you feel better? Are there ways for you that you could incorporate exercise, which by the way, like 10 minutes of walking slightly faster than you would otherwise, that's exercise.

[00:21:16] That's an exercise activity, so just like making it clear that these things are possible. But also without saying, and if you did that then the number will look better on the, no, if you did that maybe some of these elements of health, metabolic health, maybe some of this would improve, your sleep might improve, your mood might improve, that's what we're aiming for. We're not aiming for some number.

[00:21:37] LM: That's right. And by the way, when you're sleeping better and your mood is better and your dopamine hormone axis is being triggered by the lights of being outside and feeling more fit and getting the endorphins going that is good for our metabolic, metabolic health too. But I also want to be clear that I don't shy away from talking about a number when it is relevant.

[00:22:00] So if somebody has bilateral knee osteoarthritis, bone on bone, and their BMI is 40, and they're resistant to, you know, getting a knee replacement, we have to talk about weight. So it would be irresponsible for me to say, oh, weight loss isn't going to matter to this gravity-dependent set of joints. And so that is where it gets really hard, but it is where I actually like for me it's my like superpower is never to have judgment about it because by the way when you have bone-on-bone arthritis in your knees As a result of age and genetics and weight all together you can’t exercise and You gain weight more easily.

[00:22:43] And so this is what happens. So there's no shame about it. It's just, let's figure out what to do. But we have to talk about the number, not just the number, but we have to talk about what weight might make sense to that offset pressure on the knee.

[00:22:56] EO: Yeah, I mean, that's such an interesting, like, it's, this conversation is so hard because it takes, like, it's so hard to have that conversation. And I bet you are really good at this, but I think for me, it's very hard to have that conversation without it feeling like shame because of the, as opposed to just saying, look, there are a bunch of things, like, there is a physical reason why this, this number matters, not because this number has to do with whether you're a good person or not a good person or have willpower or whatever, it's just like, this is putting pressure on your knees.

[00:23:23] LM: Well, and that's why I'd really like to reinvent the healthcare system to have doctors incentivized to have more time with their patients to understand their story and to build trust and rapport and for patients to feel comfortable and then to train doctors on sensitivity on these subjects. Which, by the way, doctors went into medicine, the field of medicine to do that, but it's just people don't have time and then people don't trust and then there's diet culture and then it's just lose weight, exercise more, see you next year.

[00:23:50] EO: This is totally off topic. I mean, it's a little bit off topic, but, but one of the things that's been pretty effective in, you know, obstetrics is these group prenatal care. People have exactly this sort of same complaint about, like, there isn't enough time to talk about all the issues that have come up, da, da, da.

[00:24:05] And so they do these things where it's like six people, but you get two hours, you know, and we do, like, there's this sort of examination component that happens, like, that's short for each person, but then we all, they, people all talk together, and it turns out to actually be, some good evidence on the relationship between that and preterm birth, particularly for black women.

[00:24:20] So I wonder if there's like, I almost think there's like a parallel care model, where it's like, we have a group of people here for counseling about, you know, whatever it is, improving their heart disease metrics or something.

[00:24:33] LM: Yeah, stay tuned for some courses I'm going to be offering in 2024. One of my little kind of mantras is that health is about more than BMI. It is about having awareness of our health ecosystem, which includes ur story, it includes our data, it includes understanding our genetics, and then sort of a laddering up to acceptance of the things we can't control.

[00:25:01] Maybe we are predestined to have a higher-than-ideal body mass index because of our genetics. And we have to accept that. We have to accept that we are predisposed to diabetes. And then agency over the things we can control. So, arming yourself with tools and information to carve out space in your life to work on the things you have control over, which are a lot.

[00:25:26] But if you're stuck in the acceptance bucket where you're not accepting hard parts of your genetics or your story that you can't control and you're then listening to a lot of kind of wellness gurus who are telling you that, you know, thin is better or whatever, even just all this messaging. And then you're spending a lot of brain space trying to accept things you really need, or trying to control things you can't control, that's where people run into trouble, and that's where shame is born, and that's where people, frankly, binge on things like food and alcohol, and that's where we land in trouble. And so if we could just help people understand they're not alone, they're human, and that we all have our challenges. One of them, for a lot of Americans, is weight.

[00:26:12] And that they're not alone, and that there are things they can do to be a lot better off. So... What was the takeaway from this piece you wrote? Like, what was the reaction? Because, as you said, like, there's sort of two camps. It's like health at every size, there's a movement, which I agree with in many ways, except that there are certain medical realities we have to acknowledge.

[00:26:32] And then there's the sort of, weight is genetic, and there's nothing you can do about it. And, I mean, there's just, there's just these false dichotomies.

[00:26:39] EO: So I think like with most things, most people are in the center. And so this kind of like, I think that many people found this interesting. You know, I'm not sure everybody thinks about this data quite the same way, and sort of seeing some graphs about it, it made some people think. A bunch of the comments were like, yes, like I started exercising, and I felt like this is very validating, because like, that, you know, that totally changed, but then my weight didn't change, but still I feel better, and I was trying to understand that.

[00:27:08] So there was like some good stuff there. And then I did get, certainly, some people who said, you know, talking about BMI at all is very fatphobic and I am, like, I will say, like, I'm a relatively thin person and so I think, you know, I don't know, I guess that's part of, part of it. And then certainly there were people on the other side who said, you know, this whole thing is like, you know, anybody who's overweight is just, you know, is just lazy and I don't agree with that at all. But some of those people fought with each other and, you know, that's what comments are for.

[00:27:39] LM: That's what's comments are for. And that is why Emily Oster is here. Emily is here to help us get to these story issues, and ask the questions that... People are wrestling with every day, like, can you have a glass of wine when you're pregnant? Can you have bluebean cheese when you're pregnant? Can you jettison some of the shame about parenting and the parenting industrial complex?

[00:28:01] And thank God for you because I think you're doing so much good, Emily, and you're reassuring people based on evidence. You're not reassuring people for the sake of reassuring them for you to look good. You're reassuring them because you have the data to show. How to calibrate risk to, or sort of how to calibrate anxiety to the actual

[00:28:21] EO: Yeah, I mean, I see a lot of what I try to do is sort of help people see what those risks are and make the choices that work for them, which [are] going to reflect our own risk tolerances and preferences and, and what's important to us.

[00:28:33] LM: Yeah. I mean, at the end of the day, as we talked about during COVID quite a lot, it's about framing risk. It's not about telling people how to feel or telling people how to choose. It's about framing risk. And then it's like, you do you, and that's fine. And if you do something that's not healthy for you, that is fine too. As long as you're armed with the data, then that, that, that is, that is great. Emily, thanks for joining me. And by the way, how can people sign up for parent data?

[00:28:56] EO: So, parentdata.org, you can find me there, we have a newsletter that goes out, we have an enormous volume of writing for pregnant people and parents and, and some things for people who are not parents, and we have like a little search AI, so parentdata.org is the best place, or you can find me on Instagram at profemilyaster.

[00:29:20] LM: Thank you all for listening to Beyond the Prescription. Please don't forget to subscribe, like, download, and share the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you catch your podcasts. I'd be thrilled if you liked this episode to rate and review it. And if you have a comment or question, please drop us a line at info@lucymcbride.com. The views expressed on this show are entirely my own and do not constitute medical advice for individuals. That should be obtained from your personal physician.



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
Finding Hope & Light within Darkness16 oct. 202300:43:15

You can also listen to this episode on Spotify!

Dr Devika Bhushan is a pediatrician and public health leader who has lived with bipolar disorder for the last 13 years. She has served on Stanford’s faculty and trained at Harvard Medical School and Johns Hopkins. She's a firm believer that life’s trials and tribulations not only improve our self-awareness, they help us flourish.

While serving as California’s Acting Surgeon General last year, Dr. Bhushan publicly revealed her diagnosis in an effort to reduce stigma and spread hope for people suffering with mental illness:

I believe that our struggles can be the source of our superpowers. They can show us our capacity for vulnerability and strength, and that we can endure and overcome hard things.

Through her popular newsletter, Ask Dr Devika B, she is growing a community to help break down the stigma associated with mental illness. As she says, "Stigma festers in the dark and scatters in the light.”

On this episode of Beyond the Prescription, Dr. Bhushan shares her advice for mental wellbeing. The two doctors also discuss the complex roots of emotional distress; the shame around mental health diagnoses; and the possibility of post-traumatic growth.

Join Dr. McBride every other Monday for a new episode of Beyond the Prescription.

You can subscribe on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or on her Substack at https://lucymcbride.substack.com/podcast. You can sign up for her free weekly newsletter at lucymcbride.substack.com/welcome.

Please be sure to like, rate, and review the show!

The transcript of the show is here!

[00:00:00] Dr. Lucy McBride: Hello, and welcome to my office. I'm Dr. Lucy McBride, and this is Beyond the Prescription, the show where I talk with my guests like I do my patients, pulling the curtain back on what it means to be healthy, redefining health as more than the absence of disease. As a primary care doctor, I've realized that patients are more than their cholesterol and their weight. We are the integrated sum of complex parts. I'm here to help people tell their story and for you to imagine and potentially get healthier from the inside out. You can subscribe to my free weekly newsletter at lucymcbride.substack.com and to the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts. So let's get into it and go beyond the prescription. 

[00:01:02] Today I'm joined by the amazing Dr. Devika Bhushan. Devika is a pediatrician and public health leader who has lived with bipolar disorder for the last 13 years. Devika served as California's acting Surgeon General in 2022, where she focused on initiatives around equity, resilience, and innovation. She's a firm believer that our trials and tribulations can help us flourish, and she's learned this through her own experience living with mental illness. Today we will talk about what it's like to face a mental health diagnosis and the individually oriented lessons she's learned along the way. Devika, thank you so much for joining me today.

[00:01:42] Dr. Devika Bhushan: It's so great to be here with you, Lucy. Thanks for having me.

[00:01:46] LM: So in your op ed for the LA Times last year, you wrote some pretty powerful words. You said, I believe that our struggles can be the source of our superpowers. They can show us our capacity for vulnerability and strength, and that we can endure and overcome hard things. Can you expand on that a little bit? What do you mean by our struggles being our superpowers?

[00:02:11] DB: So my toddler, his name is Rumi. And so it's very apt. I'm going to borrow a quote from Rumi. The wound is the place where the light enters us, and this also hearkens on this Japanese tradition whereby when a ceramic bowl breaks rather than throwing it away, they will actually patch it back together with gold.

[00:02:37] And so at the end of that break, what you're left with is a stronger bowl, a more unique bowl, and a more beautiful bowl. And I firmly believe that when you have a chance to walk through a really difficult time in your life, whether that's because of mental illness, whether it's physical health, whether it is an early experience of adversity, whatever it might be, I firmly believe that once you have emerged through that, and walked through it and come out the other side, you become much more self aware, number one. You know exactly where you're able to stretch and flex and accommodate and where you're going to break. Right. And so that knowledge when you acquire it is something that will never leave you and will always make you a better whatever you decide to do after that. 

[00:03:29] So, for instance, like for me, I know that. I can endure a lot. But one thing that my brain, and anybody with bipolar disorder's brain, might not be able to tolerate is actually a lot of circadian rhythm shifts. So, for instance, when I was in residency training, I didn't really internalize this. The fact that I should, from the get go, be really careful about day night switches, about 28 hour calls.

[00:03:53] And I learned the hard way that those experiences led me to have mood episodes that required me to be out for three months, two months and really struggle to find an equilibrium again. And so that's number one, right? Like you learn exactly what you're capable of and what you cannot do, where your boundaries need to be as a person.

[00:04:13] Number two, I think you learn that there are superpowers that come from enduring really difficult things. So for me, one of those is that I'm a really deep empath and I really understand other people's struggles and vulnerabilities in a way that I don't think I would have if I hadn't had such deep and dark experiences of my own.

[00:04:36] And so when, you know, when I was a practicing pediatrician sitting with patients, sitting with families, walking through very challenging things, I could connect with how they were feeling and sometimes give them lessons from my own experiences when those were relevant in a way that really helped me be a better pediatrician. And I similarly found that when team members of mine, when I was the leader of a team, when folks would go through stuff in their own personal lives that was difficult, and impacted their work because we're all human beings first, and whatever's happening for us at home or outside of the work context does show up for us at work, I was able to connect again with what they were going through and help them make the space for whatever that was in a way that maybe a leader who hadn't had their own struggles wouldn't have been able to do. So I think on both of those levels, people don't always, acknowledge or talk about the ways in which struggles lead to superpowers.

[00:05:39] But that's a firm sort of belief of mine. And when I'm, for instance, interviewing podcast guests of my own on my podcast called spread the light with Dr. David Gabby, also published in my substack. One of the questions I always ask people is, “So how do you feel like this experience led to your unique strengths or superpowers?”

[00:06:00] And people always love reframing their experiences and distilling those strengths down for people. And I'll tell you, when I published my LA Times op ed, which you quoted from, that was the line that people most resonated with. And that was a line where people specifically said to me sometimes, “You know what? I never thought about my chronic PTSD or my... OCD or my borderline personality disorder as giving rise to these superpowers that I have. But you are so right. That's exactly how I experienced this. So I think it's a very empowering frame and it's an important one,

[00:06:35] LM: I think you're right. And I think mental health is having this moment, rightly so in the popular vocabulary, right? We've been talking about the mental health toll of the pandemic. We've been talking about the, the grief, the loss, the trauma people have experienced. And I think it's fantastic that we're finally identifying mental health as part of whole health.

[00:06:59] I think sometimes though people are confused about what mental health means or what it is. And I think sometimes we think that mental health means that you're happy or mental health means that you're content, mental health means you're not anxious And so I'm very clear with my patients and with my own kids and hopefully with myself as well, that mental health is really about that laddering up from self awareness that you described to acceptance of the things We can't control like we cannot control, for example, genetic predisposition towards bipolar disorder or breast cancer or what have you, and then leaning into the agency that we have and so mental health to me is really about self awareness.

[00:07:45] It's about sort of an understanding of where we can flex, where we have that extra Reserve and then where we need to hold a boundary. And so I think it's important to recognize what health, what mental health is. It's about having the resilience, the self awareness to weather the storms that inevitably come our way.

[00:08:06] It's not about being happy all the time. Happiness is great. We're not against happiness. We're all for happiness. I'm believer in contentedness, but I think it's those tools and that we have to get sometimes the hard way that are the most kind of beautiful and that the things we don't often count in our kind of resume of life skills.

[00:08:25] And I also want to say that Rumi is an old soul. Clearly he understands that even at two years old, when we break is when we repair as well… can shed some wisdom on our resilience. So let's talk about kids for a minute. So in your role as the acting Surgeon General in California, you did quite a lot of work on adverse childhood experiences or ACEs.

[00:08:49] And many people who are listening understand that there's an abundant amount of literature about the effect of adverse childhood experiences or ACEs on social, emotional, mental, and physical health issues later in life. So some of those are my patients, people who have had some sort of childhood experience of neglect, abuse, trauma, that shows up in their bodies in the form of hypertension, an anxiety disorder, binge eating. Our stories live in our bodies. And I commonly try to help patients with various physical problems by looking back at what happened, what's behind the curtain that we can then kind of connect to their current physical state. And it's often the case that a patient who's struggling with binge eating disorder and diabetes gets better when we put them on metformin and we get them in trauma therapy to work on kind of pulling the curtain back on what happened.

[00:09:48] And helping them understand that hypervigilance that was organized around a traumatic childhood experience shows up later in life. And that's, I mean, that's the most kind of fun part of my job, if you will. So adverse childhood experiences show up as social, emotional, mental, and physical health problems in patients later in life. And so I'd love to hear about your work on adverse childhood experiences and do you agree with me that they show up in our bodies, that our stories live in our bodies?

[00:10:18] DB: That is such a beautiful way to put that. And I could not agree more. Our experiences, whether positive or negative, end up living in our bodies, and they end up living in our bodies at a cellular level, at a organismal or organ level, um, systems level, and even for all, for the whole body, right, the whole system.

[00:10:39] And what we recognized around ACEs, so all of the folks listening, are probably well acquainted with this term, but these are essentially 10 experiences that are really difficult before you turn 18 years. So child abuse, neglect, growing up in a household where maybe somebody had an untreated mental illness, intimate partner violence between adults in the home, things of this nature.

[00:11:02] And basically what happens is that you're exposed over and over again to a threat and a stressor that is extreme. And so your threat response system and your stress response systems end up being activated and have trouble getting regulated and have trouble turning back off. And what happens is that can change the way that your brain develops, your hormonal cascades, your immune system, even your genes and the parts of your genes that regulate cellular aging.

[00:11:34] So those are called telomeres for those who are aware of this term and familiar with it. And so, you know, when you look at a population level, there is this dose response relationship between the number of ACEs you've had and all sorts of health outcomes, anything from cancer to heart disease to, of course, mental and behavioral health disorders.

[00:11:53] There's about 60 or more health conditions that you're at risk for. But equally, we know that being really intentional about turning off the stress response and using that, just as you mentioned, as part of the treatment plan for a patient who's coming in with a history of trauma and let's say diabetes or heart disease. If you are not intentionally looking at that toxic stress response that's in the background that has been with them potentially for years since their childhood and you're not specifically intervening on that toxic stress response, then you're leaving part of the physiology on the table. 

[00:12:32] So the ACEs Aware initiative, which we launched at the end of 2019, just before some of the biggest traumatic events of our lives were to unfold during the pandemic, the plan there was to really help health care workers of all kinds understand toxic stress physiology. And so, you know, there's a lot of talk about ACE screening, whether, you know, universal ACE screening is worth it on an individual level.

[00:12:59] We know all of this stuff is true at the population level, that ACEs will put you at risk for these health conditions, that sometimes the link gets lost. So the point of ACEs Aware Initiative is not, in fact, to say, do you have ACEs or do you not have ACEs? It is actually to say, hey, are you coming in with health conditions and symptoms today that are rooted in a toxic stress response? And if so, if you're at risk for a toxic stress response, how can we specifically cater your healthcare to be more individualized, and to not only give you the metformin for your diabetes, but also to help you understand that trauma therapy, as you mentioned, or anti inflammatory nutrition, or certain exercise habits, sleep habits, connection, etc., that there are these other evidence based behavioral strategies that we have in our toolkits as healthcare providers, as individuals that we can start to use to specifically turn off the toxic stress response as a way of treating somebody. 

[00:14:02] And so that, that message of hope is, I think, really important because we often talk about ACEs as posing risk for health, but we don't spend equal time sometimes talking about the fact that we do have these evidence based tools for enacting resilience if you do have toxic stress. In other words, toxic stress is preventable. And once it's in place, it's very treatable. And so that was the overall mission that we were working on at the ACEs Aware Initiative.

[00:14:31] LM: I love it. And then on top of it, there is the opportunity to make meaning and to find out where you can flex and where you need boundaries based on the self awareness from the work you might need to do on your toxic stress. So, let's talk about your childhood. Do you look back, Devika, on your childhood and see threads of your bipolar illness that predated the actual diagnosis? And, you know, to the extent you want to share that, I mean, how do you make sense of things that may have happened to you, good and bad, and the evolution of your mental health story? 

[00:15:10] DB: It's a really important question. As we know, most people who have mental health symptoms, it's most common to start to have the first symptoms when you are in your teenage years or in your early 20s. And for me, my very first symptoms happened when I was in medical school. I didn't have any kind of sign of mental health instability or any kind of mental health symptom when I was growing up. I did have a very unusual childhood in some ways. So I spent… my first 21 years about a third in three different countries. So the first one was India, which is where my family is from originally and where my majority of my family actually still lives.

[00:15:52] So we started there. I was seven when I left India, and then we came to the US for a few years where my parents were grad students here. Very stressful set of circumstances financially and otherwise. And then we went to the Philippines for my parents’ jobs, which were in health and development. And we didn't know anyone in the Philippines when we first arrived, and we were supposed to have spent three years just trying it on for size.

[00:16:18] And my parents ended up spending over 20 years there. So it was a big part of our lives and big part of their careers. And so, within each one of those countries, even there was a lot of moves. So by the time I was in fifth grade, I was 11, but I had been to seven schools in three countries. So there was a lot of changes and a lot of transitions and a lot of figuring out who I was culturally, you know, where I belonged.

[00:16:45] There were these kind of deep existential questions taking place, although I will say my four person family, so it's my sister and I and two parents are a very close knit unit, and so that unit kept us grounded and it made us feel like we were in home, wherever we were and you know, that, that made all the difference because I think I felt very grounded growing up despite the fact that things were changing on us so often.

[00:17:14] And I felt like a lot of folks who have multiple cultural influences, multiple languages. I grew up speaking Hindi, then had to learn English and. You know, uh, the whole, uh, getting made fun of for my accent in the U S and trying to get rid of that accent overnight, you know, all of those different pieces of like, am I Indian? Am I American? Do I have influences from the Philippines, but I'm not quite Filipino, even though I've spent so many years here, there's all of that stuff growing up, but I will say kind of back to your question, nothing that really would qualify as a mental health symptom, just sort of common experiences around moves and cultural identity that I think anyone would have with a similar set of circumstances.

[00:17:59] And it wasn't until I hit medical school, as I was saying, I was 23 and my first symptoms were of the depressive variety. And I didn't have a family history of bipolar disorder. I didn't have a personal history of either hypomania or mania. And so it looked for all the world, like garden variety, unipolar depression, right?

[00:18:19] And I was treated with antidepressants, which ended up over the course of three years, not working and making my brain worse, which is typical when a brain is on the bipolar spectrum. So often what'll happen is you'll induce sort of the little bit of activation that's not recognized. It's actually hypomania in retrospect, but might just look like anxiety on top of the depression, right?

[00:18:42] And that's essentially what happened to me. I had about three years where I was on the wrong meds. And I tried 20 different meds, you know, in that span of time. And luckily, you know, three years in, I was on three different activating meds and had a frank manic episode. And that really saved my life because it allowed people to understand that I was somebody who had a bipolar spectrum disorder rather than a unipolar depression with anxiety on top of it, which was the working hypothesis.

[00:19:12] And that led me to have the right condition diagnosed and also the right treatments then in place, which, which really, really truly saved my life.

[00:19:21] LM: I want to interrupt you to say, well, I don't want to interrupt you, but I would, I want to say thank you for sharing that because I think there are a lot of people, I don't know the number. I don't think we know the number of people who are suffering with bipolar disorder, who are called. Depression and anxiety, right?

[00:19:39] I mean, depression and anxiety are extremely common conditions. You know, certainly if people have enough depression, they can be anxious about it. If people have enough anxiety, they can get depressed. But I do think there is a subset of people who are inappropriately treated who actually are on that spectrum and they didn't have that manic moment or the doctor to understand that's what that was.

[00:20:02] And then they get further medicated and then sort of down a pathway that isn't appropriate for their diagnosis. So, I mean, did you have trouble recognizing sort of activation, the activation driven by the antidepressant that was then maybe the beginnings of your, of mania? Or did your doctor, like, did it go for a long time without being recognized? Or how did you make sense of those initial failures of the antidepressants?

[00:20:30] DB: It was much more clear in retrospect, you know, we had these three years where I did not feel like myself and I wasn't, you know, depressed for all of that time. At some points I was, you know, hypomanic where I might have been euphoric, right? And just tripping too quickly in terms of the energy and the thought processes.

[00:20:49] Or I had periods where I was hypomanic, but in a sort of dysthymic state of mind, meaning I was just activated and energetic, but I was irritable and angry and anxious. And it wasn't really recognized. Now in retrospect, it's very clear that, okay, all of that was hypomania. But at the time, when you're dealing with, you know, a 23 or 24 or 25 year old, because I crossed all of those numbers as we were seeking treatment, it just felt like, okay, this person is not responding to treatment.

[00:21:24] And as a patient, you feel very vilified because the statistics will tell us that most people with bipolar 2 disorder end up having symptoms that are mistreated for an average 11 years from the first time they're symptomatic to the time that they get the right treatment in place. And I was lucky that mine was only three years, but I will tell you, they were the hardest three years of my life, like, I was considering dropping out of med school, I didn't think I could hack it, I thought it was something about medicine, potentially, that was kind of triggering these symptoms that I'd never faced before, I was also pretty convinced that, like, the person that I thought I was pre symptoms, was completely gone, inaccessible, lost.

[00:22:11] Like, I would never find that person again. That I was just somehow stuck in this place of unwellness. And I think that's something that most people who have ever had any mental health symptoms can really relate to. Like, in the midst of it, you feel like you are never gonna be well again. And whoever you once were is no longer a person that you can access. I think that is the hardest part when I look back at that period of my life of true terror that I was never going to be myself again.

[00:22:39] LM: There's so many things I want to react to that with. First and foremost is deep gratitude for saying that because I think as I talk to patients with mental health issues, as I talk to family members with mental health issues, as I've talked to my myself when I've been struggling with mental health myself, there is this hijacking of our own brains that happens where you [become convinced that you're never going to feel good again.

[00:23:03] You're never going to feel okay. You're never going to be that person that you thought you were. And it's terrifying. And I think to see someone like you, Devika, who is, I mean, beautiful, healthy, accomplished mother and physician, it just gives people hope that this is not a death sentence. That it truly is a hijacking of your brain that is not a permanent condition and that you can get better.

[00:23:32] I think it's important for people to realize that if they are getting treated for depression or anxiety and they're not getting better, not getting better. You need to ask the question, is there something else going on? I mean, 11 years is too long for people to get a diagnosis. Bipolar 2 is not a zebra.

[00:23:47] I don't know the stats on the commonality of it. I don't know because I don't think we probably have accurate statistics at all. I mean, because it takes 11 years to get the diagnosis, but I know from my own experience seeing patients, I will commonly make a referral to a psychiatrist when I, for example, have tried my patient on Lexapro for what seems like unipolar depression and they're not better, or they have a little bit of an uptick in their energy, irritability, and then we ask the question.

[00:24:12] Because for people who are listening, a diagnosis of bipolar one or two, which are a bit different, we can talk about that, opens the door to another set of medications for treatment. This is one of the things I worry about with online, kind of drive through kind of mental health startups. I mean, I think it's great that people are getting better access, but I worry that we are bucketing people into depression, anxiety, depression, anxiety, when sure there's a lot of depression. There's a lot of anxiety, but first of all, do we need to medicalize all of it? I'm not sure. And secondly, are we making the right diagnosis in the first place?

[00:24:46] Such important points. You know, I think just stepping back, like, from the data, you're absolutely right. There's a whole variety of studies that have been done with differing prevalence rates of bipolar 1 and bipolar 2, depending on sort of what is counted. And it's very common within the bipolar spectrum for you to receive let's say one kind of diagnosis. I was initially diagnosed as bipolar not otherwise specified, which is sort of a soft call it's like somewhere in the on the spectrum. We don't exactly know where and then as people's lives go on you end up realizing like okay You've now had a manic episode off of antidepressants let's say, and now you qualify for bipolar one rather than bipolar two, so there's a lot of shifting along the spectrum and that makes it hard to assess and get true prevalence rates. there's a meta analysis that came out now about 10 years ago, and they said that 2.

[00:25:32] There's a meta analysis that came out now about 10 years ago, and they said that 2.6 percent of the population will meet criteria for bipolar one or two at any given time. But that's not counting the other parts of the spectrum, which we now know is also a sizable portion. But, you know, with depression, when people come in for a first time depressive episode, one in three of them. will end up being on the bipolar spectrum.

[00:25:59] And so if primary care doctors know this, if, you know, other kinds of healthcare providers know this, then we can start to turn the tide on that statistic of 11 years for bipolar 2, and it's shorter for bipolar 1 because it's much more obvious when someone has a manic episode, whereas hypomania can be a little bit more, it can cloak itself as anxiety as you said, and other symptoms that are harder to diagnose.

[00:26:23] LM: So what prompted you to be public about this? I mean, it's a pretty big move. I mean, there's a lot of stigma around mental illness, even though it is having a moment. There's a lot of misunderstanding about what bipolar is. I mean, I think people throw that word around a lot. Like, Oh, she's so moody and crazy.

[00:26:40] She's so bipolar as a derogatory term. You know, we used to call it manic depression. I think patients associate bipolar disorder with someone who's driving a stolen Ferrari a hundred miles an hour down the highway. And then someone who's standing on a ledge about to jump. And there's so much more nuance there.

[00:26:58] There's people in our lives. These are people who are functioning, who are parents, community members, people we know. I think it's, it's very brave of you to come forward as you and I were talking about before we started recording, particularly in a public role, like you had as the acting surgeon general in California, I mean, you're out there. So I'm just going to ask you, what is it that prompted you to go public? And what has that been like?

[00:27:25] DB: I was serving in the role of acting surgeon general in a moment in time when everybody was struggling with something, right? We had been in the pandemic for two years plus at that point. And we all, at that moment, knew somebody who was truly struggling, or we were that person ourselves. And so I felt like it was a really important moment to publicly own my story on a couple of different levels.

[00:27:53] One, to help everyone realize, like, you can walk through a really difficult period of your life and think that you can never bounce back from that, but actually walk through it and then, on the other end, be able to fulfill your own dreams, right, personally, professionally. At a point in my life, I thought I'm never going to have a career.

[00:28:16] I'm never going to be a parent. I'm never going to be a stable partner. But to recognize that even a really stigmatized mental health diagnosis like bipolar disorder, and it does carry a very loaded set of stereotypes with it, that even that, you know, you can look back at your hardest moments and say, those were in my past.

[00:28:36] And... The last 10 years or more, I've been well for the majority of them and now, you know, having figured out what it is that keeps me well, both behaviorally and medication wise, I can hope to be well for the rest of my life and I think that it's an important message because unfortunately, for instance, all of the people I know who are living well with bipolar disorder, there's a very small fraction of them who feel comfortable sharing that truth with their coworkers, with their  with the people in their lives beyond just a few.

[00:29:11] And so, if we all live in secret, once we've figured out how to live well with this disorder, then we have a very skewed sample of who it is that has bipolar disorder and what that can look like. So number one, I wanted people to know that when you've got the right treatments and the other systems in place to stay well, you can do the things that you want to do in your life.

[00:29:28] And then number two, I wanted to reach those people who were truly still in their hardest phases who are struggling to know that there is hope for a better tomorrow. That with the right treatments once more things can turn around very dramatically. And to have hope that can happen. And the way that it all came about, and I'll just say one quick other thing, which was NAMI California was having their annual conference and they invited me to keynote it and it felt like that would be the most authentic moment in which to share this journey. And I… same day also shared it in the LA times and online on social media. And I'm really glad that I did because in the wake of that, hundreds of people reached out to me with their stories of, I have been struggling and this meant so much to me where my son is in the hospital and I have hope now that he might be coming out and he'll be back to himself.

[00:30:29] You know, it just, it really opened. the door to understanding that we all have this commonality. We all have known struggle or known someone who has struggled very intimately. And then also it helped me understand that I had a way of connecting to this community and join in on a few different advocacy projects, which have been really meaningful.

[00:30:53] LM: I think that's incredible, and I think you're living proof that there is a better tomorrow, and that with treatment, that’s not just medicine, it's behavioral, it's environmental, you can have hope.

[00:31:06] DB: Yes.

[00:31:07] LM: What do you think, Devika, is the most important element of your wellness? It sounds like you take medication, it sounds like you prioritize sleep, it sounds like you try to eat healthy and have boundaries. I mean, if you had like a pie chart for you, and this is going to be different for different people, but what occupies the biggest slice of pie? Is it the medicine? Is it the sleep? Is it self awareness? I mean, could you break it down a little bit?

[00:31:35] DB: Yeah. There's a lot of elements of that pie. I think a big chunk of it, more than 25 percent is going to be connection and community, right? So the people that I rely on a daily basis to, to understand me, to support me, to have fun with me, to, you know, laugh with me. Those people keep me well in, in so many small and big ways, right?

[00:31:58] And then the other pieces are the daily habits, the making sure I'm getting enough sleep. At night, I wear blue light blockers. These are orange glasses that supposedly filter out the majority of blue wavelength light, nightlight, or nighttime. And so sleep is a big part of my life. I really try to do a lot to protect it. I'll tell you one other thing. My husband tends to wake up if my son is awake in the middle of the night or early in the morning. And so that's one strategy that we've sort of got in place to help protect my sleep, which is really meaningful. 

[00:32:38] Food, you know, eating a variety of foods. I tend to have sort of a Mediterranean diet over the course of, you know, the day and really, find that important. Exercise… protecting my energy. So, you know, big events, for instance, where I'm spending a lot of time talking about myself, my journey in a conversation like this, it, it tends to be really meaningful and important and also deplete my energy.

[00:33:07] And so I have to be really mindful of how I structure my weeks. So if I know I'm having a conversation like this, I'm going to try not to schedule too many other things in the next week or so. Right. And that gives me some time to sort of rest, decompressed, refill that cup, that energy cup and, and sort of be present and able to do what I need to do in the rest of my life.

[00:33:31] And so just being really aware of what's happening for me mood wise, energy wise. Am I feeling that tension in my shoulders? Like, what can I do differently? Like if I have any red flag symptoms, like let's say I'm starting to feel a little bit on edge or irritable with folks. 

[00:33:46] One of my tells is I tend to respond too quickly and with too many messages on WhatsApp. And remember, my family lives sort of abroad, and so that's a big mechanism of contact. But if I'm doing that, that is often a tell that I'm starting to feel a little bit elevated. And just knowing what it is that I need to come bring to bear in those moments to try to reverse where I'm going mood wise and come back into sort of my baseline mode.

[00:34:14] So it's a lot of kind of those maintenance mode things that we spoke about, but also recognizing red flag symptoms and then having a toolkit in place to intervene, whether that's up or down. And that looks different for different people.

[00:34:28] LM: I mean, that is such good self awareness. I particularly like what you said about the energy allocation. You have this busy life, you're a pediatrician, you're a public health leader, you're writing, you're speaking. You're parenting, you're learning from your own two year old. I think women are, I mean, we are just, I think beyond capable and we're interested in so many different things, but I think, you know, that resonates a lot with me too, is this sort of notion of an energy budget.

[00:35:00] Yes, we can do it all, but like, like with everything, there are trade offs, right? So I think that it's important that you're aware enough about yourself and your tank, where you are, of energy to sort of allocate it appropriately. And I wonder if you find like certain relationships you've had to sort of change or if you, or if there are boundaries that you've had to set.

[00:35:22] I know that as I have gotten older, I just turned 50. That I'm a real empath. I love being around people. I also know when my energy is being drained either by a certain situation or a certain set of people. And it's not their fault. It's just, that's just the way my mind and body work together. And so I'm sort of more aware of who, what, where I can tend to over-expend energy and then when I need to pull back. I wonder if boundaries and relationships are something you think about yourself.

[00:35:51] DB: A lot actually. And you know, it's one of those things that we as women are socialized to be very other oriented, to worry about other people's feelings, sometimes at the cost of our own health and wellbeing. And it's a lesson that I think I learned in my late thirties—I’m 37 now—to really honor my needs, my emotional needs, and sort of to know that with certain relationships. That there do have to be some boundaries in place and at the beginning when I first learned about this concept, you know in therapy, I thought, that's kind of I don't know how that's gonna work in an Indian family. Like we're so close. It's a very communal situation even when we're many miles apart.

[00:36:38] There's this like very open expectation that you will be there and vice versa in lots of ways and the concept of a boundary felt culturally potentially inappropriate and what I realized was that I'm putting this boundary in place not to shut this person out of my life, right? Not to have this relationship wither and die, but actually to have a better relationship, where I'm not resentful of them… of something that they are asking of me that I'm not able to do. I realize like it's been such a powerful, game changing thing because I have closer relationships with those same people now because I'm aware of my own emotional needs and triggers and sort of what those boundaries really need to be.

[00:37:24] Sometimes it's something simple like When I see them, I'm going to see them for this amount of time, and there won't be a chance for, you know, necessarily that build up. But it's been, yeah, it's been huge for me, as I imagine for you too, and for many of us who are listening.

[00:37:39] LM: I mean, I think a lot of what you're talking about pertains to the human condition in general. I mean, I think certainly when you have bipolar illness and certainly when you figure out your kit of coping tools, that's essential. I also think for most of us, we need to be careful about our sleep, our exercise, our relationships saying no, kind of recognizing our internal sort of thoughts and feelings and who drains us and who energizes us and meeting our needs, especially as a physician, as a mother, I'm socialized and trained to be empathetic and I am, I think, intrinsically empathetic, maybe not all the time, but I think I am.

[00:38:20] It is hard. It feels culturally inappropriate in my own family and as a physician, as a woman, to say no and to say, I'm so sorry, I can't do that. But I've also learned, like you, that I'm a better mother, sister, daughter, person when I am meeting my own needs, which is not selfish. It's the way I need to be healthy.

[00:38:42] And, you know, sometimes you get it wrong, right? Sometimes you get it, like, sometimes you get it wrong. Sometimes you say no because that's what it felt right. And then you realize, oh, wow, that was actually... at my own expense, but I think that's something that we as women need to practice and I think it is part of a mental health coping kit is to recognize that our needs matter and then to try to practice establishing boundaries and saying no, and you know, we all know that feeling of when you're talking to somebody, whether it's a loved one or a patient or, and they're asking you to do something that doesn't feel quite right.

[00:39:14] And you're thinking no, but then you end up saying yes, and then you're resentful and you can get angry and it's not their fault. We need to own that power and own that ability to say no.

[00:39:24] DB: Absolutely. You know, I'm reading a friend's book right now… Real Self-Care by Pooja Lakshmin. Yes. So I just finished the part about boundaries and two really insightful things that she has in there. One, don't over explain a boundary when you're giving it to somebody because then it seems like you're asking for permission, right?

[00:39:45] And then number two, to your point, allow there to be a pause between the ask of you, and your response. And in that pause, you will figure out does this feel like the right thing to do? Does this feel like a yes but, or you know, a yes and situation? Or do I have more questions? Do I need to negotiate a different situation, right? Or do I need to say no? And you won't know that if you very quickly respond “yes” which is our gut instinct as women again, and taking that pause is where the boundary can actually emerge meaningfully.

[00:40:19] LM: I think that's right. So what I'm hearing from you, Devika, is that your wellness is external. It's about sort of environmental, everything from your nightshades to your medications, to your therapy, to an internal kind of, checking in with yourself on your energy, on your relationships. It's about connection.

[00:40:42] It's about feeling loved. It's about, it sounds like it's about feeling safe. And I mean, I think those are essential parts of health for all of us and it doesn't have to be fancy or expensive. We don't have to buy fancy leggings and show up with a personal trainer and have exotic supplements and be on a yoga retreat in Bali.

[00:41:04] Although, you know, invite me with you if you're going to go, I think it really is about an internal sense of what we need, what we deserve and what, and how we relate to other people that is at the root of our mental health. So I want to just close by reading one more quote which I love from your LA times.

[00:41:23] You said “by sharing my story, I hope to dispel stigma and internalize shame and to help anyone struggling, know that they are not alone. If you feel comfortable, consider shining a light on your story. Stigma festers in the dark and scatters in the light.” So, for anyone who's listening, who feels like writing, or talking to their friend, or their dog, or just their journal, about their story, I think it's important that we acknowledge that we all have vulnerabilities, we all have grief, we all have loss, we all have fears.

[00:41:56] Some of us have mental illness, some of us have... You know, real relationship struggles. And I think that when we talk about them, we can then start to figure out the path forward. And so I just want to say, thank you so much, Devika, for sharing your story, for being such a role model and for teaching us the ways in which you stay well.

[00:42:13] DB: Thank you so much, Lucy, for having me here and for the wonderful work that you do in your sub stack for the whole community. Really appreciate you.

[00:42:28] LM: Thank you all for listening to Beyond the Prescription. Please don't forget to subscribe, like, download, and share the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you catch your podcasts. I'd be thrilled if you liked this episode to rate and review it. And if you have a comment or question, please drop us a line at info@lucymcbride.com. The views expressed on this show are entirely my own and do not constitute medical advice for individuals. That should be obtained from your personal physician.



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
Dr. Devorah Heitner on Growing Up in Public02 oct. 202300:39:04

You can also listen to this episode on Spotify!

It’s hard enough for adults to navigate anxiety, lack of privacy, and social relationships in the digital era. How can we expect young people to do it?

On this episode of Beyond the Prescription, media expert Dr. Devorah Heitner presents practical strategies for parenting in an era of perpetual connectivity. 

She offers a refreshing perspective in her bestselling new book, Growing Up In Public: Coming of Age in a Digital World. Instead of panicking about social media’s role in young people’s lives, she argues that parents should accept that it’s here to stay and focus on the benefits of technology. Instead of blaming social media’s role for the uptick in adolescent anxiety, she argues to uncover and address the root causes of young people’s distress.

She offers practical advice to help kids set boundaries, maintain digital hygiene, and learn how to make mistakes—even while everyone is watching.

Join Dr. McBride every other Monday for a new episode of Beyond the Prescription.

You can subscribe on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or on her Substack at https://lucymcbride.substack.com/podcast. You can sign up for her free weekly newsletter at lucymcbride.substack.com/welcome.

Please be sure to like, rate, and review the show!

The transcript of the show is here!

[00:00:00] Dr. Lucy McBride: Hello, and welcome to my office. I'm Dr. Lucy McBride, and this is Beyond the Prescription, the show where I talk with my guests like I do my patients, pulling the curtain back on what it means to be healthy, redefining health as more than the absence of disease. As a primary care doctor, I've realized that patients are more than their cholesterol and their weight.

[00:00:31] We are the integrated sum of complex parts. Our stories live in our bodies. I'm here to help people tell their story and for you to imagine and potentially get healthier from the inside out. You can subscribe to my free weekly newsletter. At lucymcbride.substack.com, and to the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts.

[00:00:57] So let's get into it and go Beyond The Prescription. Today on the podcast, I'm speaking with Dr. Devorah Heitner, who is a bestselling author, speaker, and expert on raising kids in the digital world. In her various capacities, Dr. Heitner offers practical advice that's backed by science and research. She's providing tools that people can use to start conversations with their loved ones about how to use technology in our lives in a healthy way.

[00:01:25] Her most recent book, out in September, 2023 is titled Growing Up In Public: Coming of Age in a Digital World. It's an essential read for parents. In short, Dr. Heitner thinks we're worrying about the wrong things. We see the panic inducing headlines, yet social media can be an excellent way to help learn about our kids and help them learn about the world we live in today.

[00:01:48] Devorah, thank you so much for joining me today.

[00:01:51] Dr. Devorah Heitner: Thank you.

[00:01:53] LM: So, I talk about inputs with my patients every day. I talk about things that we put into our bodies and brains, like alcohol, caffeine, food, of course. And then I talk about screens, because screens are something we ingest. They're ubiquitous. And it's not just about how much screen time we consume, it's about our relationship, sort of like relationship with food or alcohol.

[00:02:17] What I love about your work is not only are you exploring people's relationships with screens, you're taking a somewhat counterintuitive stance that  there's a lot of research out there to suggest that screens are destroying a generation of of youth. That it is the cause for the emotional and mental health despair.

[00:02:38] So, there's a lot of data to suggest that screens are the biggest evil for our kids, that they are the reason that kids are experiencing emotional and mental health problems, but you take a different viewpoint. You take the view that screens are indeed ubiquitous, but they also can be used as a tool. They can be used as a tool to help us shepherd kids through this complicated part of their lives. So talk to me about how you see screens as a boon, as a way to help parents understand their kids. And not just as something we need to be terrified of.

[00:03:20] DH: Yeah, I think we've been really pushed this idea that screens are the big bad that are really tanking kids’ mental health has been really pushed on us and we ignore a lot of other factors and also like, what are the screens bringing our kids? So as you said, it's not just about the quantity, the minutes.

[00:03:36] The minutes are important, too. We want to live in balance with screens and be able to do other things. But we also want to think about the quality of the experience. If your kid is a creator and is making things online, for example, or collaborating with other kids, or has started a business, or is composing music, or is writing a really interesting blog, or fan fiction, and getting a lot of creative juice and community out of that, it could be a really positive thing in your kid’s life.

[00:04:04] So we first want to look at: what is the quality of experience? What is your kid engaging with? Are they finding community there? Are they connecting with people in a positive way? Is it leading them to other interests? And sometimes, especially in the last few years, when so much of our novelty has come from YouTube or Netflix, and we maybe have forgotten about other kinds of novelty. As parents, we may want to look at our kids screen based interests as a clue. Like, oh, they're watching this kind of content on TikTok. What else might be interesting? My kids are very into strategy games on the computer, but we've also gotten into risk and some other deep strategy board games. 

[00:04:41] And part of that was like recognizing these multi layer, multi hour games, you know, with strategy and complexity are really interesting. What can we do as a family that might also be related to that? And then we also want to think about the ways kids are connecting with other humans and how this is supporting their friendships. So there's a lot that's going on socially here and we worry about the negative pieces, but we should also look at the positive ways our kids are finding affinity with other kids. Our kids are finding community and finding people who share the same interests.

[00:05:12] LM: I hear you loud and clear. I think headlines that scream: watch out parents. Your kids have a separate life that you don't know about and it's only nefarious and screens are doing harm and only harm are sensationalist and really put sort of fear in the driver's seat of our roles as parents.

[00:05:32] I do think there's a lot to be worried about. I mean, kids are looking at images that you and I never had access to as children. And I think that kids can certainly get lost in a screen addiction. Just like you can be addicted to marijuana or alcohol, you can get addicted to screens. You can develop a relationship with screens such that you're using it to “medicate social anxiety” or fear of failure or you can be bullied online.

[00:06:02] Of course, I think we all know about the harms. The way I practice medicine as a physician is that I try to be a realist. I recognize that alcohol is ubiquitous in our society. I'm not going to be able to take it away from everybody, nor should I. We have to reckon with these phenomena. We can't just mop up risk and make it zero.

[00:06:21] We have to reckon with the realities of our everyday life and screens are not going anywhere. Screens are, if anything, becoming more and more woven into the fabric of our society. So I think what's important as you're saying is to recognize that there are opportunities here. There are ways that we can use screens as a sort of window into our kids lives.

[00:06:46] And that policing them may do harm in and of itself. I mean, what do you make of this idea of restricting kids access to screens until they're 18? I think there's a new law in Utah, for example.

[00:07:00] DH: I think the Utah law is a particularly harmful example. Like I do think when school districts and other folks are trying to push back on the big companies and say, “hey, when we report bullying, we should get a response right away.” Or when we report that our kid started an account under age 13 when they're supposed to be 13 and you don't take it down or you're not doing anything to even pretend to try to age verify and any eight year old can start an Instagram account if they can do the math to change their birth date, then I think it's important to say, yeah, we do want to push back on these companies. So I'm excited to see some states and school districts pushing back on the big companies. Utah's saying, let's put this all on parents. Like parents don't have enough going on and parents should be in charge of their kids social media up to 18.

[00:07:44] I think that's a problem for a lot of reasons. One reason is that not every kid is lucky to have enlightened, wonderful parents. So, what if I'm a gay kid in Utah and my parents don't know and if they find out, I'm going to become unhoused? It's not safe for me to post on social media if my parents have access to my social media up to 18.

[00:08:04] I think 18 is particularly glaring in a state where kids can work at 16 and drive at 16. I think to say that driving and working a job are, are less responsible than posting on social media is a problem. I think when we look nationally at what's going on, where there are states saying we want kids to be able to work dangerous agriculture jobs with pesticides and work in meatpacking plants at 14, but they shouldn't be able to post on TikTok till they're 18.

[00:08:30] I think we're a little messed up as a society if we're saying that, because if we actually wanna protect kids, yes, I think none of us want our children to see pornography, for example. We don't want our children to see extreme violence, but the companies need to take down some of that content when it's getting reported.

[00:08:47] But putting that on parents and saying parents need to be checking their kids' messages and reading their kids' posts up to 18. I went to college when I was 16. I moved away from my house and went to college. I'm not saying that was necessarily the best thing in the world, but that's what I did.

[00:09:04] And to sort of say that, and many kids start college at 17 because that's when they finish high school. So to say that a college freshman in Utah, their mom should still be reading their direct messages is just a little extreme. And I think we really need to get out of that idea of big brother and think about we need to teach kids to swim, putting the electric fence around the pool is not helpful and kids entire focus will just be saying that they don't live in that state or that they're going to change their age in some way when they sign up and many parents will not be in a position to make that not happen. And again, it also assumes that every kid has a well meaning thoughtful parent on their side.

[00:09:39] So there are tremendous problems with that. What if a kid needs to use social media to report abuse in their home?

[00:09:44] LM: So do you think that the headlines about the harms of social media on kids and adolescents mental health are overblown? Or what's sort of your take, in general, on that sort of frenzy,

[00:09:54] DH I think they are overblown because it's an easy thing to blame, but some of the problems that we're seeing in kids, we have to look at the pandemic. We have to look at school shootings. We also, when we see more kids reporting mental health issues, we have to look at access to mental health care as a plus.

[00:10:09] When I was growing up in the early 90s, and there was a smoking lounge in my high school, and many peers were using substances to self medicate. Very few kids would have self identified as depressed or anxious because they didn't necessarily have that language. I would argue that there are kids who are learning the language of mental health from places like TikTok or Discord and are using that language to describe the way they feel, but I don't know that those problems are new to this generation of adolescents. But I think we're seeing increased access to both language around mental health, and hopefully in many communities, actual mental health care. The thing I would worry about is I don't want kids to get their mental health support from TikTok and Discord. It's one thing to identify, like, maybe I have an issue, and learn about it, or have a YouTuber who talks about ADHD and say “oh, I think maybe I should get neuropsych testing.”

[00:10:56] What we don't want to do is self diagnose from YouTube or TikTok, and I'm sure you see that as a physician all the time. Like, that, Is concerning, but the fact that more kids are self identifying with mental health issues, I think is partly that we as a society have shifted to destigmatize that conversation and I actually think social media is part of that in a positive way for kids. But it sounds scary to adults to hear like this many kids say that they're depressed or anxious, but it's not that kids in the past were not depressed and anxious. I think they were self medicating in the smoking lounge at their high school.

[00:11:28] I think adults were turning a blind eye to drug use and other things and alcohol use. So I think we're in a really different place as a society where we're looking harder at adolescents. And there are many reasons adolescents are feeling anxiety. For example, if your kid is looking at their social feed or at the news and information about school shootings, that's distressing, but taking away Instagram doesn't take that distress away. They're going to get that news another way. Their phone may be, in fact, the source of where they're getting that stressful information, but that doesn't mean that if we just take away the phone, they're not going to be worried about it anymore.

[00:12:07] So I think it's really important that we look at, is this a vehicle for getting access to stressful information? When we see the apps themselves encouraging things that are stressful, like the apps themselves may be a problem when they encourage us to location share and we can see that our friends are out without us. And that is a problem that I blame more on social media, versus, you know, that's not just getting information. That's kind of random. That's like, hey, this app is really encouraged us to do this very human thing, which is to want to know where the people we care about are, which is very human. But it's kind of trading on that brain what we want to do.

[00:12:41] And it also trades on parental anxiety when parents put Life360 on their kids devices to track their kids all over town. But that may also not be great for our relationships. There may be ways where that undermines trust and undermines relationships. So I think there are times where what we in the tech world call affordances, but it's basically like what the apps let us do become a problem. And that's where I think we should be looking at do we want to change our own behavior or do we want to make some feel really empowered in relation to an app? Like, yeah, I want to use Snapchat, but I'm going to turn off Snap Maps. I don't want that feature. Or I'm going to turn off location sharing on another device, or I'm not going to use Life360 unless someone actually has disappeared and I haven't heard from them way past curfew.

[00:13:20] I'm not just going to use it to see if my kid might have relationships or errands to do that. I don't know about right now to kind of resist, in other words, the possibility of what apps let us do and make choices about how we're going to use tech that might be healthier for us mentally. So to come back to the headlines, I really don't think we should panic about the ways kids are using social, we need to also just look at our own kids. Like if you have a kid who's predominantly using discord to connect with their three best friends to play a game every day after school, then my worry is, are they getting their homework done? Are they getting enough sleep? But I'm not worried that social media is making them depressed because it's clearly functional for them.

[00:14:02] LM: Right? I think as parents, the screen landscape can make us feel very out of control. Kids in their adolescence are naturally kind of differentiating themselves from their parents and they are behind closed doors a lot of the day and we don't always know what they're looking at. But that's always been the case. And that's part of growing up. That's part of developing our identity is being around our peers. And sometimes that's online. So what do you say to a parent who has, for example, an adolescent who's kind of less accessible verbally, who's spending a lot of time on screens, who you may be worried that they're spending too much time on screens.

[00:14:44] How do you even begin to sort of query whether or not you're doing a good enough job as a parent vis a vis this child and their screens? They don't want to talk about it and they don't want to share with you what they're doing online and you feel completely anxious. And then you look at the headlines and you think, Oh my God, I'm the worst person alive. What do you say to that parent?

[00:15:02] DH Well, it depends on the kid and what your specific worries are, but I do think you could have especially a younger kid who's newer on some apps, like walk you through some of the things they're doing. Like, “hey, can you show me some of the things you love?” You know, like my 14 year old will absolutely show me, you know, things that he thinks are funny from YouTube sometimes and like just getting a sense of like, oh, I can see you're diving into some political satire here.

[00:15:24] I see you're diving into some remixes of the culture and things that you're interested in and movies that you like over here and just getting a sense of like, what is the content? You can decide if the bedroom is a place for screens. Certainly with sleep, I would strongly recommend not having connected devices in bedrooms overnight, especially for younger adolescents who will really struggle to self regulate, or tweens, or younger kids.

[00:15:47] And the challenge is sometimes kids are getting phones so young that they're still little and compliant. You know, your 5th grader, if they get a phone, might be super compliant and put it away at night. But you gotta think ahead to that 8th or 9th grader in love and think about, do I want them texting their sweetie all night?

[00:15:59] Do I want them, you know, on social media late at night? And so it may be that the bedroom is a place where tech doesn't go or it doesn't go during sleep and overnight. And I think that's important to think about. So some of their tech use hopefully is around the house for younger kids. If they're gaming with friends, I would suggest not having headphones on all the time.

[00:16:17] It may be annoying. It was definitely annoying for me living in a small apartment through a lot of remote school in the pandemic. And my kid was gaming without headphones. It was extremely annoying, but I knew what the friends were talking about. And when some things came up on Roblox, where they ran into some content that was a little bit of a surprise, as in, like, naked blocky people having sex in Roblox.

[00:16:38] When I heard them start to talk about that, I was like, walking over to the computer, like, what's that? And so I think that's, that's a helpful way. It's a little bit less big brother-y than using your device to kind of spy on or get your kids data later, but just being in a place where you're adjacent, you can overhear some of the activity can help you know.

[00:16:57] As kids get older, their privacy is going to be more and more appropriate, but you can still check in with them when they're in the car. We have a no phones in car rides rule for under a certain amount of time. So, you know, my kid can't like put on a podcast and listen to it with his headphones for a five minute ride if I'm driving him somewhere.

[00:17:14] If we're going on a road trip to another city, podcast and listen together. And some of his time might be in the backseat. with music on or something. But shorter rides, we have to talk to each other. And some of that is like, he gets to pick the topic because he doesn't like to share about school, but he has to tell me about something, right?

[00:17:32] And it might be the video game he's playing, but we have to talk to each other. And family meals are important. Finding a time that actually works. And with busy teenagers who do a lot of activities, that might be late at night. And that's when your kid's ready to spill and you might be ready to fall over, but if your kid is ready to tell you about things, that's a good time to be listening.

[00:17:52] If there's a specific where you have, like, say you think your kid is. checking out pornography or something where you're like, this is a specific worry. I do not want you doing that. Then I would address it directly. A lot of us are uncomfortable there, but if you have evidence that your kid has looked at pornography, I would definitely talk to them directly about it and talk to them about why this isn't where you want them to learn about sex and consent and relationships.

[00:18:14] And we can do that in a non-shaming way. We can normalize and humanize that human beings have been preoccupied with the body and sexuality and art for a long time. This is not new. For an adolescent to be curious about sex and what that looks like and what people do is very typical and normal.

[00:18:30] But this isn't a useful way to get information and it can actually be misleading. It can offer misleading ways to get information about what partners might actually like. It's very misleading on the consent front. And so I think we, and we want to make sure they get alternative information. The older your kid is, the more I would  want them to read… certainly younger kids should get have books about puberty and sexuality.

[00:18:52] Hopefully you live in a place where they can also get good sex ed in school, but we know that's not the case everywhere. So we know kids need to be able to talk to their pediatrician and other things. But we need to make sure that they have good information. And then for older kids, like reading a steamy love scene in a young adult or even an adult novel is preferable to me by a lot.

[00:19:12] I mean, there's a lot of books I would want my kid or be comfortable with my kid reading as opposed to seeing pornography. And I think that's really important to make sure that kids do have access to information. And we need to know that it's not just boys looking at porn. Girls will look at it too. A lot of kids are accessing porn for, for sex ed purposes, or that's what they think it is.

[00:19:30] LM: Yeah. And one of the other specific worries I think that comes up for parents of girls in particular, not that boys are immune to this, is the focus on bodies and thinness and diet culture and comparison culture. And I think it's really hard to avoid those, the constant barrage of images of… and now that we have AI where these faces can all of a sudden look perfect and you can see your real face compared to what your face might look like if you had plastic surgery and you were on the red carpet in Hollywood. I mean, that is a pervasive phenomenon and it's concerning as a mother of a daughter and sons, this constant sort of focus on appearance. But again, as I think you're saying, lwe cannot take screens out of their hands.

[00:20:19] We cannot make risk zero. We can do what we can as parents to help our kids kind of have a relationship with screens. So, I was counseling a patient last week who's a mother of a teenage girl who's struggling with her eating. So she's got some binge eating and some restricting behaviors and she's on screens all the time and Focusing on her appearance and the girls, her friends are in bikinis and she's not included in all the events where the girls are wearing bikinis and it's just, you know, it's torture as a mother to watch her daughter kind of go through this and you think to yourself, Gosh, I could just get rid of the screens and everything would be okay.

[00:20:57] Let's acknowledge that wouldn't be the case. And let's acknowledge that's not realistic. So my advice to her was to have a conversation with her daughter that's led with curiosity and empathy. So instead of saying, you really need to get off your screens, that's bad for you, ask the question: “honey, I wonder what it feels like when you're sitting at home and feeling uncomfortable about maybe your body or your social life and you see your friends looking perfect because they've got this curated image of themselves and you're not there. What, I wonder what that feels like.” I mean, and you might offer even an example of what you might feel like. Like it might make me feel awful. You know, when I was a kid and I knew my, my friends were hanging out together and living this so called perfect life, it, it hurt. I wonder what that feels like to you. So curiosity is always a good way to lead a conversation. And then also with empathy and say I just feel bad for you guys that this is such a hard thing to have to navigate. You can't avoid looking at these images.

[00:21:54] You can't avoid comparing yourself to other people. And then sort of open the conversation like that instead of going at it as you really need to get off screens. You need to not look at these images. You need to just stay away from that friend group or stay away from that social media feed. These are their friends.

[00:22:07] These are their lives. But I think it's very hard to know how to have those conversations as parents. And I think the world we live in as parents consuming social media seems to suggest that there's the right way to talk to our kids and the wrong way to talk to our kids. That we have to read the right parenting book.

[00:22:25] We have to follow the right expert on Instagram. We have to listen to the right podcast and that our kids are so fragile and so vulnerable that if we say the wrong thing by just two phrases, then we're doing all this harm when I think that for parents is scary and we need to understand that just by showing up as parents, and just by being empathetic and curious about who our kids are, and showing them that we love them no matter what, that is good enough. Sure, there are parents who are doing harm. Sure, there are parents who need help. I need all the help I can get with parenting, but I also have learned to trust my instincts and intuition, and I need to listen to my kids and meet them where they are.

[00:23:06] There's no parenting book that is going to tell me how to parent child one versus two versus three. So this is a long winded way of asking you, are you saying that parents need to be able to read the room with their kid, they need to be able to understand the person they are talking to, and have a relationship at baseline with their child that involves discussing who they are, what their interests are, and understand that screens are going to be an inevitable part of it.

[00:23:34] DH: I think that empathy and curiosity as you say, is huge and just slowing down, like really saying, what do you notice when you look at Instagram and letting your kid talk. Ideally not even leading with like exclusion or your own feelings, but you can go there and in a conversation, but I would let them what it's like for them and see what insights you can get from there.

[00:23:59] And certainly with body image, as the example you used it can be an exacerbating factor. Like it probably didn't originate with screens, the eating challenges you're talking about, but that doesn't mean that screens couldn't exacerbate. And if a kid is in treatment for an ED, for a substance, for anxiety, for another mental health issue, 100% with that therapist, I would be working on a screen plan with that therapist.

[00:24:25] Especially with a teenager, it's helpful to have someone that's not a parent coming up with, like, if you are going to change the screen plan and your kid is in treatment for an ED or coming home from the hospital even or something. Those are kids who are going to need some support. And sometimes it's apps we don't think of, like Pinterest is actually filled with diet content that is quite toxic.

[00:24:44] If I had a kid with an ED. I would be thinking about, like, how can we encourage them to maybe avoid Pinterest? This may not be a good place for them. If I had a kid who's really into redecorating her bedroom, or a kid who's really into crafting, Pinterest could be fine. So it's not about the app. It's about what experiences and connections and content your kid will seek out within that app. Because I could say the same thing about discord, you know, discord could be totally positive for a kid Who's using it to connect with other anime fans? It could be very negative if kids are doing like how to on an eating disorder or something or self harm. So I don't want to scare people but there are places on the internet and and communities and sub communities that aren't going to be a positive place to be if you're struggling in those ways and asking kids to reflect on their experience, asking kids to consider taking a break.

[00:25:35] Cutting a kid off completely from an app is a pretty big step, but even taking it off your most frequently used device without closing your account can be helpful. And for some kids doing that, even for a few days, just to take that app off your most frequently used device for a weekend and spend a weekend where in order to see that app, you would have to go to your computer and log in. 

[00:25:55] I have that suggestion for a lot of kids who are stressing about their grades and actually over checking their grading app. I'll say actually take your grading app off your phone. If you're checking your grading app multiple times during the school day and getting distracted in one class because you saw a test score come in from another class, that's too much. And so some kids are compulsively checking those apps. So I do think in those cases, again, it's not like we never want to see the grading app again. You may need to check it at some point, but like if you have to go to your desktop or your janky school laptop that you don't use that much and check it there, but it's not on your phone, which for 99% of teens is going to be the most frequently used device...

[00:26:32] That's really helpful. So creating those friction moments to make it less automatic and less habitual to go to the places that maybe are kind of death by a thousand paper cuts—maybe it's not like, you know, your phone is hitting you over the head and giving you a substance use disorder and eating disorder, but it's not helping either.

[00:26:51] Maybe that's where change your access. And the more kids feel empowered about that and the more… I talked to several kids who were intentionally following size positive models, people who made them feel good about their bodies. So going in the other direction, using the algorithm intentionally. So for Growing Up In Public, I did talk to some kids who felt like it wasn't great for them.

[00:27:11] And they started using those apps more just for messaging and not posting pictures as much and kind of feeling like they had to post. And again, the people who are curating first, you know, either size positivity or following athletes that they felt like were more body positive and not giving them kind of kicking off or catalyzing feelings that were more negative was so important. But that's a lot of sophistication. Even adults often don't recognize this content is adjacent to this content. But for any kids, I would say fitness content is always going to be adjacent to diet content and diet content is not safe for children. I think it's toxic for all of us, but definitely for kids, you know, if you're looking at your eating or anything with fitness, like talk to your physician. Do not get that from TikTok because it's all very dangerous on there.

[00:27:57] LM: Absolutely. And there's a sort of moralization of human behavior that happens that's just hard not to internalize. I love what you said about suggesting these breaks from screens. I mean, I find it hard as an adult to do that myself, right? When I'm standing in line at the grocery store and it's taking too long, I'm tapping my toe, you know, I'm kind of like scrolling through Instagram to pass the time and it becomes this habitual thing you just go to your phone when you have time to kill and there's a downside there. And so what I sometimes will ask my patients, I will ask myself this too, is what does it feel like internally, and how do you feel sort of mentally and physically when you take a break from, say, Twitter or Instagram for a weekend?

[00:28:38] When you take it off your phone, you don't delete your account, but you take the app off your phone, do you feel less tense in your jaw, less tense in your back? Do you sleep better? Do you find yourself drinking less alcohol because you're less kind of outraged or kind of overstimulated? Do you find yourself gravitating to the book that you put down six months ago? So I think it's not just about restricting the apps. It's about noticing how you feel mentally, physically, how are your behaviors different? If you could give up some apps that you frequently use or gravitate to for a week, what does that feel like?

[00:29:13] So I think what we're talking about really is control. Are we in control of the screens and our utilization, or are they controlling us? It's the same thing I talk about with alcohol. 

[00:29:23] DH: I always say that to kids. Yeah, I always say that to…

[00:29:25] LM: It's the same thing I talk about with alcohol, you know, sugar, like, are we deciding how to use it? Or is it deciding for us? And when it is deciding for us when there's a Twitchiness in our brain that gravitates to the phone when you're standing in line at the grocery store or you're lying in bed and you can't fall asleep and you pick up your phone just to kill more time, that may be a sign that is controlling you. And so that's a moment to decide, let's pull back, not because we can't come back into our lives at some point, but let's recalibrate that relationship. Let's put us in the driver's seat of this relationship because it's such a slippery slope, even for grownups.

[00:29:59] DH: Yeah, what I say to kids is you want to be running your devices, not letting them run you. And that's, I absolutely feel that way. And that could be my inbox some days. It's like, wait, I need to set my priorities and not let my inbox set my priorities, right? I need to not just be reacting. I need to be planning and prioritizing and doing things in a way that makes sense like most of us check email too often too frequently throughout the day. So it's really important to talk with kids about that. And when I talk with kids about running our devices and not letting them run us I talk a lot about distraction and even what are the intentional things I do as an adult and as a writer like when I go Speak at schools or is like she wrote books like I'm like, oh, yeah like that's so easy because most kids find writing hard and guess what?

[00:30:38] I do too. I have to give myself rewards for every 500 or 1000 words I write. Like, it's not easy. And if I have to do an edit, which is even a next level challenge, often I will print it out and do it offline because of distraction, because I would much rather check the news or I mean, check the weather or scroll Facebook and see somebody's cute baby, whatever, then do that edit. And so I talked to kids about what do I do to set myself up for success? And when we as parents see our kids going down that rabbit hole, I mean, A) we have to look at how did we spend our time as teenagers? Did we always spend our time in the highest and best way? We did not.

[00:31:14] Like you probably spent some time sleeping very late. You probably spent some time, you know, like I spent time like playing songs on the radio for my friends over the phone. Wasn't like the highest and best use of, you know, our time. Like I wish I had been more like Greta Thunberg. We'd be in a much better place now if my generation had been environmental activists instead of playing songs for each other on the phone.

[00:31:35] But that kind of downtime and like watching a TikTok video with friends isn't necessarily bad for kids. They need some of that. But if you feel like it's a huge rabbit hole for a kid, your kid, and they're losing time that they need on other things like sleep or homework or, you know, any physical activity, chores around the house, Then we can talk to them about how can you choose your time? Especially when you have something with no ending cues, like a TikTok or an Instagram. How can you decide I'm going to do my hardest subject homework first. And then maybe I am going to scroll Instagram for a few minutes. And then I'm going to do another subject.

[00:32:09] And then maybe I will look at TikTok, but I'm going to set a timer on myself. Because there's no end to it. And the algorithm is really good. They're going to give you something you like. Like if they know what you like, they know what you like. They've got your number.

[00:32:21] LM: Yeah, I think at the end of the day, it's incredibly overwhelming, as you know, incredibly stressful for parents to think that we can put our arms around this behemoth of social media. And we really can't. And so I think what you're saying, Devorah, is to know our kids, to have those open lines of communication, to lead with empathy and curiosity for who they are, how they spend their time, what social media means to them, and then to recognize the good of social media, the good, the practice it can offer kids, setting boundaries and setting limits, and where to spend their time. It sounds like you also think that we can kind of tap into their interests.

[00:33:02] If you notice your kid on, you know, baking shows, then hey, maybe it's time to take a cooking class together. I mean, that would be sort of... The dream is that your teenager would want to take a cooking class with you, but I think we can use it as a road. 

[00:33:14] DH: Even they could just make dinner. I mean, honestly, like if you're, if your kid is watching cooking shows, like have them make dinner. I want to eat those cupcakes. I want to, you know, eat that homemade pasta and truly like your kid will be the most popular kid on the floor of their dorm if they can make a good meal or even just some nice cookies.

[00:33:30] And so, and, and even if they're watching like how to make slime, like I want to see some slime. Like I don't want endless how to content filtering into a kid's brains without them putting it out. And the other thing we really want them to remember is there's other human beings on the other end. So when they are connecting with kids, those people have feelings too. If you're going to make a snarky comment on somebody's YouTube, that's a real person. And not only is it to that person, but you're also dealing with the people who will read it. So if you can't say something nice, it's not a good thing.

[00:34:00] You don't want to put that out there. And if someone is really bringing about your ire and your rage, and there are people on YouTube that bring, and Twitter and other places, that bring out my rage and my frustration, but my frustration is best channeled finding people I agree with and doing something to solve the problem.

[00:34:14] If somebody's being a racist or misogynist mouthpiece on YouTube, responding to their YouTube with a comment criticizing them isn't going to fix it. They're not going to say, “Oh, well, Devorah in Chicago thinks I should change my ways. I'm having a mea culpa moment. Here I go. I'm going to go down a new road.”

[00:34:31] Instead I want to do, think about like, what can I do in my own community to fight racism? What can I do in my own community to build an accepting school district for LGBT plus students? What can I do in my community to fight misogyny? And make safe spaces for women and girls? So I think it's really important to focus on what we can do to make the world better when we see things that enrage us and not get into like an outrage cycle online. And I think unfortunately that is another thing that the algorithm is really good at is like churning us up in that way. And that's something we want to resist.

[00:35:03] LM: That's right. And being in control of our own emotions. Recognizing that it wants us to be afraid and outraged. Fear and outrage is how they, how the social media algorithms work. So if we can say, look, I'm of course entitled to be afraid. I'm of course entitled to be outraged, but I'm going to calibrate that to my understanding of the facts and not calibrate it to what the social media algorithms are serving up.

[00:35:28] Now that's a tall order for kids. It's a tall order for adults, but I really like what you're saying again, just to frame it is that we as parents need to understand that there's good, there's value in social media. We have to feel that way because it's not going away, but it's true. There is good. There is value.

[00:35:47] In fact, during the pandemic, I was grateful in many ways for social media, for my kids to be able to connect with their peers and classmates, despite being out of school. So let's end with this question. What do you think a healthy relationship with social media looks like? What is the sort of definition of healthy social media habits?

[00:36:06] DH A healthy social media relationship is one where you're using it if you want to, because you want to, and you're getting pleasure and distraction and entertainment from it. You're getting maybe ideas and inspiration from it as well. And you can have a sense of humor about it. You know, everybody's posting about living their best life, because nobody wants to see you unloading the dishwasher.

[00:36:28] But the reality is most people's lives are a lot more about cleaning the cat box and unloading the dishwasher and running around and getting things done or if you're a kid like doing your homework or whatever and that very little of your time is on top of the mountain with the sunset or at the party.

[00:36:43] And so it's good to remember that it's a performance and to just have that sense of humor about it. I mean, I try, even though, of course, like my publisher wants me to be famous and get likes as well. Like I have that pressure as an author and a speaker, but I also have to have a sense of humor about it and say like, okay, this time, I'm not going to do the reel and chase the numbers, or this time I'm going to do it, but I'm going to try not to keep checking my phone to see how many likes I got, because I know that's the app getting me where I'm the most human, where I want to be seen and regarded. And that's where we all are.

[00:37:12] So if we can let our kids know that we have empathy for them, and that we see them, and make sure that they have things that they're doing outside of social media that bring them real self esteem, which is being helpful at home and in the community. to balance out that sense of chasing that algorithm or the numbers or the followers or the likes, I think that's a healthy relationship with social media. So use it for what it's good for. 

[00:37:34] LM: I love it. I love it.

[00:37:35] DH: And be able to take some space.

[00:37:38] LM: And as we've talked about earlier, acknowledging that it is. An input, just like food, water, screens are now, you know, sort of part of our sort of nutrition, sometimes good, sometimes bad, but we have to metabolize it and we have to be aware of how it affects our bodies and minds.

[00:37:56] DH When it makes you feel bad, definitely put it away. That's I mean, That's definitely time. When it makes you feel bad, that's the time. If you're watching other people do stuff without you and it's making you feel terrible, put it away.

[00:38:05] LM: So Devorah, thank you so much for joining me today. It's been a pleasure and I've learned a lot.

[00:38:09] DH: Thank you so much. It was great talking with you.

[00:38:16] LM: Thank you all for listening to Beyond the Prescription. Please don't forget to subscribe, like, download, and share the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you catch your podcasts. I'd be thrilled if you like this episode to rate and review it. And if you have a comment or question, please drop us a line at info@lucymcbride.com. The views expressed on this show are entirely my own and do not constitute medical advice for individuals that should be obtained from your personal physician. 



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
Suneel Gupta on Finding Your Dharma 18 sept. 202300:31:22

You can also listen to this episode on Spotify!

What gives you meaning and purpose? How do you measure success? What does it mean to be healthy?

Suneel Gupta is helping people grapple with these essential questions.

His new book, Everyday Dharma: The Timeless Art of Finding Joy in What You Do, is about reconciling what we do with who we are. Gupta describes our “dharma” as our calling—or what Gupta’s grandfather called our “essence.” Gupta recognizes the central tension between outward markers of success and finding this internal sense of purpose. A successful entrepreneur and bestselling author, Gupta has also grappled with depression and self-doubt, fueled by the natural tendency to measure success with external metrics instead of asking ourselves the “Why?”

On this episode of Beyond the Prescription, Gupta explores the harms of hyper-vigilance and the power of vulnerability. They discuss the “Arrival Fallacy,” the false assumption that once you reach a goal, you will experience enduring happiness. He shares parts of his own process of self-discovery that allowed him to pursue his inner purpose and help others do the same.

Join Dr. McBride every other Monday for a new episode of Beyond the Prescription.

You can subscribe on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or on her Substack at https://lucymcbride.substack.com/podcast. You can sign up for her free weekly newsletter at lucymcbride.substack.com/welcome.

Please be sure to like, rate, and review the show!

The transcript of the show is here!

[00:00:00] Dr. Lucy McBride: Hello, and welcome to my office. I'm Dr. Lucy McBride, and this is Beyond the Prescription, the show where I talk with my guests like I do my patients, pulling the curtain back on what it means to be healthy, redefining health as more than the absence of disease. As a primary care doctor, I've realized that patients are more than their cholesterol and their weight.

[00:00:31] We are the integrated sum of complex parts. Our stories live in our bodies. I'm here to help people tell their story and for you to imagine and potentially get healthier from the inside out. You can subscribe to my free weekly newsletter at lucymcbride.substack.com and to the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts.

[00:00:57] So let's get into it and go Beyond The Prescription. My guest today is the ever dynamic. Suneel Gupta, who's passionate about helping people achieve success in a healthy, sustainable way. Suneel is a beloved speaker, a visiting scholar at Harvard Medical School, and best selling author of two books. His new book is just out. It's called, Everyday Dharma: The Timeless Art of Finding Joy in What You Do. It's really a practical guide to finding your dharma, your inner calling, and learning to integrate ambition, work, and well being to create a balanced life. The book combines Suneel's own stories with history science, Eastern philosophy, and Western methods. Suneel, thank you so much for joining me on the podcast today.

[00:01:49] Suneel Gupta: Oh, Lucy, I'm so glad we were introduced and it's good to be here.

[00:01:52] LM: So let's talk about Dharma. There's something about it that resonates with me as a physician who's in the constant quest tohelp patients pull the curtain back on their story. So what is Dharma?

[00:02:04] SG: Yeah, I mean, I wrote this book really for the same reason. I think that we are experiencing an overwhelming sense of emptiness right now and society sort of speeding up. All right, we're using artificial intelligence, we're using automation to continue getting faster and more productive. But I think as individuals, we're kind of in a lot of ways moving in the opposite direction.

[00:02:28] We are starting to feel like we are disassociating with our work, we are quietly quitting. And I think the result of all of it is that we are losing an emotional connection to what we do, which I think is a shame because we spend so much of our time either at a job or with the work that we do. 

[00:02:45] And to not feel that connection is, I think, I think it's devastating, right? It causes, I think, a lot of the symptoms that you talk about on this show. And so the reason that I wrote this book is because I wanted to to talk about how do we bring that emotional connection back to our work in a way that really feels real to us? And dharma is an age old philosophy really about that connection and one of the underpinnings of dharma is that while it may be tempting sometimes to try to find happiness and bliss outside of your work, there also is another path which is finding it through your work, right?

[00:03:22] And Dharma is really the alignment of who you are and what you do, because when those two things are lined up, you feel creative, you feel energized. My grandfather called this your essence, right? And when you are expressing that essence, you're lit up, you're energized. But when you're not, you feel depleted, you feel burnt out.

[00:03:43] And so I think the question for us is, how do we now start to come back to this essence, right? And it's something that's available to I think all of us. It's not the kind of thing that you get to luxuriate about when you've hit a certain level of status or wealth. I think it's it's available to every single one of us no matter where we are in our career the the challenge though is that most of us don't know what our Dharma is and even if we do understand to a certain degree, what our Dharma is, what our inner calling is, we don't necessarily feel like we have the time or the space or the money sometimes, or even the courage to pursue it. And I wanted to write this book because I wanted to go directly into those struggles. Not to write a book about what purpose is sitting behind a desk, but how do you take this thing that you feel that you need to express, right, it needs to speak, and how do you once and for all start to bring that into your everyday life?

[00:04:39] LM:  I love that I commonly talk with patients about this gap that exists in all of us between our best intentions and the execution of them. Meaning, like, we know we want to eat healthy. We want to exercise. We want to be more purposeful. We want to be more intentional. We want to put our phones down. We want to be happy and pursue things that are joyful, but there's that gap and the river is wide between the intentions and the execution. And you just said it, Suneel, sometimes the gap is filled with financial insecurity. Sometimes it's filled with logistical obstacles. Sometimes it's filled though, with fear and maybe even ambivalence, and then maybe even not knowing what your purpose is. So talk to me about how you might mind the gap. Those are my words, but how you kind of actualize and take control over your sort of sense of purpose and meaning.

[00:05:37] SG: Yeah. So two different things that come together, right? Who I am and what I do, right? And I think the what I do is the execution. Who I am is really sort of getting into like, what it is I care about. Let's start with who I am because I think that's just a natural place where I think a lot of us, I think me, me included would skip over. And the reason I would skip it over is because I would look to what everybody else sort of had, right? I would look to people I saw with nice cars and nice homes and really nice sounding LinkedIn profiles and bios. And I'd say, let me go follow that. And what I found over time is that I was really walking somebody else's path, not my own.

[00:06:12] And I think the work to sort of coming back to yourself and understanding what you want, it doesn't have to be something that you go on a huge meditation retreat. to do, right? I think it comes through starting to ask yourself certain questions. And in the book, I go through a list of sort of questions that really sort of helped me kind of get to this point.

[00:06:31] I call these the chisels. And the reason I call these the chisels is because Michelangelo, when he would look at a block of marble, he would say the sculpture is already inside. All I have to do is chisel away the layers. I don't have to create something from the ground up. And I think dharma, or calling, is very much the same thing.

[00:06:48] I bet that at some point in time, you have experienced your dharma. Like, you have lived up in a certain way. It may have been when you were a child. It may have been last week. It may be something that you're actively doing even at your job right now, but you're just not, you're not in tune with that.

[00:07:03] You're not in touch with that. So what I think of one of the very first things that we can start to do is start to identify the bright spots, whether that be in a past role or in a current role, these moments that really made us come alive. I think the key here that I think that we sometimes miss, I know I did, was that when we think about things like purpose and dharma, we think about a job.

[00:07:23] And so like in the book, for example, I tell the story of a woman named Mila, who really wanted to be a teacher. She was a project manager, but she really wanted to be a teacher, right? And she was frustrated because she couldn't, like, realistically, she had kids, her family relied on her health benefits, like the idea of leaving her job, going back and getting a teaching certificate was just not something that fit her practical life.

[00:07:46] And she was frustrated by that. And I think a lot of people sort of find themselves in a similar position. But when she was able to peel back the layers and understand, well, what is it about teaching that I love, right? When I dig below the occupation and into the essence of teaching, what ultimately arrived for her was that she loved to help people grow.

[00:08:05] And there was this emotional conversation she had with her mom, where her mom's like, Yeah, you've always loved helping people grow. Ever since you were a little kid, you were the kid who helped the kids on the other, on the block, like, learn how to ride bikes. It's the thing that's always been a part of you.

[00:08:19] And once she sort of reconnected with that essence, all of a sudden, all these different ways of expressing that began to open up for her, right? Teaching was obviously one of them, but she could start to coach people at work. She could step into a lateral shift into HR and start growing people inside the company.

[00:08:35] And all these options started to pop up for her. When that happens, Lucy, it's liberating because how many of us right now are like, Oh my God, like if I just took that other fork in the road in my career, then I would have ended in this job that would have been perfect for me right now. And I would be so much happier.

[00:08:52] Well, the reality is that over 90% of us right now are looking for jobs, right? In 2023. Over 90% of us right now are looking for our next job, and what the data almost overwhelmingly shows is that we're going to jump to the next job, and within a few months, we're going to feel exactly the way we feel right now, right?

[00:09:09] So I think with Dharma, with who I am, we're peeling underneath the occupation layer, and we're going into the essence layer. When you tap into that essence, you can start to figure out how to express that, and your world kind of opens up.

[00:09:21] LM: It's amazing the way you describe it. I love the Michelangelo image, right? The block. And he says, I'm just repeating it back to you, but he says the sculpture is already there. It's just that you have to pull back the layers and that's exactly right. I think when people are able to do that, as you've described in your book.

[00:09:40] LM: To me, that's the definition of health. I mean, health also includes having nice cholesterol levels, not having a heart attack, doing your cancer screenings, but health at its core is about awareness of our stories and how they live in our bodies, awareness of medical data, our own data, and the way our data is contextualized in the literature and then accepting the things we can't control, so other people, our genetic predisposition to breast cancer, and then finding agency where we can, because we can't control other people. We can't control certain genetic predispositions. We can't control the fact that we may be financially bound to stick with a job we're not fully actualized in, but people often have more control than they think.

[00:10:28] And I think what you're saying, Suneel, is that part of the control and the agency we have, which is ultimately. To me, a part of definition of health is simply querying our own bodies and minds and asking ourselves, like, what is my passion? What am I here for? How do I feel when I'm doing something that gives me joy? And can I recreate that in other spheres of my life, whether it's at work or parenting and ultimately that feeds back onto our health. I mean… 

[00:10:55] SG: It does.

[00:10:56] LM: During the pandemic, for example, I saw people every day who were experiencing physical manifestations of emotional distress. And some of it was burnout from caring, caregiving and parenting and living through a pandemic, just being a human.

[00:11:08] But even now, I mean, people are wired and tired and they don't feel well. And so it's reassuring to me to hear someone like you talk about, to me, what is really the essence of health in your book. 

[00:11:24] SG: Dr. Tal Ben-Shahar, who you may have crossed paths with at Harvard, really sort of, I think, Explains this nicely, which is like he has this phrase called the arrival fallacy and the arrival fallacy is basically this idea that like we're going to hit this moment where we've attained enough wealth, enough status in order to feel this lasting sense of joy on the inside.

[00:11:47] And until then, we're willing to suffer. Until then, we're willing to sort of grit it out, grind it out, do whatever we need to do because we believe we're going to hit this moment where it's all going to have been worth it. And at some point in time, I think we all get wiser to this idea right? And I would argue that We're starting to realize that earlier in our lives. 

[00:12:05] I think Gen Z is asking difficult questions that older generations sometimes don't like because they're like we didn't ask those questions when we were your age, right? And they're, I think, very understandably saying, yeah, but you don't seem very happy. And we want to do things a little differently than you.

[00:12:20] I mean, the country has gotten richer, we've become more productive, but we're also more lonely than ever before. Mental health issues have never been higher, right? We feel disconnected from one another. That's not necessarily sort of the train that I want to get on. And so to ask the difficult questions right now, and to your point, to be inside out about it, right, to peel back the layers, I think it's a very reasonable thing. And then the question I think becomes, well, then once I start to peel back those layers, how do I actually put it into practice, right? Because there's nothing more frustrating than understanding who you are, but showing up every day and feeling like you're walking in somebody else's path.

[00:12:55] And what I try to do in the book is really get into those struggles again, like we may not feel like we have enough time. We may not feel like we have enough money. We may feel like we know exactly what it is, but we're scared of that. And so I wanted to tell like the everyday stories of people who were able to not necessarily even leave their jobs.

[00:13:14] Like one of my favorite stories in the book is, is about a nurse who really wanted to be a writer. And her parents said, no, you can't be a writer. You're first of all, writing is not a profession. It's going to make money. You're not a, you're not a man, right? Like, and, and like, if you're a son, if you're a son, maybe, but like, as the daughter, no, you're not going to be a writer.

[00:13:31] And so she got pushed into a different field and became an outstanding nurse. But one of the things that she realized is that she was able to bring her persona as a writer into her work of nursing. And one of the ways that she did that, it was through her patient paperwork. So, while most people like, try to get through, and you know this Lucy, try to get through the paperwork as quickly as possible, like put the clinical details in, she started to actually expand on those clinical details into like, who were these people?

[00:13:56] What did they care about? Who do they love? What was their life like at home? What was their experience of being a human like? And she would start to pour her heart as a writer into these clinical patient forms to the point that like literally this paperwork was getting passed around the hospital like novels people loved reading it because it gave them a sense of purpose and what they were doing and so she was able to express this dharma as a writer through her occupation as a nurse and the point of it all is that oftentimes we think that in order to live our purpose we have to blow up our lives. We have to leave our jobs, right?

[00:14:30] We have to move to a different place and become a painter or leave everything we have behind. Not true. And there's so many situations and stories in the book. We talk about sort of how Dharma doesn't have to be a separate path, but it can be a permutation of what you have right now. You don't have to leave everything behind. You can start to bring a new persona into where you are today.

[00:14:49] LM: I love that Suneel, I think you're right that life happens in the mundane in a way, right? It's not in the big sort of huge moments. It's really in the everyday moments that sometimes we don't even know exist. It's just a tuning to the present. How did you get to be so wise? I mean, you're young and you talk a lot about burnout and failure.

[00:15:12] I love that story you told about. You told your wife, I'm a failure and she's like, no, you're not a failure. And you're like, well, the New York Times says I'm a failure. And then you showed her the article about your talk about failure. And so like, what is your story? How did you get to the place where you are now writing and speaking and talking about these very soulful topics?

[00:15:36] SG: Yeah, I mean, I think success is a lousy teacher, there's no doubt about that. It's wonderful, I'm not trying to downplay success, like, I think that I've had some success in my life and has been able to provide the sort of, I think, a life for my family, it's allowed me to sort of take care of my kids, and I'm very thankful for that.

[00:15:54] And yet, if I look back at sort of where the learning really came, where the growth really came, it didn't come from success, it came from setbacks, it came from mistakes. It came from change when I coach sort of organizations and leaders today, and I asked them, what was the most important part of your career, right? Most important year of your career. Very rarely do they say like it was the winning year when I had the most profit or it was when I earned the biggest salary. Most of the time it's like something big happened, it was a big change and usually that change isn't positive. It's like it was something that got knocked back on their ass and they had to sort of learn and that changed everything for them.

[00:16:32] But that was really meaningful. And I think I've had no shortage of I think those moments where I felt like I wanted something really badly and I put myself out there and it didn't happen. I think the learning for me, though, sort of came from sitting down and writing about that. Right? So, I think, if I'm being honest, like, I started writing because I was depressed.

[00:16:55] I was feeling anxious. And I realized that I was dumping a lot of that on my wife. I was spending a lot of time talking to her about that, and I realized, and as, like, loving as, like, Lena is, I realized it was unfair for her. She was always listening, but it was unfair to just, like, almost, like, vomit my trauma on her.

[00:17:13] And so I started to use the page, right? Literally sit down at my desk every morning and I started to write about these things that I felt like I was struggling with and searching for answers to that would do it every morning because the page always listened, no matter what it just listened. And I'd say 99% of what I've written in my life has ended up in like a trash bin, nut there were some pearls there were some little pearls that was able to string together along the way and eventually those pearls started becoming blog posts that became published articles. Eventually they became books and that's just kind of the thing like I think if you look hard enough There are these poor these pearls of wisdom.

[00:17:55] I talk about this a lot in the book is like I think I was following sort of an outlook of resilience before right and now I feel like I'm following an outlook of growth and the difference between the two is that like with resilience, there can be a tendency sometimes to just like want to get back up right like pull yourself up by the bootstrap, let's get back up. But I think growth is getting back up, but also taking some time to understand. What did I learn. If my kid was in a similar situation? Well, how would I sort of help coach them through a situation like this? What would they learn from my mistakes? Taking such a taken like a reflective view on that.

[00:18:35] Even just spending some time moments, right, to write about it, to learn about it, even if it's just for your benefit. Nothing you're gonna publish, but just something that you're gonna reflect on yourself I think can be the difference between cycling through the same mistake over and over again, and I think actually using a setback to create genuine.

[00:18:56] LM: I love that. I have a comment and then a question. The comment is about the writing. Like you, I find writing to be very therapeutic. I find that I can really crystallize a lot of my thoughts. I mean, writing ultimately is about thinking. And when you're putting things on the page, it's clarifying to oneself about how you're thinking.

[00:19:17] It also can disarm some sort of scary thoughts. I have found, like, when I've had depression symptoms or I've been anxious, when I journaled, I was a journaler from a young age. Just intuitively, I knew to write. When you look at the words, A day or two later, you realize that with time and with perspective, they're not so terrifying.

[00:19:37] And so, I too find writing really therapeutic and I recommend it commonly to patients who are experiencing depression or anxiety or trauma as an adjunct to other sort of treatment modalities, but certainly kind of writing down our thoughts can help disarm them.

[00:19:52] SG: Yeah. One of my favorite techniques is to write what I call sort of the if true, then pattern.

[00:19:58] LM: Tell me about that.

[00:19:59] SG: going a little bit deeper into the fear can be a really illuminating thing. So if I'm scared that I'm going to blow a presentation, right, I'll write that down. Like that's the thought inside my head, you're going to blow this presentation.

[00:20:12] And then I kind of talk with the fear. I say, okay, let's pretend that happens. If true, then what? And then it's, you're not going to get the deal or you're not going to get the, you're not going to get the job or whatever it is. Right. And they say, if that's true, then what? Well, then you're, you're not going to have this role that you wanted.

[00:20:27] If that's true, then what? Well, then you're going to blow up your career. And if that's true, then what? And I continue to just sort of go deeper down. And when it starts to make me realize is that underneath this surface level fear, all these sort of deep seated concerns that almost in all probability will not come to happen, but the other thing is that at the very bottom of that list Right when I really dig down to the root of it It always ends with something like well your wife is no longer going to love you, your kids are no longer gonna love you, right?

[00:20:59] And I think to myself Wow, that's the deepest root of my fear and I actually have more control over that right now Then I do whether I get this presentation done like I can go give my kids a hug I can go tell my wife I love her. I can do that right now. What happens inside that presentation, I don't know. But I know the deepest fear, I can deal with right now.

[00:21:21] LM: It's such a powerful point, Suneel, because I think all of us have at our core, the fear of not being loved or being worthy. Like shame and feeling excluded or not loved are like the deepest fears. And I think a lot of those fears come up in our childhood naturally, right? Like I think of life as this set of experiences and we're like a blank canvas when we're born and then you experience loss and challenge and hardship and dings on your self esteem.

[00:21:57] And then we create this sort of network of connections in our minds. In fact, we call it the default mode network. It's a set of neural pathways in the front of our brains that basically are derived from a lot of pattern recognition so that we don't reinvent the wheel every time we come across a new scenario, right? Like, we lose that wonder and curiosity of childhood.

[00:22:20]  But we also gain some street smarts, but the downside of that default mode network in the front of our brains is that we can start to make assumptions about things and make connections and thought and behavioral patterns that actually aren't serving us at the time. In other words, you can have an experience as a child where you were terrified and felt vulnerable.

[00:22:41] Maybe you weren't picked for the team or something. And then you wrote a story in your mind about why. And then the next time something happens to you that's like that, even in your adulthood, you might then go back to that sort of I'm not worthy narrative. So, this is a long way of asking you, about your childhood.

[00:22:59] And now we're going to do like go deep here. Like, I love that pinned tweet on your Twitter feed. I guess it's called X now, about your mom. And I'm like, okay, there's a story there. First of all, her story and then your story of her being your mother. Someone says to her, “go back to your country.” And she says, this is my country.

[00:23:17] And then I think the man says, get out of my kitchen. She says, this is my kitchen. And then there she is in all of her glory on time magazine, telling her story. Tell me about like growing up in your family. What was her story? How did that affect your story? And then your telling of it to yourself and then the experience of fear and vulnerability, like you just described,

[00:23:37] SG: So, mom grew up on the border of India and Pakistan, right? When it was all one big country, when it was India. When the country split, during partition, was one of the bloodiest conflicts that humanity has ever known and she was part of that. She was in, she was right in the mix of it and their family fled.

[00:23:56] She ended up in a refugee camp as a kid, very little running water, no electricity, but she decided that she was going to teach herself how to read. And she felt like that was going to be sort of her path out of poverty. And so she did. And she knew she had enough foresight even back then to know that like English was sort of the language that she would have to learn if she wanted to get herself to the United States because that was her dream. And so she started reading and the first book that she read from cover to cover was a story about Ford Motor Company because Ford Motor Company was literally the Google of its day.

[00:24:30] The big, it was the big company. Everybody knew about it, right? If you were rich and you were driving sort of a Ford car, even around sort of certain parts of India and she would see that and that's what she wanted. And she wanted to be an engineer, as well, and she set her heart on that, and it was a very unlikely dream because people from her country, especially women, that period of time were destined for the kitchen, right?

[00:24:53] And I mean, the best case scenario for her as told to her by some of the other people in her village was Find a rich man, find a wealthier man, somebody who isn't in poverty, and that's your path out. She wanted more, like she wanted to express herself. And so she studied hard and people got behind her, her parents got behind her, they saved every rupee that they had.

[00:25:13] She was able to get on a boat to eventually the United States. She got a scholarship to Oklahoma State University. The day after she graduates, she finds herself to Detroit, Michigan. She applies for her dream job. There's a lot there. There's another story there. But she gets it. And in 1967, the reason Time Magazine wrote about her is because she became Ford Motor Company's first female engineer.

[00:25:34] Ford Motor Company had thousands of engineers on staff at that point in time. Not a single one of them was a woman. And so here she is, this woman who tends to dress in saris, and she cooks and eats mainly Indian food back at home, and she is now amongst this, like, sea of mainly white men who are doing this job, and she finds a way to sort of fit in, or I shouldn't even say finds a way to fit in, she finds a way to be herself in a very different environment.

[00:25:58] And, and I think that for me as a kid growing up in almost the opposite situation. I'm an Indian kid now growing up in America. I live in suburban Michigan. Everything is compared to my mom. We lived in a pretty, we lived in a three bedroom house, but like it was a night and day difference from the conditions that she grew up in.

[00:26:17] It was the equivalent of a silver spoon in my mouth and the fact that I could eat every single night. I think that for me, what. I've learned about my mom and what I've learned about, I think other leaders who I spend time studying and I think admiring who have done difficult things is I think that the thing that holds a lot of us back are the words, “I'm not ready.”

[00:26:40] Right? Like, I'm not ready to, to run with that thing. I'm not ready to step into that role. I'm not ready to speak my mind. I'm not ready. And I think the confusion sometimes is in believing that the people who did difficult things, my mom included, is that they were somehow ready to do what they did, but they weren't, right?

[00:27:01] I call this the game of now, in my book, versus the game of someday, right? The game of someday is you wait for courage. You summon up enough courage, and once you actually have enough courage, you take action. And I think that's the way that most of us behave. There is another game, and that's the game of now, which is that instead of waiting for courage in order to take action, you just take action, and you let courage catch up along the way.

[00:27:27] And I think the thing that I've learned is that it almost always does. If you just say like I'm gonna go do that thing courage will come even begrudgingly courage will be like, okay. I'm with you, right? That's the thing I learned about her story is that it wasn't the story of a little girl in a refugee camp who said f*ck it all I'm gonna go do this thing. It was more a story of a scared person who said I want this really badly and I'm scared And I'm going to do it anyway.

[00:27:58] LM: that is a huge lesson. And I wonder how she expressed that. I mean, you told me in so many words, but like. Did she talk about like the lack of courage? Did she talk about her fear and just doing it despite having the courage or did she just model it? Was it the kind of thing you talked about as a kid?

[00:28:17] SG: Not as a kid, no. I think as a kid, I had very surface level conversations with my mom. I marveled at her story, I marveled at who she was, but I didn't really dig into the how. If there's anything that I felt as a kid, I felt like kind of almost insecure because here was a parent and I have a brother who's done amazing things as well and my father's an immigrant too.

[00:28:40] And so I sort of, I felt like I kind of came from this really brave family and I felt insecure because I actually didn't feel all that brave. I just didn't. And, and that made me feel bad because it was just, I felt like, wow, like, gosh, I'm surrounded by all these incredibly courageous people and I'm not one of them.

[00:28:58] But. I began to realize over time, more from the stories that I would dig into, more from hearing about what it was like at Oklahoma State University when she was sitting in her dorm alone, right? What was that sort of like for her because she didn't eat meat and she couldn't go to the cafeteria because she was a vegetarian?

[00:29:17] What was that like for her? And I think when you dig into people's stories and you get beyond this happened and this happened and you just simply start to ask the question of like, what was that like for you? And that's when you start to get insights, but I didn't start asking those questions until I was a teenager or maybe even in college when I would come home and have conversations with her.

[00:29:35] And the thing about it, Lucy is like, I love that question now. Like I host a documentary series where I travel around the world and I meet with all these leaders who've done crazy things. And I almost always dig into less of what they did, but what were they feeling in those moments along the way?

[00:29:54] LM: It's the essence of who people are. Right? Suneel, I can't thank you enough for joining me on the podcast. You are such a bright light and I can't wait to share your book more widely and to reread it. And I just thank you so much for your pearls of wisdom and for acknowledging that you're a work in progress too.

[00:30:13] I think that we're never done. We're never done in the process of self discovery and then bringing our best selves to our relationships, to our work. And so I appreciate the humility that you offer as well. So thank you.

[00:30:26] SG: Thanks, Lucy. It's so good to be here.

[00:30:35] LM: Thank you all for listening to Beyond the Prescription. Please don't forget to subscribe, like, download, and share the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you catch your podcasts. I'd be thrilled if you liked this episode to rate and review it, and if you have a comment or question, please drop us a line at info@lucymcbride.com. The views expressed on this show are entirely my own and do not constitute medical advice for individuals. That should be obtained from your personal physician. 



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
Monica Gandhi on What's Next with COVID04 sept. 202300:44:11

You can also listen to this episode on Apple Podcasts or Spotify—or wherever you get your podcasts!

Confused about how to handle COVID this fall and winter? Wondering how to think about masks, boosters, and reducing your risk of getting sick?

On this episode of Beyond the Prescription, Dr. McBride talks with Monica Gandhi, MD, MPH, who became one of the most prominent public health experts in the country during the pandemic. Dr. Gandhi is a Harvard-trained physician, expert in infectious diseases, and professor of medicine at the University of California, San Francisco (UCSF). She is the director of the UCSF’s AIDS Research Center and the medical director of the San Francisco General Hospital HIV Clinic. 

Dr. Gandhi’s career centers on the principle of harm reduction, born out of her decades-long work in HIV. Harm reduction is the belief that public health policies should consider not only the pathogen (i.e., HIV or COVID) but also people’s basic needs for social connection, intimacy, and agency—and that public health’s job isn’t to shame, stigmatize, or even to eliminate risk (that’s impossible) but rather to arm people with information and tools to mitigate the inevitable risks we face.

Her new book, Endemic: A Post-Pandemic playbook, published in July 2023, aims to reckon with the country's present condition: comprehending and living with a new respiratory disease and how to face the coming variants and next pandemic with reason, science, courage and compassion.

Listen to hear Drs. Gandhi and McBride discuss where we have been, where we find ourselves now, and how we ought to manage the virus this season, and in the coming years.

Join Dr. McBride every Monday for a new episode of Beyond the Prescription.

You can subscribe on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or on her Substack at https://lucymcbride.substack.com/podcast. You can sign up for her free weekly newsletter at lucymcbride.substack.com/welcome.

Please be sure to like, rate, and review the show!

The transcript of our conversation is here!

[00:00:00] Dr. Lucy McBride: Hello, and welcome to my office. I'm Dr. Lucy McBride, and this is Beyond the Prescription, the show where I talk with my guests like I do my patients, pulling the curtain back on what it means to be healthy, redefining health as more than the absence of disease. As a primary care doctor, I've realized that patients are more than their cholesterol and their weight.

[00:00:31] We are the integrated sum of complex parts. Our stories live in our bodies. I'm here to help people tell their story and for you to imagine and potentially get healthier from the inside out. You can subscribe to my free weekly newsletter at lucymcbride.substack.com and to the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts.

[00:00:57] So let's get into it and go beyond the prescription. Let's talk about Covid. Joining me today is my dear friend, Dr. Monica Gandhi. Monica is a physician and professor of medicine at the University of California, San Francisco. She's the director of the UCSF AIDS Research Center and the medical director of the San Francisco General Hospital HIV clinic.

[00:01:21] She studied at Harvard Medical School and then at UCSF where she focused on infectious diseases, specifically HIV. She holds a master's in public health from UC Berkeley, with a focus on epidemiology and biostats. During the pandemic, Monica became one of the most prominent public health experts in the country.

[00:01:42] National and local political leaders, medical professionals, and the media often turn to Monica for her thoughts and recommendations on how to handle the constantly shifting dynamics and demands of COVID. She has now put her thoughts together in a new book, Endemic: A post pandemic playbook out in July 2023.

[00:02:02] It aims at reckoning with the country's present condition, comprehending and living with a new respiratory disease back in 2020, and how to face the coming variants and the next pandemic with reason, science, courage and compassion. Monica is not only an accomplished physician and public health star, she's also a dear friend.

[00:02:24] I got to know Monica during the pandemic when I started noticing that patients were suffering not only from COVID, but also from the sustained fear, anxiety and social isolation of the pandemic. I was immediately drawn to her straight talking, evidence based and compassionate voice.

[00:02:42] It was a rarity in a sea of COVID experts. She seemed to consider the whole patient, to value the importance of human connection as much as guarding against an infectious disease. So we became fast friends. We've written op eds together. And we started a group text of seven women in medicine and public health who now have communicated multiple times a day for over two years today, Monica and I will discuss where we have been, where we find ourselves now and how we ought to manage this virus this fall and in the coming years, Monica, it is so fun to have you on the show today. Thank you for joining me.

[00:03:21] Dr. Monica Gandhi: Thank you so much. It's so good to see you.

[00:03:23] LM: So tell me about your book, let's start there. What are the lessons learned and then how can we move forward with COVID in our midst in perpetuity and the potential for new viruses coming along? So tell me about the book and what are the major themes in the book?

[00:03:40] MG: Yeah, so thank you. It starts out with an introduction to the concept of why I was so interested in infectious disease and I went into it and that really had to do with my interest in HIV, even from a very young age, my interest in social justice, my interest in disparities, and my interest in the fact that people are stigmatized for infectious diseases, which I always found completely shocking in the world of HIV.

[00:04:04] It's kind of Lehman's language on the whole pandemic and where we are with vaccines and therapeutics. And then it goes into harm reduction. And what that means is really that you have a pathogen. Let's say we had HIV which we did and we still do. And the way that we dealt with HIV, at least those people who are expected dealt with HIV is they dealt with this kind of whole person aspect of care.

[00:04:29] So you have a person living with HIV, but you also have their mental health and their sexual needs and their needs for companionship and their needs to have hope and it to become an HIV doctor became a really, I think, a doctor that sees the whole person and doesn't just see the disease or the pathogen or just the virus.

[00:04:51] And what I saw with COVID 19 is that we used the same bad stigmatizing language that we used with HIV with COVID. There were actually public health people that said, COVID idiot, or you're a bad person for getting COVID, which I still will never understand. And then I thought of harm reduction. What are the ways that we can absolutely fight the pathogen?

[00:05:12] In my mind, it's biomedical advances, but also minimize the harm done to society. And the three I think, or supposed mitigation, because I don't think they helped, that did harm, in my opinion, were prolonged school closures, were closing other medical care, not taking care of other medical needs, especially mental health, and then third is not letting people see their family members in the hospital.

[00:05:36] I think that's actually, frankly, inhuman. So I dwell on those for some time, chapter five is all school closures, then the subsequent chapters on around global equity, because if biomedical advances are your way out of a pandemic, you need to give them to everyone. And then the last chapter is a 10 point pandemic playbook.

[00:05:54] How do we go forward. If this happens again, and I hope it doesn't for 100 years and not get to this point where we are now, where there's about a 30% trust in public health. By the latest poll, a health affairs paper showed that in March of 2023, 30% of people trust the CDC. I mean, there must have been mistakes made for such a low number of trust.

[00:06:14] I don't subscribe to the view that Americans are anti science. I think they saw all the confusion. They saw the harm and they don't trust. And how do we get to a pandemic playbook that makes sense, that takes other people's needs into account, societal needs into account, outside is safer, therapeutics, vaccines. And then we're in the building of trust phase and we can go into that.

[00:06:36] LM: Yeah, harm reduction makes sense on a population level. It also makes sense on an individual person level, just for people who are listening and you don't know what that exactly means. It's rooted in the idea that risk is everywhere, that being a human being involves risk by being in relationships, by driving a car, by existing with bacteria and viruses, merely being a human carries occupational risk.

[00:07:08] And we cannot make risk zero. In the case of HIV, correct me if I'm wrong, the message never should have been abstinence only. Because what abstinence only as a message does... is it deprives people of their basic biological needs to have sex and intimate relationships, and it stigmatizes the person for having human needs.

[00:07:33] So, Harm Reduction's message to HIV patients and populations is, let's not tell you no, let's tell you here are the risks, let's arm you with facts and nuanced information, and give you the tools. Condoms, education, and a way to frame risk so that you can make your own decisions based on your risk tolerance, which you're entitled to.

[00:07:58] You can be very afraid of HIV and never have sex, and that's Up to you, you can be less afraid, but as long as you're aware of the data, you're talking to your partner, then you do you. So I think what I saw in my practice was people suffering from being shamed for going to their child's graduation, even after they'd been vaccinated.

[00:08:24] You remember those pictures of people. On beaches and media pundits were shaming them for being outside when we knew from get go that outdoors was pretty darn safe. And we know that people need to be outside. So somehow we lost the plot and we of course cared about death and dying from COVID, like that is a given, right?

[00:08:47] There's no question that human tragedy. I mean, zero question, but somehow people started moralizing human behavior. And then, if you spoke out, like you and I did, about trying to balance the harms of the virus with the harms of not living a life that is just meeting basic biological needs, somehow if you're talking about that, you're morally reprehensible.

[00:09:15] So, it's a really weird time in our country. I don't need to say that to you, but I just wonder, what do you think is that in inherent tension? Like, where does that come from? That this concept that like doing things, living your life, even if you've been vaccinated is morally reprehensible. I just don't understand.

[00:09:37] MG: Yeah, I didn't understand it until I really went back to the history of HIV, and then I think I made a connection, which is that in the history of HIV, 1981 was when these case reports were first described in the CDC, MMWR, and the President of the United States of, at the time was Ronald Reagan. And because of that, he and his wife also with Just Say No as a campaign for addiction, pushed an abstinence only approach.

[00:10:03] He actually didn't even talk about HIV until 1985. And there was a very like, just say no, there's just something wrong with you if you want these needs. And so the public health community. who tends to be left, as I am, completely pushed against that and said, no, that is a absence based only is an awful approach.

[00:10:22] And it's really unkind and not compassionate. And we can't tell people what to do. And instead we'll give you tools to stay safe. And we'll tell you about condoms and later prep and treatment, but really like it is up to you. You are a human being with your own needs, like you said, in your own risk tolerances and what happened during COVID, as Trump was president, so the public health establishment who's left, and so are ID doctors. They pushed against him no matter what he said, even when it was reasonable, like prolonged school closures weren't happening in Scandinavia and Europe. And he said, let's open schools in summer of 2020. And then people were all writing about opening schools, public health officials, and then they changed their mind when he said that.

[00:11:02] So I think it is actually a push against, it was not reasonable because it was clearly A reactionary pose against the right. And the problem with that reactionary poses at harm children. And it was completely topsy turvy from what we did with HIV. And I think there were two other reasons. One is the media thought that would with a lot of fear, they thought that would kind of scare people into compliance with masks or public health measures. But the problem with that is fear doesn't work. It makes people like paralyzed. I mean, that's what it does in nature. And so it doesn't make you say, oh, I completely understand that even though we have vaccines, they're still telling me to socially distance, even though Europe's gone back to normal with the vaccines.

[00:11:48] Instead of understanding that again, distrust came. And then I think that the third was that we just didn't celebrate the vaccines and no physician is really against vaccines in general. Like it's just a degrading 96% of physicians got vaccinated for COVID with the first two shots. Boosters I think have to be nuanced, but it was a celebration of the vaccine of the HIV therapies in 1990s and with the vaccines. At least the media still made it seem like it was really negative and that didn't unlock the key to normal life, but they didn't do that in Europe. They did. They unlocked the key to normal life. I don't know where anyone thought that normalcy wasn't an important human need, like being connected, being together, joy.

[00:12:37] Being around people, celebrations, church, synagogue, temple, these are part of the rituals of human existence. They're so terribly important for our mental health. So when the vaccines came we could have really celebrated them and instead there's been so much fear still.

[00:12:53] LM: And it's so funny how anti vax, like true anti vax sentiment, people who are saying that the vaccine, you know, alters your DNA and, you know, turns you into an alien, that messaging almost touched the messaging of let's have a vaccine that's life saving in some high risk populations, but it's not enough.

[00:13:15] Let's continue to mask and distance. It almost felt anti vax, as you just said, for me, the moment, I mean, there are many moments during the pandemic when I thought, golly, Baba, we are not messaging this Right, was Provincetown. So Provincetown was that weekend when it was rainy and cold up in Provincetown, Mass. There was a lot of people in intimate settings, post vaccine, and a lot of people got COVID. But no one died. A lot of people got colds, flus. To me, that should have been the CDC's moment to say, “Oh my gosh, this was the stress test for the vaccine. These people have been vaccinated, they got together, they had sex, they had fun.

[00:13:58] And they got colds. And they got flus and that's terrible and we don't want that.” But you know, what are you gonna do? And we should have said, “that's a vaccine success story.” But instead, that's when the CDC said, “nope, put masks back on. And that's when, among other moments where I thought, oh my gosh, we've lost the plot because we're moving the goalpost.”

[00:14:17] It's like kicking a soccer ball down the field and you're, you shoot for the goal and then the goal gets moved. And again, just to be clear to people who are listening, this is not to say, go get COVID, And you know, who cares? Not at all. We can do two things at once. We can be mindful of our risks for a virus and arm people with tools and information.

[00:14:38] We can also be mindful of the risks of living in a state of hypervigilance and fear where we aren't allowed to be ourselves and be in relationships and go to school and see the faces of our teachers. Like, we can do hard things. We can do many things at once. And I think it was this sort of paternalism from public health institutions, it felt very draconian and sort of condescending like that we know better when the vast majority of people who got COVID particularly after the vaccine did extraordinarily well.

[00:15:07] MG: I mean, I think that the interesting thing about what you just said and where I had a little different twist to the conversation was my history in HIV. And so if you look, people were saying a lot of people around that time was saying the same thing, actually, CDC's moment and they blew it, but I could bring in this concept that HIV.

[00:15:28] We never judged people, or what I mean is the people who judge people, we didn't like those people. We didn't like those public health officials who judged. We thought they were really out of line. And we used a harm reduction pro, in this case, sex approach. And so in the case of COVID, what happened with the Delta variant surge in Iceland is the Iceland prime minister came out and said, Look what's happening, everyone.

[00:15:55] You all got vaccinated, the hospitalizations are extremely low. This means the vaccines work. Go back, go forth, be with one another. This is an excellent example of how the vaccines work. And then everyone got vaccinated and the appropriate people got boosted, like older people, and everyone moved on. And they really did move on in Europe.

[00:16:14] So there was this kind of celebration of that moment, and I do write about this in the book. That was, I think, the moment. where the CDC really did lose its trust with the American people and we need to rebuild it, which is a lot of what the latter half of this book is, that the people who are talking right now, like the vaccines and therapeutics don't work are not actually rebuilding trust and certainly not rebuilding trust in technology and advances.

[00:16:42] Like we rebuilt hospitals. Trust in antiretrovirals with HIV to say that life wouldn't change after these advances didn't make sense. This is the other thing that's really important is that beyond bringing the HIV angle to it that I could because I've just thought about it for so long. [00:17:00] It's also important to say that respiratory viruses, cause I live, I'm an infectious disease doctor have always plagued humanity and I worry every winter about respiratory viruses.

[00:17:11] I worry about RSV, and I worry about influenza, and rhinovirus, and other coronaviruses, and adenovirus, and human metapneumovirus. But, actually the difference is, we have better tools for COVID than we do for human metapneumovirus in an older person, for example. I can give Paxilovir to an older person. There are boosters.

[00:17:29] There are no vaccines for human metapneumovirus. There are no treatments for that virus. RSV, we just got a vaccine. So, it means... That we really moved quickly, and we didn't celebrate that, that rapid movement, that incredible biomedical advances. But we did in HIV. We did. We said undetectable equals un-transmittable.

[00:17:49] You don't have to use a condom if you're on antiretroviral therapy. And we were just much more harm reductionist and sitting with the patient, making shared decision making. At least that's what, again, the good HIV doctors were doing. And here it was top down decision making.

[00:18:03] LM: And the MRNA technology that is so incredibly advanced is being deployed now for potential vaccines in HIV.

[00:18:12] MG: it's very exciting. Yes.

[00:18:13] LM: It's very exciting. I mean, I'm with you. Like, you and I got accused, both of us, for spreading hopium. It's so funny

[00:18:22] MG: It's a strange word. Yeah.

[00:18:23] LM: It's such a strange word. Like, you know, but it's sort of the way American medicine addresses patients in general. We think about health as this sort of set of boxes to check. It's about your cholesterol, it's your height, your weight. When hope, joy, and the sense of an end point to a crisis are really important for health. I mean, it's foundational. It's fundamental. The other thing is that hope and caution are not mutually exclusive.

[00:18:50] You can protect yourself like you and I did by getting vaccinated and boosted as needed and staying home when you're sick and celebrate the successes of the vaccine. Celebrate that. Now, as you just said, we have so many more tools to protect ourselves from COVID than we do for, um, metadenoma virus or para influenza virus, which every single year get many of my patients sick and in the hospital, because this is not a new concept that viruses tip people into crisis when they're particularly vulnerable.

[00:19:22] I mean, again, this is not new. We have done this before.

[00:19:26] MG: Well, I mean, I'll give you a good example of what you just said, what it reminded me of. Number one, my husband passed from cancer three months prior to the pandemic, and actually we didn't have hope fundamentally with bad cancer and we had moments of hope, but there wasn't. The thing about infectious disease is it's the other, unlike cancer, which is the self.

[00:19:48] I just wish, I kept in thinking as we were going through the beginning of COVID, I wish that I had someone to turn to during the worst parts of his cancer who would say vaccines work, therapeutics work. And so I wanted to be that person to help tell Americans that advanced therapeutics for an infectious disease, which is other. work. And it's not hopium. It's actually modern medicine technology. And then the second thing is it also could be that if you look at the world right now, I think there's a kind of a microcosm maybe on Twitter, but if you look at the world, I went to a large concert at something called the Chase Auditorium in San Francisco, which is like 20,000 people in an indoor space.

[00:20:30] And it was a large rock concert. And then later I went to Cirque du Soleil and. All these people, because I just was on the news a lot in San Francisco, came up to me at the concert and they said, Hey man, got vaccinated, rock on, you know, like, and they weren't, you know, distancing or masking. They were really living back with that joy that made life so meaningful.

[00:20:51] And I was really happy to see that is. It's kind of the point, right, of combating infectious diseases or combating anything that you're doing in medicine is the point is to infuse as much joy and normalcy into human beings lives as possible. And the other thing, and I really want to mention this, is my father was immunosuppressed during COVID. He was 88 and going through B cell lymphoma treatment. So this is as you know, when we talk about the vulnerable, this is really as vulnerable as we can get because he's not only vulnerable to a virus that is really age stratified in this risk. But he was on chemotherapy. And I kept on writing about how well the vaccines were working in my father.

[00:21:32] Trying to give people the personal anecdote. Because after vaccines and a booster, he had sky high antibodies during chemo. He sailed through his episode of COVID that he got at a family wedding, you know, very well. We did give him Paxilovid and I think that's very appropriate. I couldn't get at why... People didn't think the vaccines worked among the immunocompromised because the mRNA vacs, and I work with an immunocompromised population because I work with HIV, these mRNA [00:22:00] vaccines are so immunogenic. They're much more than like a whole virus vaccine or old protein based vaccine. So I'm really pushing the mRNA vaccines on my immunocompromised populations because they work so well.

[00:22:10] If someone wanted a Novavax, I was not encouraging immunocompromised, but Novavax was great for others. So it was just, again, like knowing that they really work. Even there was this idea that we would leave immunocompromised people out of the loop, but we weren't because we had this new technology that didn't leave them out and I kept on bringing my dad up to try to tell that I'm not just saying that even though I do work with an immunocompromised population.

[00:22:36] This is as bad as it gets and he's done very, he's done very well and he's back to normal life. He's, he went to the Shakespeare Festival in Utah the other day with his 92 year old friends. Yeah, he's 88, he's turning 89 soon.

[00:22:49] LM: It's amazing. I mean, you were always the champion of the T cells being cellular immunity, the arm of the immune system that protects against severe disease. So we learned pretty early on that it was post Delta that the vaccine could no longer block infection. That ship sailed, you could get 4, 5, 10 vaccine doses and still get infected,

[00:23:13] MG: Yes, exactly. T cells and B cells together are literally arming us from future protection from severe diseases. That's why it's so enduring.

[00:23:20:] LM: Right. And somehow that message just didn't get across, like the waning immunity conversation, it's like, I felt like, probably like you, I wanted to poke my eyeballs out because people thought waning immunity meant you were naked, like you're running outside of your house without any protection, when that just was never true.

[00:23:38] MG: These are basic principles of immunology that we learned in medical school. And I wrote a thread on Twitter just two days ago, cause I'd been thinking about it for a long time. How long does immunity last? Cause we've had some very nice new data about antibodies and it looks like it's going to last a long time for years actually.

[00:23:55] And so, and. The reason I thought about T cells so much is it's so hard to have seen an early AIDS and infection that HIV that hurt the very arm of the immune system, T cells that helped you combat infection. So I think about T cells all the time. I say the word T cells to my patients because what's your T cell count?

[00:24:14] But beyond the basic concepts of immunology, we've had a wealth of immunology information during the pandemic from really sophisticated groups in the UK and San Diego. They have done beautiful work that shows T cells cover all variants, and that's really important because I know we think we have to update the vaccine all the time, but they really do cover all variants because it's kind of a blanket of protection, and then B cells adapt their antibodies towards new variants.

[00:24:41] So there is really an adaptive immunity that we've shown both in this pandemic and from basic principles.

[00:24:47] LM: Monica, let's do a rapid fire Q and A. I'm going to ask you the questions that patients ask me every day About COVID and how to face the upcoming fall winter season. So there's a lot of buzz about these new variants, right? The BA

[00:25:03] MG: 286. Yeah. Yeah. I remember it because it's like 86, Ward 86. Yeah. Our

[00:25:09] LM: right. And the fear about this is that it has so many mutations that it may be, it may have escaped immunity from the vaccine. So when someone asks me, what should I do? Should I mask? Should I distance? Should I get another shot in the face of this new variant? What do I tell them?

[00:25:28] MG: So, there's two variants that keep on being talked about in the news, EG5 and BA286. And the one thing I will say is, actually, BA286 is not taking off like EG5 is. So we keep on saying, hey, there's a case in the UK, and there's a case over here. Actually, it seems extremely not very transmissible, and I think it's going to end up being one of those ones that go away.

[00:25:49] Because... If you're more transmissible, then you keep on rising in incidence. And the one that's rising in incidence is EG5. It looks like it's more transmissible than XBB1.5. These new variant directed vaccines that are coming out in mid-September are directed against XBB1.5, and they're going to very happily cover EG5 because there was just a paper on that. That EG5 and XBB 1.5 just differ by one mutation. So that's done with EG5. We'll know it's going to work.

[00:26:18] LM: But, let me ask you this. When you say cover, it doesn't mean you're going to, you can get the new booster and you won't get COVID. Right. So let's clarify that; it doesn’t block infection.

[00:26:27] MG: what's so important going back to BA286, which you were asking about originally, is that there's a concept of sterilizing immunity. What is sterilizing immunity? It's what we saw with smallpox infection or smallpox vaccine. And that was really the ability of Antibodies in the nose, which are called IGA to block all infections and the intramuscular vaccines that we get for COVID-19 do not produce that high of IGA in the nose.

[00:26:55] Guest: They did actually earlier on, or at [00:27:00] least the IGA was adequate to cover alpha. So there was blocking of transmission early on, but when Delta came along, 2 things happened. Number one, our antibodies go down with time and Delta had mutations across its spike protein and the vaccines didn't work as well against Delta, at least in terms of antibodies.

[00:27:16] But this is where our T and B cells are so important because there's never been a variant or a sub variant where the vaccines or your natural immunity don't work against at least in terms of cellular mediated immunity because T cell coverage is very broad so you can have lots and lots of mutations. But it still provides a blanket of protection and that's been shown again and again by Dr Setti's lab and other UCSD and then the second reason is B cells which T cells help produce more antibodies from those B cells are sitting dormant.

[00:27:50] Like you said they're in memory And then if they see another subvariant, even if it is BA286, they say, Oh, I, my job is to make more antibodies. I'm not going to make antibodies directed against some old variant in the past. That's not how these work. They're adaptive. I'm going to make antibodies directed against what I see.

[00:28:05] It will take a couple of days, but they will make, and you'll get infected, but you will be protected against severe disease. So there will be ongoing protection, even with both of these new variants with severe disease. If you've been naturally infected or had he vaccine before, and most people have had both, many people have had both. What about who needs boosters? That's the next question. I

[00:28:29] LM: Yeah. So as for boosters, so people are asking all about these boosters coming out at the end of September, early October, I remind people, cause most of my patients. I've had COVID and have been vaccinated. So they asked me, what's the optimal timing? I'm going to my daughter's wedding in November. What should I do?

[00:28:46] I remind them that again, you can get 10 shots and still get COVID. So they're not, these vaccines are not sterilizing. But if you wanted to try to time the vaccine to get a transient bump in your antibody levels before the wedding, which again, may not. It's like, if you jump into a freezing cold swimming pool and you're wearing a wet suit, aka vaccine, you're still going to get wet.

[00:29:11] MG: but it doesn't harm you with the severe disease. Yeah. Like it doesn't harm you.

[00:29:15] LM: Exactly. It's not, you're not going to have severe disease, but having had COVID and having had the vaccines previously is already going to likely protect you from serious outcomes. But if we're talking about the new booster, you might time it to get two weeks before the anticipated crowd you're going to be in.

[00:29:35] But, I mean, what do you think? Do you believe in like timing the vaccine to an event?

[00:29:37] MG: I don't actually believe them in timing them to an event because like you just said, I don't know if it's going to rise high enough to prevent infection at that event. What I actually really believe in and I wrote about this a lot of times is spacing the vaccines appropriately to get the best immune response.

[00:29:51] So I'll give you a good example that it looks like you should definitely wait at least four and likely six months since your last infection or last booster, whatever, they're the same thing. They're showing you the virus or parts of the virus in the case of to get another shot because you're essentially, you're going to interfere with that B cells trying to settle into memory, and this was data from the NIH.

[00:30:13] So, for example, my father, I would have encouraged him at 88 and going through chemotherapy to get the fall booster. However, he got, just got COVID, and it was in mid-July when he got COVID. So I'm going to ask him to please wait four months, regardless of events. So July, August, September, October, and then get the vaccine then. At least four months, maybe six so that he is doing exactly what vaccines are supposed to do, which is help refresh his immunity.

[00:30:41] Again, his immunity is more needing of refreshment than a young person's because young persons have very good immune responses to vaccines or infection.

[00:30:50] LM: It's a great point. And the other thing to remind people is that, you know, you can go to your daughter's wedding in November as planned. And if there's no one in the room with COVID, you know, it doesn't matter if you had the vaccine or the booster at all. In that moment, you can also be in any room anywhere because COVID is ubiquitous and it's not a wedding, but just because it's a wedding doesn't mean you're more likely to get it.

[00:31:08] That said, the virus tends to spread in closed Poorly ventilated spaces. It's just an odds ratio. It's not like weddings equal COVID and walking to the, the small boutique pharmacy, you're not going to get COVID. The virus isn't that smart. It's just different.

[00:31:24] MG: yeah, I think that's a really, not only is that a really good point, but the inoculum question, which I wrote about really early on. Oh, by the way, I was really mask focused very early on. In fact, when you say that I was on the, on the news, actually the first year and a half, it was all about masks, but I actually was talking about masks and this concept of inoculum.

[00:31:43] And there was just a recent paper that showed this is likely true, but it's amount, it's the amount of virus that you're exposed to. So that's why, yeah, dose. Right. And so, That's why in a closed indoor space, you'd be more likely if someone has COVID. Because the other important thing is not everyone has COVID all the time.

[00:31:59] That was the issue about treating people like they were vectors or something was wrong with them. Or we taught people to be scared of breathing. Actually, that is a thing that my patients said again and again to me. They said, I've been through one pandemic and I was told to stay. These are people living with HIV.

[00:32:15] And they said, I was told the way to stay. Stay away from people now. You're telling me to stay away from people and I can't even breathe like it was so hurtful the messaging a very soundbite messaging wear a mask save lives stay at home save lives Because it was not nuanced and spoke to the fact that It's really more likely when you have COVID that you're spreading disease.

[00:32:37] That was another interesting thing that changed with time is the degree of spread is really most when you're symptomatic and now we have really updated data around that But there was this idea that and I also wrote about that idea at the beginning but I changed my mind with time when I saw the data that you were spreading it when asymptomatic Just like most other infections. The majority of it is spread when you're symptomatic And that's good because that's what updating of data and recommendations means, right?

[00:33:01] LM: We have to have the epistemic humility to acknowledge that when we have new knowledge, we can change recommendations. That's not rooted in politics or ideology or, you know, who we vote for. It's, it's science change. It's iterative.

[00:33:14] MG: There was this idea that Americans needed simple messaging and I thought that was really insulting to the American public because I actually find Americans very pro science and very sophisticated. And I mean, just like everyone else. And so I didn't think they needed simple messaging, boosters for all mass for all. Like I thought they needed, you know, an explanation of the data instead of just say no.

[00:33:35] LM: Yeah. So there is sort of no more hot button. Issue than masking in this country, right? It became this sort of lightning rod and. It was just a fascinating sort of display of vitriol and science entangled with politics when masks are just masks. So when patients ask me now, should I mask in the fall?

[00:34:00] Should I wear a mask in an airplane? Should I mask when I'm outside? I tell people that despite searching for data to show that masks Reduce the risk for transmission. We failed to prove that they are that effective, particularly cloth masks and so even surgical masks. we do think is that a well fitted mask that is worn consistently and that is high grade can protect the wearer and whether or not to wear it is really up to you and your personal risk tolerance. Will I wear a mask when I'm sick with COVID? Well, I'll probably be at home in my room anyway, I wouldn't want to go to work sick or go to a social event sick. So first of all, I think there's no role for band aids because again, masks are for the wearer.

[00:35:00] But I also am trying to manage people's expectations because I think most people want to understand the reasoning. At the same time, there are some people who just want to be told. Mask up.

[00:35:10] MG: Yeah, I mean, so I will say that you're absolutely right, like I really go over the data on masks in this book. So it, because it was such a contentious issue, I really wanted to go over the data and it's kind of a vast section about all the studies, the Cochrane Review and negative studies in children. I mean, meaning negative harms in children, especially those who are learning how to speak.

[00:35:32] And so I really try to. comprehensively review that. And I agree with you that the only conclusion we can make as physicians and those who evaluate data is that if you all the time, we're a very well fit and filtered mask, like N95, KN95, KF94s, that you're going to protect yourself to a certain degree, but not always actually, cause it loosens, you'll take it off to drink something like it's not always, but that is all we can say. In medicine, putting all of this data together and I wrote the chapter actually for our infectious disease Bible on COVID and we really with another infectious disease doctor and we go over the data on masks. And that's what we conclude. You really mass mandates. It's not appropriate to put them back because of the different ways people are mass.

[00:36:16] And also because there is personal determination. If someone chooses to wear a mask or not, for example, my father. Again, I like to bring him up because he's high risk, except that I don't actually think he's that high risk because he's been vaccinated and now he's had COVID, but he doesn't hear very well because he had an accident 10 years ago.

[00:36:33] So masks are really, he doesn't like them because they interfere with his hearing. So it's when we think about people who are living with disability, um, it's a nuanced approach to what they would like to do. It has to be a personal decision, but I also reassure people so much about the vaccines that it's really interesting to see I don't think I have a single patient who's still masking. To my knowledge. They come in and they're like Hey, you convinced me. Like, you know, you got me to even take it sometimes if I didn't want to. And I, now I'm living with this risk like I've lived with other respiratory viruses.

[00:37:05] LM: At the same time, I, you wouldn't either shame anybody for wearing a mask if you want to wear a mask. That is your prerogative.

[00:37:13] MG: We are not very kind. Why don't, why are we so unkind? Like, we never, I don't know, in medicine the nice doctors are the ones who don't tell people how they have to be. I don't know, like, you just give them tools and then you let them...

[00:37:24] LM: Wasn't that the deal in medical school? I was, like, humility, empathy, compassion.

[00:37:30] MG: Not stigmatizing, not blaming, not people calling them idiots. So I can remember we treat lung cancer with compassion. If there's maybe an associate, you know, there is an associate of smoking. I mean, we'd never say, well, they don't deserve care. And in this epidemic, we were so unkind. We said the unvaccinated don't deserve care. Some people said…

[00:37:48] LM: Right. And we called children vectors of disease, grandma killers. I mean, you know, it's just not appropriate. It's not really in keeping with the sort oath of kindness that we take as doctors or

[00:38:00] MG: It really isn't in keeping with the principles of physicians.

[00:38:03] LM: it's also just not accurate. I mean, like, okay, let's talk about long COVID, which is real. I have a patient who has, I'm not satisfied with the diagnosis, by the way, like he carries a diagnosis of long COVID. But I look at the diagnosis of long COVID in this patient as a placeholder for when we actually get the diagnosis. I think COVID tripped a wire such that he has myriad. I mean, he has every organ systems on the fritz.

[00:38:30] He has profound dysautonomia. He has neuropathy. He has new anemia, renal insufficiency. I'm like a dog with a bone with my patients. We're going to figure out what's going on. He's going to have a bone marrow biopsy, a kidney biopsy. But my question is about long COVID. What is it? What is it not? And how did we get to a place where some of my patients and the general public are really afraid of it.

[00:38:57] MG: So I think that three and a half years and almost four years in, unfortunately we've done a disservice in terms of catching too many things into the long COVID diagnosis and not really being clean about our examination of data. So, What it looks like through all that noise and the WHO calls it an infodemic because you can put out papers that aren't very good and that's too much information and then you really look into it and you see that analyses were done improperly or it was observational confounded data or you didn't control for X or was ICD 10 not codes and it wasn't, you know, really understanding if they're inflammatory biomarkers.

[00:39:33] And if you put all the data together, it does look like any severe illness, sepsis. Influenza, COVID causes longer symptoms, but we knew that because as a specialist in infectious disease, I knew that from influenza. And that's why the incidence of this has gone down with the reduction of severe disease.

[00:39:52] So that's one good thing. That's good thing because we have the tools to prevent severe disease. Second is that we don't know all the contributors to. Why when you've had a severe infection that you get lingering symptoms, but in general, it has something to do with inflammation. We knew that for a long time in HIV and the anything that's even remotely promising or being tested as promising has anti-inflammatory properties, meaning like metformin looked promising in an observational study and it has anti-inflammatory. Property. So it's gonna go ahead and there's gonna be a study of randomized metformin, or a paxlovin study, like trying to kill the virus that actually closed early at Stanford. They are gonna study it more, but that would really imply that there was persistent R N A virus in multiple parts of the body.

[00:40:37] And we haven't seen that with other R N A viruses like hepatitis C, which is an RNA virus, does stay. But only with hepatocytes, only with liver cells. So we haven't seen that with other coronaviruses either and we do have six other coronaviruses. So that'll be studied but I'm more interested in the anti-inflammatory and I'm very interested, actually committed to preventing severe disease among, you know, the entire planet.

[00:41:01] And again, we have those tools to do that now with the vaccines and therapeutics. We need therapeutic access globally. We need something besides Paxlovid, which is Shinogi Protease inhibitors being studied. There's a Gilead nucleoside analog that's being studied. We're gonna have two more antivirals if they work.

[00:41:18] Hope they come soon because we need ongoing therapeutics and ongoing booster vaccination for people who are at persistent risk like older people and those on immunosuppressants in perpetuity for COVID because just like influenza, it will never go away.

[00:41:32] LM: Right. And we also need, as you talk about in your book, vaccine equity

[00:41:38] MG: Yes. It was so unfair.

[00:41:40] LM: The travel bans. I mean, as someone said early in the pandemic, that's like create it, trying to create a urine free zone in a swimming pool,

[00:41:47] MG: Oh no. Yuck. Yeah,

[00:41:50] LM: …until we vaccinate the world. First of all, that's just not, that's just not right. But secondly. Helping the collective [00:42:00] with immunity helps

[00:41:59] MG: It does. And that is, there's a long chapter on the book or like extensive on global equity and also how we should have learned more from HIV equity. And again, the same people who were urging HIV equity and of antiretrovirals weren't beating the drum. I thought for COVID vaccine and therapeutic equity, there was a lot of judgment being applied to human beings in this pandemic.

[00:42:19] I hope we get past this polarization, this politicization. I hope we increase trust in public health. We're going to have other problems in life and other pathogens, and we shouldn't be at this point.

[00:42:30] LM: I mean, if I were going to follow any guidance for the next pandemic, it would be your book.

[00:42:36] MG: It is a step by step, so I hope people do. The last chapter is a 10 point step by step.

[00:42:42] LM: It's a brilliant book. You're brilliant, Monica. And you kind of embody the humility and kindness that we hope other physicians and public health leaders adopt.

[00:42:51] MG: Thank you, but that's why I was drawn to you too, because I find you very compassionate, very kind and very loving with your patients. And that is the only duty of a doctor is to be kind, compassionate, meet them where they are and consider the entire patient. When I disappear into a room with a patient, it's just that patient and I, and that's, it is all about that person and it is holistic, every aspect of their life.

[00:43:16] LM: Monica, thank you so much for coming on the podcast and I hope to see you next time you're in

[00:43:21] MG: Thank you so much. I will.

[00:43:24] LM: Thank you all for listening to Beyond the Prescription. Please don't forget to subscribe, like, download, and share the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you catch your podcasts. I'd be thrilled if you liked this episode to rate and review it. And if you have a comment or question, please drop us a line at info@lucymcbride.com. The views expressed on this show are entirely my own and do not constitute medical advice for individuals. That should be obtained from your personal physician.



Get full access to Are You Okay? at lucymcbride.substack.com/subscribe
© My Podcast Data · Projet indépendant · Données issues d'Apple & Spotify